\'VH A T H A P P AET N E D VATICAN II UNCORREPCATGEPEDR OOFS NOT FORS ALE ' .. .•'.. '. . I. . - '- ... ., .. ·• Theasreue n corrpeacgptere odo fs. Nop arotft hepsreo omfasyb e reprodwuictehtdoh uwetr itten permisosfHi aornv Uanirvde rPsrietsys . Nofto sra le. WHATH APPENAETDV A T IC ANI I ByJ oh\nVO .' Malley PublicDaatitSoeen:p te2m0b0e8r Pri$c2e9:. 95 ISB9N7:8 -0-674-03169-2 40p0a g9eh sa,l ftones BelknParpe osfHs a rvUanirvde rPsrietsys Fomro rien formpaltieocanos,ne t act: JennRiefdedri ng SeniPourb licist Phon6e1 7.495.1284 Fa6x1 7.349.5244 je [email protected] VisoiutWr e bs ite www. hup.harvard.edu What Happened at Vatican II What Happened at VATICAN II John W O'Malley THE BELKNAP PRESS OF HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS Cambridge, Massachusetts London, England · 2008 Contents Prefa1cxe Introdu ction 1 1 BiPge rspeocnat B iiMvgee est i1n 5g 2 ThLeo nNgi netCeeennttuh5r 3y 3 ThCeo unOcpieln 9s3 4 ThFei rPsetr( i1o9d6 122)7 ThLei nAerDser awn 5 ThSee coPnedr (i1o9d6 136 )0 AM ajoPrrietyv ailing 6 ThTeh iPredr (i1o9d6 149 )9 TriumapnhTrdsi bula tions 7 ThFeo urPtehr( i1o9d6 254)7 BrintghiSenh gii pnP too r t Conclu2s9i 0on ChronoolfVo agtyiI cIa3 n1 7 CounPcairlt iFcriepqaunMetensnt tliyo3 n2e1d Abbrevi3a2 t9ions Note3s3 3 Index ooo Preface WI LEw orkoinnm gyd isseritnha itsitaoocHnr a yr vUanrid versIwi atasyw ,a radfe eldl owcsoth hiAepm eriAccaand eimnRy o mce o complmeyrt ees eoanrt chhe sixteernetlhi-rgceiefoonrutmsGue irrloy e f s Vice(rEbgoid daVi cioe rbDou)r.im nygy eaartcs h Aec amdye1, 963- 1965, chSee coVnadt iCcoaunn wcaiisln s essnioomtno rteh aanm ilaew ay. ThroutghAhec adeImo yb taitniecdkc eott wsoo ft hger ePautb lSiecs sioonfts h ceo unacnitdlh ,r oculgehr ciocnatlIam catnsa gceosd li inpca o numboefcr h per ebsrsi ecfihncagotso pkl aevceera yft ernoIow na.ks e enly interiencs htceeo du nbceicla Iuw saaesp riaenskdtn ecwh cahtde e cisions ofV aticwaonu lcIedIr tainlyc hisanitflo dufeme yln ic fee . Buea lIhs aoa dm orsep ecific, pirnotfeierntse hssceito o unnaMclyi l. worokn G ilfoecsu soendh iwsr itainnadgc st ivaisatr ieefosr moeftr h e Augustoirndiweahrne h new apsr igoern e1r5a0l6,- T1h5ec1 o8u.n hcai dl takaeggni omamuenptdoa,ta ison ngoe,fi ts tahneIdmu ensd,e rstth oeod teramsa e uphemfoirrs emfo rTmh.ec ounpcriolv imdewe idt ahg oo d foifolr u nderstaasnpdeoicfntt ghss e i xteceenntthau nrcdyh ,se i xtc ehen centpurroyv imdewe idta foh i folr i netrprestoimtnehg i hnagpsp ein ning VatiIc Ia.n Thiesx perwiaeesnx ccei atnihdne gl pmeefod r mulcahtaeer gumoefm s myd isserbtuaIttd iinodo ndt,r eaamcc htei mceh awti thafi enyw e aI rs woulbde gwirni taibnogtu htce o unocnia lp rofesbsaisoIinns1a .9l 7 1, howevIpe