ESSENTIALS OF MODERN OPEN-HOLE LOG INTERPRETATION JOHN T. DEWAN Disclaimer The recommendations, advice, descriptions, and the methods in this book are presented solely for educational purposes. The author and publisher assume no liability whatsoever for any loss or damage that results from the use of any of the material in this book. Use of the material in this book is solely at the risk of the user. Copyright © 1983 by PennWell Corporation 1421 South Sheridan Road Tulsa, Oklahoma 74112-6600 USA 800.752.9764 +1.918.831.9421 [email protected] www.pennwellbooks.com www.pennwell.com Marketing Manager: Julie Simmons National Account Executive: Barbara McGee Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Available on Request Dewan, John T. Essentials of Modern Open-Hole Log Interpretation ISBN 978-0-87814-233-0 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transcribed in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying and recording, without the prior written permission of the publisher. Printed in the United States of America 6 7 8 9 10 11 10 09 08 07 DEDICATION This book Is dedicated to my former colleagues at Schlumberger, who did much to advance the science of well logging, and to my present associates and my family, who patiently endured Its preparation. CONTENTS DEDICATION v INTRODUCTION xi 1 The Logging Environment 1 The borehole 1 logging procedure 2 The undisturbed reservoir 4 Disturbance caused by drilling 8 Summary 13 References 15 2 Evaluation of Hydrocarbons 17 Fundamental Interpretation relations 17 The basic Interpretation procedure 22 Impact of Invasion on resistivity measurements 26 Summary 31 References 33 3 Permeable Zone Logs 35 Spontaneous Potential (SP) log 35 Source of spontaneous potential 36 SP behavior over a long log 39 Shape of the SP curve 40 Computation of Rw from the SP 43 SP log In shaly sands 49 SP anomalies due to vertical migration of filtrate 49 SP anomalies due to noise 50 The Gamma Ray (GR) log 50 Basic GR logs 50 Spectral GR logs 53 Statistical fluctuations 57 Summary 60 References 61 vII viii CONTENTS 4 Resistivity logs 63 Classification and Application 63 Electrical survey (ES) tools 65 Fresh mud tools 66 Salt mud tools 68 Ranges of application of Induction logs and laterologs 69 Dual Induction-Spherically Focused logs 70 The spherically focused log (SFl) 76 log presentation 77 Duallaterolog-Rxo logs 82 The Dll-MSFl tool 83 Depth of investigation 86 Characteristics of the MlcroSFl (MSFL) 88 Log presentation 88 Quick-look hydrocarbon indication 89 Summary 93 References 94 5 Porosity Logs 95 The current trend in porosity logging 95 Recent developments 96 Compensated Density and litho-DenSity logs 97 The compensated density tool 98 Porosity derivation from the density log 105 The litho-Density log 108 lithology interpretation with Pb-Pe curves 114 Compensated Neutron and Dual Porosity Neutron logs 115 Neutron tool evolution 117 The Compensated Neutron 117 Combined Density-Neutron Interpretation 128 The Dual Porosity Compensated Neutron log 136 Compensated Sonic and long-Spaced Sonic logs 139 The borehole compensated log 141 Porosity determination from Sonic logs 146 The long-Spacing Sonic log 158 CONTENTS Ix Electromagnetic Propagatlon-Microlog Combination 170 The EPT-ML sensor array 172 The Mlcrolog 173 in The Electromagnetic Propagation Log Summary 191 References 194 6 Clean Formation Interpretation 199 Resistivity-Porosity Crossplots 199 The Hingle plot 200 The Pickett plot 207 Range of uncertainty In calculated water saturations 209 Multlmlneralldentlflcation 211 The M-N plot 211 The MID plot 214 The Litho-Denslty-Neutron method 217 Trends In multlmlneral Identification 223 References 225 7 Shaly Formation Interpretation 227 The nature of shale 230 Shale or clay distribution In shaly sands 231 Shaly sand Interpretation models 236 Cation exchange capacity 237 Shale porosity and conductivity 243 Application of the dual-water method to shaly sands 247 Summary of dual water Interpretation 257 Summary of earlier shaly sand Interpretation methods 261 References 265 8 Prediction of Producibility 267 Flow relations 267 Absolute. relative. and effective permeabllitles 269 Irreducible water saturation 271 Estimation of permeability from logs 279 x CONTENTS The Multiple Formation Tester 284 Permeability from pretest drawdown 290 Permeability from pressure buildup 292 Sampling and sample analysis 301 Applications of pressure measurements 307 Summary 313 References 314 9 Wellsite Computed Logs 317 TheRwa log 318 Porosity overlays 319 Resistivity overlays 322 The SP overlay 324 The Cyberlook log 327 The Prolog analysis 331 Office-computed logs 333 Summary 334 References 335 10 Recommended Logging Suites 337 Fresh mud, medium-fe-soft rock logging suites 340 Hard-rock, salt-mud logging suites 343 Special situations 346 References 349 Index 351 INTRODUCTION The aim of this book is to present modem log interpretation as simply and concisely as possible. The book is written for the geologist, petrophysicist, reservoir engineer, or production engineer who is familiar with rock properties but has little experience with logs. It will help him specify good logging programs with up-to-date tools and hand-interpret zones of interest with the latest techniques. The book will also familiarize him with computer-processed logs generated by the service companies at the wellsite. Accordingly, obsolete logging tools are mentioned only in perspective. Very brief descriptions of the instruments in common use indicate how they apply to different logging conditions. Salient features of new tools, including Spectral Gamma Ray, Litho-Density, Dual Porosity Neutron, and Long-Spacing Sonic, emphasize how these tools fit into the everyday logging picture. The interpreter need not be overly concerned how a tool operates. What is important is the instrument's response to the various formation and borehole variables. In a similar vein, interpretation equations and charts are kept to the minimum needed for routine evaluation of logs. Fundamental principles are stressed, rather than mechanical application of formulae. This is particularly true in the chapter on shaly formation interpretation where an effort has been made to draw together the latest concepts in this ever changing field. This book addresses the normal well situation where a standard set of logs is run in a liquid-filled open hole to locate hydrocarbons in place and where promising zones are then tested to evaluate their producibility. Abnormal situations such as empty hole, water well, and geothermal and mineral logging are not included. To provide a little perspective, well logging is in its third major development stage. The first 20 years, from 1925-1945, saw the introduction and gradual worldwide acceptance of the so-called ES (Electrical Survey) logs. These logs were run with simple downhole tools and, while quite repeatable, were often difficult to interpret. The second phase, from 1945-1970, was a major tool development era, made possible by the advent of electronics suitable for downhole use. Focused electrical devices were introduced, having good bed resolution and various depths of penetration. A variety of acoustic and nuclear tools were developed to provide porosity and lithology information. There was a progression through second- and even third-generation tools of increasing capability and accuracy. Simultaneously, much laboratory and theoretical work was done to place log interpretation on a sound, though largely empirical, basis. xl