W R HAT EALLY L ED TO I F NDIAN REEDOM Rajnikant Puranik “Far from claiming any credit for achievements of 1942 [Quit India], both Gandhi and the Congress offered apology and explanation for the ‘madness’ which seized the people participating in it.”{AD1} —Noted historian Dr RC Majumdar “The claim that Quit India led to freedom is a state sanctioned hoax.”{AD1} —Author Anuj Dhar “I see it as clearly as I see my finger: British are leaving not because of any strength on our part but because of historical conditions and for many other reasons.”{Gill/24} —Mahatma Gandhi What Really Led to Indian Freedom by Rajnikant Puranik Categories: Non-fiction, History First Edition, August 2018 Copyright © 2018 Rajnikant Puranik Available at Amazon and Pothi.com Please check www.rkpbooks.com for all the books by the author, for their details, and “from where to procure” them Floral Indian Flag on the Cover : Courtesy Vecteezy.com All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, distributed or transmitted in any form or by any means, whether electronic/digital or print or mechanical/physical, or stored in an information storage or retrieval system, without the prior written permission of the copyright owner, that is, the author, except as permitted by law. However, extracts up to a total of 1,000 words may be quoted without seeking any permission, but with due acknowledgement of the source. For permission, please write to [email protected]. P REFACE “I see it as clearly as I see my finger: British are leaving not because of any strength on our part but because of historical conditions and for many other reasons.”{Gill/24} —Mahatma Gandhi This book comprehensively covers all the factors that really led to the freedom of India from the British. Chapter-1 covers prominent international timelines, particularly that of World War-I and World War-II, that had major bearings on India’s freedom. Chapter-2, a mega chapter, chronologically covers all timelines, events, and developments relevant to the Indian Freedom Movements— revolutionary, constitutional and Gandhian— right since 1600 CE. Chapter-3 covers the three major, once-in-a-decade Gandhian Movements—all of which, unfortunately, were major failures. Chapter-4 covers Netaji Subhas Bose, his INA, and the army mutinies that hugely contributed to winning freedom for India. Chapter-5 evaluates the Gandhian Movement, and compares it with the other freedom movements—revolutionary and constitutional. Chapter-6, the last chapter, analyses in detail ‘What Really Led to Freedom’. Ambitious coverage of this book would have required over a thousand pages to do full justice to the topics. However, this project (book) is restricted to presenting a comprehensive yet compressed view of the relevant factors, events and timelines. It is a summarised work deliberately limited to as few pages as possible. —Rajnikant Puranik www.rkpbooks.com A N C & B OTE ON ITATIONS IBLIOGRAPHY Citations are given as super-scripts in the text, such as {Azad/128}. Citation Syntax & Examples: {Source-Abbreviation/Page-Number} e.g. {Azad/128} = Azad, Page 128 {Source-Abbreviation/Volume-Number/Page-Number} e.g. {CWMG/V-58/221} = CWMG, Volume-58, Page 221 {Source-Abbreviation} … for URLs (articles on the web), and for digital books (including Kindle-Books), that are searchable, where location or page-number may not be given. e.g. {VPM2}, {URL15} {Source-Abbreviation/Location-Number}… for Kindle Books e.g. {VPM2}, {VPM2/L-2901} Example from Bibliography Table at the end of this Book Azad B Maulana Abul Kalam Azad—India Wins Freedom. Orient Longman. New Delhi. 