Table Of Content

Index 823 Abuse of process, Belize extradition, 557 death pr enalty 52-553 Administration of justice, Book reviews, appeals and access to court, 349-350 Always on the Same Path—Essays on Foreign appointments, 154 Law and Comparative Methodology Basil S conditional fee agreements, 152 Markesinis, 585-587 criminal courts, 153, 350 Civil Rights: New Labour, Freedom and the illegally obtained evidence, 549 Human Rights Act Helen Fenwick, injunction to protect integrity, 547 384—386 judges, Constitutional Justice: A Liberal Theory of the complaints about, 350 Rule of Law T.R.S. Allan, 379-381 juries, Devolution Noreen Burrows, 588-59 allegations made after sentencing, 350 Discrimination Law—Text, Cases and Materials permission to alter answers, 153 Aileen McColgan, 194-195 legal aid, Membership and the Judicialization of suspension of certificate, 548-549 British Politics Danny Nicol, 792-794 legal representation, Governing By Numbers: Delegated Legislation availability, 152 ind Everyday Policy-Making Edward (¢ Page, 590-591 fairness of trial, 152 muscarriage of justice, 548 Implementing Amsterdam Elspeth Guild and Carol Harlow (Fds), 193-194 precedent, ial Activism in India: Transgressing Borders Court of Apper al, conflictingss decisions of, 549 1 Enforcing Limits S.P. Sathe, 389-39 Legitimate Expectations in Administrative Lau previous decision of two-judge court, 35 Soren Schonberg, 591-593 reasonable time, hearings within, 153 itimate Expectations and Proportionality in settled law, power of court to overturn, Administrative Law Robert Thomas, 547-548 19 Sexual Offences (Procedure and Evidence Refugees, Race and the Legal Concept of Asylum (Scotland) Act 2002, 547 n Britain Prakash Shah, 790-791 undue delay, effect of, 349 Regulating Financial Markets in the 21st Century unfair trials, 153 E. Ferran and C.A.E. Goodhart (Eds), vexatious litigants, 152 & Administrative Court, 369 wd Risk: Occupational Health and Adoption, m the Railways Bridget Hutter, human rights, 363-364 Advertising, ays n Human Rights lo n tobacco, 22—30 ipbell, K.D. Ewing and Adam Aggravated trespass, 184 Eds), 789-790 Appeals, Seeking A ylum in the UK: Problems and access to court, 349-350 Prospects Colin Harvey, 587-588 immigration, 366 Sexuality in the Legal Arena Carl Stychin and legal aid, 415-421 Didi Herman (Eds), 594-595 permission, 362 Social Law and Policy in an Evolving European Asylum seekers, Union Jo Shaw (Ed), 386-389 detention of, 17 The Birth of a European Constitutional Order reform proposals, 176 Jiirgen Schwarze (Ed), 191-193 [2002] PL. Winrer © Sweet & MAXWELL AND CONTRIBUTORS 824 Index Book reviews—cont onstitutional law—ront The Government of Risk: Understanding Risk separation of powers, 15¢ Regulation Regimes Christopher Hood, ‘orporal punishment, 174 Henry Rothstein and Robert Baldwin, -ouncil on Tribunals, 381-384 annual report, 156 The Law of Human Rights Richard Clayton ourts martial, 168, 56¢ and Hugh Tomlinson, 190-191 A“Kr iminal courts The Office of Lord Chancellor Diana administration of justice, | 53 Woodhouse, 593-594 Auld Report i Tort Law & Human Rights Jane W Lord Ch incehor § review, 1‘ 53- -i 794-796 row! Breach of injunction, Commonwealth systems, 4 | confidentiality, 155 Crown Proceedings Act 1 347. 55 554 Breach of peace, 183-184 stoppel per rem iu licatam 415~9 c47 ? || Broadcasting, mmunity Office of Communications Act 2 eclarat f incompat y 4I6D4 ibstantive law, 554 remedy against ¢ *itizen’s Charter, 9-1129 —i tizenship » British Dependent Territories, 571 2 eecct uon ivil Service t Common 4 Civil Service Act, case for, 559—5¢ al s9_cc special advis« rs, lo ~~ ymditional tee agreements ii veaitl 4 riot it 7R—H® xt din 54 Confidentiality breach of injunction, 155 Jetama disc losure of personal information Te it ( freedom of information Jer ra health care worker, protection Dice AV 48 Interception of ¢ Commmiimsiussisoionnee r $s reeyn ort at ecurity ional privuege ive rds aisck sure ! ai iw rets Act daeten Dic A.V., 48-5 " ar ndard 43 " lit te < tla 3K A As erai, f Dicey, A.