Paulo Freire: A Critical Encounter

215 Pages·1992·6.92 MB·English

by  Peter McLaren et al.

.{
.
·. :i.--.. ......
#'
• •' ,.
PAULO FREIRE
•
PauFlroe iirsoe n oef t hcee ntugrryet'ahsti noknee rdsu caatnitdoh ne
poliotfli icbsie ornKa.nt owmno stfloyhr i lsi tecraamcpya iignLn ast in
AmericAaf craaina,dn fdo hri sse miwnoarlPk e dagooftg hyOe p preesds,
hitsh inkcionngt itnoub eers e discobvyge erneedr aotfit oehanecs,r s
·
scho,lc aormsmunaicttyi avnicdsu tlst wuorraklie nrE su roapneNd o rth
AmeriWchai.lh ein sa mes yinso nywmiotuthsh per acotfi_c 'eC ritical
•
Literaanc'dyA P' e dagoofLg iyb eiroanht'i,s hwaobsre ke anp praotperdi
..... .
�- ..- ......� .......
inm andyi vefiresloedfd s i pslciiannesd i te-pbraosjeoedfsc otcsri eaflo. r m
Thivso lurmeep resae pnattsh finadnianlgoy fsF irse iwroer'aksn d
inm ancya sietos f faernes x tenosfhi iotsnh iniknio nrgdt eorm akie.t
moraep plictaoFb ilreWs otr lcdo nt.ePxettseM rcL araenndP eter
.
·
Leonahradvb er ougthotg etah deirv erggreonuotpf s cholwairdse ly
recognfoitrzh eecdio rn tribtuoct riiottnihsce aoalrn ycd r itpiecdaaglo gy.
Themeasd,d reisnsecdlF urdeei rree'lsa ttiof oenm incirsitt ihqiuse ,
.h.i lP.o..sqph.,�i.��� n�'!� la.l!.Q2.!u�ao tfhi oi11s. . fi rdoepmao.ss ��odaenr·d n ist
·
posltocnoipaelrissiptve ecst.
Thec ollewcitlbileoe ns senrteiaadflio nargn yoinnet erienst theed
r�qis�o�cli �qlfeo 4guy� aatnitd�h npe.o litlii�bsie orna.t
<>.{
PetMecrL aren
isR enownSecdh oilnRa ers idaetnM ciea mUin ivte,yr si
Ohiaon,Pd e tLeero nairPsdr ofeosfSs oocrWi oarlak tM cG�Ulnvlie rt,sy i
Montarle.
•
\-
'l
'
I
I
I
A critiecnaclo unter
Londoann dN ew York
1qq�
The editowrisst ho g ivsep ecitahla ntkosC hriRso jek
forh iesn couragemaenndat d vitcher oughtohuiptsr oje.c t
.
Firpsutb lis1h9e9d3
byR outledge
11N ewF ettLaenre ,L ondoEnC 4P4 EE
Simultanepouubslliys ·hietndh eU SA andC anada
byR outledge
_
29W est3 5tSht reNe tw, Y orkN,Y 10001
Repreid 1993
I
I
© 1993P eteMrc Lareann dP eter I:.eosnealredc,ta inoden d itomraitatle era;c h
authotrh,e indicvhiadputaelr s.
Typeseitn T imebsy J &LC ompositLitodFn,i leNyo,r tYho rkshire
.
Printaenddbo undi nG reaBtr itabiyMn ackayosfC hatham ChathaKme,n t
PLC,
'
Allr ighrtess erveNdo. p arotf t his bomoaky be reprintoerrd e produced
oru tiliiznae dn yf onno rb ya nye lectromneicch,a niocraol t,h emre ans,
nowk nowno rh ereaftienrv entiendc,l udpihnogt ocopyainndgre cording,
ori na nyi nfonnasttioorna ogrre e triseyvsatle wmi,t hopuetr missiino n
writifnrgo mt hep ublishers.
·.
� .
'
• <
BriLtiibsrhCa aryt aloignPu uibnlgiD caattai on .i
,
·. .
