2 THUCYDIDES THE HISTORIAN, You discovered when - Angelfire

21 Pages·2011·1.04 MB·English

2. THUCYDIDES THE FIS'TORIAN,

ow discos when ceding show the Scion Repo Haw hint of the dine
sipm re payed Chics own ew veniam appenent stator
hse, Belous yi goon end more cxtasely Cm li wor J ould ike go 9
condor ene eviderse we have about Thurles sms meted under g his
Akkaya the Plopnican Wan

24 THUCYDIDES AIMS AND METHODS

Meow: wad ‘hey LY ant 21 3° Az yu zon uke bah note othe Elling

{8h Why do yo nik Thoepies suc eh purine bis ustey uf he eF

{19 Thayldesmeons to mis eapomeons oko wig. Whe ae the sd
tov docs hey tha he aces them

WPT RER IRIS ELE SOOM P OS NTT OIESONE

{bi Youigh lev upped sha he wus was real inporen to Taeydider nd
‘outs itd, sons, gover swale i (We dames koa ease wheal were
Taam be ssreatngesin 424th hem have ater ke minima ga iy.
ac thn) Hora a ths eae at he eae salty Bile He ded sonst ihe
fina Athan cen in 408. Boe perranalcoidrations se wt th nin Thay
‘hams sina de ingpatanes uf the war Although wer wae eodenie amoug De Che
sink, at oas th legit seope uf che Plegorman War wlih dingnbed i
hassles. Na ple cel ecg bung desman ceo al Benne
‘on th sudgcak fats gions Well ad the succinyl wth wee
eteie sti prorated. ye se well jaefying bi wnat cathe woul oF Be
Inyertanc our, hazy dds an aw hail wate pein eaking
vl sesnuneocun loc he ahs heli he at v0 sntcnsin 2) hasbece uh
Mixpn by char uk ar he preige ai om seam Ua ou bat Theale
rushing abe elsins: The Bre be tht hie wack wil ly people waar oe
happaved — surely am inpescable aim toe the Worn. His acasmd la is lest
sangria. syed! sian wl be we Lin efi he ae
Strives aie The ropes Goin what dnt Ties an byes Does eed
it lies sh tory il epen itel psepe eels Fora tay vie te ey
vies ia ancaprta ee psegs a naan ustcrcbsing hac Thueyecdees tot
wean ke bear eapeat lf evselly tr thes it sitar poles soos ola
eis tl atc last dh aking nd eerie of pace oul ant apn me
ste ie wsch nmenbsning tar Thesiger at sing trex edncaed adored
{Geek utiense~-menvho roads italy co havea yal inthedeiooe makngpeocetof
kei a ya the uadertading' hick he shes perma wand den wedi

Ive weal ication
hi_The tou sopoaua of hintosen weiiog Mangala hy Thay (nba) te
Ae ence nd Ec partg oe ovo cn raed Song
the move sughutrwaed. His stats nates, bed nly op the eotapisen 30

sian af eye-wlunes avourtenéaperal sean othe pasty Bins gear
a the pr afin pus Ew here, 26) he eveicen Usa hac hive gave
hn 3 moe balaneed sear ofthe evidence tee bd ade tha ihe lad semaine in
22 THUCYDIDES: THE FACTUAL REPORTER

‘There an rany substan wees nfhivarcl wri Ter. Se nen sa
sconibined with esriples al oa hae aren encore a enna wn you
‘he section a the dept a he Sein xpeen, Moy Lvoul tke yout rad
artical fran parse hh Thay feropt hi anraive nf hers
Aheseconl year of ae (10) oF ees dtl herp “hick ds
sc Alben Phase rend Todi a7 8. Ab or rend hep in id hos

questions Cevaking noes i wi

G) Tu whut vst do you eibk Thuy eerie cept 4 ied ean

(65) To what anew Aor ic infeen aur anderrtanng af the ages al Ra

(19 roe up yout vind sb tis you il ave en ems eh he pcg fen ort
of te page nthe maerative andthe apy sceunaslf ble Tir

IIE NDOT TTPO SETTER EIT

‘she Eee mare pot te mote te wy in lich They sel the rena he
inmeane maraive context. He dearer ihe Pelnnesinn easy che Ate
‘rye, whleh in gar aeouoets Rar the congcasinof oporinn win As
iel€ (52). Thicewergepubein cere the serine a th peste ined Te
incatiny a eroded coins my “wel Have cenribal on the esis Pe
pilemie (hich wae probably “phe

Nolee tn hacelthough Tuc decel dus det the sympa of he iti ek
equally Saeceted in the lcs mci.

