The PRINCETON FIELD GUIDE to PTEROSAURS 0011 PPtteerroossaauurrss iinnttrroo ppaaggeess 11--9955..iinndddd 11 1155//0099//22002211 1111::3300 0011 PPtteerroossaauurrss iinnttrroo ppaaggeess 11--9955..iinndddd 22 1155//0099//22002211 1111::3300 The PRINCETON FIELD GUIDE to PTEROSAURS GREGORY S. PAUL Princeton University Press Princeton and Oxford 0011 PPtteerroossaauurrss iinnttrroo ppaaggeess 11--9955..iinndddd 33 1155//0099//22002211 1111::3300 Copyright © 2022 by Princeton University Press Princeton University Press is committed to the protection of copyright and the intellectual property our authors entrust to us. Copyright promotes the progress and integrity of knowledge. Thank you for supporting free speech and the global exchange of ideas by purchasing an authorized edition of this book. If you wish to reproduce or distribute any part of it in any form, please obtain permission. Requests for permission to reproduce material from this work should be sent to [email protected] Published by Princeton University Press 41 William Street, Princeton, New Jersey 08540 6 Oxford Street, Woodstock, Oxfordshire OX20 1TR press.princeton.edu All Rights Reserved Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Names: Paul, Gregory S., author. Title: The princeton field guide to pterosaurs / Gregory S. Paul. Description: Princeton : Princeton University Press, [2022] | Series: Princeton field guides | Includes bibliographical references and index. Identifiers: LCCN 2021015050 (print) | LCCN 2021015051 (ebook) | ISBN 9780691180175 (hardback) | ISBN 9780691232218 (ebook) Subjects: LCSH: Pterosauria—Identification. Classification: LCC QE862.P7 P38 2022 (print) | LCC QE862.P7 (ebook) | DDC 567.918–dc23 LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2021015050 LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2021015051 British Library Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available Editorial: Robert Kirk and Abigail Johnson Production Editorial: Kathleen Cioffi Jacket Design: Layla Mac Rory Production: Steven Sears Publicity: Matthew Taylor and Caitlyn Robson Copyeditor: Laurel Anderton This book has been composed in Goudy Old Style (introduction), ITC Galliard Pro (species section and headings), and Optima (labels) Printed on acid-free paper. ∞ Typeset and designed by D & N Publishing, Wiltshire, UK Printed in Italy 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0011 PPtteerroossaauurrss iinnttrroo ppaaggeess 11--9955..iinndddd 44 1111//1100//22002211 1144::3388 CONTENTS Preface 6 Acknowledgments 6 Introduction History of Discovery and Research 9 What Is a Pterosaur? 10 Dating Pterosaurs 15 Evolution of Pterosaurs and Their World 16 Extinction 27 After the Age of Pterosaurs 28 Biology 29 General Anatomy 29 Walking, Running, Climbing, Swimming 36 Pterosaur Pneumatics 43 Skin, Feathers, and Color 44 Flight 46 Respiration and Circulation 68 Feeding Apparatus and Digestive Tracts 69 Senses 70 Vocalization 71 Disease, Pathologies, and Injuries 71 Behavior 72 Brains, Nerves, and Intelligence 72 Social Activities 73 Reproduction 73 Growth 76 Energetics 77 Gigantism 79 Mesozoic Oxygen 82 Pterosaur Safari 83 If Pterosaurs Survived 84 Pterosaur Conservation, Keeping, and Consumption 84 Where Pterosaurs Are Found 85 Pterosaur Count 86 Using the Group and Species Descriptions 91 Group and Species Accounts Pterosaurs 97 Rhamphorhynchoids 98 Pterodactyloids 123 References 177 Index 181 0011 PPtteerroossaauurrss iinnttrroo ppaaggeess 11--9955..iinndddd 55 1155//0099//22002211 1111::3300 PREFACE If I were, at about age twenty as a budding paleoresearcher and Remaining frustratingly unresolved are the origins of ptero- artist, handed a copy of this book by a mysterious time traveler, saurs. Unlike with birds, whose descent from advanced dino- I would have been startled as well as delighted. The pages would saurs has become well understood in many respects, but like with have revealed a world of new pterosaurs and ideas that I had bats, the early evolution of which remains little documented in only a hint of, if any such ideas existed at all. My head would the fossil record, we do not yet have a detailed understanding of have spun at the revelation that Pteranodon was not, as had been which archosaur group pterosaurs evolved from, or how. calculated, the largest flying creature possible, but that Quetzal- Producing this volume has been satisfying in that it has given coatlus was even more colossal, with the wingspan of a small me reason to illustrate the skeletons of almost all pterosaur spe- human-carrying glider, and a weight exceeding that of land- cies for which sufficiently complete material is available. These bound ostriches manyfold. Visually pleasing would have been have been used to construct the most extensive library of side- the array of pterosaurs bearing fantastical