A catalorgeuceo frodr tbohoiks i sa vailafbrloemt heB ritiLsihb rary
r
LibroafCr oyn gCraetsasl ionPg uibnlgi Dcaattai on
A catalroegc ofrodtr h iboso k isa vailafbrloemt heL ibraorfyC ongress
ISBN0 -415-038(9h5b-k2)I SBN0 -415-087(9p2b-k9)
•
. . . .
. ,
l.. ;
·.>'.
.
Ill
'.
'
.>
.
'I
. : .
't
'
;
..
l·
'
'
CONTENTS
•
••
Notoenst hceo ntributors
Vll
•
Foreword
• IX
PauFlroe ire
• • •
Prfaece
Xlll
CornWee/s t
Edirtsio'n trodAubcsteidnoitns couPrasuFelrsoe: ia rntedh e
dangemreomuosr oifle isb eration 1
.
1P AULOF REIRER'ASD ICADLE MORCATIHCU MANISM
StanAlroenyo twzi 8
2 EDUCATIOINSP OLITIPCASU:L OF REIRE'S
CRITICPAELD AGOGY
IrSah or 25
3 KNOWLEDGE UNSDIEERG TEH:E B RAIZLIAN
DEBATE
TomazT adedua S ilavnaPd e tMecrL aren 36
4·D ECETNERINPGE DAGOGCYR:I TICLAILET RACY,
..
RESISTANACNEDT HEP OLITIOCFSM EMORY
PetMecrL araennTdo mazT adedua S ilva 47
5 FUNCTIONLAILTR EACYF ROMA FREIREPAONI NT
OFV IEW ·
ColLiann kshear
90
6F ROMT HEP EDAGOGYO FT HEO PPRESSETDO A
LUAT CONITNU:AT HEP OLITICPAELD AGOGOYF
PAULOF REIRE
CarlAolesbr Ttoor res
191
v
PAULO FREIRE:A CRITICALE NCOUNTER
HOOKSS PEAKIANBGO UTP AULOF REIRE
7 BELL
v
-THEM AN,H ISW ORK
behlolo ks 146
8C RITICPAELD AGOGAYN DS TATEW ELFARE: -
- ;
INTELLECTEUNACLO UNTEWRIST IFIR EIRAEN D
'
' •\'
GRAMSC1I9,7 4-86
-' --·
'. '
'7) .
'
'
PertL eeonard . ' '
155 - .' ' •
'
9A DIALOGUWEI THP AULOF REIRE
PauFlroe ainrDdeo ndaoM/ acedo
169
10P AULOF REIRAEN DT HEP OLITIOCFS
POSTCOLONIALISM
HenAry.G iroux
177
Namien dex
189
Sujbect index
191
'
•
•
VI
NOTES ON THE
CONTRIBUTORS
StanAlreoyn owitz
isf roam etrr audnei aocnt iavnisdst te elewrHo.er·i k s
aP rofeosfSs oocri oloDgiyr eacontfdo Crtu hlet SutruadlPi reosg raatm
thGer aduCaetnetC eirtU,yn iveorfNs eiwtY yo rHki.ms o srte cebonotk
TheP oliotfIi dcesn :tC iltayCsus,l taunrSdeo cMioavle mse.n t
is
HenrAy.G iroux
holtdhsWe a terbCuhraPyir ro fessaotPr esnhnispy lvania
StaUtnei rvseiHtiysm. o srte cebnoto iksB ordCerro ss:iC nuglstural
Workaerntsdh Peo liotfEi dcusc na.ti o
belhloo ksi st haeu thoofTr al kiBnagc kTh:i nkiFnemgi nisTthi,n king
BlacYke,a rnRiancgGe:e, n daenr,dC ultuPorlailat nidcw,si tCho rnel
WesBtr,e akBirnegaI dsn:u rgBelnatIc nkt eecltlLufiae.lS hiesP rofessor
ofE nglainsWdho menS'tsu daitOe bse rCloilnl ege.
ColiLna nkshear
is eadnua ctiocnoanls ulatnadwn rti tbears eidn
PalmerNsotr,otN nhe wZ ealaHnehd a.hs a adc ontiinnuvionlgv ienm ent
reseaarncdsh m all-dsecvaelleop prionjgei cnNt isc arsaigun1ac9 e8 4.