Dil you notes that Thueyder mer ice rom Veils’ Fener Spereh MAY
Inthe anor of he play: (30) Tink ack sso ado he Fone pon
(One and compare the sisaphan fenatisn of Ahewim achiceement a tsetlelidon
coweyed by the spech with the salering wo toca ngnetatian dense rh
scconnt of te pig. hndeed,isiothivelesining pe fhe aren 51-4) eee
‘imtast with the sf ceailant society pretayed so the Feral Spec fo
pried

Om balance, before. mn yaa huey inden nee des
tm heyond hare y rogue by te mare, thera a hols rely Ps
fe ane anderson tet rvrly of the evcnts af 4 be tere parley elie
fats of iets nex siny and psa yg ca 3 ym wl nd
Cousin in the plsge's securrnee aul ie effects ob the Fen ert othe
Sdhenian, Surprising’ she effect on manpoveeisisnstianed intact ths sect
Sn of, 563), ohsbly bresuse Thocyes ently omer nih the eel se
Police ees, lading reemrte tr orl fe is mie omens Sechus SI

Use! hi actin "etd: he Fatal reper il lay Ws eu sha
salty on eioprleal evidence, Bet he point af the aerars Tes ie These
Imterpsetae ol whet happened Even citar non. lcheugh hiatal essere
Dew deere a iis irs cleat theists ot mel whe secure testing
‘of daa tt als of luninating Ms ental heme, the pops fh anh upon
Sod nverpreaciohoftheceienee

23° THUCYDINES: THE REPORTER OF SPEECHES

The mtd oid by ae bist in the at apecksn ie adhe a ey
enconatered i any study of Tepes Formal oes aed dehaves te ah chen path
of wy anew hitcra's work — st shen ies ax tener ba hob inladed
‘Wihac isin here is Zhe dscerne af he ay he tacts ehem, (An Pe he
use the pat tease tego Line we ca abe Shieh lee page a talc
scbievetent not merely af ineaton) Me ackwedgys the imi yee

2
seen $e tepoting. Ui eel wus crea "while sping a closely os posible tthe
sonra save of words tat ete acnaly Ged, tue the pears mp hat ney
ra et ralle Eby each suaion Agi tpg to aterpen thrncence wesc
"ating schelilseunell. Notice tae Wyden shes dvetonberrcce Wt
wesc ofthe peels he himself card al om ported at cso hand, Whar he
chiang thar ‘hs ramnieat of each apsech cnnvtye let wus nectar ike
‘ercunalauses wha as calle fox by ch stuatnyinocber roel wrsuen cs
sel fb cn aden samt wa wee the sal esol prnilesivoloedc wes
hee ine couveying che sen nine of hatte speakers Te pecan then ore
ot rasan ivan. fu ey ar (5 well am bsg vial eveseotns ae nose
cpl" wn eenumsatary on eheuadedying rsa eatin and event whic
ree spt ally. Comers a he reltanship bere spelen alpine
soi be antl ie in eu aad of te Sinn Bs pen,

You ars tow ging toad IL 59-8, which ede la pel of sie ogee with
‘haw sides out sarurenr, baw. ebiuen hin spec for specie atcaton beecne br
teres aatrly wit one ence rating uf the FunedlSpech al with Be olga
teins Ie abe ater sme ie welch wll bs important or your tay of he
Dali Bape, Psu ral seston ceil nl wee shot meter an then topes

{5 ue Gin cay sk Peles post was pial hy wath append en che
Aiken oe det tro yoatr of be ea?

(3) Wha, ascnting te Uhael, Perils atcede othe pte?

