AI ART Machine Visions and Warped Dreams JOANNA ZYLINSKA MEDIA : ART : WRITE : NOW AI Art Machine Visions and Warped dreaMs Joanna Zylinska The MEDIA : Art : WrItE : NOW series mobilises the medium of writing as a mode of critical enquiry and aesthetic expression. its books capture the most original developments in technology-based arts and other forms of creative media: ai and computational arts, gaming, digital and post-digital productions, soft and wet media, in- teractive and participative arts, open platforms, photography, photo- media and, last but not least, amateur media practice. They convey the urgency of the project via their style, length and mode of engagement. in both length and tone, they sit somewhere between an extended es- say and a monograph. series editor: Joanna Zylinska AI Art Machine Visions and Warped dreaMs Joanna Zylinska OPEN HUMANITIES PRESS London 2020 First edition published by open humanities press 2020 copyright © 2020 Joanna Zylinska Freely available at: http://openhumanitiespress.org/books/titles/ai-art/ This is an open access book, licensed under creative commons By attribution share alike license. Under this license, authors allow anyone to download, reuse, reprint, modify, distribute, and/or copy their work so long as the authors and source are cited and resulting derivative works are licensed under the same or similar license. no permission is required from the authors or the publisher. statutory fair use and other rights are in no way affected by the above. read more about the license at creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/ cover art, figures, and other media included with this book may be under different copyright restrictions. print isBn 978-1-78542-086-3 pdF isBn 978-1-78542-085-6 OPEN HUMANITIES PRESS open humanities press is an international, scholar-led open access publishing collective whose mission is to make leading works of con- temporary critical thought freely available worldwide. More at http://openhumanitiespress.org/ contents acknowledgements 7 ai (and) art: an introduction 11 1. a so-called intelligence 23 2. The ethics of ai, or how to Tell Better stories about Technology 29 3. Why now? ai as the anthropocene imperative 39 4. ‘can computers Be creative?’: a Misguided Question 49 5. artists, robots and ‘Fun’ 57 6. The Work of art in the age of Machinic creation 65 7. Generative ai art as candy crush 75 8. seeing like a Machine, Telling like a human 87 9. Undigital photography 105 10. an Uber for art? 117 11. From net art and post-internet art to artificially intelligent art – and Beyond 129 12. ai as another intelligence 137 Future art, art’s Future: a conclusion 145 (art) Gallery of Links 155 notes 161 Works cited 165 acknowledgements everal events gave impetus to the emergence of s this book. The 2017 edition of the ars electronica festival in Linz, austria, held under the banner of ‘ai: artificial intelligence / das andere ich’, served as its original inspiration – and provocation. i am extremely grateful to the organisers for the invitation to present at the festival symposium and to see the art- works, many of which featured, or engaged with, ai. i am also much indebted to daria parkhomenko from the LaBoraToria art & science space in Moscow, for asking me to speak about the renewed interest in ai in art as part of the conference ‘daemons in the Machine: Methods for creating Technological art’, held at the British higher school of art and design in March 2018. Last but not least, the opportunity to serve as a jury member and keynote speaker at the awards ceremony for p3 prize, focusing on collaborative and interdisciplinary developments in the field of post-pho- tography and organised by Fotomuseum Winterthur at The photographers’ Gallery in London in May 2018, allowed me to crystallise the skeleton of my argument acknowledgements 8 that went to on become this book, while also planting the seeds of the visual project which accompanies it. sections of the book have subsequently been tri- alled at the royal college of art, prague’s FaMU, the University of applied arts in Vienna (die angewandte), Ben Gurion University of the negev, Vassar college, international photography festival photoszene cologne, Berlin’s internet and digital society conference re: publica, University of Manchester’s Whitworth Gallery, pratt institute, Trinity college dublin and Tekniska museet in stockholm. i am grateful for all the invita- tions, the generous engagement with my work in all of those places – and the new ideas and directions all those visits sparked off. i am very grateful to the artists who have gener- ously shared their work with me, in particular Katja notivskova, Leonel Moura, Guido segni and Mike Tyka. i owe a special debt to Mario Klingemann for his elo- quence, patience and generosity of spirit in engaging and humouring me at the various platforms we have shared over the recent years, especially when i raised issues with ai-driven art. My biggest debt of gratitude is to the legion of amazon’s MTurk workers, whose ‘arti- ficial artificial intelligence’ – as amazon unironically puts it – is responsible for the more critical direction this book has ended up taking. Many individuals have helped me develop and fine- tune the ideas contained here. i would especially like to thank Giovanna Borradori, Tomas dvorak, nea ehrlich, Beate Gütschow, alex Grein, Greg hainge, anne Kaun,