David Bain appendices tabs F to J

233 Pages·2012·1.87 MB·English

Ta F
BETWEEN JUSTICEI ANB INNIE
Itnerviewer
AND MILTONW EIR
Itnerviewee
DatoefI tnerview:1 9J uy2l 012
Palc:e JohWni cikfflHeo usDeu,n iend
Atntedees AnnabMeaklrh a(mCr owLna wO ffice)
INETRVIEWO F MITLONW EIR( IRNE SPECTO F CLAIMF OR COPMENSATION
BY DAVIDC ULLENB AIN)
BINNIJE:
Goomdo nrignM rW eir.
MRWEIR:
Goomdo nring.
5 BINNIJE:
Thanyko ufo crom inIga ,p epcriaittIe.h aveh eer bai eb alndiy fo uwo udl
sweairna nwsert ot hqeue sitonIs'.gm o git noa sk tyoot ulet lh tert u,ht he
whotlretu hs,oh elypouG o.d
MRWEIR:
10 Id o.
2
BINNJI:E
Thanyko vue rmyu hc.I w anttos ttaj rsutb yl otciawnhge rweea rien t his
peiceb ecaumsyme a ntdear aelfllayli tsno t wos ecotnisO.n e htoad sow ith
fatcuailno ncenacned tIh'semunp posteofd o ramno pinaisto onw hethite r
5 wasf atcuianlon cecnee,i tbheeyro anr dae sonadboluteb ort hboean leao nfc
porbbaitliieSso.t hatth'fesri s stei reosfi sssu,be uattt hsea mtei mIae m t o
rpeotir Ifw eret ofn idf atcuiannlo ecnec,a rteh ecronedt iioonrcs ic rumstances
thtam ake iintt h iene etrstosfj utsicteh acto mepnasitobne p aida,n dt he
mantdeai vse rgye nebruaitlt e 'sses ntiraelllatytop e rdo ceYsosuk. no wh, ow
10 itsh iinsq yud iearlwti tahte vesrtya agnesd ub seuqenattlt yht er ial?
Ando noef t hfee ws peciifntih cMesi i nstleert'itstse o er n uqiea rst ow hether
theew rasa f ialeut rom akea popprirtaee nquriietso aebsslthii noncecnea,n d
asy ouk nwo froymou ry eaorfsiv noelmvenwtit thh ciass teh,ii sasr efirnoa f
15 thBea icnam pt hatth ewraesa nu nfiaro cpersAsn.dt haitws h yIs ugegsted
thtwa ew orfkr otmh isi cPeo/lPCoolmipclaean sitA nuthtoyrr eiprtow,h iwcahs
focuosnep dr ocess.
SoI a mg ogi ntboed ealwiintsgho moef t hee csipftihtcag so t of atcual
20 incnenoce butw haIth avoen t hree cdow rertee tsimofnryot mh 1e9 95t rial
antdh e 200a9n dIt 'rnmiot ga oli,tn org e -hash tehxece irwsSheoo.r l aeel, l y
I'lmo okfironn ge wi fnromatainodin t d'rise ctteotd h see cnodp hsaeo fm y
inqyub iercauIs me-y m antdeai snt'oc to muep wtihtaehn w serto t hferi st
grouofpq uestiaonnsdt, h ecno mbea ctko N ew Zelaanadn dl ooaktt he
25 secognordu opfq uestnisoI.h avteo dweiatilaht l lo ncaeto,k ay?
And wtahyet hatw ilwpleor ceeidts h ta wIi blela skiqnusgeit o.nC setariyn l
ata ntyi myeo u nwtaa b era,kj suts asy oW.e a ern ootn a nryi igdt itmaeble
herWeh.e nIh avfneis ihdet hqeue stioIwn asn ttop osteh,ew new ilaldj onu,r
30 antdh ees rhodub lec offaerrveii nagts ompeo nitt,e aa,n cdo nfientrh neex t
room MwriB tahis rn e'prnetsaettiovs eeseit f h eea rerp onittsh ewyou dll kie
me too fa usy.ko
WEIMR OLeI NTERV(I1EJ9WU L2Y0 12)
3
Andw hetnh aitsd onmey,v ieiwst htaI 'dmo itnhgii tnse rvsioeb we,c ause
soembodwya ntsso mteihnags ekdd,oe snm'eta inwt i blela sk,eb duItw ant
toh ear twhheahyta vteos ayA.n dw hetnh adto'nste h,e n MaMkrsh awmil l
re-aemxiynoeuo nt hoisses sut ehahta vbee ecno verdeuidrn tgh meo nring,
5 jsutt ob ec leiatfrh ee raproeni ttsh awte rneo t calsea asrs hweo ulldei k
thetmob eo,ri s fh wea nttosb riunpsg o mteihnegl se.
