Alteration of Scientology Materials Report

230 Pages·2005·0.84 MB·English

Alteration of Scientology Materials Report
Alter-is of LRH Materials in Published Church Materials
Misapplication of Scientology Materials
Introduction to Scientology Ethics Book
Life Orientation Course Materials
Division 6 Course
Researched & Written by
Gene Zimmer
Clearwater, FL 33763
1 90
Introduction
The situation described in this report is especially significant because Scientology public
and staff in orgs and missions all across the world are using an incorrect definition of the
Second Dynamic as a basis for various Scientology methods and processes.
When a basic definition is changed, such as the “second dynamic” in this case, then what
any PC or student is “doing” with their mind changes when the process is now ”applied”
with a different understanding of basic terms. Exchange by Dynamics does not result in
the same “process” if one uses “creativity” as the definition of the Second Dynamic
instead of “sex and family”. In fact, WHAT the person will be “doing” will change as the
definition changes. The results are different. The EP cannot be the same because the
person is “doing” something different. This is true for anything done using Scientology
where a correct understanding of the “second dynamic” is required.
MAA’s have been steering public and staff to use the “new” definition of the 2D.
There is no minor thing and anyone in charge of the application of Scientology processes
in any org should be concerned about what is happening under their jurisdiction. Please
read on. This is a KSW violation of severe magnitude.
2 90
SECTION ONE
3 90
Section One
The quote below is taken from the most recent printing of the Introduction to Scientology
Ethics book. This quote also appears in the LOC pack, and in a basic course pack (the
name of which I do not recall). Apparently it is also appearing now in other publications.
Please read the paragraph below. Ask yourself if it makes sense, and if it aligns with the
rest of extant LRH data in the related areas.
The SECOND DYNAMIC is CREATIVITY. Creativity is making things for the
future and the second dynamic includes any creativity. The second dynamic
contains the family unit and the rearing of children as well as anything that
can be categorized as a family unit. It also incidentally includes sex as a
mechanism to compel future survival.
Break it down into sentences and consider each of them.
The SECOND DYNAMIC is CREATIVITY.
Creativity is making things for the future and the second dynamic includes
any creativity.
The second dynamic contains the family unit and the rearing of children as
well as anything that can be categorized as a family unit.
It also incidentally includes sex as a mechanism to compel future survival.
Ask how each line can be that way, and ask how each line could not be that way. Pull out
the Data Series and apply the various ideas to these statements. Compare these
statements with all other extant LRH references on the second dynamic and creativity.
If you notice or realize that the first two sentences are totally false, that the last two alter
the pure meaning of the second dynamic, and shouldn’t exist in print as legitimate LRH
materials, close this report, because there is no need to read any further. Then take
immediate actions to get the false data canceled and the books reprinted with correct LRH
data.
If you somehow think, consider, maintain, believe or remain convinced that the above
sentences “make sense” in any way, and are consistent with all other LRH data on the
second dynamic, then please continue reading the report.
4 90
SECTION TWO
5 90
Non-Contradictory Definitions of The Second Dynamic
The definitions given here are taken from LRH books and issues. I have recently re-read
over 15 LRH books. I also sat down with all the OEC, Management and Technical
Volumes, Tech Dictionary, Admin Dictionary, What Is Scientology, and the Volunteer
Ministers Handbook. I have searched and read every index listing for “second dynamic”,
“dynamic”, “sex”, “family”, “procreation”, “create”, “creativity”, and “creation”. A
sampling is given below of definitions from many different sources that consistently
define the second dynamic as sex, family and/or the continuance of the race.
There were NO definitions found in any reference that define it as given in the LOC pack
and new Introduction to Scientology Ethics book. In fact, there was not one reference even
remotely close.
There are a few non-definition type cases where the second dynamic is discussed in
relation to the idea of creation or creating, and these are discussed in another write-up
included in this report.
THE SECOND DYNAMIC – is the urge toward existence as a sexual or bisexual activity.
