SANDGROUSE Volume 19 1997 (1) ORNITHOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF THE MIDDLE EAST OSME ORNITHOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF THE MIDDLE EAST OSME OSME was founded in 1978 Publications : : as the successor to the OSME publishes a scientific journal, Sandgrouse, containing Ornithological Society of papers, news and features on all aspects of Middle Eastern Turkey. Its primary aims are: ornithology. Published twice yearly, it is issued free to To collect, collate, and members. Further copies are available for sale from OSME. publish data on all aspects Meetings of the birds of the An Annual General Meeting is held in London at which guest Middle East. speakers provide new perspectives on ornithology in the To promote an interest region. There are also occasional special meetings, some in ornithology and bird taking place outside the UK. conservation throughout Projects the Middle East. i OSME organises field expeditions to collect data on birds in To develop productive little-known parts of the region and in areas where OSME can working relationships assist by teaming up with local groups. with other governmental and non-governmental The Conservation & Research Committee grants funds to organisations with an valuable field projects and desk studies which further interest in conservation knowledge and conservation of birds in the region. Grants and/or natural history have been awarded to over 30 projects since the Conservation in the region. & Research Fund was set up in 1982. Membership OSME is open to all, and its Vice Presidents: membership spans over 40 Prof. Abdulaziz H. Abuzinada, B. Behrouzi-Rad, countries. Sherif Baha El Din, Prof. W. Buttiker, Annual membership Shaika Noora Bint Major M. D. Gallagher, MBE Individual £12 (£15 air mail outside Europe) Isa Bin Sulman Al Khalifa, Dr Saeed Mohamed, Family £15 Lord Barber of Tewkesbury, N. Yazgan (£18 air mail) for two, plus £3 for each additional family member. Council as at March 1997: Supporting £24 Dr G. Allport R. P. Martins (co-opted) & Cover the subscription of a Conservation Research Turkey Bird Report national birdwatcher in the A. Colston R. Parslow region (£27 air mail). Treasurer Membership Life Membership P. Davidson H. Scott (co-opted) Individual £225 Information Officer Publications Officer (£100 if 60 or over) A. Grieve F. E. Warr (co-opted) Family £300 Publicity Officer Sales for 2 members. Dr D. Harvey G. R. Welch Please add £3 ifpaymentis made Features Editor Chairman in non-sterlingcurrency. Fordetails A. Morris H. Welch (co-opted) ofpayment by banker's order, and J. J. for any otherinformation on the Secretary Librarian Society, write to the Secretary at the address below. c/o THE LODGE, SANDY, BEDFORDSHIRE SG19 2DL, UK OSME Web site - http://www.netlink.co.uk/users/ag/osme/osmehome.html Contents Sandgrouse OSME News 2 Volume 19 (1) 3 News and Information 7 Requests for Information Editor Features Guy M. Kirwan 8 Observations of Dunn's Larks Eremalauda dunni in the Ramlat al-Sab'atayn, Republic of Yemen C. D. R. Heard Features Editor and Guy M. Kirwan, on behalf of tfie OSME South Derek Harvey Yemen expedition Assistant Editor 12 Birding in the Goksu Delta, south Turkey Hilary Welch Ian J. Andrews 16 Profile Major Michael Gallagher MBE Derek Harvey Editorial Committee Duncan J. Brooks, 18 Photospot Mike Evans, Ben Hoare, White-eyed and Sooty Gulls on the Red Sea coast of Mike Jennings, Saudi Arabia Dr. Graham R. Lobley Rodney Martins Papers and Notes & Dr Stephen Newton 22 The birds of the islands at the mouth of the Gulf of Suez, Photographic Editor Egyptian Red Sea Richard Hoath, Dr Derek Russell, Paul Doherty Rafik Khalil and Dina Khalil A & 30 list of bird specimens held in the Robert's College, Design Production Bebek (Istanbul, Turkey) collection, with some comments Harry Scott I. on Mathey-Dupraz (1920-24) Guy M. Kirwan Identification Consultants 39 Five new bird species in Bahrain Michal Skakuj and C. G. Bradshaw, Tadeusz Stawarczyk Arnoud B. van den Berg & Steve Madge 45 Breeding birds of the Taurus foothills bordering the Goksu Delta, south Turkey Jan van der Winden and Vincent van den Berk 51 Preliminary observations of the incubation and covey behaviour of Houbara Bustard Chlamydotis undulata macqueenii Frederic Launay, Ronald A. Loughland and Elena Mukhina 56 Birds new to Qatar Bob Nation, Helen Nation