Interdisciplinary Works in Logic, Epistemology, Psychology and Linguistics: Dialogue, Rationality, and Formalism PDF
Preview Interdisciplinary Works in Logic, Epistemology, Psychology and Linguistics: Dialogue, Rationality, and Formalism
Logic, Argumentation & Reasoning 3 Manuel Rebuschi Martine Batt Gerhard Heinzmann Franck Lihoreau Michel Musiol Alain Trognon Editors Interdisciplinary Works in Logic, Epistemology, Psychology and Linguistics Dialogue, Rationality, and Formalism Logic, Argumentation & Reasoning Interdisciplinary Perspectives from the Humanities and Social Sciences Volume 3 SeriesEditor ShahidRahman Forfurthervolumes: http://www.springer.com/series/11547 Logic, Argumentation & Reasoning TheSeriesisdevelopedinpartnershipwiththeMaisonEuropéennedesSciencesdel’Hommeetde laSociété(MESHS)atNord-PasdeCalaisandtheUMR-STL:8163(CNRS).Aims&Scope:The scientificobjectivesoftheseries,wherehumanitiesandsocialsciencesareconceivedasbuilding interdisciplinaryinterfaces,are: ThisseriespublishesvolumesthatlinkpracticesintheHumanitiesandSocialSciences,with theories in Logic, Argumentation and Reasoning, such as: Decision theory and action theory, Argumentation Theories in: cognitive sciences, economy, sociology, law, logic, philosophy of sciences. The series is open towards research from the Analytic and the Continental traditions, andhasfourmainfocusareas:Pragmaticmodelsandstudiesthatdevelopadynamicapproachto reasoninginwhichargumentationisstructuredasaninteractionorasagame,inwhichtwoor moreparticipantsplaymovesdefinedbythetypeofargumentationinquestion,communication, languageandtechniquesofargumentation:studiesbetweenthepracticalandtheoreticaldimen- sionsofargumentation,aswellastherelationshipsbetweenargumentationandothermodesof communication,reception,persuasionandpower:studiesinwhichreasoningpracticeisconsidered from the point of view of its capacity to produce conviction of persuasion, and focusing on understanding what makes an argument performative, Diachronic transformations of reasoning practicesstudiesthatemphasizetheinventionandrenewalofreasoningforms,withrespecttoits performanceanditseffectiveness. GeneralEditor ShahidRahman(Lille,UMR8163) ManagingEditor LaurentKeiff(Lille,UMR8163) AreaEditors ArgumentationandPragmatics CognitivesSciences.ComputerSciences MarceloDascal(TelAviv) YannCoello(Lille) ErikKrabbe(Groningen) EricGregoire(CRIL-Lens) FransH.vanEemeren(Amsterdam) HenryPrakken(Utrecht) JohnWoods(BritishColumbia/King’s FrançoisRecanati(ENS,Paris) College) EpistemologyandPhilosophyofScience ArgumentationandRhetoric AndréFuhrmann(Frankfurt) FabienneBlaise(Lille,MESHS-NordPas GerhardHeinzmann(Nancy) deCalais) GöranSundholm(Leyden) GabrielGalvez-Behar(Lille,MESHS-Nord PasdeCalais) Logic AndréLaks(Sorbonne,ParisIV) MichelCrubellier(Lille,UMR8163) RuthWebb(Lille,UMR8163) DovGabbay(King’sCollege) SvenOveHansson(Stockholm) DecisionTheory,Mathematics,Economy TeroTulenheimo(Lille,UMR8163) JacquesDubucs(IHPST-Paris1) FredéricJouneau(Lille) PoliticalScienceandSociology RichardSobel(Lille) Jean-GabrielContamin(Lille) FranckFischer(Rutgers) JoshOber(Stanford) MarcPichard(Lille,MESHS-NordPas deCalais) Manuel Rebuschi (cid:129) Martine Batt Gerhard Heinzmann (cid:129) Franck Lihoreau Michel Musiol (cid:129) Alain Trognon Editors Interdisciplinary Works in Logic, Epistemology, Psychology and Linguistics Dialogue, Rationality, and Formalism 123 Editors ManuelRebuschi MartineBatt LHSP–ArchivesH.Poincaré(UMR7117) LaboratoiredePsychologiede MSHLorraine(USR3261)CNRS l’InteractionetdesRelations UniversitédeLorraine Intersubjectives(InterPsy–EA4432) Nancy,France UniversitédeLorraine Nancy,France GerhardHeinzmann MSHLorraine(USR3261)CNRS FranckLihoreau UniversitédeLorraine FaculdadedeCiênciasSociaiseHumanas Nancy,France InstitutodeFilosofiadaLinguagem UniversidadeNovadeLisboa MichelMusiol Lisboa,Portugal MSHLorraine(USR3261)CNRS ATILF(UMR7118) AlainTrognon UniversitédeLorraine LaboratoiredePsychologiede Nancy,France