2004 CWMG D, W Collected Works of Mahatma Gandhi. Vol. 1 to 98. http://gandhiserve.org/e/cwmg/cwmg.htm The second column above gives the nature of the source: B=paper Book, D=Digital Book/eBook other than Kindle, K=Kindle eBook, U=URL of Document/Article on Web, W=Website, Y=YouTube To the fond memory of my late parents Shrimati Shakuntala and Shri Laxminarayan Puranik Thanks to Devbala Puranik, Manasi and Manini T C ABLE OF ONTENTS { 1 } Relevant International Timelines { 2 } Indian Freedom Struggle Timelines { 3 } Three Major Gandhian Movements { 4 } Bose(s), INA & the Army Mutiny { 5 } Gandhian vs. Other Freedom Movements { 6 } What Really Led to Freedom Bibliography D T C ETAILED ABLE OF ONTENTS { 1 } Relevant International Timelines Timelines of Prominent International Events WW-I Chronology & India’s Role WW-II Chronology & India’s Role India’s Role in WW-II WW-II as a Military Training Opportunity for Indians WW-II Chronology { 2 } Indian Freedom Struggle Timelines 1600–1770 1772–1880 1880–1897 1900–1910 1911–1915 1915: The Grand Ghadar Mutiny 1916–1920 1916 : The Lucknow Pact [P] 1915: All India Home Rule League 1917 : Champaran & Gandhi 1917–18: Sardar Patel’s Successful Agitations 1918–19: Mont-Ford Reforms & the GoI Act [P] 1919: Rowlatt Acts & Satyagraha Jallianwala Bagh Massacre 1919 1920s: Kisan Movement in UP 1920 : Chamber of Princes Nagpur Congress Session, Dec-1920 1920–30 1920–22: Khilafat & Non-Cooperation Movement (KNCM) Aug-Sep 1921 : Moplah Anti-Hindu Attacks Jan-1923: Swaraj Party 1923: Jabalpur & Nagpur Satyagraha Sep-1923: Patel’s Successful Borsad Satyagraha 9-11 September 1924 : Kohat Anti-Hindu Attacks 1924-27: Patel’s Commendable Work for Ahmedabad Municipality 1927: Patel’s Unforgettable Work during Ahmedabad Floods 1928: Patel’s Bardoli Satyagraha 1928 Feb-1928 : Simon Commission Aug-1928: Motilal Nehru Report 1929–30: Nehru’s Unjust Anointment as Congress President 26 January 1930 : Congress Call for “Purna Swaraj” 1928–31 : Lahore Conspiracy Case, etc. 1930–34 1930: Dandi March & Salt Satyagraha 1930: Qissa Khwani Bazaar Massacre & Garhwali 1930–31: First Round Table Conference (RTC-1) 1931: Gandhi-Irwin Pact Mar-1931: Sardar as Congress President Sep–Dec 1931: Second Round Table Conference (RTC-2) 1932: Civil Disobedience Movement (CDM), Phase-II Aug–1932: The Communal Award Aug–Sep 1932: The Communal Award & Poona Pact 1932: Third Round Table Conference (RTC-3) 1932–33: Name ‘Pakistan’ & Rahmat Ali [P] 1935–39 Government of India (GoI) Act 1935 1934-37: Elections Jan-1939: Gandhi vs. Subhas: Presidential Election 1939–43 October 1939 : Anti-Hindu Riots in Sindh [P] WW-II: British Declaration of War, Sep-1939 Nov-1939: Resignation of Congress Ministries After Hitler’s Blitzkrieg : Oct,1939–Jun,1940 Rajaji’s Proposal of July 1940 Oct-1940: Selective Individual Disobedience Pearl Harbor, Dec 1941 & its Aftermath 1940 : Udham Singh Avenges Jallianwala Massacre March 1940 : League’s Lahore Resolution 1940–46: Congress Descent & League Ascendency 1940-42: Netaji Subhas Escapes March-April 1942 : Cripps Mission Apr-1942: CR’s Formula on Pakistan August-1942: Quit India Movement [P] 1943–46 1943–44: British Gift—The Great Bengal Famine May 1944 Onwards: Gandhi’s Major Come-Down Moves May 1944 Onwards: Side-lining of Gandhi 25 June 1945 : Shimla Conference End 1945—1946 : Elections April 1946 : Gandhi-Nehru Hijack Presidential Elections March-June 1946 : Cabinet Mission Aug-1946: Muslim League’s Direct Action (Riots) 2-Sep-1946 : Interim Government Oct–1946: Noakhali Anti-Hindu Killings Oct-1946: Nehru’s NWFP Visit—a Blunder Dec-1946 Onwards: Developments on Groupings Dec–1946 : Constituent Assembly 1947 Feb–1947: Attlee’s “Quit India” Deadline Declaration 8 March 1947: Patel & Partition, the Lesser Evil 22 March 1947: Mountbatten Arrives Gandhi’s 1-Apr-1947 Offer for Jinnah May-1947 Onwards: Freedom & Partition { 3 } Three Major Gandhian Movements Khilafat & Non-Cooperation Movement (KNCM) Khilafat (Caliphate) & Khalif (Caliph) Defeat of the Ottomans in WW-I & its Consequences Khilafat & Other Muslim Countries Khilafat & Indian Muslims Gandhi & Khilafat Approval of Non-Cooperation at Congress Sessions in 1920 KNCM Gathers Steam Gandhi’s Inexplicable Calling-off of KNCM!