and Andrew Hooper 63 The second-calendar year plumage of Crab Plover Dromas ardeola Michal Skakuj, Erik Hirschfeld, Jan Lontkowski and Tadeusz Stawarczyk 65 Graceful Prinia Prinia gracilis colonisation of Kuwait C W. T. Pilcher, W. A. Stuart and S. T. Spencer 68 The first Red-fronted Serin Serinus pusillus in Jordan Fares Khoury 68 New information on the breeding biology of Cover Photograph: Cretzschmar's Bunting Emberiza caesia Peter Castell Sooty Falcon Falco concolor, & Hawar Island, Bahrain 70 Reviews Recent Literature taken by Dr. Mike Hill 76 Around the Region OSME isgratefulforsponsorship P. Davidson and G. M. Kirwan fromJulian Francis towards thecost ofprintingthecolourphotographs inside this issue. 1 Sandgrouse 19 (1): 1997 OSME AT THE BIRDFAIR OSME once again manned a successful stand at the 1996 British Birdwatching Fair at Rutland Water, Leics: 33 new members were recruited, sales items especially the new, multi-colour sandgrouse tee-shirt proved popular and visiting luminaries included former society chairman Richard Porter and Israeli birder par excellence Hadoram Shirihai. OSME would like to extend its warm thanks to Paul Doherty of Bird Images Videoguides for the use of his excellent video footage from a recent trip to Turkey, which was a popular feature of the displays. RECORDS OF RARE BIRDS The most recent (October 1996) newsletter of the Association of European Rarities Committees (AERC) contains details of the 1997 meeting, to be held in the Slovak Republic on 18-22 July. It also provides guidelines to magazines and journals, such as Sandgrouse, which publish details of recent rarity sightings. Four points are raised by the AERC: records of rare birds are being published without prior substantiation; faulty records (e.g. records later rejected by the Plate 1. The OSME stand at the British Birdwatching Fair, responsible Rarities Committee) are Rutland Water, Leics.. August 1996 with from leftto right: Lilly subsequently not being rectified; details of Shirihai, Hadoram Shirihai, Richard Porterand GeoffWelch. {Geoff& Hilary Welch) rare birds appearing in a birding magazine very often do not reach the appropriate national Rarities Committee; secondary Thinking of citations of news section reports are being more and more often used without being OSME? OSME AERC joining checked. fully supports the in taking this strong line, the compilers of Around the Region already make every effort to follow similar guidelines and to this end Enjoy a year's membership for only £12! work in co-operation with a number of OSME national committees. We would like to urge any similar bodies, operational in the OSME promotes the study and conservation ofbirds throughout the Middle East region, to forward accepted records for encourages the standardised recording of publication in Around the Region, in order bird observations that this feature can be as complete and brings together knowledge of the region's accurate as possible. Photographs substan- birdlife tiating such records are also welcome. Anyone maintains a conservation and research fund with knowledge of records, previously to support small-scale projects by members publishes Sandgrouse twice a year, sent to all published in Sandgrouse but subsequently members rejected by the relevant national body, are also invited to contact the compilers as soon as To join, write to: Membership Secretary, possible. OSME c/o The Lodge, Sandy, Bedfordshire, SG19 2DL U.K. 2 News and Information NEWS INFORMATION T/ze flzm 0/ this section is to inform readers about proposals for tourism and development in the events in the OSME region. It relies on members area. The wetland complex is most notable for and others supplying relevant news and its breeding population of herons, ibises, information. If you have anything concerning egrets and wildfowl, including the globally birds, conservation or development issues in the threatened Marbled Teal Marmoronetta OSME area please send it to News and angustirostris. It also supports vast migratory Information, OSME, c/o The Eodge, Sandy, and wintering populations of pelicans, Bedfordshire SG19 IDE, U.K. wildfowl, storks and birds of prey. Current plans include provision for intensive boating This section is not intended as a definitive report and commercial activities with the aim of or write up of the projects concerned. Many of the bringing up to 14,000 