\ adi 40-43 ie i +5 1¢ 48 Hi Rig! A he] 4/ 4s egitimate expecta i if ve * ‘ naturahsath state liability for defective functioning of i t law ustice, 782 TRE Dis ty discr at Constitutional a yuNntabaility TI ) 1 ‘ See also Minusterial responsibil lisat \ s reconstruction a party pe dy 1ppointme Advocate General, interv Travel ¢ sions (Elig Church d State, relationship between vict at 1 death penalty, 552-553 Di sei devolution, 351 acce 203 European Communities Act 11907729, 351 mit thorirt ) ? + [2002] PL. Winter C Sweet & MAXWELL AND CONTRIB rOR‘ 19> Index 825 WEI & MAXwWEL! a 826 Index Health and medical treatment—vront. Human rights—cont duty to give reasons, 560 fair trial, right to—ront Human Reproductive Clening Act 2001, 162 civil juries, 564-565 medical profession, regulation of, 703-723 housing cases, 563 Mental Health Act and ECHR, 358 independence of tribunal, 360, 361 reconsideration of decision by tribunal, interruptions by judge, 362 560-561 licensing cases, 564 Remedial Order 2001, 561 planning cases, 563-564 witness protection, 166-167 public safety certificates, 562-563 Health Service Commissioner, representation, right to, 562 report, 572 victim, meaning of, 358-359 Hong Kong, family life, right to, substantive legitimate expectations, 688-702 planning control, 1 House of Commons, fitness to plead, 172 code of conduct, 573 home, right to respect for, 221-231 data protection, 179 illusory rights, interference with, 170 Deputy Speakers, 574 injustices, 473-474 duties, parliamentary, 1 ) International Covenant on Civil and Political facilities, 179-180 Rights, 485-500 Modernisation Committee, 180, 593 introductory tenancies, 172 Parliamentary Commissioner for Standards, Joint Committee, 175 179 Joint Committee on Human Rights, 365 register of interests, 371, 573, 574 licensing, 564 Speaker, impartiality of, 179 life, right to, 567 standards and privileges, 179, 574 . local authority housing, 364 sub judice, matters, 178-179 necessity, 407-414 House of Lords, nuisance, 364 reform, 178, 371, 572-573 Parliamentary scrutiny of legislation working practices, 573 penaities, imposition of, 169 Housing, police presence at interview, 17 Homeiessness Act 2002, 5¢ political background, 475-484 Housing (Scotland) Act 2001, 164 political donations, 77 1—77¢ human rights, 364 prisons, introductory tenancies, 172 discipline proceedings, 172 local connection, 164 killed in cell, prisoner, 566-567 Human rights private and family life, access to court, 171, 362 adequacy of review, 172-173 adoption, 363-364 property, interference with appeal, permission to, 362 attachment of property, 56¢ background, 475-484 nuisance, 173-174 bias, 407-414 political nature of decision, 567-568 compulsion, material delivered under, Public Law, writing in, 395-398 169-170 questioning, detention for, 167 confiscation proceedings, 360, 364-365 religion, freedom of, Convention Rights (Compliance) (Scotland cannabis use, 174 Act 2001, 164-165 retrospective effect, 165 corporal punishment, 174 security certificates, 171 courts martial, 168, 56¢ security for costs, 363 covert listening device, 171 sex offender order, 361-362 criminal offence, nature of, -167 State immunity as bar to access delay in criminal trial, 167 suicide, assisted, 16€ derogation, 174, 365 witness protection, 359 entrapment, 169 Human Rights Act 1998, equality of arms, 363 See also Human rights European Court of Human Rights, acts done before incorporation o reform proposals, 264 Convention, 165-166 extradition, 557-558 common law, 654-657 fair trial, right to, Community law and, 724-742 absence of accused, 361 constitutional impact, 438-448 burden of proof, 562 Dicey, A.V., 46-48 [2002] PL. Winter © Swerr,& MAXWELL AND CONTRIBUTORS Index 827 Human Rights Act 1998—cont Judicial review—cont economic, social and cultural impact, alternative dispute resolution, 368-369 456-472 availability, 570 first two years of, 649-662 bye-laws validity of, 368 horizontal effect, 232-241 , Carltona principle, 570 interpretative obligation, 561-562, 650-654 Convention rights, judicial review, 657-661 basis of review, 176 proportionality, 265-287 errors, Parliamentary scrutiny of legislation, 323-348 domestic tribunal, 570 parliamentary sovereignty, 359-360 errors of fact, review of, 368 proportionality, 2I655I-2R8T est ppel in exercise of powers, 23 public authority, meaning Of. 965-366 fettering of discretion. 