Table Of Content

WISCONSIN LAW REVIEW VOLUME 2008 INDEX CONTENTS ii lola iliceabosinuadsensebcanaiaavatdsnawesdaeatecden 1260 I ieee kicatxcdnaeeiavacabiiiitixexiczenriddeerneenie: ies 1262 NN hi sop rAd asain tabdarinkianiddvnnder ciutineninnens 1265 Copyright 2008 by the Board of Regents of the University of Wisconsin System 1260 WISCONSIN LAW REVIEW AUTHOR INDEX BARRETT, JEFFREY M., A State of Disorder: An Analysis of Mental-Health Parity in Wisconsin and a Suggestion tor Future Legislation BAUMGARTEL, SARAH, Nonprosecution Agreements as Contracts: Stolt-Nielsen and the Question of Remedy for a Prosecutor's Breach 1.01... 0.06ccsccence nceecn eeneeene ns ene BRUSICK, PHILIPPE, Should Developing Countries Worry about Abuse of Dominant IN ag hg ohn Som arstoislaisice eee eee wea da nek dyino aaie ae gi Neko dere cee rosa ...269 BURCH ELIAS, STELLA “Good Reason to Believe”: Widespread Constitutional Violations in the Course of Immigration Enforcement and the Case for Revisiting Lopez-Mendoza CARSTENSEN, PETER C., Fa/se Positives in Identifving Liability for Exclusionary Conduct: Conceptual Error, Business Reality, and Aspen ..............0.00eseeeeeeee 106295 CASTIGLIONE, JOHN D., Human Dignity Under the Fourth Amendment CHRISTENSON, TIERNEY, Fish on Morphine: Protecting Wisconsin’s Natural Resources through a Comprehensive Plan for Proper Disposal of NN doh ofcnss hoa uae loud ees watnca vabuwse ened ccaineussunyiissbuekenbntne vk COMANOR, WILLIAM S., /s There a Consensus on the Antitrust Treatment of Single- COSTELLO, DANIELLE M., The Right to Make Informed Reproductive-Health-Care Decisions Regardless of Age: Maintaining the Focus on the “I” in “I Want to be One Less” Dosson, PAUL W., The Waterbed Eftect: Where Buying and Selling Power Come SERPEIL LRET ED: 331 EVENETT, SIMON J., Should Developing Countries Worry about Abuse of Dominant DU SS fener cht we reed Cece oan be eae es Uae onan ain Paw eee uaie ame ++. 269 FOER, ALBERT A., Zhe Spectrum of Monopolism: An Introduction to the Future of Monopoly and Monopolization Gist, RYAN, Transactional Pleading: A Proportional Approach to Rule 8 in the Wake of Bell Atlantic Corp, v. Twombly GREENE, MATTHEW C., Unsuspected Shoals in Equal Protection: Adapting Wisconsin's Special-Transter Program to Survive Parents Involved HOLCOMB, LEANNE, Wisconsin's Public-Records Law: Preserving the Presumption of Complete Public Access in the Age of Electronic Records, ..........00.00000000+ 2008: 1259 Volume 2008 Index 1261 INDERST, ROMAN, The Waterbed Eftect: Where Buying and Selling Power Come 331 OMMAEME <x oS warsaca at sag de asd 4 dpa pas uae CANORA RANE esaOs ees waC ease tuand ny vanandeKeneadanaee ISAAC, JAMES, Wisconsin’s Public-Records Law: Preserving the Presumption of Complete Public Access in the Age of Electronic Records JOHNSON, MARK T., A “Simple” Probate Should Not Be This Complicated: Principals and Proposals tor Revising Wisconsin's Statutes for Probate AMRIT RUMAND TIRE 255 Sc cv ad ow tsst ane tedssnv a sanaddccuanncaudecssendtnekeinadvanaivant 575 JORDAN, KAREN A., Agency Preemption