Volume 81-3 – 1975-76

63 Pages·2017·45.89 MB·English

THE
AMPLEFORTH
The CATHOLIC HERALD
means so much to
JOURNAL
a missionary
Uruguay, July 1976
. . congratulations for the marvellous job you do in the AUTUMN NUMBER 1976
church of our time through the Catholic Herald: for us,
missionaries, it is a very good friend who comes to visit us
are ngeuwla rblrye e(nzeev oefr s mpiirnidtu iafl i tli afer.ri'v es one month later!) and gives VOLUME LXXXI PART 111
Kenya, July 1976
. . the Catholic Herald gives me a fresh view on the world
of Christian men—something I am cut off from here and
which I cannot get in the professional clerical periodicals. '
IT COSTS ONLY £8.50 FOR A FULL YEAR OR £4.25 FOR SIX MONTHS TO
SEND THE CATHOLIC HERALD TO A PRIEST OR SISTER ABROAD. WILL
YOU BECOME A SUBSCRIBER?
Please send this coupon to the Circulation Director, Catholic
Herald, 63 Charterhouse St, London, EC1M 6LA
I wish to take out a subscription for a missionary and I enclose
Name (blocks)
Address (blocks)
AMPLEFORTH ABBEY. YORK
CONTENTS
page
EDITORIAL: TEN PROPOSITIONS
ABBOT AMBROSE GRIFFITHS
.1. B. Sandeman. O.S.B. 7
APPROACHES TO BELIEF
Aelred Graham, O.S.B. 9
ST FRANCIS AND THE BENEDICTINES
Eric Doyle, 0.F.M., S.T.D. 18
ERASMUS IN ENGLISH
Abbe Germain Marc'hadour 2
CONDITIONAL ORDINATION: A LETTER TO A CONVERT
Rev. Prof. John Jay Hughes 31
SOUTH AFRICA THROUGH ENGLISH EYES
Dr Anthony Walsh 38
BOOK REVIEWS 41
COMMUNITY NOTES 49
OLD AMPLEFORDIAN NEWS(Full Edition only) 81
SCHOOL NOTES(Full Edition only) 86
SUBSCRIPTIONS.
Full edition (including notes on Ampleforth College):
Annual subscription ... £4.20
Single copy £1.90
Articles and Reviews edition:
Annual subscription ... £3.40
Single copy ... £1.35
Back Numbers are available at the above rates.
Some back numbers are available in microfiche copies.
THE AMPLEFORTH JOURNAL. Ampleforth Abbey. York YO6 4EN
Telephone: Ampleforth 225, STD 043 93 225
Literary communications should be sent to the Editor,
Revd A. J. Stacpoole. M.C.. M.A.
Business communications should be sent to the Secretary.
Revd T. F. Dobson. 0.S.B.. F.C.A.
OA News communications should be sent to the Secretary,
The Ampleforth Society, Rev J. F. Stephens, 0.5.8.. M.A.
School Notes communications should be sent to the School Sub•Editor.
E. G. H. Moreton, M.A.
THE AMPLEFORTH JOURNAL
EDITORIAL: TEN PROPOSITIONS
First in many places they sang the service in their mother tongue, men and women and all, and
1 that was a pretty sport for them for awhile. But after a little use thereof the pleasure of the
novelty passed, and they set somewhat less thereby than by a three-man song. They changed also
the Mass, and soon after that. many cast it up clean.
St Thomas More
We now live in a world which hurries on so constantly and quickly to new de-
velopments that there is scarcely time for those who belong to confederations or
even Churches to discover what is afoot or how far it has progressed, never mind
to reflect upon it and so allow a digested opinion to become concertedly
accepted. It is no surprise then that, in the Catholic Church in Europe, strong
sentiments have progressively tended to the support of Archbishop Marcel
Lefebvre's traditionalist movement even though this may precipitate a schism in
the Church; while at the other end of the spectrum the Churches' Unity Corn-
mission in England hurries on past the steady, infinitely painstaking delibera-
tions of such as the Anglican' Roman Catholic International Commission, to
propose 'as from an accepted date' establishing by a fiat of general assent what
can only in effect be reached by due discovery and consolidation.