1 Foe lossy a Seton 85. Whois Uys’ Pasig?

ROAR GTEISNTREA TTS H LOTTE OSI LET

Pinson

{Bowel te sgstd your wom as only 3 mating on far he dacs)
1a) Pov! posinos Tau dest ingen rementetha Peis wera slectedenes of
Misco nacray us oF ss en stestego see Uni Ce, Sevina 22 2 fle wan Move

seecantae ancl his psi 4 et the id secegoe aed oun or
ity wal eepoaten sal win nosaa ofl pot, td ean te be wld have bora
be bot peli oe moltary eva. Ii pep deans tht Thucydides
Suggest thas policy spel of Perils wat devcted ats de men not ay oa
Acinvine be devatced by lags nd hae esmnryle cea tos teed Serie
ivan, Rut clo the expiry furor which Peels hal argmnized ager the
Pehonie Hh 6) re oly paul sacewatl adhe ep efanc those,
Hage fo rape Pes ks i 1, 8) rey Ink tates 59) ne adie
"ean blans Piles fr having pid hem nova wasn an wes yore
(01,38 14, why ial fon =tcre Ba 2, besides Pvc the policy of

(i) The evsersoan of dhe pups af dhe ented ins the city inthe face
Invacine by Spartan bndorct

{HD Considvinn of way acength raphe dm engaging in bed by lh ad

‘ov elice oe hag uc emer amase Sr iention woth he ae
Fras Thr caloaton fe aol vanprandpopeiy m sterile satbeak
Pn he erred bayou en, a jedon etcctom Absence
Tatyhes ges hl 9) He rena i Des wishing trebles Sees
{eet sally adel to besmnmoned bth pene, re Usenet
2a. aihongh docile Pent protige wen sac Ha ey woul ot have eal be

et sh Three epi hs ome ech fn lng
veka ovat Thi orgie he way tn lac Thassos ny
Soeslest et Wa harass hac hedowress ean, open
"ling su heer choc the the Athan Pole rps at
ole pion wos caly lice d by Bug. Se ean care rt
hn, bu posi cuterned me Hana mpropity. This wes aac! aetna
sk enesing pps of ding tin pyc We ltr
Stee canned Atel Fanos seh Phys nde
Beskee ea snc fod ne ci Lanse ts Ebon pl
oohion

Tao ey latch eile pa wan alee dit si aon wih
‘cae appl, ge sine reanimation af opr: ne han
string abou slow hotwnen the famnracy in isdn se ae
"the ylcy decisis of ihe Atsely (bough compre Thy mak lS
sth ane of orchid On, Seon #2 Seco
Sana the teurtand ssn iced we Aten ple, rly Reais
so isn fel plage, bun al cae fe erect
descation of hi eee iy, hye" olen vt noe =
lnegr pengetive Han fa de ore nputing of veal eine Ho ie
ttc made wit ne avsaags afd Ie sees eran
two raid tons; ah an thar sonra a he king od ean
rower pope ts dete able abch Flees hae? sae ka
lence the condoe te

(ey Peneles stew 0 the Emgiee ant the wae, acueding te Thurs, ae
ose ecameted spt of He part, Brel, Poieos wets dato Salvia
tear fare pt che late al oth, So fra he war feserine sl be oh
Sihonottable an dean ty tose peace merely bce shy we er F
snl depressed Not he ser paca 16 al el ba reo
sch yl that Pile appeal He sis rests te Ahsan thts sie

in ther omg (Fs een cloel lsh of the Aen spokesman
Sparta athe ate Pe sn, 7 Tay gi sno the ili ye
Soar bu baie Faia Fle fecen of ek prispesiy ave toe, Per ee

Tesiere the Athen’ cendenee hy erphitatd the Sn sate sao
supenet oF the allie bat un the Athenians reid aapentny Ulor ewcdon o
Snurrasoe nfs pear compate I, 399d Healer the CO wc abu
AB The yage fn which Ie evinjnss the poser aemng fare the wry with he
lluence presented by hove aida pel sienomet evn psn
thse who wate alg Sor pene represented the iets they
feors swerve dvs by Sea

"Tc lds maker eric apply vrs sil apcatsn se ectinow Eure,
Holding om oo the Fuge 2 ater both oF hrm al <I sll ere, lhe
‘Inger ole tgs. he analy wa sprenny he ean mich ics, Sore hor
ser at ata evil ml conn by Tharydes ut ¥il the Gece of theless
esse fm he reakatic imc tat eh yore be ral te
se depoted — an fing ts cveniye pesion gener they las vuthory cade =
faring that de sme le tne of inj owen

‘We sl etre the next sei to probe eseeemed with sseesiae pss
boc hese ie slifcant Hat Pile snacies the setng up sd ried fee Ere
vik cea yale of the eirtens — cautaye,iklinre med the copy deck s+
atin. Politically jal ioe racteve people sme lors with ase le aarp,
bee pace the sage te oe oll wer “he wor

he we iret pas
sap dhe est. feo se work comping the avin epiene in A wh oa
‘etre nthe quaiie label inthe Funttl Spssch (Unit One, Sex.