head crests, including view life studies of these archosaurs of the air to date in print. Tupuxuara, Thalassodromeus, Shenzhoupterus, Tapejara, Sinopterus, An advantage of producing large sets of rigorous profile-skeletals Tupandactylus, and most especially the superelongated, psyche- is that the restorations can reveal information that would not delic prongs of Nyctosaurus, which had long been thought to be otherwise arise. One pertinent example, first appearing here, dully crestless. Equally surreal would have been the hyperelon- is the discovery of the differing head/body proportions of Pter- gated, superslender head of Moganopterus, which looks like it is anodon, one species of which was startlingly big beaked. The out of an avant-garde Looney Tunes cartoon. Then there would overall result is a work that covers what is already well over two have been the weirdly twisted beak of Cycnorhamphus. Plus the centuries of scientific investigation into the group of tetrapods novel formations, at least to my eyes and ears, of Dolomia di that inhabited the skies for up to 170 million years. Enjoy the Forni, Nugget Sandstone, Zorzino, Tiaojishan, Yixian, Jiufotang, travel back in time. Tangshang, Toolebuc, Bissekty, Densus Ciula, Csebanya, Jagu, Santana, Crato, and Javelina. The sheer number of new ptero- saurs would tell that an explosion in pterosaur discoveries and Acknowledgments research, well beyond anything that had previously occurred, and often based on new high technologies, marked the end of the twentieth century going into the twenty-first. Many thanks to those who have provided the assistance over Confirmed would be the long-held speculation that the years that has made this book possible, including Peter Well- pterosaurs—often called pterodactyls by the public (but those nhofer, Wann Langston, Paul MacCready, Alec Brooks, Asier are just a portion of the group)—were not reptiles limited to Larramendi, Kenneth Carpenter, Michael Brett-Surman, Frank gliding and weakly powered flight, but highly energetic fliers like Boothman, Brian Andres, Kevin Padian, David Peters, Michael their distant archosaur relatives the birds, as well as mammalian Habib, Sandra Chapman, David Martill, Robert Telleria, and bats. And, like bats, pterosaurs were covered with fuzz. How others. I would also like to thank all those who worked on pterosaurs got around when not in the air has long been this book for Princeton University Press: Robert Kirk, Abigail contentious—trackways have shown that they often walked on Johnson, Kathleen Cioffi, Layla Mac Rory, Steven Sears, and all fours like bats, but the situation is otherwise complicated. Namrita and David Price-Goodfellow. Pterosaurs are often seen as living in warm Mesozoic climes, but some at least visited chilly polar regions and high altitudes. 6 0011 PPtteerroossaauurrss iinnttrroo ppaaggeess 11--9955..iinndddd 66 1155//0099//22002211 1122::2200 I N T R O D U C T I O N 0011 PPtteerroossaauurrss iinnttrroo ppaaggeess 11--9955..iinndddd 77 1155//0099//22002211 1111::3300 Anhanguera 0011 PPtteerroossaauurrss iinnttrroo ppaaggeess 11--9955..iinndddd 88 1155//0099//22002211 1111::3300 HISTORY OF DISCOVERY AND RESEARCH Pterosaur remains have been found by humans for millennia area were discovered, first by Othniel Marsh and soon after by and may have helped form the basis for belief in mythical beasts, his equally notorious competitor Edward Cope, the often largely including winged dragons. In the prescientific West, the claim complete skulls and skeletons of the classic, largest known ptero- in the Genesis creation story that the planet and all life were saur—and future star of feature films—Pteranodon. With wings formed just two or three thousand years before the great Egyp- spanning 6.4 m (21 ft), it was a monster of the skies. At the turn tian pyramids were built hindered the scientific study of fossils. of the next century, the much less enormous Nyctosaurus was The discovery and subsequent detailed illustration of the virtu- found in the same beds, but unfortunately, those specimens did ally complete and articulated skull and skeleton of the small not include its amazing head crest. Pterodactylus found in fine-grained Lagerstätte sediments of Ba- After the loss of Seeley early in the 1900s, the new century saw varia in the late 1700s began modern pterosaur paleozoology an extended slowdown in the paleozoology of pterosaurs. Good decades before the discovery of teeth and a few bones led to the specimens continued to emerge from Europe, especially from the recognition of land-bound dinosaurs in the 1820s. The strange Bavarian quarries, but nothing particularly novel. The same was pterodactyl skeleton posed a major problem for early science true for the American plains, where Pteranodon specimens with because it was still thought that major extinctions had