visitors a day to the projects are sponsored; such support is appreciated area. The Society for the Protection of Nature but is not generally given acknowledgement here. in Israel has requested that the planning authorities relocate commercial activities away from the Valley and to limit the number CYPRUS of tourists that visit the areas of wildlife Birding information The Cyprus Ornithological conservation importance. BirdLife has written Society (1957) has provided an Information to the Israeli Ministry of Tourism in support Centre and telephone 'Birdline' service. This of the SPNI request. (Source: Network News 4 is continuing but with the following (3).) alterations: the Information Centre (open SAUDI ARABIA daily from 10.00 to 12.30) has moved from the A Apollo Hotel, Katopaphos to the adjacent Houbara Bustard draft agreement for the taverna on the Lighthouse Road. The Cyprus conservation and management of the Birdline has a new number: Paphos 233707. Houbara Bustard Chlamydotis undulata has been approved by the National Commission These services are provided free of charge to for Wildlife Conservation and Development visitors but please send in your sightings, and is to be distrubuted to the species' Range preferably before you leave Cyprus to Jeff States through diplomatic channels. The Gordon, Director Information Centre, PO Box agreement, which relates to the Asiatic 1129, 8131 Kato Paphos, Cyprus. subspecies C. u. macqueenii, was developed as an initiative by the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia EGYPT under the auspices of the Bonn Convention, in which the Houbara Bustard is listed as Sinai Wildlife Projects have been campaigning requiring special attention to restore its for the protection of White Storks Ciconia population to a more favourable state. This ciconia on migration through Egypt. They international agreement is based on the need have produced a leaflet in English, Arabic, for increased international cooperation for the German and Italian explaining the interna- conservation and management of the tional importance of the White Stork and what people can do to protect them. A bustards. (Source: Network News 4 (3).) rehabilitation centre to treat sick and injured Saudi Arabia joins CITES Saudi Arabia acceded birds has been established in Sharm El to the Convention on International Trade in Sheikh, South Sinai. Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora (CITES) on 12 March 1996 (effective on 10 ISRAEL June 1996). The total number of parties to The Hula Valley in Israel, of international CITES is now 131. (Source: Traffic USA 19 in importance for its wildlife, is threatened by Oryx 30 (4).) Simon Albrecht Sandgrouse 19 (1): 1997 TURKEY that the harvest of snopdrops and winter Global 500 awards Congratulations to Mrs aconites would be on sale in the UK in Nergis Yazgan, OSME Vice-President and autumn 1996 which saw the publication of General Director of DHKD and to Dr Tansu the third edition of FFI's Tlw Good Bulb Guide, Gurpinar, DHKD's Ankara representative as which lists bulb retailers and exporters who well as to the Garanti Bank, who are DHKD's show a responsible attitude towards wild- collected bulbs. Companies who sign up main sponsor, on their 1996 Global 500 Awards from the United Nations either pledge "Never to knowingly sell wild- Environment Programme (UNEP). collected bulbs" or to label such bulbs as "From wild source". For the first time there is New Turkish reserve 6787 ha of the Eregli now a US version of The Good Bulb Guide in collaboration with the American marshes have been designated a Strict Nature Reserve following campaigning by conserva- Horticultural Society. (Source: Fauna and Flora tionists. The marshes have suffered many News 6, October 1996.) years of degradation from pollution and UNITED ARAB EMIRATES decreased freshwater input. The area provides an important stop-over and The Federal Environment Agency (reported in breeding habitat for many species of water Sandgrouse 18 (1)) is known as the UAE bird including Pygmy Cormorant Environment and Wildlife Research and Phalacrocorax pygmeus, White Pelican Development Agency and is based in Abu Pelecanus onocrotalus and White-headed Duck Dhabi with branches throughout the Oxyura leucocephala. (Source: BirdLife in Europe Emirates. The agency will monitor the natural May 1996, 6 in Oryx 30 (4).) environment and its