(61th ropa ie They’ tine Peis the whale serongepe e bea
vindrrion of Pesce. tthe pmeript ne wees Teele afl Pe le plies
Tisintericy al bisjudyersemtsigniesely coping Poles uns chee 1)
ssssara, whose plies were esa, boda tue tions sm es dong mtd fh
"ain were ft Ge Let offal eve, Note expels che cnt bene
alleged capaciy of Betis to goide she dstsesacy iesiretifrling fal
‘hazyieeasertin be ee aubaequere leader pee ile Ase
thy lee rami of pac tot fet Perec act out (and Thuy ides ov a fv
leaderhip—knledge fs mund waren anh oiiy ev espucs iii aeons
Ue Azebly), ernie th inegriry a ptatian, In esting Bersales 2
speck Theyddes (sav! only yiving oe We own jadgenea! wf Pesci pices sl
attinds, be eli on what be, oa hii ha ch thi ws ie
timo ht hey doubted sid feared, what Hey valed wo ened atwccing ew hoy

“
esac inesf ae, Toone she speck tikes noe of inmeincy and ei which
ching tke ealted eject mcr of ee Fonte Speech Bat ply Boe of the
ise fhe Fat Sper weight he sn digs bring eee wey bys
ihe Jetgeuers concen ie, Whey Thasyids denis Pelee diel and
Seven ow a Es nell eqn as el ston wl eal eevee io
the Aken, he decent ell wee whole wary. He conveys tee Porehran ome,
Fog engine histanesrn wih pliy athe soto te war (Oise
skate she s¥e0 before te wr Verily have ren aner very severe atch nbd
sored the prance of ome af bis rca, oe Units Section Sted Cae Sde
Pond 3.
‘We shu neal encode the extent which Thucide acl n Feiks cout
1y fa view the wrorhug uf the ermcruey-hoveanach 4 daz mere fact of ore
prem hich Thuspdadee braed) conte tn the, pully reimient eel
Themis setts? Was povermmeeby te Gat cise pradelby Vheeyddes ac oort
2d high ser evils’ jrdgenen oe heraue hz dst ed the reac of tee
‘scemby of Louk? Ie spins thar Thuyde, necting tae ibe Asem 8
‘onvincal by Pesce’ egmons s agred xan hii, a8 bc of od
posed ay way. Th what ental bt comment onthe Askew’ x cleogs of nd
{facehe say withernes) coumtsbalnced by dhe esideave clewbereinthe seem it
ivan goes al coring eany a he pation whic earl eto esc apeet
‘he ssl apptoul of eves ad aach Win peramallt The Lee pone soe
ween he waking of det at9iulathr chan aerclyem ecg eens of
edad jean
iv agent poe Cassetoe Nancy, You ould ise to Ha eve yo ead fetid

fis es

«6
3 SPEECIIES AND DEBATE IN THUCYDIDES

So far yau fave Ton in some devil a to ofthe aprsher i Thcales Boch er
Arh 1 Peles bat yn 30 hoe it pte one cal tn ths pet
fierenzre iy content and ove were 4 sei ofthe Rcd’ en the estan 39
‘cera om he tive actinm Youn, to that the Hatin canes or

reporting ened giving sping role Ws judgeriene svat ska rsh
Zequzed at well oculing the ewe of what ar
you srse rang these of Tey wk you wraldcnranrser ony iene

bind of seach, sang Bar the Fngral Speech Heong deltas the Assy
Uetwcenambasans i generale eacourngenent to ee eopator bat te
setton fl is spate quetons bout eathshiphetneen pelos and ae
tn hci’ acco ef the Sten Fxpedition. tn he eon Vago tok
fet an ene rather spcilexangse ul Thacedte’ oe of este i avd de
1 ial £4, 89-119}. The dates Has peovebed ap enced rage al eal
frwrment he sos portant excels of sie lited abe yom frter seing
have chosen ts cones i ere fr co eesone Thema sil ep fern 30
ndeestandag ofthe Sciam Epon, ds eth erty he ee ery
power st atin Pees hy I, ad Coola ze of these a
sts whi erly he dents sb Sicily sich ot nll ences Ms
{1 Seana he fogs ae ale hak imperanqpstons abo thal

