Science $28.99 US / $32.00 CAN Advance Praise for L Victoria o W e e Physics in Mind w r e n n e Physics s r te R i . n No one can escape a sense of awe when reflecting in Mind on the workings of the mind: we see, we hear, we “The more we think about it, the more challenging it becomes to answer the apparently simple question: feel, we are aware of the world around us. But what how do we think? Here, eminent scientist Werner Loewenstein has assembled recent insights from biology is the mind? What do we mean when we say we are “aware” and physics to give us his richly textured new view of this great challenge.” —Jared diamond, of something? What is this peculiar state in our heads, at once Professor of Geography, UCLA, and Pulitzer Prize–winning author of Guns, Germs, and Steel utterly familiar and bewilderingly mysterious, that we call awareness or consciousness? In Physics in Mind, eminent biophysicist Werner R. i P Loewenstein argues that to answer these questions, we must first d n dwar h understand the physical mechanisms that underlie the workings Woo “Werner Loewenstein’s Physics in Mind is a passionate exploration of how biological systems process M y of the mind. And so begins an exhilarating journey along the Lynn information. Starting from how molecules transform information and energy at the most microscopic in sic sensory data stream of the brain, which shows how our most 6S-:1 1/4 3 x/1 96-”1/5” © level, where quantum mechanics plays a central role, Loewenstein provides clear and elegant explanations d s A B: 15/16” complex organ processes the vast amounts of information of the mechanisms of sight and smell, of senses and neural signals, culminating with the phenomenon BASIC Werner R. Loewenstein Quantum coming in through our senses to create a coherent, meaningful HC of consciousness itself. Erudite, witty, and highly accessible, Physics in Mind proves once and for all picture of the world. Bringing information theory to bear on View of the 4/COLOR + was professor of physiology and biophysics at Columbia that the unquantized life is not worth living.” —Seth LLoyd, Professor of Quantum-Mechanical recent advances in the neurosciences, Loewenstein reveals PMS 485 C (red)+ V University and director of its Cell Physics Laboratory. Author Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and author of Programming the Universe BiewQu Brain a web of immense computational power inside the brain. He P+ MSSpo 2tg9l7o5s s( coyna n) of The Touchstone of Life, he lives in Woods Hole, on Cape ra oanA introduces the revolutionary idea that quantum mechanics head, 3 circles inf tu and white lines on Cod, Massachusetts. t hm could be fundamental to how our minds almost instantaneously cover only e Werner R. deal with staggering amounts of information, as in the case of FINISH: Matte Poly the information streaming through our eyes. Loewenstein Combining cutting-edge research in neuroscience and $28.99 US / $32.00 CAN physics, Loewenstein presents an ambitious hypothesis about ISBN 978-0-465-02984-6 the parallel processing of sensory information that is the 52899 Jacket design by Thomas Beck Stvan A Member of the Perseus Books Group heart, hub, and pivot of the cognitive brain. Wide-ranging and www.basicbooks.com brimming with insight, Physics in Mind breaks new ground in 01/13 9 780465 029846 our understanding of how the mind works. 9780465029846-text_Layout 1 11/9/12 9:51 AM Page i Physics in Mind 9780465029846-text_Layout 1 11/9/12 9:51 AM Page ii 9780465029846-text_Layout 1 11/9/12 9:51 AM Page iii Physics in Mind A Quantum View of the Brain Werner R. Loewenstein New York A Member of the Perseus Books Group 9780465029846-text_Layout 1 11/9/12 9:51 AM Page iv Copyright © 2013 by Werner R. Loewenstein Published by Basic Books, A Member of the Perseus Books Group All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. No part of this book may be reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews. For information, address Basic Books, 250 West 57th Street, 15th Floor, New York, NY 10107. Books published by Basic Books are available at special