biodiversity, and conduct scientific research for the Turkish bird names standardised At a meeting improvement and protection of the held in Ankara on 4-5 November 1995, an environment. It will also conduct environ- agreed list of Turkish bird names for species mental impact assessments for industrial and recorded within the country was formally economic projects in the emirate of Abu adopted, with the support and under the Dhabi. A further role will be to propose auspices of DHKD and the Ankara Bird protected areas for wildlife and manage areas Group (AKGT). Six representatives attended once they are established. Education and the meeting, including the Director-General spreading awareness about wildlife is also of the National Parks network, Serhan Goksu, high on the new agency's agenda. as well as several of the authors of the six lists of Turkish bird names previously in IBA updates About 20 large signs appeared circulation. The new, standardised list was round the roadside lagoon at Ramtha Tip (a published in August 1996 by AKGT and UAE Important Bird Area) in August 1996. DHKD and is available from the latter: The signs read "Sharjah Municipality, Bird DHKD, P. K. 18. 80810 Bebek-Istanbul, Protection Area. Anyone found shooting or Turkey. (Contributed by DHKD) disturbing birds will be prosecuted." Management of this area is an issue that Sustainable bulb harvest Flora and Fauna BirdLife has pursued with the Ruler of International (FFI) saw the fruition of their Sharjah. Indigenous Propagation Project in May 1996. Over 200 villagers at Dumlugoze in the The outlook for Huylayla Island, part of an Taurus Mountains celebrated their first extensive area of mangroves, coastal dunes harvest of propagated bulbs. The harvest and marshes, is not so good. There has been a followed five years of collaboration between recent announcement to construct an FFI and DHKD to stem the trade in wild industrial and commercial free zone on the bulbs from Turkey. The villagers used to island. The island has some of the declining collect wild bulbs in the mountains but have number of lagoons that remain along the now been shown how to propagate their own coast and is one of the few areas where bulbs. This has relieved the pressure on wild mangroves flourish in the UAE. (Source: populations as well as providing the villagers Network News 4 (3).) with a higher, and sustainable, income. It is hoped that other villages will be encouraged to follow Dumlugoze's success. It was hoped 4 Simon Albrecht News and Information BARCELONA CONVENTION Five Nature Reserves proposed After three months of research in the UAE mountains by Mediterranean action plan The contracting Chris and Tilde Stuart of the African Arabian parties to the Convention for the Protection of Wildlife Research Centre the following have the Mediterranean Sea against Pollution have been proposed as nature reserves: Rus al Jebel adopted a number of amendments to the (important for Arabian Leopards), Mediterranean Plan of Action. The Shimaliyyah (important for Arabian Leopard convention now includes the concept of and Arabian Tahr), Khor Kalba (important for sustainable development and a new protocol birds and now approved as a nature reserve on specially protected areas and biological by HH Dr. Sheikh Sultan bin Mohammed al diverstiy in the Mediterranean. (Source: Qasimi), Khor al Baydah (coral reefs, seagrass Naturopa Newsletter No. 96-1,2 in Oryx 30 (4).) beds and wildlife area of Siniya island), near Jebel Ali in Dubai (gazelles need protecting ARABIAN PLANT SPECIALIST from ongoing development). (Source: Gazelle GROUP 11 (10) October 1996.) An Arabian Plant Specialist Group (APSG) has ABBA SURVEYS 13-16: TO SAUDI been established to promote plant conser- ABABIA AND OMAN, 1992-4 vation in the Arabian peninsula. Judging by the report we have seen on the workshop that OSME The library has received the following founded the group, this is clearly an ABBA report: Results of four ornithological important development for plant conser- surveys to the Southern Tihama of Saudi Arabia, vation in the area. Unfortunately we have no North Eastern Saudi Arabia, Northern Oman and contact address for anyone wishing to contact North Western Saudi Arabia during the period the APSG but hope to publish one in the December 1992 to April 1994. The report future if it is sent to us. Abdulaziz Abuzinada ABBA presents