and the Shimer Analysis: Unmasking Strategic Characterization by Agencies and Giving Eftect to the Presumption against Preemption KopETSKY, BRAD A., Deutschland Uber Alles: Why German Regulations Need to Conquer the Divided U.S. Renewable-Energy Framework to Save Clean Tech (and the World) MAUN, TIMOTHY J., Hack, Therefore iBrick: Cellular Contract Law, the Apple IPhone, and Apple’s Extraordinary Remedy for Breach MAYER-SCHONBERGER, VIKTOR, Demystifying LeSSig.............4.+. MAYRACK, BRENDA R., The Jmplications of State ex rel. Thomas v. Schwarz for Wisconsin Sentencing Policy after Truth-in-Sentencing IT...............00.00 0000000 181 MCMILLIAN, LANCE, 7he Proper Role of Courts: The Mistakes of the Supreme COI TAR UIE v5 ccden coca ccdccneneccausdcadaccscsySaeudseunneabuccsn e PAREJA, SERGIO, Taxation Without Liquidation: Rethinking “Ability to Pay” PeTTys, TODD E., Zhe Jmmoral Application of Exclusionary Rules ...463 PRITIKIN, MARTIN H., /s Prison Increasing Crime? 1049 RICHARDS, WENDY, An Analysis of Recent Tax Retorms from a Marital-Bias Perspective: It Is Time to Oust Marriage from the Tax Code °.......... SNEIRSON, JUDD F., Soft Paternalism tor Close Corporations: Helping Shareholders Help Themselves SWEENEY, BONNY E., An Overview of Section 2 Enforcement and Developments THUMANN, HENRY C., Mu/tijurisdictional Regulation of Monopoly in a Global Market 261 WALLER, SPENCER WEBER, Aveeda, Epithets, and Essential Facilities ........... Wwa WELLE, ADAM, Campaign Counterspeech: A New Strategy to Control Sham Issue Advocacy in the Wakofe F EC v. Wisconsin Right to Life .....................66. ee p> Woop, HON. DIANE P., Snapshots from the Seventh Circuit: Continuity and Change, POPE a sis dacedsceddancupugscduevnusc Maaascaisnsviaetscceensdusses ) ‘ 1262 | WISCONSIN LAW REVIEW TITLE INDEX ADDRESS SNAPSHOTS FROM THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT: CONTINUITY AND CHANGE, 1966-2007 ERR Re ere Te Soe SB chet PoE ae Re CR Fence IMCD ] ARTICLES AGENCY PREEMPTION AND THE SH/MER ANALYSIS: UNMASKING STRATEGIC CHARACTERIZATION BY AGENCIES AND GIVING EFFECT TO THE PRESUMPTION AGAINST PREEMPTION RR AS Ba eee ee ht Oe ee, ER Tee ee Meo 69 AREEDA, EPITHETS, AND ESSENTIAL FACILITIES CITING WIIIIIIIN oosoca ces ccs coscccacsdibcss aacuerudeacaucnnavacdssncxenaavarcwaerscsead e en DEMYSTIFYING LESSIG ee NN NNN hos cts dc gat pas Siacar al caxsvisnksasecdseuseceotdooumeotneske s 713 FALSE POSITIVES IN IDENTIFYING LIABILITY FOR EXCLUSIONARY CONDUCT: CONCEPTUAL ERROR, BUSINESS REALITY, AND ASPEN a cri eh a cage deed ces emmun toe Cae “GOOD REASON TO BELIEVE”: WIDESPREAD CONSTITUTIONAL VIOLATIONS IN THE COURSE OF IMMIGRATION ENFORCEMENT AND THE CASE FOR REVISITING LOPEZ-MENDOZA IN osc cncccciptah we casacannuuaocnawneean deonns bcoantwinu vseasucnnenecesnee s 1109 HUMAN DIGNITY UNDER THE FOURTH AMENDMENT Pe INE ocr ss oes Seiya cue sacs vasudchals Kaadoaidettacedescevadicandiaosn s 655 THE IMMORAL APPLICATION OF EXCLUSIONARY RULES Neca alacraivctacoPusiy cicttcan cates Seve eh anasdseucteeeviacacessercaxcueacmerteaees 463 Is PRISON INCREASING