ebook img

Problem-Based Learning in Police Academies: Adult Learning PDF

125 Pages·2009·0.38 MB·English
Save to my drive
Quick download
Download
Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.

Preview Problem-Based Learning in Police Academies: Adult Learning

PROBLEM-BASED LEARNING IN POLICE ACADEMIES: ADULT LEARNING PRINCIPLES UTILIZED BY POLICE TRAINERS A Dissertation Presented to The Faculty of the School of Education Liberty University In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Education by Eric Paul Werth March, 2009 ii Problem-based Learning in Police Academies: Adult Learning Principles Utilized by Police Trainers by Eric Paul Werth © March 2009 APPROVED: COMMITTEE CHAIR Brian Satterlee, Ed.D., D.B.A. COMMITTEE MEMBERS Alice Obenchain, D.B.A. Dawn Weiler, Ph.D. CHAIR, GRADUATE STUDIES Scott B. Watson, Ph.D. iii ABSTRACT Eric Paul Werth. PROBLEM-BASED LEARNING IN POLICE ACADEMIES: ADULT LEARNING PRINCIPLES UTILIZED BY POLICE TRAINERS. (Under the direction of Dr. Brian Satterlee) School of Business Administration, March, 2009. This study explored the use of adult learning principles by instructors at two state-run multi-jurisdictional police training academies using Problem-Based Learning (PBL). Instructor use of adult learning principles was assessed using an electronic version of the Principles of Adult Learning Scale (PALS). PALS scores indicate that instructors at both institutions favor an instructor-centered as opposed to student-centered teaching style, that time since PBL implementation did not lead to a greater use of adult learning principles by instructors at the academy utilizing PBL for a greater length of time, and that there is little significant difference in the use of adult learning principles by instructors at the two PBL academies compared to instructors at an academy not using PBL. The results of this study will potentially impact the training provided to police instructors both prior to and following adoption of PBL as well as the decision of some agencies to convert to PBL-based curricula. iv DEDICATION This study is dedicate to all police educators who are willing to look beyond the confines of traditional training practices to investigate what is the best method to prepare student officers for a life of service to their communities and society as a whole. In a training profession where stepping outside the established boundaries is often greeted with skepticism, you are evidence of the truth of the statement damnant quod non intellegunt, they condemn what they do not understand. v ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I could not have completed this dissertation without the love and support of my best friend and wife, Lori. Thank-you so much for everything you did to make this achievement possible including the many hours of proofreading. I love you with my whole heart. You are truly a blessing in my life. To Erica and Emily, you both mean more to me that you ever will know. Thank- you for understanding when daddy could not play because he had work to do or deadlines to meet. I love you both and always will. To my parents, Paul and Vickie, you put me on this path years ago. Thank-you for instilling in me the importance of education and the idea that the pursuit of wisdom is worth the time and cost. To Director Black and the staff of Idaho Peace Officer Standards and Training, thank-you for your support in this research. I truly appreciate your willingness to see this as a worthy endeavor, and will not forget your encouragement. To those at the Kentucky Department of Criminal Justice Training and Washington State Criminal Justice Training Commission, thank-you for your time and support. This study would not have been possible without your dedication to advancing peace officer training practices. We would not be as far as we are today as a profession without agencies like you who are willing to step beyond what is commonly done to answer the question, “What is best for student officers and the public they serve?” To my committee, Dr. Satterlee, Dr. Obenchain, and Dr. Weiler, you have taught me how to think like a researcher and educator. The lessons I have learned through this vi process will last a lifetime. I cannot thank you all enough for your time, patience, and guidance. To Dr. Gary Conti who developed the Principles of Adult Learning Scale (PALS). Rather than personally profiting from the development of this questionnaire, you made it available free to teachers and researchers. This altruistic decision demonstrates your commitment to helping teachers improve their classroom instruction though assessment of the adult learning principles they utilize. Thank-you for placing the well-being of students before your own personal gain. Finally, no acknowledgement section would be complete without thanking the good Lord. With Him all things are possible and I could not have conquered this challenge without Christ carrying me on His shoulders. vii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Dedication ................................................................................................................iv Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................v List of Tables .............................................................................................................x CHAPTER I. INTRODUCTION ..............................................................................1 Introduction...............................................................................................1 Background...............................................................................................1 Research Questions...................................................................................4 Significance of the Study..........................................................................5 Methodology.............................................................................................6 Definition of Terms...................................................................................8 CHAPTER II. LITERATURE REVIEW ...............................................................10 History of Law Enforcement in America................................................10 Policing Models......................................................................................15 Educational Philosophies and Learning Theories ..................................20 Problem-Based Learning........................................................................29 PBL in Police Training Academies.........................................................32 CHAPTER III. METHODOLOGY ........................................................................37 Introduction.............................................................................................37 Research Framework..............................................................................37 Data Collection Procedure and Sample..................................................41 viii Operationalization of Variables..............................................................44 Use of Adult Learning Principles...........................................................45 Implementation Time for PBL Methodologies.......................................46 Implementation versus Non-implementation for PBL Methodologies...46 Validity and Reliability ..........................................................................46 Data Analysis Techniques ......................................................................48 CHAPTER IV. FINDINGS ....................................................................................52 Introduction.............................................................................................52 Overview of the PALS Questionnaire....................................................53 Description of the Sample.......................................................................57 Research Question #1.............................................................................59 Research Question #2.............................................................................69 Research Question #3.............................................................................71 Summary.................................................................................................73 CHAPTER V. SUMMARY AND DISCUSSION .................................................75 Introduction.............................................................................................75 Background.......................................................................................75 Research Questions...........................................................................77 Methodology.....................................................................................78 Summary of Research Findings..............................................................79 Research Question #1.......................................................................79 Research Question #2.......................................................................80 ix Research Question #3.......................................................................81 Discussion of Research Findings............................................................81 Research Question #1.......................................................................82 Research Question #2.......................................................................89 Research Question #3.......................................................................92 Study Implications..................................................................................94 Police Training..................................................................................94 PBL in General.................................................................................97 Limitations..............................................................................................98 Recommendations for Future Research..................................................99 REFERENCES ......................................................................................................100 Appendices .........................................................................................................109 Appendix 1: Principles of Adult Learning Scale..................................109 Appendix 2: PALS Use Information.....................................................112 Appendix 3: Letter to Agency Instructional Staff.................................113 Appendix 4: Demographic Questionnaire............................................114 Appendix 5: IRB Approval...................................................................115 x List of Tables Table 1: Description of PALS Categories ...............................................................54 Table 2: Study Agency Demographic Data..............................................................58 Table 3: PALS Descriptive Statistics for National and Study Groups.....................60 Table 4: Number of Instructors Who Scored at Various Locations..........................63 Table 5: T-test Results for Study Groups versus National Norms............................68 Table 6: T-test Results-Kentucky DOCJT Compared to WSCJTC..........................70 Table 7: T-test Results-Study Groups Compared to McCoy (2006)........................73

Description:
This study explored the use of adult learning principles by instructors at two state-run Many police training facilities focus on the mechanical .. have a great reservoir of experience that should be tapped by the learning facilitator.
See more

The list of books you might like

Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.