Alternative Perspectives on Psychiatric Validation DSM, ICD, RDoC, and Beyond

287 Pages·2015·1.886 MB·English

by  Peter Zachar, Drozdstoj St. Stoyanov, Massimiliano Aragona, Assen Jablensky

Alternative Perspectives
on Psychiatric Validation
International Perspectives in Philosophy and Psychiatry
Series editors: Bill (K. W. M.) Fulford, Lisa Bortolotti, Matthew Broome,
Katherine Morris, John Z. Sadler, and Giovanni Stanghellini
volumes in the series:
Portrait of the Psychiatrist as a Young Man Schizophrenia and the Fate of the Self
The Early Writing and Work of R. D. Laing, Lysaker and Lysaker
1927–1960
Responsibility and Psychopathy
Beveridge
Malatesti and McMillan
Mind, Meaning, and Mental Disorder 2e
Body-Subjects and Disordered Minds
Bolton and Hill
Matthews
What is Mental Disorder?
Rationality and Compulsion
Bolton
Applying Action Theory to Psychiatry
Delusions and Other Irrational Beliefs Nordenfelt
Bortolotti
Philosophical Perspectives on Technology and
Postpsychiatry Psychiatry
Bracken and Thomas Phillips (ed.)
Philosophy, Psychoanalysis, and the A-Rational The Metaphor of Mental Illness
Mind Pickering
Brakel
Mapping the Edges and the In-between
Unconscious Knowing and Other Essays in Potter
Psycho-Philosophical Analysis
Trauma, Truth, and Reconciliation
Brakel
Healing Damaged Relationships
Psychiatry as Cognitive Neuroscience Potter (ed.)
Broome and Bortolotti (eds)
The Philosophy of Psychiatry
Free Will and Responsibility A Companion
A Guide for Practitioners Radden
Callender
The Virtuous Psychiatrist
Reconceiving Schizophrenia Radden and Sadler
Chung, Fulford, and Graham (eds)
Addiction and Weakness of Will
Darwin and Psychiatry Radoilska
De Block and Adriaens (eds)
Autonomy and Mental Disorder
Oxford Handbook of Philosophy and Psychiatry Radoilska (ed.)
Fulford, Davies, Gipps, Graham, Sadler,
Feelings of Being
Stanghellini, and Thornton
Ratcliffe
Nature and Narrative
Recovery of People with Mental Illness
An Introduction to the New Philosophy of
Philosophical and Related Perspectives
Psychiatry
Rudnick (ed.)
Fulford, Morris, Sadler, and Stanghellini (eds)
Values and Psychiatric Diagnosis
Oxford Textbook of Philosophy and Psychiatry
Sadler
Fulford, Thornton, and Graham
Disembodied Spirits and Deanimated Bodies
The Mind and its Discontents
The Psychopathology of Common Sense
Gillett
Stanghellini
Is Evidence-based Psychiatry Ethical?
One Century of Karl Jaspers’ Psychopathology
Gupta
Stanghellini and Fuchs
Thinking Through Dementia
Emotions and Personhood
Hughes
Stanghellini and Rosfort
Dementia
Essential Philosophy of Psychiatry
Mind, Meaning, and the Person
Thornton
Hughes, Louw, and Sabat (eds)
Empirical Ethics in Psychiatry
Talking Cures and Placebo Effects
Widdershoven, McMillan, Hope, and Van der
Jopling
Scheer (eds)
Philosophical Issues in Psychiatry II: Nosology
The Sublime Object of Psychiatry
Kendler and Parnas
Schizophrenia in Clinical and Cultural Theory
Philosophical Issues in Psychiatry III Woods
The Nature and Sources of Historical Change
Alternative Perspectives on Psychiatric Validation
Kendler and Parnas
DSM, ICD, RDoC, and Beyond
Discursive Perspectives in Therapeutic Practice Zachar, Stoyanov, Aragona, and Jablensky
Lock and Strong (eds)
Alternative
Perspectives
on Psychiatric
Validation
DSM, ICD, RDoC,
and Beyond
Edited by
Peter Zachar
Drozdstoj St. Stoyanov
Massimiliano Aragona
Assen Jablensky
1
1
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford, OX2 6DP,
United Kingdom
Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford.
It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship,
and education by publishing worldwide. Oxford is a registered trade mark of
Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries
© Oxford University Press 2015
The moral rights of the authors have been asserted
First Edition published in 2015
Impression: 1
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in
a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the
prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted
by law, by licence or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics
rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the
above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the
address above
You must not circulate this work in any other form
and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer
Published in the United States of America by Oxford University Press
198 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, United States of America
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
Data available
Library of Congress Control Number: 2014940087
ISBN 978–0–19–968073–3
Printed and bound in Great Britain by
Clays Ltd., St Ives plc
Oxford University Press makes no representation, express or implied, that the
drug dosages in this book are correct. Readers must therefore always check
the product information and clinical procedures with the most up-to-date
published product information and data sheets provided by the manufacturers
and the most recent codes of conduct and safety regulations. The authors and
the publishers do not accept responsibility or legal liability for any errors in the
text or for the misuse or misapplication of material in this work. Except where
otherwise stated, drug dosages and recommendations are for the non-pregnant
adult who is not breast-feeding
Links to third party websites are provided by Oxford in good faith and
for information only. Oxford disclaims any responsibility for the materials
contained in any third party website referenced in this work.
Acknowledgments
The editors would like to thank Charlotte Green and Martin Baum for their
support and assistance during the preparation of this volume. Kitty Walker also
helped manage chapter submissions and deadlines. Thank you also to the entire
production team employed by Oxford University Press. Thanks especially to
Bill Fulford, who supported and encouraged this project from its inception.