CRIME? INET 223 sh 580th s kc heh ia a Nas, y iments daehs aa apse Cau Reem 1049 Is THERE A CONSENSUS ON THE ANTITRUST TREATMENT OF SINGLE-FIRM CONDUCT? William §. Comanor.......... SELES ELE ALAA RR ET PREP OREN oe A ee 387 MULTIJURISDICTIONAL REGULATION OF MONOPOLY IN A GLOBAL MARKET WRN POE a ginsc s soci caavaneiesc oust¥sensns acasces vciabatauatsissnncdinveenedsuannece ss 261 2008: 1259 Volume 2008 Index 1263 NONPROSECUTION AGREEMENTS AS CONTRACTS: S7OLT-NIELSEN AND THE QUESTION OF REMEDY FOR A PROSECUTOR’S BREACH NC RUIN sisakds xavaccats casudeadsaasuaqhueds densa tcates segdierddotacesestenustdeansicuewe e AN OVERVIEW OF SECTION 2 ENFORCEMENT AND DEVELOPMENTS PE Ee ID cise onasdnccvncnoctcaceshewne Se cucdwnnddaceuaeoive duuedaddednsdudginccucsccmen’ THE PROPER ROLE OF COURTS: THE MISTAKESO F THE SUPREME COURT IN LEEGIN MN I 655d ond dacs cecraid tie Salida iced cen insk eudcde dRchcaniaididee ee 405 SHOULD DEVELOPING COUNTRIES WORRY ABOUT ABUSE OF DOMINANT POWER? PRE DIB SR S.C icine saissscnis ten dniincinvnsaeundagaaysteuaqacesedeces 269 SOFT PATERNALISM FOR CLOSE CORPORATIONS: HELPING SHAREHOLDERS HELP THEMSELVES ME UN 5 Si ids cacti dy On Sa ga ao ara ka Nae Heke ue 899 THE SPECTRUMO F MONOPOLISM: AN INTRODUCTION TO THE FUTURE OF MONOPOLY AND MONOPOLIZATION TAXATION WITHOUT LIQUIDATION: RETHINKING “ABILITY TO PAY” IER os icds ces vdcclo cou casaads es xacetakasanegs Sona tass sedans devs tuigeedadaundascnaeanaeaet 841 THE WATERBED EFFECT: WHERE BUYING AND SELLING POWER COME TOGETHER Pima WO, Team FE a TS a osvoc s incvgcdcicncacceccccexcecacacccwcduscavcavedcaaucee STUDENT NOTES & COMMENTS AN ANALYSIS OF RECENT TAX REFORMS FROM A MARITAL-BIAS PERSPECTIVE: IT IS TIME TO OUST MARRIAGE FROM THE TAX CODE eee CE Ss cs uitc scauaeinnsdseacegccasesate siuchucdaiduwiincndendausindinasangdassates 611 CAMPAIGN COUNTERSPEECH: A NEW STRATEGY TO CONTROL SHAM ISSUE ADVOCACY IN THE WAKE OF FECV v. WISCONSIN RIGHT TO LIFE : Adam Welle.............. jb adaed te Meaaash ae Rael chu dudicnutatiacnecna a swtb dwausguatscaoue eae DEUTSCHLAND UBER ALLES: WHY GERMAN REGULATIONS NEED TO CONQUER THE DIVIDED U.S. RENEWABLE-ENERGY FRAMEWORK TO SAVE CLEAN TECH (AND THE WORLD) PE FE MCI 55: 3 ava dic yencenasGieeeteseresieccdsessgasdateyeuenedoed Noletigtaxcasenions 941 FISH ON MORPHINE: PROTECTING WISCONSIN’S NATURAL RESOURCES THROUGH A COMPREHENSIVE PLAN FOR PROPER DISPOSAL OF PHARMACEUTICALS ye) 7 oD | SACRE ODER MEET nee PETC ECT Se IP REEL ERT AO I Aer rey y PE PEE ETT err Te 141 IHACK, THEREFORE IBRICK: CELLULAR CONTRACT LAW, THE APPLE IPHONE, AND APPLE’S EXTRAORDINARY REMEDY FOR BREACH fe)”: ERIE Reco Pe eee en tee apron petit te mien emer Mrasrr Perper re heer 747 1264 WISCONSIN LAW REVIEW THE IMPLICATIONS OF S7AT7E EX REL. THOMAS V. SCHWARFZO R WISCONSIN SENTENCING POLICY AFTER TRUTH-IN-SENTENCING II Pa PIT 2 ds ctsinics eaineccado season oecasiecasieas agin maaan «laeavanolentaneveerenanes THE RIGHT TO MAKE INFORMED REPRODUCTIVE-HEALTH-CARE DECISIONS REGARDLESS OF AGE: MAINTAINING THE FOCUS ON THE “I” IN “I WANT TO BE ONE LEss” | RR Pee er a