Now thgeo veirncngon siadteirhoeenr i wsh aitsh efluptlom ei nm akimnyg
repoIr'tnm.ot s tiithnege ra sa J dugea ntdh iissna c' irtmi ncaasle a,n idt 's
10 noatc ivcaisl.e Ita'nsi nomfrailn iqrutyh arte suilnat spr oetrb ym et ot he
Miinstoekra,y ?
Sot hoaseret hgee naelgro runrdu les antdet siimnot nhtyayh otue rp o rvided
in2 00y9ou,r erfreeadta n umbeorfp onittsow haItc atlhlPe C A repotrhte,
15 PoilcCeo mpltasAi untorhirtpeyo tra nydo us aiadto nep oitnhtay to uh adn't
raeyl llookaetid ft ro lao ntgi maen ds oo n, Iaw nadnt tos ttaj rsutw itah
porcesqsue stiaobnot uhtte ar inoifnt ghd ee tecitinv eeDsdu itnnh atta koen
whawta sa v ercyo mlpeixvn estiio.gnN aotw MMsa krhahma as, l osol kei ka
weltlh uemdbc opoyft h1e8 83 edoiftt hiDeoe nt ec'tsMi avneuaCla.ny ou
20 jsuto utilnfeo mre whaaitnn gyit ourh ad tihsra etl etvoat nhtiev n etsigation
youu ndetrooikJn u noef1 994?
MRWEIR:
Welfli rsIat rrliyv,he eder inD unedino moont oiponyrnl aa ryb eefotrhea t,
befotrheii vsne tsigactomimoen necd,s od ay--tdoatyar inipnertgt myuc h
25 noithngT.h eo nylr eaali nttirhntagI ' hda tdh awtou ladpp eatrob ei ns ome
way for dealBianisgnc ewniet ahwte a itsth mheye d re tecpteriq-vueia flnygi
cousreo rq uafiylnicgou sre, hww heirsceo myeea srb efotrhiee ne vstiigo.an t
BINNJI:E
It hiynokju on ietdh feo ricn1e8 9 0?
30 MRWERI:
Thatrg'ihts.
WEIMR OLeI NTERV(I1EJ9WU L2Y0 12)
4
BINNJI:E
Andt heynou c amet oD undeiinwn h ayte ar?
MRWERI:
Ij onietdh peoi lcien1 890I.w as- Ij onietdh CeI Bfro,w anotf baet tret er,m
5 ina bou1t89 28/3e,ar l'y8 3I.w enttoC hricshtcuhrf roImvn ergciaalrnld
camet oD uendin on tpitrooodn m etoectsievreg eian1n 99t3 .
BINNJI:E
Sot heqsueia flnygti estthsay toj usu tr erfreetdof oard etecttiovopekal cei n
1993?
10 MRW EIR:
No, tnhoet yo opkalc -eI 'smor rbyu Itd otnr 'meembeexra cbtul-ty
BINNJI:E
Noj sutg enaeylr.l
MRWEIR:
15 Yess,o myee arbse fo1r99e3 s,o m-yt hqeu afiylnifgo ar d etecitsai ve
porcestsh agtoe sr ihgtb actkot her le8ya0 wsh eInw asi nv eIrngciaslrolI ,
wasa dimttteotd h CeI aBs a d eteccto-i fvrieso tf aac loln stoantb rllie.Sa o
you basyiocguao fl rlobyme, i unnigf orpml atcioln oe tsbh,u ytou s tlhilo ltdh e
desitginooafna c onasbtlaen tdeh na,f rtI,et ihnfkr omme moyr,s imxon thisf,
20 yohua sdu iatblree pionrtr e lattoyi ouornb ehviaoiutnrh CeI Bt,he yno wue nt
awaayn dy ou didIt ,h ifnrkom me moyr,e itah tehrer ew eeokr f uorw eek
indtuiccoonus rei tnot hCeI BA.ft ecro pmltneigt hta Itr unreetdoI vnergcialrl.
