Andreas Blank Biomedical Ontology and the Metaphysics of Composite Substarrces 1540-1670 Analytica Investigations in Logic, Ontology and the Philosophy ofLanguage Editors Ignacio Angelelli -Austin (Texas/ USA) Joseph M. Bachenski t Christian Thiel (Erlangen I D) Editor-in-Chief: Hans Burkhardt ( Murrich I D) Andreas Blank Biomedical Ontology and the Metaphysics of Composite Substances 1540-1670 Philosophia Die Deutsche Bibliothek CIP-Einheitsaufnahme Der Titelsatz für diese Publikation ist bei der Deutschen Bibliothek erhältlich ISBN 378-3-88405-098-9 2010 for this compilation by Philosophia V erlag GmbH Munich © TNPARTICULAR © 2008 by Massachusetts Institute ofTechnology (MIT) for Juuus CAESAR SCALIGER ON CORPUSCLES, THE VACUUM, AND COMPOSITE SUBSTANCES © 20 I 0 by Koninklijke Brill NV Leiden for ]ULIUS CAESAR SCALIGER ON PLANT GENERATION AND THE QUESTION OF SPECIES CONSTANCY © 2010 by Georg Olms Verlag AG Hildesheim for ]EAN FERNEL ON SIMPLE FORMS, COMPOSITE SUBSTANCES, AND DIVINE lMMANENCE © 2010 by Taylor & Francis for MATERIAL SOULSAND IMAGINATION IN LATE ARISTOTELIAN EMBRYOLOGY © 2007 by Cambridge University Press for COMPOSITE SUBSTANCES, COMMON NOTIONS, AND KENELM DIGBY'S THEORY OF ANIMAL GENERATION © 2006 by Cambridge University Press for ATOMS, MINDS, AND WALTER CHARLETON'S THEORY OF AN I MAL GENERATION © 2010 by Massachusetts Institute ofTechnoloy (MIT) for DANIEL SENNERT ON POISONS, EPILEPSY, AND SUBORDINATE FORMS © 2010 by Springer Science & Business Media B.V. Dordrecht for SENNERT AND LEIBNIZ ON ANIMAT E ATOMS For Kathrin 7 Contents Acknowledgements 11 Note an Citations and Translations 13 Abbreviations 15 Introduction 17 Chapter 1 Julius Caesar Scaliger on Corpuseies, the Vacuum, and Composite Substarrces 27 1.1. Introduction 27 1.2. Fracastoro on Corpuseiesand the Vacuum 29 1.3. Scaliger on Corpuseiesand the Vacuum 35 1.4. Corpuseies and Mixture 41 1.5. Coneiusion 45 Chapter 2 Julius Caesar Scaliger on Plant Generation and the Question of Spe cies Constancy 53 2.1. Introduction 53 2.2. Concepts ofBiological Mutability 55 2.3. Composite Unities and Subordinate Forms 57 2.4. SubordinateFormsand Species Flexibility 59 2.5. SubordinateFormsand Singular Species Mutability 64 2.6. Coneiusion 69 Chapter 3 Jean Femel on Simple Forms, Composite Substances, and Divine Immanence 73 3 .1. Introduction 73 3.2. Varieties ofDivine Immanence 74 3.3. SimpleFormsand Celestial Causation 76 3.4. SimpleFormsand Divine Immanence 80 3.5. Coneiusion 83 8 Chapter 4 Material Souls and Imagination in Late Aristotelian Embryology 89 4.1. Introduction 89 4.2. Liceti on Material Souls and the Union of Soul and Body 91 4.3. Liceti on Material Soulsand Animal Seeds 96 4.4. Liceti on Material Souls and Imagination 99 4.5. Parisano's Criticism 104 4.6. Conclusion 108 Chapter 5 Composite Substances, Common Nations, and Kenelm Digby's Theory of Animal Generation 115 5 .1. Introduction 115 5.2. Rarity, Density, and Animal Generation 118 5.3. Animal Generation and Minimal Parts 121 5.4. Mixture and Organic Unities 124 5.5. Animal Generation and the Epistemology ofCommon Notions 130 5.6. Conclusion 136 Chapter 6 Atoms, Minds, and Walter Charleton's Theory of Animal Genera tion 143 6.1. Introduction 143 6.2. The Metaphysics ofGeneration and Corruption 146 6.3. Vital Heat, Vital Spirits, and Animal Generation 150 6.4. Emergent Properties and the Problem of the Origin of Minds 156 6.5. Conclusion 162 9 Chapter 7 Daniel Sennerton Poisons, Epilepsy, and Subordinate Forms 167 7 .1. Introduction 167 7.2. Poisons, Epilepsy, and Diseases ofthe Whole Substance 169 7.3. Poisons, Epilepsy, and Chemical Causation 172 7.4. Poisons, Epilepsy, and Species Mutability 177 7.5. Conclusion 182 Chapter 8 Sennert and Leibniz on Animate Atoms 189 8.1. Introduction 189 8.2. Animate Atomsand the Question ofPalingenesis 191 8.3. Sennerton Animate Atomsand Emanative Causation 196 8.4. Leibniz on Animate Atomsand Emanative Causation 200 8.5. Concluding Remarks 203 References 211 Index 229