A “SIMPLE” PROBATE SHOULD NOT BE THIS COMPLICATED: PRINCIPLES AND PROPOSALS FOR REVISING WISCONSIN’S STATUTES FOR PROBATE SUMMARY PROCEDURES RCS OO MEER NA Pe Pre ee erat OnE ee ee ee ee ef 2. A STATE OF DISORDER: AN ANALYSIS OF MENTAL-HEALTH PARITY IN WISCONSIN AND A SUGGESTION FOR FUTURE LEGISLATION OEY MRT 5 Seis ect neh pase ec a tenc meen po tcac sh teas uaadeadduedassaneexMONRORy) TRANSACTIONAL PLEADING: A PROPORTIONAL APPROACH TO RULE 8 IN THE WAKE OF BELL ATLANTIC CORP. V. TWOMBLY REM incerta coe carccu ssid ee ayaa escaeee aes alen ae saaed occa vaoRUesaUae aaa Sia nOneR UNSUSPECTED SHOALS IN EQUAL PROTECTION: ADAPTING WISCONSIN'S SPECIAL- TRANSFER PROGRAM TO SURVIVE PARENTS INVOLVED IN ico coos aces oeeaniecavaciee alonlad eisuuldasicmaddaeaScedeadaant eeec u WISCONSIN'S PUBLIC-RECORDS LAW: PRESERVING THE PRESUMPTION OF COMPLETE PUBLIC ACCESS IN THE AGE OF ELECTRONIC RECORDS ENS es tie I PRI oasis vc ca can csc coarse LiciewsvovaWecsseseceuesetdeend s re| 2008: 1259 Volume 2008 Index 1265 SUBJECT INDEX ANTITRUST BRUSICK, PHILIPPE & SIMON J. EVENETT, Should Developing Countries Worry about Altias OF DGGE POWGEE oo ss. sch cevonds ccs ve cas wa cesean canine tadtuamnareccesawanewcess 269 CARSTENSEN, PETER C., Fa/se Positives in Identifving Liability for Exclustonars Conduct: Conceptual Error, Business Reality, and Aspen.............0.0.0.000e0eeeeee2e9-5 COMANOR, WILLIAM S., /s There a Consensus on the Antitrust Treatment of Single- TUE COMMIIEES soca cassis d concen due sesen evan ce ovr ousend tne ueapuete oRausanddee Ceca ck skhas Tae DoBSON, PAUL W. & ROMAN INDERST, The Waterbed Effect: Where Buying and SOLVEER CO IIP ROMINER os 550s os occu cainc aine ine xnsnehocneannsenaxetenddeacresacssstscoee FOER, ALBERT A., The Spectrum of Monopolism: An Introduction to the Future of Monopoly and Monopolization 225 Maun, TimotTuy J., Hack, Therefore iBrick: Cellular Contract Law, the Apple iPhone, and Apple's Extraordinary Remedy for Breach ..........0.0.0.000ccceveeeeeeees 747 MCMILLIAN, LANCE, The Proper Role of Courts: The Mistakes of the Supreme COD TAR CDIN nso ccc 8 ai fe Seach gases ean VaR Es shde tae nhan eaudandaaauaeteeacaa 405 SWEENEY, BONNY E., An Overview of Section 2 Enforcement and Developments .........231 THUMANN, HENRY C., Mu/tijurisdictional Regulation vf Monopoly in a Global 1) Se PoE ROMO RRR ERR T ACERS EE RAREST Ort cee ney WALLER, SPENCER WEBER, Areeda, Epithets, and Essential Facilities BUSINESS LAW SNEIRSON, JUDD F., Soft Paternalism for Close Cerporations: Helping Shareholders Pei VAAT )a ]| ES PEED OR RP EE feet REE eee PerC ERO PEE RODE rE ECCT TET CPOE OT OTE RE LS 899 CAMPAIGN-FINANCE LAW WELLE, ADAM, Campaign Counterspeech: A New Strategy to Control Sham Issue Advocacy in the Wake of FEC v. Wisconsin Right to Life ...................cc0eeeeees 795 CIVIL PROCEDURE BAUMGARTEL, SARAH, Nonprosecution Agreements as Contracts: Stolt-Nielsen and the Question of Remedy for a Prosecutor’s Breach .............