information collected during is Chair of the APSG and one of the Vice- Surveys 13 to 16 and is published by the Chairs is Dr. A. Miller of the Edinburgh National Commission for Wildlife Botanical Garden, Edinburgh, Scotland, UK. Conservation and Development, Riyadh as (Source: Species 26-27.) their Technical Report No. 36. Copies are available (price £12.00 including postage) BALD IBIS from Michael Jennings, Warners Farm, 1 In the last issue we reported on the death of Warners Drove, Somersham, Cambridgeshire We 38 Bald Ibis Geronticus eremita in Morocco. PE17 3HW, U.K. have still not heard of any definite cause of A similar report on ABBA surveys 17 to 19 to death. Viruses have been ruled out but poWste- Saudi Arabia and Oman in March 1995 to mortems have given no clear indications. have not yet heard the the final results of April 1996 is in preparation. pesticide analysis but early results gave no WORLD CONFERENCE ON BIRDS OF clear answer. When we have further PREY AND OWLS - AUGUST 1998 information we shall report it. In the meantime if anyone has any reports or The World Working Group on Birds of Prey and sightings from anywhere in the Middle East Owls will be holding a World Conference region, will they please send a report to from 4 to 11 August 1998 in Midrand, OSME. Johannesburg, South Africa. Further information from: Mr Robin Chancellor, 15b Bolton Gardens, London SW5 OAL, U.K. Fax: Int+44-171-370-1896, or Dr Bernd-U. Meyburg, Wangenheimstrasse 32, 14193 Berlin, Germany. Fax: Int+30-892-8067, or Dr Gerhard H. Verdoorn, PO Box 72155, Parkview 2122, Johannesburg, South Africa. Fax: Int+27-11-646-4631. Simon Albrecht 5 Sandgrouse 19(1): 1997 The dependable, experienced, worldwide mail order book service. Specialists in all aspects of the natural sciences, birdlife and wildlife, plus travel books, guides and maps. Including all books in SANDGROUSE. print as advertised in PISTYLL FARM, NERCWYS, Nr. MOLD, FLINTSHIRE FREE CH7 4EW, UK TEL: +44 (0)1352 756551 CATALOGUE 1997 FAX: +44 (0)1352 756004 ON REQUEST E-mail: [email protected]. 6 Requests for Information The BIRDS of the Hashemite Kingdom of REQUESTS JORDAN vr INFORMATIfOt N "by IcUi. <JT# j^kxiiclire'vv^s ThB Birds ofthe Hashemite Kingdom of / Jordan, is tne first comprehensive summary of the status and distribution ofail 374 bird species recorded in Jordan. Arabic bird names Foreword byHisMajestyKingHusseinI Dr Omar Al-Saghier, BirdLife International's Description""to all habitat t>pes accompanied by 30 photographs representative for Yemen is currently working T1i6m0 LBiorsdebpyhoatnodgroatphhesrsby the author, on a list of Arabic bird names that can be iDnetfaoirlmeadtisopnecoineswhacecroeunatnsd,wgihveinngeuapc-htos-pdeactiees universally agreed. He will be consulting with occurs all leading ornithologists in the Arabic- * Breeding distribution maps Migration timingemits speaking world but in the meantime if anyone FDuelrlaiJloerddbainrdcwheactkclhiisntgsitesguide, with maps wishes to contact him in respect of this issue illustrations byJohn Busby his address is: Dr Omar Al-Saghier, P. O. Box £18.50 13330, Sana'a, Republic of Yemen; fax. + 967 1 (plus £1 ,50 P&P UK, ,£2.50 Europe, £4.35 205299. elsewhere) Bird lore and bird mythology Enquiries andorders totheauthor/pwAisl\er: Mark Cocker is currently collecting I.J. Andrews, 39 Clauknouvs Drive, information for a book on the mythology and Musselburgh. Midlothian EH2 6UW, 1 lore associated with birds from around the Scotland S 0131-665 0236 world. He is interested in the cultural associ- ations that birds have acquired both in an historical and contemporary context and is especially keen to gather information on the significance birds have had for pre-industrial peoples. He is also interested in examining the cultural importance and exploitation of birds. SANDGROUSE Two examples are the pre-Colombian Aztec feather art and use of birds-of-paradise in Papua New Guinea ceremonial dress. Any data on these themes would be gratefully received and fully acknowledged in any publication. Please contact: Mark Cocker, 9 Primrose Road, Thorpe Hamlet, Norwich NR1 4AT, Norfolk, U. K. tel./fax. +44 (0)1603 611797. Photographs wanted To illustrate forthcoming articles in Sandgrouse we are in need of good quality photographs (preferably slides) of Black Vulture, Greater BLACK & WHITE ADVERT RATES and Lesser Sand Plovers, all species of