Thasyles hear 7 he hela nl exerting of power Ths digas el 373
will dicaver far fers repeal of Tedd trestnent of delberatin and slvr
Diglenatic sel pola metre ae etpped ay Uh hati conten whieh 2
harroing but mut ubtyien, no explved

3 THE MELIANS AND THE ATUENTANS

Fis. a wurde econ end florins Aegean ee Mine
the Coun Cae nd county vfs tn py tbo te Aen oe
ince towards Spans sly hive ven be upp Ws aware ae
ig ate foe ohare of Re lea Eure dw py Brame sls See
ose on ie Seo al fi wachnged a recy send hh
ey ape were lle, et uth popes enol usr efooe
iA, vielen se le Sch Habel tent. 12)
Mt on a (8) What gn hey laps ae

lait loge been he Ns ne lows gre

tere Mosbade

32. THE MELIAN DIALOGUE

Please ead Thad, V.#4-13band Ayycadis ofthe Pngsaneition ppt tiwhiek
says semathing about he unypicl arf sly Sbucyllec teammate testes
props tu leo aly rio af he reap preblens the doe ese sl el hely iy
Seep there te quetons fn ind 25 you read

(5) Wh the Aton © basic juidoatn order etsn in ebsceing Mele?
(3) What delet dae nse in eying en Aecoeey Thiele ow ade ro wht
Resid?

WLC REIMER TESCO OTE IMO TOVTPE IIE

(poke = op tthe We

4%
2) "he Adhean state shat they ane no0 ingen jut hel cin by dhe oul entire

Nsabst ei hoi etn the kaden of he Guvis again de Povinal Be
ar ey anes wit wha ui jst or coat ene wih eligioetohels arcing
teat tea uur mtecents must be panini snd snr they cobs racdale nae
ntl les they weit exeicir hele opeioe poor an de> = in owe and
vwecesiy aw of matte eee heaven ame et (¥, us).

Me philsophical maplizations of thicmy inter! you, You willbe se wwenjtote her
is OnicTenan Pew Piw Ging. Yo may have cemumberd, te laswrs eediog
len Sues ae Gb) hates was sane lyng once esee,
veto leon Diodouss tha de Athens boul alrnpvscei ith suns Te
‘iho war mon thout wotaty, it wav shown da ingecanenn ar tbor sete ee
Slew: warm Ahean test inces, As Diode pesi teal ups you neers

volte coer a. ho aot be stayed ena nuh hy pip oe by oniny dee
Kelis as oachan Clea, wish voarvie saliency uuketone, lnk liveng
‘is eoorse ps wll ee acing wit Sor the Ese ull | lng uanehng which
eke gr esos Fan yo tw” CE 8

iy ems

ve the Athen indent cree. She is weager thn Meky end
‘cys anions cis ala me ansfictghe gv, eh Cok
stein ofthe aganenantastatieaerlsohe Albee okie oe
= i lo joing Speen dat

3 nese acre scouaye bet eco ae dae ied Revonah
0 fi ac ened). Barbe deve now tea Wags eter he

1 Atherina? A bet of tor
stv ds On hee Mtl beer ed
his oe nf the eos you wl be explora 2
Uchewr sha be dowing one aenton tn the"anaccep le fae of opens barkes
Hein a + mals tung oa ene teva. Tis ince me a ee de
Dost, Dur i the sean! Gat ne ray hau

‘ysl

rs cant ber iinabat They aia rs ea ay
<i icy tha bes outta pena ithe of twa vewpeine eeafed eae

hws pact. Wa cles ete th sbtnsemumevi le utvceesep ta
fat Tt sae "ago ceo a oan a ea