+00ceceececessesceseeeeeee 2D 1266 WISCONSIN LAW REVIEW BURCH ELIAS, STELLA “Good Reason to Believe”: Widespread Constitutional Violations in the Course of Immigration Enforcement and the Case for POO VEIN TOE MII 9.555.655 5 sess ces an dow annenspasdsailadovasdsdansedduasdasnawesarsecs 1109 GisT, RYAN, Transactional Pleading: A Proportional Approach to Rule 8 in the VERE OF ME AGAUNC COED: Ve TWODIY sccs casececescsvsscecsiaescdesecesedvovncesenss 1013 PeTTys, TODD E., The Jmmoral Application of Exclusionary Rules.........0..0.00000 000000 463 CIVIL RIGHTS GREENE, MATTHEW C., Unsuspected Shoals in Equal Protection: Adapting Wisconsin's Special-Transfer Program to Survive Parents Involved................. 1201 COMPARATIVE LAW KOPETSKY, BRAD A., Deutschland Uber Alles: Why German Regulations Need to Conquer the Divided U.S. Renewable-Energy Framework to Save Clean Tech AREER SD OS TESA G RAVE oe ORNS ete ea ER RET ee Hs ete SAN A 941 CONSTITUTIONAL LAW BURCH ELIAS, STELLA “Good Reason to Believe”: Widespread Constitutional Violations in the Course of Immigration Enforcement and the Case for PORCH IMMNELLE NOOUNM TENMI BA co cc. cinyino s nessa abies avai bin Gee ake mas caenina sies dvanseaomeaate 1109 CASTIGLIONE, JOHN D., Human Dignity Under the Fourth Amendment ..........00.000000044 655 MCMILLIAN, LANCE, 7he Proper Role of Courts: The Mistakes of the Supreme COUT TT LOLI. «0.05505 5858: Paracascra nett enaneee aa tee detev ied.c auwewe Gon uanleeachan oawat eateaies 405 CONTRACT LAW BAUMGARTEL, SARAH, Nonprosecution Agreements as Contracts: Stolt-Nielsen and the Question of Remedy for a Prosecutor’s Breach ...........0ccccscsesesesceeeesesseenees 29 Maun, Timotny J., ‘Hack, Therefore iBrick: Cellular Contract Law, the Apple iPhone, and Apple’s Extraordinary Remedy for Breach .......c.ccc. cc.e e6c e.ee 6eee0en es7 47 CRIMINAL LAW MAYRACK, BRENDA R., The /mplications of State ex rel. Thomas v. Schwarz for Wisconsin Sentencing Policy after Truth-in-Sentencing I] .......0c.c.cc 0ec.ee 0ee6e ecen e s1 81 PeTTys, TODD E., The Jmmoral Application OF EXGIUSIONALY RUTES: «.«:ciisidsc aiserreirncsce s 463 PRITIKIN, TWARTIN Fl, 48 227800 INGIEASING CANE? «cnc ssvaves cxseesssenton vassecdsaacsvsaees 1049 2008: 1259 Volume 2008 Index 1267 CYBERLAW MAYER-SCHONBERGER, VIKTOR, Demystifying [email protected] 713 ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT BRUSICK, PHILIPPE & SIMON J. EVENETT, Should Developing Countries Worry about SIUEIEE OF ERIE FOES. ooo ceeds cera Canes d ane aah rae db av ai ablattees 269 ENVIRONMENTAL LAW CHRISTENSON, TIERNEY, Fish on Morphine: Protecting Wisconsin’s Natural Resources through a Comprehensive Plan tor Proper Disposal of Wp T EEE)2 eMC AOE LE LETL ECCE OE eT ETC CEE PTET LP ED PCEO P TEC CELI EE EDEL CEPTCC TE 141 KOPETSKY, BRAD A., Deutschland Uber Alles: Why German Regulations Need to Conquer the Divided U.S. Renewable-Energy Framework to Save Clean Tech (SINTER VO ORI go ick ccaestndelcs kV adele enn aweianaple pi natac oavesn sgiandedda dans oasis sdaewauioe 941 FAIRCHILD, THOMAS E. Woop, Hon. DIANE P., Snapshots from the Seventh Circuit: Continuity and Change, PIOOGOUE ost ca betannastetue saetee elaw avesaau ddysmaveiccedas acsascesaecedescdandesdaucesatinapeaan l FAMILY LAW RICHARDS, WENDY, An Analysis of Recent Tax Reforms trom a Marital-Bias Perspective: It Is Time to Oust Marriage from the Tax Code..............0000000000008 611 FEDERAL LEGISLATION JORDAN, KAREN A., Agency Preemption and the Shimer Analysis: Unmasking~ Strategic Characterization by Agencies and Giving Eftect to the Presumption SGA PACGIMINNIN. 