discounts for bulk purchases in the United States by corporations, institutions, and other organizations. For more information, please contact the Special Markets Department at the Perseus Books Group, 2300 Chestnut Street, Suite 200, Philadelphia, PA 19103, or call (800) 810- 4145, ext. 5000, or e-mail [email protected]. Designed by Trish Wilkinson Set in 11.5 point Minion Pro Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Loewenstein, Werner R. Physics in mind : a quantum view of the brain / Werner R. Loewenstein. p. cm Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-465-02984-6 (hardcover) — ISBN 978-0-465-03397-3 (e-book) 1. Neurophysiology. 2. Neural networks (Neurobiology) 3. Brain. I. Title. QP355.2.L64 2013 612.8—dc23 2012028268 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 9780465029846-text_Layout 1 11/9/12 9:51 AM Page v To my children, Claudia, Patricia, Harriet, and Stewart 9780465029846-text_Layout 1 11/9/12 9:51 AM Page vi 9780465029846-text_Layout 1 11/9/12 9:51 AM Page vii Contents Preface xiii A Thumbnail Sketch of Our Journey xvii 1 Our Sense of Time: Time’s Arrow 1 Our Awareness of Time 1 The Stream of Consciousness 2 Inner Time versus Physics Time 4 The Way the Cookie Crumbles 6 How to Predict the Future from the Past 8 Why the Cookie Crumbles 11 Can Time Go Backward? 12 Time and Our Perception of Reality 13 2 Information Arrows 15 Retrieving the Past 15 The Arrows of Time and Information 19 The Products of Information Arrows: An Overview 21 Life’s Arrow 22 The Strange Circles at Coordinates 0,0,0 25 Molecular Demons 26 Wresting Information from Entropy: The Quintessence of Cognition 28 Who Shoulders Life’s Arrow? 32 3 The Second Coming 35 The Demons for Fast Information Transmission 36 The Sensory Demons 41 vii 9780465029846-text_Layout 1 11/9/12 9:51 AM Page viii viii Contents A Generalized Sensory Scheme 42 The Demon Tandem 44 How the Demon Tandems Censor Incoming Information 46 4 The Sensors 49 The Sensory Transducer Unit 49 A Lesson in Economics from a Master 51 The Silent Partner 53 How Electrical Sensory Signals Are Generated 54 5 Quantum Sensing 57 The Quantum World 58 Our Windows to the Quantum World 61 Coherent Quantum Information Transmission 64 The Advantages of Being Stable 66 Why We See the Rainbow 67 The Demons Behind Our Pictures in the Mind: A Darwinistic Physics View 70 Why White Is White 72 The Quantum View 75 Again, Why White Is White 76 Lady Evolution’s Quantum Game Plan 77 Quantum Particles That Don’t Cut the Mustard 78 6 Quantum into Molecular Information 81 Boosting the Quantum 81 A Consummate Sleight of Hand 83 The Ubiquitous Membrane Demon 86 7 Molecular Sensing 87 A Direct Line from Nose to Cortex 87 A Thousand Information Channels of Smell 89 Mapping, Coding, and Synonymity 90 Molecular Sensory Synonymity 92 Why Sensory Synonymity 95 Quantum Synonymity 97 Harmless Double Entendres 98 9780465029846-text_Layout 1 11/9/12 9:51 AM Page ix Contents ix 8 Electronic Transmission of Biological Information 99 Evolution’s Favorite Leptons 99 Electronic Information Transmission: A Development Stumped 101 Two Old Batteries 103 9 The Random Generators of Biomolecular Complexity 107 Genuine Transmogrification 107 A Quantum Random Generator of Molecular Form 109 The Heuristics of Transmogrification 113 The Random Generator and Our Genetic Heritage 114 An Algorithm Is No Substitute for a Demon 116 The Second Generator of Biomolecular Form 118 Complexity as a Windfall 122 Ikats 122 10 The Ascent of the Digital Demons 125 Quantum Electron Tunneling 125 The Electronic Cul-de-Sac 127 The Rise of the Digital Demons 127 Do Plants Have Digital Demons, Too? 128 11 The Second Information Arrow and Its Astonishing Dénouement: Consciousness 131 The Structure of Time 132 The Evolutionary Niche in the Structure of Time: A Hypothesis 133 Forecognition 134 12 How to Represent the World 137 The Universal Turing Machine 137 Rendering the World by Computer 140 The Neuronal Virtual-Reality Generator 142 Our Biased World Picture 143 Computing by Neurons 145 Correcting Our World Picture 148 Flying the Coop of Our Senses 149