urb,l imsyhfi eradsr tt oincV laet iIcIaa,nn Id h avceo nticnou ed publoinsi hit na cadeamnimdco rpeo pujloaurrn eavlessri nDcuer.i ng mym anyye aartts h Wee stJoens Sucihto oofTl h eolionCg aym bridge, MassachIuc saeutgaths stt, a ndcaorudr" slew,Go r eCaotu ncTirlesn:t andV atiIcIaw,nh" i cwha ssy mptomoafht oiwmc y a cadeimneitrce sts oscilblaacatkne foddr tbhe twteheseni xteaenntdth thew entcieentthu rieMse.a nwhmiyli en,t eirnse tsytol fde iss cohuerlspmeee ud n derstand chtew coo unicnain lesww a,yco t hpeo icnhtam tyb ooFko uCru ltoufr es thWees wta fosr m ea v estilbeualdiein ntWgol uH1,t1 pp,m1Vaettd i cIIa.n Thibso ohka tsh uhsa adl ongge stapteiroianon did si ndebttote hde insicghhcatotsn verswaittcihoo lnlsea angsdut eusd heanvtsesp arokveedr thceo urosfme a ndye caIditems so .r iem mediiantdeelbtytot e hgdee ner osiotfcy o llewahgohu aevsre e apda roefis ta s Ip roduccheedam n odf fermeedt hecirri tiJcoihBsnam l:d oJvoihBnno, r eHleliiBd,yi rn eMsa,r k HenninRgiecrhM,ac rBdr iaennRd,o beTraftt.I a me specgiraalctleoyfu l choisnet raenpgdie dn erpoeurssw ohnors e atdhe en tmiarneu scPraiuplt : BradfoDradv,Ci odl lHionwsa,Gr rda Oyt,t Hoe ntLza,d iOsrlsaaysn, d FranAc.Si usl liTvhaecnio.rm mehnatvsme u cihm protvhetede xatn d savmeedfr omm aneyr rosrosmo,efw hicwhe reel emenatnaedrm yb ar rassiintn hgee x trIew maen.tt ot haAnakr Joonh nfosrop nr odutchien g chaforutn odn p agoeo oa ndD orDiosn nealnldKy h alAenda tofolri os supplsyeivnepgrh aolt ogrToan poho sn.ea mI m orien debttheatdno JarWeidc kfosr,m edre aonft hteh eolofagciucloatftly h Ger egoUrniian versiinRt oym aen frdi efonrdm orteh afinf yeaHresr .e atdht ee wxitt h ty meticuclaoroueffs,e rmeedd etaciolmemde natnssd,h arweidtm het he fruiotfhs i osw nr eseoanrt chcheo unFcoicrlh .ee r rcohrraste maiincn h e texIta loanmer espo.n sible Thibso owko ulhda vbee eunt teirmlpyo sswiibtlhteoh usetp lendid editoifto hnoe f fic,i1aoclftt ahce o unpcuibll ibsyth ehVdea tiPcraens s. Nocto untiinndgea xnesdsi miilnasrt rutmheeend tistc,io onnso iffis fttys onveo lummeasno,yf w hircuhtn o m orteh aeni ghhutn drpeadgT ehse. serwiaecsso mploentlieynd1 99T9ot. h eed itoofcr hsov soel uomveetsrh e pasfotr tyye aIra smd eepglrya tAesfuw li.tm hy t hroeceh beoro wkist h HarvUanridv ePrrseiIsot swy,me u cthoL indWsaatye Erxse,c uEtdiivteo r fort hHeu matnii,ew hsoh anse vleorfas itti hnt hvei aboiftl hipitrsyo ject. Ia md eligchhtafoetrcd h foiusr tbho ookfm inwei tHha rvCahrrdi stine Thorstewianfossr ts hofoenu rttih mmeyc ongeannisdah la rpc-oepyyed editMoyrd .e bitsg retaoJt . L eoHno opdeirr,e ocftt ohWreo odstock TheoloLgiibcraaatlGr eyo rgeUtnoiwvnte yar,ns tdio h iasb laeng de ner ousst aff. X c,a. Prfi1ece