53220 hoes en succ sa ciuddaatnacainscaceszamieatnesess etdnauatwassasedeensease : 69 KOPETSKY, BRAD A., Deutschland Uber Alles: Why German Regulations Need to Conquer the Divided U.S. Renewable-Energy Framework to Save Clean Tech CREE ER WII ovis ba cou axa Daca s backend ance Rcasigas eee dsess ees ewianteceessedassqaaKens 941 SWEENEY, BONNY E., An Overview of Section 2 Enforcement and Developments.........231 FIRST AMENDMENT WELLE, ADAM, Campaign Counterspeech: A New Strategy to Control Sham Issue Advocacy in the Wake of FEC v. Wisconsin Right to Life .................:ceceeeeeees 795 FOURTH AMENDMENT CASTIGLIONE, JOHN D., Human Dignity Under the Fourth Amendmenmt..............0..+++ 655 1268 WISCONSIN LAW REVIEW GENDER AND SEXUALITY COSTELLO, DANIELLE M., The Right to Make Informed Reproductive-Health-Care Decisions Regardless of Age: Maintaining the Focus on the “I” in “I Want to RM IN, oie Saw esro a seg Tees Pepe ee OR Oe TOR CSE LN as HeaG Santon e sasmasnanencemnemas 987 IMMIGRATION LAW BURCH ELIAS, STELLA “Good Reason to Believe”: Widespread Constitutional Violations in the Course of Immigration Enforcement and the Case for ROVE I CT NAOT MRO 5a 5325s SS et guide ces dandy ncasinhaaeindareseemmancueees 1109 INSURANCE LAW BARRETT, JEFFREY M., A State of Disorder: An Analysis of Mental-Health Parity in Wisconsin and a Suggestion for Future Legislation ...........00c0ccneecssveesc eeeen s 1159 JURISPRUDENCE CASTIGLIONE, JOHN D., Human Dignity Under the Fourth Amendment..............0.00.4. 655 PeTTYS, TODD E., The Immoral Application of Exclusionary RuleS............0.0000000c0e0es 463 LAW AND ECONOMICS CARSTENSEN, PETER C., False Positives in Identifying Liability tor Exclusionary Conduct: Conceptual Error, Business Reality, and ASpen............0.00c0ecseeeeeeeeees 295 Dosson, PAUL W. & ROMAN INDERST, The Waterbed Effect: Where Buying and ONE PAPI PONMM so occ saviasnncacude ccs ceovareswacccsepeusesccutuaeemcestnees 331 PROPERTY PAREJA, SERGIO, Taxation Without Liquidation: Rethinking “Ability to Pay”............... 841 PUBLIC-RECORDS LAW HOLCOMB, LEANNE & JAMES ISAAC, Wisconsin's Public-Records Law. Preserving the Presumption of Complete Public Access in the Age of Electronic Records......515 SCIENCE AND THE LAW HOLCOMB, LEANNE & JAMES ISAAC, Wisconsin's Public-Records Law: Preserving the Presumption of Complete Public Access in the Age of Electronic Records...... S19 MAUN, TIMOTHY J., ‘Hack, Therefore iBrick: Cellular Contract Law, the Apple iPhone, and Apple’s Extraordinary Remedy for Breach ...0..0..0 .cc.ece.seee.nen.eeen es 747 MAYER-SCHONBERGER, VIKTOR, Demystifying LeSSIQ...........ccccccecseneneeneneceeneeeeuens 73