l’InteractionetdesRelations Intersubjectives(InterPsy–EA4432) UniversitédeLorraine Nancy,France ISSN2214-9120 ISSN2214-9139(electronic) ISBN978-3-319-03043-2 ISBN978-3-319-03044-9(eBook) DOI10.1007/978-3-319-03044-9 SpringerChamHeidelbergNewYorkDordrechtLondon LibraryofCongressControlNumber:2014932162 ©SpringerInternationalPublishingSwitzerland2014 Thisworkissubjecttocopyright.AllrightsarereservedbythePublisher,whetherthewholeorpartof thematerialisconcerned,specificallytherightsoftranslation,reprinting,reuseofillustrations,recitation, broadcasting,reproductiononmicrofilmsorinanyotherphysicalway,andtransmissionorinformation storageandretrieval,electronicadaptation,computersoftware,orbysimilarordissimilarmethodology nowknownorhereafterdeveloped.Exemptedfromthislegalreservationarebriefexcerptsinconnection with reviews or scholarly analysis or material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the Copyright Law of the Publisher’slocation,initscurrentversion,andpermissionforusemustalwaysbeobtainedfromSpringer. PermissionsforusemaybeobtainedthroughRightsLinkattheCopyrightClearanceCenter.Violations areliabletoprosecutionundertherespectiveCopyrightLaw. Theuseofgeneraldescriptivenames,registerednames,trademarks,servicemarks,etc.inthispublication doesnotimply,evenintheabsenceofaspecificstatement,thatsuchnamesareexemptfromtherelevant protectivelawsandregulationsandthereforefreeforgeneraluse. While the advice and information in this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication,neithertheauthorsnortheeditorsnorthepublishercanacceptanylegalresponsibilityfor anyerrorsoromissionsthatmaybemade.Thepublishermakesnowarranty,expressorimplied,with respecttothematerialcontainedherein. Printedonacid-freepaper SpringerispartofSpringerScience+BusinessMedia(www.springer.com) Contents 1 GeneralIntroduction....................................................... 1 Manuel Rebuschi, Martine Batt, Gerhard Heinzmann, FranckLihoreau,MichelMusiol,andAlainTrognon PartI HistoricalContext 2 Phenomenology, “Grundwissenschaft” and “Ideologiekritik”: Hermann Zeltner’s Critique oftheErlangenschool...................................................... 11 ChristianThiel 3 Geometry as a Measurement-Theoretical A Priori: Lorenzen’sDefenseofRelativityAgainsttheOntology ofItsProponents............................................................ 21 OliverSchlaudt 4 CorrespondenceBetweenEvertWillemBethandJean Piaget(1951–1955).......................................................... 45 GerhardHeinzmann,AlainTrognon,andFrédérickTremblay PartII Epistemology,Context,Formalism 5 PrinciplesofKnowledge,BeliefandConditionalBelief................ 97 GuillaumeAucher 6 ProceduralInformationandtheDynamicsofBelief ................... 135 EricPacuit 7 ReasoningAboutKnowledgeinContext................................. 155 FranckLihoreauandManuelRebuschi v vi Contents 8 The Epistemic Closure Principle and the Assessment SensitivityofKnowledgeAttributions.................................... 181 TomoyukiYamada PartIII ReasoninginInteractiveContext 9 FromDialoguetoCalculation............................................. 203 MartineBattandAlainTrognon 10 DialogueofRationalities:ACaseStudy ................................. 219 MarceloDascal 11 PragmaticsofVeridicity ................................................... 229 DenisVernant PartIV Conversation,Pathology,Formalization 12 ModelingtheDynamicEffectsofDiscourse:Principles andFrameworks............................................................ 247 MaximeAmblardandSylvainPogodalla 13 DialogueAnalysis:PragmaticandRhetoricalAspects................. 283 JeanCaelenandAnneXuereb 14 InvestigatingDiscourseSpecificitiesinSchizophrenicDisorders ..... 315 MichelMusiolandFrédéricVerhaegen 15 Using SDRT to Analyze Pathological Conversations: Logicality,Rationality,andPragmaticDeviances ...................... 343 ManuelRebuschi,MaximeAmblard,andMichelMusiol Index............................................................................... 