in this book modality and its learner variety in Japanese are investi r a gated from the perspective of grammaticalization in the functional z a S framework. it describes the grammatical system of modality in Japa ul C i K t nese in terms of the form–function relationship within the scope of a a S r ui framework based on the european school of modality. accordingly, i m g it deals with the modal system and its constituents in Japanese, F n a i accommodating all the grammatical means of modariti (modality) q L u e in the Nihongo bunpou ( Japanese grammar system). this study also i v r e i casts light on the learner variety of modality, which is comprised of t p two core systems, epistemic and deontic, both of which are evident at ri C the utterance level and the morphosyntactic level. the learner variety S e of modality elucidated here is presented as a protomodality, which d M n is viewed as a system in its own right rather than as an improvised or o i distorted version of the native modal system in Japanese. d S a e i l d it u y t a S Modality and n y d r a it r s o its learner Variety l p e m a r e n t in Japanese n e o r C V a a.B.M. razaul KariM Faquire was awarded his phd by the rie 29 razaul Karim Faquire university of dhaka. He is an associate professor of Japanese at the t . y L o institute of Modern languages, university of dhaka. His research i n v interests include general linguistics, language contact and language J a acquisition. p a n e s e g n a isBn 9783034301039 L r e t e www.peterlang.com p in this book modality and its learner variety in Japanese are investi r a gated from the perspective of grammaticalization in the functional za S framework. it describes the grammatical system of modality in Japa ul tiC nese in terms of the form–function relationship within the scope of a K S a i r u framework based on the european school of modality. accordingly, im g it deals with the modal system and its constituents in Japanese, n F a Li accommodating all the grammatical means of modariti (modality) q e in the Nihongo bunpou ( Japanese grammar system). this study also ui v re ti casts light on the learner variety of modality, which is comprised of p i two core systems, epistemic and deontic, both of which are evident at Cr the utterance level and the morphosyntactic level. the learner variety S e of modality elucidated here is presented as a protomodality, which M n d is viewed as a system in its own right rather than as an improvised or o i distorted version of the native modal system in Japanese. d S a e i l d it u y t a S Modality and n y d r a its or its learner Variety l p e m a e r t in Japanese n n e o r C V a a.B.M. razaul KariM Faquire was awarded his phd by the r 9 razaul Karim Faquire ie 2 university of dhaka. He is an associate professor of Japanese at the t . y L o institute of Modern languages, university of dhaka. His research in v interests include general linguistics, language contact and language J a acquisition. p a n e s e g n a L r e t e www.peterlang.com p Modality and its learner Variety in Japanese ConteMporary studies in desCriptiVe linguistiCs Vol. 29 edited by dr graeMe daVis & Karl a. Bernhardt peter lang oxford • Bern • Berlin • Bruxelles • Frankfurt am Main • new york • Wien razaul Karim Faquire Modality and its learner Variety in Japanese peter lang oxford • Bern • Berlin • Bruxelles • Frankfurt am Main • new york • Wien Bibliographic information published by Die Deutsche Nationalbibliothek die deutsche nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the deutsche national- bibliografie; detailed bibliographic data is available on the internet at http://dnb.d-nb.de. a catalogue record for this book is available from the British library. library of Congress Cataloging-in-publication data: Faquire, razaul Karim, 1963- Modality and its learner variety in Japanese / razaul Karim Faquire. p. cm. -- (Contemporary studies in descriptive linguistics; 29) includes bibliographical references and index. isBn 978-3-0343-0103-9 (alk. paper) 1. Japanese language--Modality. 2. Japanese language--Variation. 3. Japanese language--grammar, generative. 4. interlanguage (language learning) i. title. pl629.M63F37 2012 495.6'56--dc23 2012003603 issn 1660-9301 isBn 978-3-0343-0103-9 © peter lang ag, international academic publishers, Bern 2012 hochfeldstrasse 32, Ch-3012 Bern, switzerland [email protected], www.peterlang.com, www.peterlang.net all rights reserved. all parts of this publication are protected by copyright. any utilisation outside the strict limits of the copyright law, without the permission of the publisher, is forbidden and liable to prosecution. this applies in particular to reproductions, translations, microfilming, and storage and processing in electronic retrieval systems. printed in germany To five bright icons of modality study: Richard Matthews, Frank Robert Palmer, Yoshio Nitta, Anna Giacalone Ramat and Norbert Dittmar whose works highly inf luenced this study Contents List of Tables xi Acknowledgements xiii Abbreviations of Linguistic Concepts xv Abbreviations of Grammatical Forms and Formatives xvii Definitions of Japanese Language Terms xix Part 1 Unfolding the Theoretical Underpinnings 1 Chapter 1 Introduction 3 Chapter 2 The Functional Linguistic Approach 9 Chapter 3 The Notion of Modality 13 Chapter 4 Second Language Acquisition Theories Based on the Functional Linguistic Approach 41 viii Chapter 5 The Concept of Learner Variety 49 Chapter 6 The Learner Variety of Utterance Structure and Modality in Grammaticalization 55 Part 2 Setting the Stage for the Study 73 Chapter 7 The Present Trend of Modality Studies in Nihongo Bunpou 75 Chapter 8 The System of Modariti as Described by the Nihongo Kijutsu Bunpou Kenkyuukai 95 Chapter 9 Formulating a Grammatical System of Modality in Japanese Using the European Framework 115 Chapter 10 Present Trends in Studies on the Acquisition of Modality in L2 Japanese 131 Chapter 11 Projecting the Shape of the Learners’ Modal System in the Interlanguage of Japanese 135