not oc- broader, more erect crests than the better-known, more backward- curred. The creature had a hyperelongated single finger, which bladed structures showed up. The onset of the age of aviation did was radically different from the feathery airfoils of birds and also inspire a pre–Great War study on the aerodynamics of the big quite distinctive from the multifingered wings of bats. Nor did pterosaurs, which were not all that much smaller than the first the very long, spike-toothed jaws belong to either group. airplanes. And in the 1920s, Tilly Edinger did innovative work In the early 1800s, various researchers believed that the pecu- on the avian-like structure of pterosaur brains. In the 1950s a liar fossil, as well as more remains found in the Bavarian quarries fossil trackway was attributed to a pterosaur, but this assignment that would later produce the feather-winged dinobird Archaeop- was disputed and little was done with it. Overall, remarkably teryx, belonged to flippered swimmers, or to mammalian bats, little effort was expended on better understanding of pterosaur perhaps of a marsupial nature. However, in the first decade of biology and flight, and a similar disturbing lack of vigorous sci- the 1800s, the famed comparative anatomist Georges Cuvier ence afflicted the study of dinosaurs during the same period. Like realized that pterosaurs were a distinctive group that used the dinosaurs, pterosaurs were seen as an extinct group, good for get- single elongated finger to support a flight membrane. The new ting crowds through museum doors, but not of great biological German remains further showed that there were two major sub- importance. And their origins remained vexingly obscure. The groups of pterosaurs—the long-tailed rhamphorhynchoids epito- two superwars and grim economic troubles did not help matters. mized by Rhamphorhynchus, and the short-tailed pterodactyloids Again in parallel to dinosaur science, pterosaur science started to epitomized by Pterodactylus. English sediments began to produce revive in the 1960s and 1970s. In China, despite extreme political pterosaurs, some found by the famed early field paleozoologist strife, new pterosaurs such as Dsungaripterus were described. Mary Anning, and others described by Richard Owen, who de- Meanwhile, in Argentina the remarkable Pterodaustro, which cided that the ancient fliers were low-energy reptiles. In the later sported long, slender, reverse flamingo-like filter-feeding jaws, was 1800s, Harvey Seeley became the leading pterosaur expert. He revealed. Of much greater paleobiological importance was the concluded that because pterosaurs had fully developed wings publication of the central Asian Sordes. The specimen was a typical like birds and bats, they should have had similarly high meta- small pterosaur, but what was remarkable was that it included an bolic rates and were therefore not classic reptiles. This led to extensive covering of fur-like fibrous insulation, solid evidence a bitter dispute between Owen and Seeley. At about the same for an elevated metabolic rate. That boosted the hypothesis that time, it was realized that fossil thecodonts, as well as crocodil- pterosaurs were energetic at the same time that this same idea ians, dinosaurs, birds, and pterosaurs, are all archosaurs. was being applied to dinosaurs. Peter Wellnhofer conducted an The pterosaurs coming out of Europe were generally small extensive examination of the anatomy and biology of pterosaurs, forms, often very well preserved, from the Jurassic period of the German and otherwise. During this preliminary pterosaur middle Mesozoic, but some less complete English fossils showed renaissance, attention was again directed toward giant pterosaur that Early Cretaceous pterodactyloids were of considerable size, flight, with the conclusion that pterosaurs were superlight aircraft competitive with and even exceeding the size of the largest living that wafted around in the light airs of the warm and calm Mesozoic. birds. What caused some head scratching was that these remains The stunning event that truly ignited the second golden age were too fragmentary to reveal the identity of what seemed like of pterosaur paleozoology was the announcement in 1975 of an bizarre rounded snouts and other oddities. Pterosaurian gigan- extreme pterosaur, Quetzalcoatlus, from just before the end of the tism was confirmed when the focus of pterosaur paleozoology Mesozoic in Texas. Although the early wingspan estimates were shifted to the newly open plains of North America. In the de- too high by as much as a factor of two, it was soon settled that posits of the Late Cretaceous seaway that had then covered the these ultrafliers were borne by wings spanning 10 to 12 m (33 9 0011 PPtteerroossaauurrss iinnttrroo ppaaggeess 11--9955..iinndddd 99 1155//0099//22002211 1111::3300