111—129 ) > 356 tA) , } sc sovereignty of Parliament, 359—3¢ adoption of policies, 114-115 fetters on the face of the policy, 115-120 genuine policies, 124-126 Immigration, , human rights, 126-129 2 adjudicicaattoer’ s r'sd edceciissiiono n bbii nding zy onon SeScreectraertya ry « of i1)l legitimately not providing for exceptions, State, 568 116-117 appeals, 366 legitimately not providing for exceptions, asylum seekers, 117-121 } ; ; a“ changes to ~~ A/C policies, courts and adoption of, 114-115 detention of, 175 . ’ procedure, 120 House “ Lords Select Committee report, spelling out exceptions, 120-124 wu human rights, 126-129 ban on entering UK, 568-569 Human Rights Act 1998, certification, basis of, 365-366 proportionality, 265-287 deportation, 17 intial iegitumate expectation, 36 national security, 175 - ae permission to appeal, refugee status, Getermuination of, 56 : ; py ; 176 time limits, 569 rules, ) . _ Statistics, 176 ) pt lanningg law, 366-36 : F Ww p 264 prerogative remedies, 95-105 hite Paper, 366 . ; ; remedies in supervisory jurisdiction, 96-98 Information, freedom of. See Freedom of , sl caiiitinas ibstantive principles in supervisory informatio 2 , urisdictions, 95—96 Intelligence Services, Commissioner, report of,> a1c6a2 Judiciary, P International | Covenant on Civil , and Political , PpEp ointments annual otre port, 154 MS aDoUt, JDU Rights, 485-500 constitutional exceprt ionalism or 6m2e6nt-a6r3y9 privilege, attacked under, obstructionism, 492-494 ECHR and, 496-497 First Optional Protocol, ratification of, -gat«i ons ama de after sentencing, 35 497-499 ivil, 564-565 incorporation, possibility of, 495—496 defamation awards, 578 individual petitions, 490-491 ppeerrnm ission to alter ans} wers,r 115535 interpretation of obligation of state, 491-492 inter-State complaints, 488 werview, 487-491 Legal aid relevance post-HRA 1998, 494-495 . suspension ofc ertificate, 548-549 role. 499-50 Legal professional privilege, 55 State reporting system, 489-44 Legal representation, Introductory tenancies yvailability, 152 human rights, 172 fairness of trial, 152 Italy Legitimate expectation regional government idicial review, 367 lacking, 367 Licensing, Judicial review, human rights, 564 adjectival law, 98-103 Life, right to, 567 Administrative Court, 369 Local Agenda 21 process, 134-138 [2002] PL. Winter © Sweet & MAXWELL AND CONTRIBUTORS 828 Index Local government, Nuisance, 173-174 best value, 147-150 human rights, 364 Codes of Conduct, 177 community planning, 139-144 councillors, liability of, 177 Official Secrets Act, defences under, 154, executive structures, 145-147 549-550 Italy, 242-251 Ombudsmen, Local Agenda 21 process, 134-138 Financial Ombudsman Service, 640-648 new agenda for, 138--139 reports, 178, 572 powers, 369 ~ Scottish Public Services Ombudsman Act prosecute, power to, 177 2002, 572 reform, 130-151 regional government, 570-571 responsibilities, 369 Parliament sustainable development, 130-151 House of Commons. See House of White Paper, 177, 570-571 Commons Lord Chancellor, House of Lords. See House of Lords separation of powers, 15¢ Prime Minister's accountability to, 573 standards and privileges, 371 r Parliamentary Commissioner, Magistrates’ Courts, report, 572 annual report, 154 * Parliamentary Ombudsman, Medical profession, reports, 37( regulation, 703-723 . Parliamentary privilege, Medical records, disclosure of, 551 judges attacked under, 626-639 “Metric martyrs”, 399-406 Parliamentary sovereignty, Ministerial responsibility, Dicey, A.V., 43-46 amendatory responsibility, 83-86 Human Rights Act 1998, 359-360 causal responsibility, 74—7¢ Regency, 449-455 explanatory responsibility, 83-86 Parole Board, 182 generally, 73-74 - Police, incompetence, 79-83 body samples, retention of, 574 negligence, 79-83 “civilans, role of, 670-677 parliamentary questions, 573 hindering, 574 reformulation, 77-89 i informers, 180-181 reports, 357-358 interview Ministers, disclosure of information, 18( Ministerial Code, 162 interviews, visual recording of, 575 responsibility. See Ministerial responsibility mask, order to remove, 181 salaries, 162 objectives, 574 Miscarriage of justice, 548 PACE, review of, 575 powers, 180, 575 reform, 181, 372, 670-677 National security reports, 181 deportation, 175 retention of property by, 552 Natural justice search, power of, bias, extradition, 159 appeal, effect of, 571 ; Political advertising, 615-625 appearance of, 370 Political donations, 758-781 re-open case, powers to, 369-37! orruption, 761-766 councillor, conduct of, 178 treedom of expression, 771—77¢ reasons, no duty to give, 370 ‘ . human rights, 771-776 Negligence, political equality, 766-77 educational, 208-308 reforms, 776-780 New Zealand, Political party, suspension by, 352-353 remedies, 107 Precedent Non-departmental public bodies, 606-614 Court of Appeal, conflicting decisions of Northern Ireland, 549 Human Rights Commission, 572, 602-605 previous decision of two-judge court, 35 [2002] P.L. Winter © Sweet & Maxwett AND CONTRIBUTORS Index 829 Prerogative remec Scotland—vont 4ga Khan line of cases, 105 Scottish Parliament—cont characteristics, special, 103-105 judicial scrutiny, 36-38 generally, 91-92 primary legislation, 32-33 judicial review, 95-105 ‘ report, 180 Supreme Court Act 1981, 92-94 secondary legislation, 32—33 rime Minister Scottish Public Services Ombudsman Act accountability to Parliament, 573 2002, 572 rison discipline proceedings, Westminster legislation about devolved human rights, 172 natters, 501-523 risons, Scottish Commission for the Regulation of disclosure of reports, 57¢ Care, 182 disenfranchisement, 524—54¢ security tor costs, killed in cell, prisoner, 566-567 life sentence prisoners, 575, 57¢ rights, 363 mandatory life tariffs, 181-182 Separation of powers, media communications, 576 Lord Chancellor, 156 Parole Board, 182 Sex offender order, 361-362 Parole Board proc eedings, delay i Sexual relationships, private, 182 ynfidentiality, 155, 356-357 reports, 182 Spee h, freed4 om of. See Freedom of speech Scottish Prison Service annual report, Statutory interpretation, Procedure, Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act fresh evidence, 372 990, 370-371 Public appointments, Suicide, assisted, 16¢ representativeness, 611-613 judgment women, 607+ ation, 160-161 Public authority, Surveillance, educational negligence, 288-308 ynfidentiality, 351 tort, liability in, 288-308 Sustainable development, Public inquiries, procedure, 391 14 European Community, 132-134 Public order Local Agenda 21 process, 134-138 iggravated trespass S4 local government, 130-151i 1 Anu- Terrorism, Crime and Secu r ity breach of pea 83-184 Telephone interception, 154 tootball bann rders 6-57 Terrorisn ten 577 S rI e alo , 77 etention without trial, 210-214 Refugee statu . at f % idicial review, 217-21 Regency, 449-455 national securitya, nn2e17 -21ome9 Rehgious often 57% 206-21 RemreWnw deiw es2 , ana ; T| ot dvertising, 22 t Sec I rder j OT S7R United 4 y 4 Ri t law fae’. Se Dicey, A.\ ' scn s lucational 1 e, 208 8 t w, 200-202 Scotland, devolution, 31—38 remedies, 107-109 Scottish Parliament m case, 743-75 npetence, 33-35 nedies, 106-107 tv0 02] PL. Winter C Sweet & MAXwWeELt AND CONTRIBUTORS 830 Index United States—cont. Wales, sexually explicit expression, regulation of, devolution, 663-669 743-757 law-making in, 663-669 Witness protection, 166-167 Vexatious litigants, 152 [2002] PL. Winter © Sweet & Maxweit AND CONTRIBUTORS Public Law 2002 AUSTRALIA LBC Information Services Sydney CANADA AND USA Carswell Toronto NEW ZEALAND Brooker’s Auckland 4 SINGAPORE AND MALAYSIA Sweet & Maxwell Asia Singapore and Kuala Lumpur .