This dynamic actually has two divisions. Second Dynamic (a) is the sexual act itself and
the Second Dynamic (b) is the family unit, including the rearing of children. This can be
called the SEX DYNAMIC. (Fundamentals of Thought, Chapter Four)
AXIOM 55. SURVIVAL EFFORT FOR AN ORGANISM INCLUDES THE DYNAMIC
THRUST BY THAT ORGANISM FOR THE SURVIVAL OF ITSELF, ITS
PROCREATION, ITS GROUP, IT’S SUB-SPECIES, ALL LIFE ORGANISMS,
MATERIAL UNIVERSE, THE LIFE STATIC AND, POSSIBLY, A SUPREME BEING.
(Advanced Procedures and Axioms)
2. Survival through Children (includes sexual act). (Advanced Procedures and Axioms)
2. Sex and family (future generations). (The Creation of Human Ability)
The SECOND dynamic is SEX. This dynamic has two sections, 2s and 2c. The first section
is sex itself, the sexual act, anything relating to the physical action of sex. The second
section is the urge for survival through children, the product of sex. This dynamic also
includes a portion of the family since the family as a unit affects the rearing of children.
(Handbook for Preclears)
THE SECOND DYNAMIC – is the urge toward existence as a sexual or bisexual activity.
This dynamic actually has two divisions. Second Dynamic (a) is the sexual act itself and
6 90
the Second Dynamic (b) is the family unit, including the rearing of children. (P.A.B. No.
83)
The second dynamic is the urge toward survival through sex, both the act and the
production and raising of children. (Introduction to Scientology Ethics – Previous
Edition)
The Second Dynamic is the urge toward survival through sex, or children. (Scientology 0-
8)
Second, the urge to survive through sex in the procreation of children. (Scientology 8-
8008)
Second dynamic has two divisions – first – Sex as an act. Second – Children and the
family, the future. (Notes on the Lecture)
Second Dynamic – Sex and Family (Notes on the Lecture)
THE SECOND DYNAMIC is the urge towards survival through sex or children. This
dynamic actually has two divisions. Second Dynamic (a) is the sexual act itself and the
Second Dynamic (b) is the family unit, including the rearing of children. (Notes on the
Lecture)
DYNAMIC TWO is the urge of the individual toward ultimate survival via the sex act, the
creation of and the rearing of children. It includes their symbiotes, the extension of culture
for them, and their future provision. (Dianetics)
DYNAMIC TWO is the urge of the individual toward survival through procreation; it
includes both the sex act and the raising of progeny, the care of children and their
symbiotes. (Dianetics)
The Second Dynamic is divided in two parts.
The first part of the Second Dynamic is the sexual act, which is as itself for itself. That
includes sensation, pleasure, pain and other things people get out of it.
The second part of the Second Dynamic is children, care and raising of. (The Second
Dynamic book)
This is the column devoted to the second dynamic. This dynamic would normally be called
sex. In Dianetics, one considers sex to be divided into parts; the sexual act; and the
product of sex, children. (Science of Survival)
7 90
Dynamic Two is the urge of the individual to survive through his progeny. The second
dynamic has two main sub-divisions, the sexual act and the creation of children and their
rearing. (Science of Survival)
The second dynamic is the urge toward existence as a future generation. It has two
compartments: sex; and the family unit, including the rearing of children. (The
Scientology Handbook, chapter The Dynamics of Existence)
Creating the Second Dynamic Lectures – A dynamic is an urge toward existence in an
area of life. The second dynamic is the urge toward existence as a future generation. It has
two compartments: sex, and the family unit. (Description: The Scientology Handbook)
THE SECOND DYNAMIC – is the urge toward existence as a sexual or bisexual activity.
This dynamic actually has two divisions. Second Dynamic (a) is the sexual act itself and
the Second Dynamic (b) is the family unit, including the rearing of children. This can be
called the SEX DYNAMIC. (The Volunteer Minister’s Handbook)
The second dynamic has two compartments: one is sex and the other is the rearing of
children. This dynamic is man’s urge toward survival as a future generation. On the first
dynamic he is an individual. But by sex – procreation – he creates other individuals and
future generations. This is an urge toward survival through children. (Personal Values &
Integrity Course pack)
THE DYNAMIC OF SEX embraces the procreation of progeny, the care of that progeny,
and the securing for that progeny of better survival conditions and abilities in the future.