369 Contributors Maxime Amblard LORIA, UMR 7503, Université de Lorraine, CNRS, Inria, Vandœuvre-lès-Nancy,France GuillaumeAucher UniversityofRennes1,INRIA,Rennes,France Martine Batt Laboratoire de Psychologie de l’Interaction et des Relations Intersubjectives(InterPsy–EA4432),UniversitédeLorraine,Nancy,France Jean Caelen Laboratoire d’Informatique de Grenoble (UMR 5217), Domaine universitaire,Grenoble,France Marcelo Dascal Philosophy Department, Tel-Aviv University, Ramat Aviv, Tel-Aviv,Israel GerhardHeinzmann MSHLorraine(USR3261)CNRS,UniversitédeLorraine, Nancy,France FranckLihoreau FaculdadedeCiênciasSociaiseHumanas,InstitutodeFilosofia daLinguagem,UniversidadeNovadeLisboa,Lisboa,Portugal Michel Musiol MSH Lorraine (USR 3261) CNRS, ATILF (UMR 7118), UniversitédeLorraine,Nancy,France Eric Pacuit Tilburg Institute for Logic and Philosophy of Science, Tilburg University,Warandelaan,ABTilburg,TheNetherlands Sylvain Pogodalla LORIA, UMR 7503, Université de Lorraine, CNRS, Inria, Vandœuvre-lès-Nancy,France Manuel Rebuschi LHSP – Archives H. Poincaré (UMR 7117), MSH Lorraine (USR3261)CNRS,UniversitédeLorraine,Nancy,France Oliver Schlaudt Philosophisches Seminar, Universität Heidelberg, Heidelberg, Germany ChristianThiel InstitutfürPhilosophie,UniversitätErlangen-Nürnberg,Erlangen, Germany vii viii Contributors Frédérick Tremblay LHSP – Archives H. Poincaré (UMR 7117), Université de Lorraine,Nancy,France Alain Trognon Laboratoire de Psychologie de l’Interaction et des Relations Intersubjectives(InterPsy–EA4432),UniversitédeLorraine,Nancy,France Frédéric Verhaegen MSH Lorraine (USR 3261) CNRS, Laboratoire APEMAC, EPSaM(EA4360),UniversitédeLorraine,Nancy,France Denis Vernant Département de philosophie – ARSH, Université Pierre-Mendes- France,Grenoble,France Anne Xuereb Laboratoire d’Informatique de Grenoble (UMR 5217), Domaine universitaire,Grenoble,France Tomoyuki Yamada Division of Philosophy and Cultural Sciences, Graduate SchoolofLetters,HokkaidoUniversity,Sapporo,Hokkaido,Japan Chapter 1 General Introduction ManuelRebuschi,MartineBatt,GerhardHeinzmann, FranckLihoreau,MichelMusiol,andAlainTrognon Aswitnessedbyitstitle,thepaperscollectedinthisbookaimtoprovidearenewed perspectiveontherelationshipsbetweendialogue,rationality,andformalism.More precisely, the goal of this volume is to shed light on the use of formalisms in psychologicalandphilosophicalexplanationsoftherationalityofinteractiveagents. This book grew out of an interdisciplinary scientific project called DiaRaFor (“Dialogue, Rationality, Formalisms”) and hosted by the MSH Lorraine (Lorraine Institute for Social Sciences and Humanities) from 2007 to 2011. The project was led by two Lorraine research teams, the LHSP–Archives Henri Poincaré (UMR7117),andtheLaboratoiredePsychologiedel’InteractionetdesRelations M.Rebuschi((cid:2)) LHSP–ArchivesH.Poincaré(UMR7117),MSHLorraine(USR3261)CNRS, UniversitédeLorraine,91,avenuedelaLibération,BP454,54001Nancy,France e-mail:[email protected] M.Batt(cid:129)A.Trognon LaboratoiredePsychologiedel’InteractionetdesRelationsIntersubjectives (InterPsy–EA4432),UniversitédeLorraine,CampusLettresetSciences Humaines,3,PlaceGodefroydeBouillon,54015Nancy,France e-mail:[email protected];[email protected] G.Heinzmann MSHLorraine(USR3261)CNRS,UniversitédeLorraine,91,avenuedelaLibération, BP454,54001Nancy,France e-mail:[email protected] F.Lihoreau FaculdadedeCiênciasSociaiseHumanas,InstitutodeFilosofiadaLinguagem, UniversidadeNovadeLisboa,AvenidadeBerna,26–4ıpiso,1069-061Lisboa,Portugal e-mail:[email protected] M.Musiol MSHLorraine(USR3261)CNRS,ATILF(UMR7118),UniversitédeLorraine, 44,avenuedelaLibération,54063Nancy,France e-mail:[email protected] M.Rebuschietal.(eds.),InterdisciplinaryWorksinLogic,Epistemology, 1 PsychologyandLinguistics,Logic,Argumentation&Reasoning3, DOI10.1007/978-3-319-03044-9__1,©SpringerInternationalPublishingSwitzerland2014
The list of books you might like