Id ipder ttmyuc ht woy eaorfsw hatc'alesld i ns-ervtiarcineng iu nti,sw hich
deawlitta lh o otft hies ssu,el oaot fw haytou 'slelie tn ah ti,tn h oel dde tective
25 mauna.l Sow eektleys atnsdt hinlkgiets h aatn tdh eantt hceom pletoifo n
tohseu nti,s tIh ewne natn ddd i qau a-la d etectqiuvafeyln iigc ousrea,n d
havincgo mlpettehda ctou srea ndp assietdI,w ast heanb lteo use the
desitginooafdn e tective.
WEIMR O LeI NTERV(I1EJ9WU L2Y0 12)
5
BINNIJE:
Andy out ihntkh waotu dlh avbee eanb owuhta yte ra?
MRWEIR:
Ohm,di 8 0s.
5 BINNJI:E
Mdi 80sa,n ydo um entido tnarhee eo rf uorw eeckou sre.W ast hmea nual
useads tpo aftr hiesn trtuicmoant reiafrolt sh ceou sre?
MRWEIR:
Id onr'mete mbeerx acbtulIty uwloidm agtihnaeit ct e rityna wloulhda ve
10 bee,n sy.e
BININEJ :
Sow oludyo uh avhea odc ciaosdnu irnygou rta riunpu ntli1 993t og ot horugh
thmea nuiasnlo mdeet a?i l
MRWEIR:
15 Duirnmgy t arinaisna g d etec,yt eisvb,eu atf rtt ehavte rrya raenldyId on't
thitnhkea yct uahlaladyd etectmiavneup aeslro nya.l l
BINNIJE:
Wast heeo rnietn h Deu ndeiCnI ?B
MRWEIR:
20 Oha,b slouteYlehya.t, h ee rwudolh avbeee ny,ea h.
BINNJI:E
Now thveol uemw hiwcehh avheee ra nwdh iicishtn h bioso lkeIvt'e p rovided
isd ated1 893.T heer aer somaed diiotnpaalg etsh at tsoeh eamvb ee en
substitiun1t 89e5ds, o tt huwadolb em oero rl escso nrcruewnittt hh ea itnring
25 youv'ej utds esbcer.di
WEIMR OLeI NTERV(I1EJW9U L2Y0 12)
6
MRWEIR:
Iw oudlt hisnoyk,es .
BINNIJE:
Ia mi tnreestietnd h wea yi nwh iht chiinsq yuw iasrs trtuuecrda nidyf ou j uts
5 opetnh beo oiknf roonft u y,toh e PrCeApt o.Or n tfrhisept a giett a lakbsot u
how theiv netsigasthiuoodln p orce,ea dndi tc arroineg se naellrya ndi n
paargra8p iht s ayast t heb ottoofmp ag3e, " Thbea siivcne stieg ativ
porcedeusrl aoiudit nt h deet ectmiavneu aanldi s iv naricalbolsyfe lolwlyeo d
ienv eirsnyat nec.D"o etsh aactc ordy ouwreix ptehr iee?n c
10 MRWEIR:
Yesid to e.sI otb viyod uepselnodnst htey poefi v netsitgiaboutny, e .s
BINNIJE:
Andi np araapg9hra tt heen ,di t taabloktushtd e et ect'ismv aenuaanldC IB
tarinniotnegs C.a ny ojusu t lmtlee w hatth CeI tBar inniontgae ers?
15 MR WEIR:
WelIlh ,av en oi desaor,r yN.oI d otnb 'uIt -
BINNIJE:
Sot hewseeer ns'otm teihntght ya ouw erdee taw litihnD uendin?
MRWEIR:
20 Unle,s sgIue sst htac oubledr erfnregit ot hosiens evricaei intnrg psa per
whihc tIae ldak boeuatlr itehtra hIa tdo p aspsat ro fm yt arinngti ob ecoam e
detec.t ive
BINNIJE:
Yes.
25 MRWEIR:
Ia susmet htahta wth'astt hartee'frrsi tnog.
WEIRM OLeI NTERVI(E1JW9U L2Y0 12)
7
BINNIJE:
PirotroJ un1e99 4 hadyo ub eeans sigansoe ffdi ciecnrh arogfte h sec nee
ona ntohehroi mci-daenyo thheorm iidccea s?e
MRWEIR:
5 NoIh andt'.
BINNIJE:
MhmW.a st haif si rasssti gennmats o fficiecnrh gaero ft hsece nien r eloant i
to acnryi? m e
MRWEIR:
10 No,Ih ado bviyo bueselinvn olviensd c neee xamniaitonrso,b befroire s
exapmlaen ds eribouugraslr iaensdt htas otor ft hibnugct,e ritynaI ld' nevre
bee-nI 'nde vheartd h relo eof o fficiecnrh gaero ft hsece niean h omicide.