sandgrouse occurring in the region, and Full page: 21Omm tall x 135 wide £80 Radde's and Arabian Accentors. We would Half page: 100mm tall x 135 wide £40 also welcome shots of any Middle Eastern Quarter page: 100mm tall x 61 wide £30 birds for possible front covers or inside FULL-COLOUR ADVERT RATES Sandgrouse. Please ensure that all slides show FBualclkpacgoev:er: 2214O5mmmm ttaallll xx 113750 wwiiddee ££347200 itdheeapllhyotowghrearpehera'nsd nwamhee,nthite swpaescietsakaennd. Submissions should be sent to Paul Doherty, Flyers & Insert: Please call for details 28 Carousel Walk, Sherburn in Elmet, North Yorks LS25 6LP, U.K. Simon Albrecht Sandgrouse 19 (1): 8-11 1997 Observations of Dunn's Lark Eremalauda dunni in the Ramlat al-Sab'atayn, Yemen Republic of C. D. R. HEARD AND GUY M. KIRWAN, ON BEHALF OF THE OSME SOUTH YEMEN EXPEDITION Dunn's Lark Eremalauda dunni inhabits desert areas along the southern edge of the Sahara, from Mauritania east through Mali, Niger and Chad to Sudan and north-east to Arabia (Sibley & Monroe 1990) where it is apparently largely nomadic and most widespread in north and central Saudi Arabia (Jennings 1995). Its identifi- cation, poorly understood until the late 1980s, was discussed by Round & Walsh (1981), Tye (1988), Shirihai et al. (1990) and Shirihai (1994). In Yemen there are seven records: singles collected at Sheikh Othman near Aden on 15 January 1922 Umm (Meinertzhagen 1923), al Samr, east of Mushainiqa by Philby on 5 August 1936 (Bates 1938, specimen in BMNH, Tring) and Zumukh, Hadramawt on 31 October 1950 (Guichard & Goodwin 1952) with sight records of one near Marib dam on 2 December 1985 (Brooks et al. 1987), 25 between Shabwah and Marib on 6 May 1993, three 30 km south of al-'Abr on 13 January 1994 (Martins et al 1996) and at least six in the Empty Quarter on 5 November 1996 (D. Farrow pers. comm.). THE OBSERVATIONS 1993 metres a.s.l.) with an extensive covering of On 6 May 1993 the OSME expedition crossed annual grasses e.g. Aristida sp. and Cyperus the Ramlat al-Sab'atayn from Shabwah to the conglomerate with abundant herbs, including tarmac road connecting the Safir oilfields and Indigofera sp. and Tribulus sp.; the lowest- Marib (c. 80 km). This route was through lying areas also had perennials such as increasingly arid and virtually treeless, pure Panicum turgidum (a grass) and Dipterygium sand desert apart from the occasional glaucum (a low bushy herb). Sodom's Apple Solatium sp. bush. However, Midway across the desert stretch the dunes the first third of the journey crossed rolling sand dunes covered with a fresh green became less undulating and the grasses sparser, interspersed with spiny succulents. growth of ephemeral grasses, doubtless the A result of exceptional rains during the further 18 Dunn's Larks were identified previous six weeks (reputedly the first rain in from the road in these areas. The last Dunn's Larks were seen in the final dry grass area, this area for four years). with none in the open desert beyond this Remarkably few bird species were point. It seems reasonable to assume that the species vacates areas where the vegetation encountered but, soon after entering the grass-covered dunes, the first of many has died back and that their apparent close Dunn's Larks was spotted from the vehicles association with this ephemeral habitat may and c. seven apparently territorial birds were be the key factor in Dunn's Lark's nomadic soon located in an area of c. three km 2 breeding distribution. The only other bird Although only brief bursts of song and. species seen during the crossing of the Ramlat al-Sab'atayn were Hoopoe Lark display flight were noted, they were clearly unwilling to leave the area. When disturbed Alaemon alaudipes (four), Black-crowned they flew a short distance and then ran on the Finch Lark Eremopterix nigriceps (four in area bare sand between grass tufts, before of tor-like, rocky outcrops close to the former border between North and South Yemen), a invariably taking shelter in the shade of one of the thicker plants (usually quickly making female Rock Thrush Monticola saxatilis, a Whitethroat Sylvia communis, seven Great a scrape to nestle in). The area in which the first Dunn's Larks were observed was part of Grey Shrike Lanius excubitor and a House a vast system of mobile sand dunes (c. 1000 Bunting Emberiza striolata. 8 C. D. R. Heard and Guy M. Kirwan