(Dianetics: The Original Thesis)
2) Children (How to Live Though an Executive, glossary)
On the second dynamic, family and sex, we have gotten into a winning position. We know
the answers to marriage, children, and sex. (HCOPL 23 June 1960; The Special Zone
Plan)
The dynamics are: One, self; Two, sex; Three, group; Four, mankind; Five, life; Six; the
physical universe; Seven; thought; Eight, universal thought or infinity. (Dianetics: The
Original Thesis)
On the second dynamic, the individual is conquering future MEST wherein theta is
assured a line of conquest into the future. It requires for this both the sex act and children.
If one is to assure the future conquest of MEST, then it is necessary to insure that one’s
children can conquer MEST. (Notes on the Lectures, chapter Group Dianetics)
8 90
* * *
That is a fairly extensive listing of the LRH DEFINTIONS of the Second Dynamic, but
there are plenty more if you want to take the time to look further.
It should be noticed that among all of these definitions not one of these ever comes close
to describing the Second Dynamic as "creativity”. There are no LRH comments that
suggest even slightly that the second dynamic “includes any creativity”, and every extant
definition, in fact, specifically refers only to sex, children and their care.
In quite a few of the definitions LRH calls the dynamic the “sex dynamic”. From this it is
clear that this dynamic has much (or all) to do with sex. There is no way that the
following two statements can be true at the same time:
The SECOND DYNAMIC is CREATIVITY. (bogus version in new Ethics book)
The SECOND DYNAMIC is SEX. (Handbook for Preclears)
Unless we are supposed to dispense with all logic and reason, and accept or believe that:
Sex = Creativity (which is a falsehood)
Simple logic rules give us:
If A = B, and A = C;
Then, B = C
Or,
If One Dollar = Four quarters, and
One Dollar = Ten Dimes;
Then, Four Quarters = Ten Dimes
That is simple two-valued Aristotelian logic. If you are not familiar with that, then look it
up in the Tech dictionary or review any simple text on logic. The following two
statements are also mutually incompatible because they directly assert contradictory
things:
9 90
It (the second dynamic) also incidentally includes sex as a mechanism to compel future
survival. (bogus version in new Ethics book)
THE SECOND DYNAMIC – is the urge toward existence as a sexual or bisexual activity.
(FOT)
The second dynamic cannot include sex as a minor factor (“incidentally”) and at the same
time be an urge to exist as a sexual activity. The two statements cannot both be true at the
same time. Of course, thetans can conceive, imagine, assert and believe that these two
ideas are consistent, but in fact, they are not.
Comments
LRH clearly defines the second dynamic as having very much to do with the activities of
sex and family. He consistently refers to it that way, and weighs the definition heavily in
that direction time after time, yet the “new” definition relegates sex to some minor and
unimportant role. The definition of the word “incidentally” is “aside or apart from the
main subject”. LRH makes it very clear that SEX IS THE MAIN SUBJECT of the Second
Dynamic. A review of the above references makes that very clear. Sex cannot be both “the
main subject” and, at the same time, “a minor aspect” of the main subject. The two ideas
are wholly inconsistent and incompatible to any fairly observant and rational person. The
second dynamic doesn’t “also incidentally include sex”. The second dynamic IS sex. That
is, unless we ignore or cancel all of LRH’s earlier writings in the area. It sadly seems that
many Scientologists have chosen to disregard all forms of logic and somehow have made it
so that these conflicting facts no longer conflict. These data cannot agree or align yet
thetans have somehow mentally forced them to do so in their apparent goal to make sense
and ensure consistency of anything and everything.
Since the definition in the new Ethics book (and the LOC pack) is the ONLY example of
it, and since there are numerous examples along the very different lines of sex and family,
it makes complete sense to throw out the version in the new edition of the Ethics book.
They cannot both be true because they describe very different things. The words and
concepts involved refer to different things, situations and realities.
The wording of the new version in the Ethics book, even after discarding the first two
sentences about “creativity” still leaves the reader with a different understanding in sharp
contrast to the many examples given above here. Sex drives the second dynamic, and it
alone propagates the life forms of any species. Sex is NOT some overall “creativity”, the
second dynamic is NOT creativity, and saying so and putting such into print, besides
being false, can only cause a student difficulty in understanding and application.
10 90