BINNIJE:
Hady oub eeinn lvvoeidon t ehrh oimciidvnee sattiig?o ns
15 MRWEIR:
Yes.
BINNIJE:
Andw heynou w eraess igdn ienJ uen 1994 tot hciass ,te haes snimgent,
takiedt i tdh caotm e otuhgrRho bnisoonrD oyle?
20 MRWEIR:
Ic anr'mete mebre xacbtultyc, e iarttiy nw lou'lvdbee eeni tohfet rohs etw ,o
yes.
BINNIJE:
Andw ast haisssi gnnmtme adea tt hset taiotnhp,eo ilcset oant-i
25 MRWEIR:
Thatc'oresrc yte,.s
WEIMR OLeI NTERV(I1EJ9WU L2Y0 12)
8
BINNIJE:
-antdh -e
MRWEIR:
Yesiw ta s.
5 BINNIJE:
Andd di you havaen yd sictrieowni twhh oevietwr a st hta made the
assigntma esn toy ohwuoe wrt eoc arroyu ytou rd utioersw e reu l yeojftut s to
deawli tiahts y osua wf it?
MRWEIR:
10 Iw asl etftod eawli tihmt y seblafs,i cIar lmeleym.b tehroe n yld sicussIi on
hadi nrle attioto hnaw ats f roDme tecCthiievIfesn pectRoorb inwshoohn a,d
beetnot hsece new,h ot omledt haitnh,s iw odrsh,ed escriibates ad ' ohvel',
som,e ainn-g
BINNIJE:
15 House.
MRWEIR:
-thheo uews asa m ess.
BINNIJE:
Yes.B uitn terwmhsai tno qfiu etisor b em ad,ew haetvi deen wcast o be
20 colelcetdw,h atth iongusgtt h ob el oeodkf oirnt hheo usteh,wi ass l euftp t o
you?
MRWEIR:
Thta'csor rect.
BINNIJE:
25 Alrli gahnttd,h etnhp ee opwlheow eraess igdno etehrt as,ak sntdh earreae
lsit tohfei mtn h ree ptao trp ag7e,t hPeC Ar epoartpt a,r raapg2h0 .D id you
havaer loei nap pnotiitnhgeo mrw erteh eayp pnotiebdys ombeodeysl e?
WEIRM OLeI NTERV(I1EJ9WU L2Y0 12)
9
MRWEIR:
Ih aadr oilean p ptoiiDnnegt ecCtointvsbael Teh omsaosn tOhCee x ihibtfso r
thseec neO.u otft hlisist-
BINNIJE:
5 Yes?
MRWEIR:
-thatth'oesn yl pesront haIwt a sr esnpsoei bfrola ppoinhtiitmno tg h at
posibteicoanu hsewe a sp atro ft hset awffho had beeanp pnotietdot he
scenbey e itRhoebri nosrDo ony le.
10 BINNIJE:
Alrli gnhotwj, u tsi nte romfsh owy oup orceede,td hmea nutalalsk ,n otth e
manutahlPe,C Ar peotrt asl aktp arrapagh1 1g enaeylr hlowt op orce,e d
wheer,w henw,h yh,ow anwdh o,a ntdh einnt e romfsa rreassyt o,u ogvoe r
onttoht eo opfp ag5e,t hetyla akb ou"tAe,na irelarrr esmtay b ea poppriraitfe
15 theirsaep ossitbyti hlseius pecctou lrde -eonffod rfl weheie la tl agre."It ake
itth waats n ota ni ssiutne h ciass? e
MRWEIR:
Icte ritynaw lasna'nti ssfuoemr e .Iw asa t tschneee s,o i tn'osst o mtehing
thaIe tv edrwe lleodn o,rt hotua gbhoourct o neseridd.
20 BINNIJE:
Mhm.I nt he trtasn stochftrei ri apilit,s staiimaden dt imaeg atihnao tn
th
ModnayJ un2e0, D avBiadi wna ss eebnyt hpeo ilce vaitsci -am
MRWEIR:
Absuotlely.
25 BINNIJE:
-andt haitwt a st entattihvoeutlghyha ittwt a sa mudre/sruicidAen.dw e
knotwh ta,a ccoirntdgo M rD oylteh,ab tyW ednesndgiahytt h vei ehwa d
WEIMR OLeI NTERV(I1EJ9WU L2Y0 12)