Contents
List of Figures and Tables ix
List of Contributors xi
Part 1 Prologue
1 Introduction: The concept of validation in psychiatry
and psychology 3
Peter Zachar and Assen Jablensky
Part 2 Matters more philosophical
2 Rethinking received views on the history of psychiatric
nosology: Minor shifts, major continuities 27
Massimiliano Aragona
3 Reality and utility unbound: An argument for dual-track
nosologic validation 47
Adriano C. T. Rodrigues and Claudio E. M. Banzato
4 Validity, realism, and normativity 60
Dominic Murphy
5 Natural and para-natural kinds in psychiatry 76
Nigel Sabbarton-Leary, Lisa Bortolotti, and Matthew R. Broome
6 The background assumptions of measurement practices in
psychological assessment and psychiatric diagnosis 94
Jared W. Keeley
7 Neuroimaging in psychiatry: Epistemological
considerations 112
Ivana S. Marková and German E. Berrios
8 Translational validity across neuroscience and psychiatry 128
Drozdstoj St. Stoyanov, Stefan J. Borgwardt, and Somogy Varga
9 Psychiatry, objectivity, and realism about value 146
Michael Loughlin and Andrew Miles
10 Scientific validity in psychiatry: Necessarily a moving
target? 164
James Phillips
viii ContEntS
Part 3 Matters (slightly) more clinical
11 The importance of structural validity 189
Kathryn L. Jacobs and Robert F. Krueger
12 Validation of psychiatric classifications: The psychobiological
model of personality as an exemplar 201
C. Robert Cloninger
13 Person-centered integrative diagnosis: Bases, models, and
guides 224
Juan E. Mezzich and Ihsan M. Salloum
14 The four domains of mental illness (FDMI): An alternative
to the DSM-5 236
René J. Muller
Part 4 Epilogue
15 United in diversity: Are there convergent models of psychiatric
validity? 255
Drozdstoj St. Stoyanov and Massimiliano Aragona
Index 265
List of Figures and Tables
Chapter 2
Table 1 Contents comparison between Kraepelin and the DSMs 32
Chapter 7
Figure 1 Diagrammatic representation of structure of subjective
mental symptoms 118
Figure 2 Schematic representation of mental symptoms with primary
and with secondary brain inscriptions 121
Chapter 10
Table 1 Research domain criteria matrix 172
Figure 1 Schizophrenia 176
Figure 2 Major depression 177
Figure 3 Alcohol dependence 177
Chapter 12
Figure 1 The dynamics of well-being 202
Figure 2 Cycle of reciprocal interactions among the domains of
personality 210
Figure 3 Schematic summary of the psychobiological model of
personality 210
Figure 4 The temperament cube 212
Figure 5 The character cube 215
Chapter 13
Figure 1 Broad informational domains or levels covering ill health
and positive health in the person-centered integrative
diagnosis model 229
Figure 2 Cover of the Latin American guide of psychiatric diagnosis,
revised version (GLADP-VR) 231
Chapter 14
Table 1 The four domains of mental illness 250