Jindal portance tobe snduct a the pin and of he wer, He egg ecar
‘sees te Ahsrats genetics. to tounge atess a ees elie
boned te bis taal exploration fst atl diploma eseeere le need ngs
lak romnsot on ie hueth relies of Be Maglt nag x he val gh bate
revere deuie, Ula other pees, dele enor commeany rtp
“ie af aren alhongh wemay he 3 waremenety aw the whole sak loping
‘chat he sasirion requir’, Taye con bundy be efering athe eopienee oat
planes? the vegunemon' axe ar tho aoc wand emereue opt He
og bls wn he sv vpion, alecaly intone os the Mylene dba cones
et ausoing tn eu wien mtereste a they gracive hen sedan she fs coe
thas the posimeteas of ntere te delned By power This conjanetin of tee aed
Die a ssporsn orn derstand uf be prchslay bein Ue Aten cones
Skil wohich ge ball ten inthe eat ston

Iden neste ¢

bt seca
4 ‘THE SICILIAN EXPEDIHON

‘This i the ore abso cecton of ewe no wil be ding most o our died
reading nf Tianhe. We dll be prog the weal an tw
Pevnctns, Bein poe ve aod inerpecnon of Thuyier are ain mere 1
bil sl eda othe prelnary meas whee ae ae nes et tome
ths nt The anette sas cioainDaed 2 whl calc aspect so
Sccredy in fees on he fe (ont rete inden Ania
tail ce reer yon Bee tia qa om Unit Ove al enn 1 eh
thi ae ow the Atheism ley delim, hn i hin sme
svorki id he they scabies tyng tna oof eto whisk ah
Spare had lle,

Thais poe dred acon of he ila Expo in Backs Usa LY
sel ere exqrea a dts ety, gle dat ny fl
“tom toed ragh he whole econ, Out a lead wil ons fp
readug of key pssges Seco 42 16) illned he rls fo
jes "Why Hil Aten in ie Frton 2) Keep Fs -vel
Yow sore Hough she felon bik a ep

44° THE IMPORTANCE OF SICILY

Plea ook: Map Ith rhe Cree ide, You ons dt the Sil cesar ented
valle of Athens oe oF Spars. Acruly, che poo way clr wns sme ie!
hongeatle The reso Forth are tobe Fed The mig of the iis ares Ie.
Rodio Programme t, Grmk Cnlosfatin, A. Guahiny capsid Fos srracer oh

Sigore in Ye,

bene sf Lee

L ts

Sie

EP Hind eet cl

SEmigeatn

se ett he
Fan ah Noe Sb etn Liar afi ed Me ie ge ee
en

epic topic Frm shawighth evant wt atheannury ele te nse eer
Conuling clone along chr Mereearcan ean acy te apically posing
“non ne sottasn aly and Sly. Thee 9€¢ apart eclopta ferences Beran
osc Sty lhe lad which wares sacive colonization Acie Sly wae
Sl cella youd ply of ates fata iversandapngs, Ue vanilla ich,
Igor thn sways 4 se sl a Ferales nado, toe sh ces ifred ged
Tez. lt wax hall Ue Geech practi fo beach thei his. The GreseHbeur a
Syren es develope late } The vlsuce apie hes devslopnem local condi
bvevaincd di Gteckiaecntone and coe andalibengh moor wer lyn
they vssinel ang inks with ir Fromding ete nel wore sly lied eth rnin
wets In din, sie cles founded ante iis dor elves, The ating the
Peloponnesian Wr the Suan cin wid sa hve Ue some allegince 3 thee naehet
Fin, New Tooke at Fie ups inc the ana ie iv Scly ae iene
srcovling to the aging of hr Fass atic he Cagis dee
Shem, Ader netrest pice Moe Aca ily ook. trom Si.