Formewrilttyhh Eed ucatDiepoanr tmaetAn utc klUannvide r,s ithyis
bookisn clLuiedtrea cSyc,h ooalniRdne gv uotliaonndC ritLiticearl:a cy
PoliPtriacxasin,std h Peo stmo(dweirPtneh t MecrL ar.e n)
•
PetLeero nard
iPsr ofeosfSs oocrWi oarlak tM cGiUlnli vte,yrM sointarle;
fromerPlryo feosfAs poprl SioecdSi tauld aitte hsUe n iveorfWs airtiwyc k,
UK.H ei asu thoofPr e rnsaloiatnyId d eolaonogdty hbeoro aknspd a p,e rs
anGde neErdailto ofCr r itTiecxaitlnSs o cWioarlak n tdh Wee falrSet a.t e
Hei csu rrePnrtelsyio dfte hnCeta nadAisasno cioafSt cihoonoo fSl osc ial
Work.
DonalMdaoc edo
isP rofeosfsE onrg lainsdDh i recotfto hrBe i lingual
EducaatniEdoS nL Proagttr haUemn si rvseiotfMy a ssacshH.ue she atst
co-aut,wh iotPrhae udFlroe iLrieetr,a Rceya:d tihnWego radn tdh Weo r.l d
PeteMrc Laren
isR enownSecdh oilnaR ers idaenndDc ier ecotfto hre
CentfeoErrd ucaatniCdou nl tSutruadlai tMe isa mUin irvse,iO thyiHoe.
iasl sAos socPiraotfeei snts hoDere partomfEe dnutc atLieoandael.r ship
• •
VII
.
PAULO FREIRE: CAR ITICALE NCOUNTER
Hei st haeu thoofSr c hooalsai R nigt uPeaforlr manLciee/i ,n S cohols
anidts h ceo -edwiittHoher n rAy.G irooufCx r itPiecdaalg tohgSeyt ,a te,
anCdu ltSutrraul.gP grloefeMscsLoarri eosn nt hien rntaetioandavli sory
boaorfdt hPea ulo IFnrsetiirSteau Pota eu,,lB oralz.i
IraS hoirs P rofeosfsE onrg laitst hh Ger aduCaetnert o ef tChiety
.
.! "
' .
•
-
.
UnirvseiotfNy e wY or.Wk itPha uFlroie rhee,c o-autAh Poerdeadg ogy ••
·.•
•
.
forL biera.tH iioosnt hbeoro akrsCe r itTieccaahlia nngEd v yedraLyfi e,
EmpwoeriEndgu catainodCn u ltWuarre:sS choaonldS ociientty h e
ConserRveasttiovre1a 9t6i9o-n1,99 1. l
.- 1
•.
TomaTza dedua SiilsPv rao feosfsT ohre oorfyC urriciunlt uhme
DepartmoefTn eta c�ainnCdgu rricauttl huFeme deUrnailrv seiotfRy i o
GranddoeS ulB,r ai.zlH ea lstoe acShoecsi oolfoE gdyu caitnit ohne
GraduPartoeg roafEm d ucaattit ohsnea muen iveHriswsir tiyt.oi nn gs
curricauntldhu smeo cioolfo geyd uhcaavtbeien oep nu bliisnsh eevde ral
Brazijloiuarnon fae ldsu coantH.ie i s etdhieot foT re oriEad uca,� iio
&
anhda rse cefinntildsyw h reitWihantgP r oduacneWdsh aRte prodiunc es
Educiaotwnh,i icsbh e ipnugb liisnBh reaidzl .
CarlAolsb eTrotror es
isa nA ssisPtraonftei snts hoGerr aduSactheoo ofl
Educataitto hneU nievrsiotfCy a lifoartL noisAa ngelWeisd.e ly
publiisnSh peadn ,iP sohrteusgaeun dE nglhiesi hst, h aeu thoofTr h e
PoliotfiN cosno frmaEld ucaitinLo ant Aimne ri(caal psuob liisnh ed
Porgtuue;sw ei)tDha nliM eorales-TGheoS mteazCt,oep r,oa rtiPsolti tics,
andE duciaotnPaoll ·imcaykiinnMg e xi;ca ondm,o srte cenTthley ,
ChurScochi,e atyn Hde gmeonyA, C ritSioccailo olfRo eglyi igniL oant in
Ameri(ctar anbsylRa itcehdAa .rY do ung).