The Skil cides with grbich Adiocr Jad bad the cleat eelaionbip were tbuse
wigeally Tneded fiom lana. (OF which Aes wondered lw te ser ity al
Ta lave ue Shenoy Tmpte dros great trang (Lk a eh ser panee Mp 10
andace Cite One, Servon 3 he abr alli bora wich waren ee of noe
“vain ach a lieyae au gests. Cide of Davin foodarnn nell sapped Sper
{tus tov at Bork Joan and Dowie ha ears eb sera wh the je
baiting pupae Generally speaking, the Toma od acuta Ia oper and
[pala vesorpina, ihe Dovast fer donaninn {Onc Wl, toe coma
lenalozialy aspect excuse barry of Sly. Casvere Side Mand oxplves
lone the question of Tepes roi when he arm in flcy,26 se aya
fer he epee rete sty of the Geek}

‘We ns! on ineripione Hate ania bad enteediat alias wih rset
liege fin weacerm Si) nthe 450 at ead uh Fogo i ola tl
Cexntn in he ion pln 99 2 Si parler (in 2) baths pone tn Aens
‘ike eontin reer herp rite iyo yea aw
‘ohich wn lacy alld en the Athantansryensy Corinth Albagh 9a ower erp
the sme poe bad bad inthe As, Space wt lean ity ine wee
Mediterranean ard we kaw fret Biodoras Sak 3M, 20, 1 abst by 109 se
Syracuse ld fait HHO cen, euuhled the numberof ee rvaly, nciszed Hel”
fnfany and raacted honey tcibate Fons che ndganeeppeaton. Disa at ndbuh
those acts tds to aint the ole of Sel

Twa elealy in the Atboeam tere te pres ily och ts vadoble can eet
Ing dren into the Pel: unos exp, 20a explant fase for Se we
srs Thaeydes sys the Athenian lth “tony Beco of Beir hth at he
Leuotinizns, thnogh ele teal aie sere 49 provene cor Ee be
Pelipnase Frome wr: and to make paclimsmiry ory tse echether it wel be
pose for thom tpn eel wt Sey" [E25] Phares empltes ne ft he
‘Adjen hal long ated to dominae Silly whe he atta the lance will ere
(405) box oly he witht ain help othe repracey vy baat the "Ze ha
{Coruyta lay err comeencely ot te ctl me to Vel an Sid Ey

‘ess wgrced to jan Athesnd Achone hte echo dh ess
he Stains of Mein ethers ly wwe ala wun vay Th ld saree
got was removed bur oukcrs: Be eto kd esas

Evenly 2 coupres ofthe Siiton vac Blab Cla 24 apron» gee lan
accor co Mich the Sicilians eee arrange thir eo hate lel
threw (1, 88-48). Nethingeffrrive wasn hy he tenis rep
Df Tanti then dey eae driven ol bye lance who
Spratt Fra while he ibe ieerea Sky append aie sean raha
Ul oF Athenian cents bre hewlett too Galo Cir ad ke
Pehopontess, heir Hits eeaned ene are whan eins rvention was ese Ay
gest in 16. Apparent Alena bad Forget they nd gor es gers hor
ie

Wealann sth

42 ATHENIAN POLICY IN SICILY IN 415

“The arguments weed by the Rysraran 0 peated the Athevins fe ot ene en tir
bokeh qusttl wid be eminent by Vacs in Bok VE
Brief, these arguments wee steeqic and Branca The ae anpaviry wes il
Ans prrmired he Selluonties wo Sora head a Space, he Sercarars wl.
onze the whale of Sila would waste be or ssn spine
sip ith Athets(re haven vlan eid ohelpa decide wheshe heed
therar font Syracise yan # alone). The Branca sa tha He Frcs
themes could spely ulceot mney tn Roane tht eat The Ahead Ac by
herein died send represetative to pte t otf lech ol the Ege

“The repartof the Athenian delegation, te decison af the Athens oil healer
dette inthe Boseebly ae eecaunenSby Uh dain Bsck UL 79. Pease ene
and a yon tend anak sh. ¢ hater mane t th falling quest,

(a) What wos the Achen atin decison Section 82

(h) Why did Nici wane che nate se opened? Who were hit iin arguments erin
"he expeton? (Seton 9-14)

fe} What meee Alebidetagguncnt is favonr ofthe evpedition? (Suetons IR}

(4) Aveonding to Bin, wha were dhe iti yoblens mend? {Sevan 29-28)
ES) fla epsom doe thacydile agg the mation of dhe Het ffesct the
Saumching ofthe expt? tection 279)

AS CLT SIROTA SSOESSOO ESET TI PEELS OIE,