CornWeets itst haeu thoofPr rp oheFtriaceg nm,tT shAe meriEcvaans ion
ofP hilosaonpdwh,iy t bhe lhlo okBsr,e akBirnegaI dn:s urBgleanctk
IntellLefiec.Ht eui asPl r ofeosfRs eolri gainodDn i recotfto hrAe f r­o
AmeriSctaund Pireosg raatPm r incUentiorvnse .it y
•
• ••
Vilt
I •
'
'
,.
i'
I
FORE ORD
PaulFor eire
TranslabtyDe odn aldMoa cedo
Int hiism presvsoimlveue,P etMecrL araenndP etLeero nahradv e
attemtpobt reidtn ogg eatg hreorou fip nternsacthiooalnnaaedrld s u cators
ino rdteorr efleucptom ny w oraks i th abse etna kuepni nv arious
educatainodpn oalli tciocnatlei xnEt nsg laAnfdcr,ai N,e wZ ealand,
LatAimne riacnatd,h U en itSettdae Mso.r teh aatn e statmome ynw to rk
alohnoew,e vtehrvi,os l uamtet emtpogt rsa pwpiltaenh u mboefpr i votal
isscuuersr eenntglaybg yec dr itsicchaolwl haohr asv se�o tu trj?e fiaRnd__e
deyeJql? a. c �t�.c��elc!g !l):_atg _to en_tti�ov he_c eh angfiaocog�_f s oc,i al
__
culatlue,rn dearn,dg l obraell atTihoensises. s iunecsl ,bu udater neo
meanlsi miote, e mannienrw hicshu ebcjtiivsci otnys tiitnu ted
langgeut;ah ree latiaomnosndhgii spc o,su orcsaiecatnli ,ao nhdi storical
memortyh;ce o nnecbteitownei ennt erpraentdha itsitoopnrr iacc;at li ce
· anhdo wf ro1nosf a uthomraiyt aybd ed reasnsjdeu ds tiintfi hecedo ntext
off emipneidsatg aongdpy r ac.tI insc heortth,ivs o lurmeep resae nts
fuondatiinoqnuaiilnr ttyoh r ee latiboentswhpeioepwn e arn pde dag.o gy
_,,,,
Id on owti sthod iraetctte nttoei aocnoh ft hceh aptientr usrb nu,t
rathteoar f firsmo moef t hcee ntprrailn coifpm lywe osr wkh icahr e
reflecttheeeidran n,id ns od oiantgt etmocp lta sroifmiyes swuheishc ahv e
.
beerna iasbeodmu ytp osiotnit ohpneo liotfli icbseo rn.a ti
Ovetrh yee aerdsu,c astuocrahssH enrGyi rxo,Pu eter eMn,cI Lraar
ShoCra,r lAolsb eTrotreors D,o nalMdaoc e,da ondb elhlo o,ka\sm ong
othehrasvt,er iteord e inmvyew nrti tainndrg ess eaornlc iht earnadc y
pedagsootg hya tth emya yb ea ppltioNe odr tAhm erisctarnu gfgolre s
liberiants icohsno, ot lhew. orp�lacteh,e meh,oa ndu niverasnidt ies
colelseI.gn m yv ietwh,i s beheaensx ceedinglyw opr.rkA o ductive
numbetrh eoasfue t hhoarvaset temtpobt reidmn ygw orikn tcoo nversa­
tiowni tEhu roptehainn wkheorr se prewsheanhtta c so me betc oa lled
'mordneiasnt'd'p omsotdersntirsatoi'ftn hso ught.
Althomuygo hw nw ordko enso tsp ecifiacdadlrlmeyas nsoy f t he
isscuoenst aiinn etdh eo ftw hoortskhe i nwkheoar rsce u rreanstsleys sing
thmee riotfps o stmocdreirtnti hcoaulgI h nte,v erthapeplreescsi ate
:1owm uchha bse eanco cmplibsyhw ehda t Gdiersocurxai s'b cersi tical
•
IX