It must be known to every Christian in England that the last few years have
witnessed some swift 'advances' (that word begs the question) in doctrine,
liturgy and practice which have not been absorbed by many of the clergy and
many more of the laity. It takes time, a lot of time, in matters of central faith
and its expression in awe and love, to change one's old habituations or thought
processes; for they embody the very experience of that reality. Religion has so
much to do with expressive and effective signs and symbols, that to dislodge
those signs—as to dislodge respected law in society—is to run grave risk of
draining away the experience in men's minds of the underlying reality. It is a
Hidden God whom we worship, the God of unapproachable light known to us
only through the revelation of Christ and through our acts of love and trust: we
worship God in spirit and in truth, but through doctrinal concepts and adoring
acts which have been bestowed meaning by long and well-tested usage. Change
RT REV AMBROSE those by slow degrees, with understanding and consent, and you have evolutio-
GRIFFITHS, O.S.B. nary life; but change them swiftly and without due consultation, and you
FIFTH ABBOT OF achieve only regression of faith, withering of love and the dimming of hope. If
AMPLEFORTH. 1976 that should happen, two paths are possible thereafter—indifference (for which
there is abundant evidence, alas, from formal surveys and common experience)
and traditionalist retrenchment (a return to what was tried and not found
wanting).
2
THE AMPLEFORTH JOURNAL
,2otsta cmhhmiShttavtmtcatnettarhtolhahtaNyS efdm3eic7eChFdoaehntipdsAnramSclhPcoaCceadciphtaee1optee enroaoom0osscennrckl adokethtrlresfeo itnc-omeni n rartupsarr opalm i,illhue ef ige tf,lybetettnv ren 0dgagslrnelietnra ehdAae dethonfepiietalimerot-,sno ioese-engrla res 0nifeer Tiitcopshbe wcea to. t pctra tgvtntro nuiasiw tsco sr.hm0trgilfinpedha eyuuir oenAhr s1ahh o yeeEeen uteeinncsesoK im trIBaropdr t t l ,alionu9neneparltn ciihonhoht.sgidt elrgoe seiosb pasofli gnndtlotmn n dtnossw eaab6c.rM.eso da s.ufnC a eeeCphnn ait ahr e a shmoe taal tmnetgpgetcaoor(tpgEtesrertehh7oitibpha fd.idrti2ih l,.ilh un rt h at drehrec :sdo sefsa te, oofalsS ela0evta u tt-ii pdrail aWoiurga le' ydwriil-a glt' nuanscveso 'tsnin aaa7fie acTcnsStstilhorn1Cblk wiestst rncpdsotnsrihet'yrde. ognhit .loeenrihesmh,neo1iitmt9 doyiiuht tendl er,d oer e eehdpafiiehidodsalmevd gSsheypds7bo s nt Uarsfc.tniioeaiyt't ar ne ksyui k Ta mpe e.a e 'tt f eisnita0ehonvms rslec or a dndystCm7tsaouIssmenesra etle Ch rse f hgts ow Ti tep y0nrc acnge,d ei;wg'ercidetugcoi tdeuo n,ab 'ne ont co mthgeicaoedregahad epihpeeh os sherwfeheaptmop fafaoeloegnrDsnt-nea effec uhs' detrberoeanadaarlssbr'ehspyeeonmoflr)r byofr rdai ! cthe,pttg soo n itiynls. eecr es ie .aoo,sciphcdrs ca llnTwh nlie'e fscwa neglaurTnid d'crt cdir e eeellnsDoleon Timo 1setu hthngaeiacnrios il:nectihrttsahecenmn ilhhletullt tee erni9dcet srrceogitish enhoehhias edisndo nge ona oseyteabmdl cncei sw 5v-to Bta tp so,ehrsidcibef-oliat otncsr rsgs ymeol hofoatev tse9ii yss'.oeice gnry o rae ee fonarlew h nibmavf ,unliaeaen tbtlaagi nsCs dh da t l l ah aRlmat,vpfise ereotihavnrep—rl h c aem ct ithahcl pa eb.eohwkc anaiasatn,erhoem sfllcieeeggtln vie fsaflmanieautElpes tre d ntipdhe du t ioire o eslsio ah 1cas uinhetsbrhril hg bimttmokpcomva Geniarsmco :rl9scun unwlaat th aysgseptrt eteee1a ei miimwir 7etohrbgrptamntnhguettno gteiutbteoonr is aa.toiee 3b9rahh'soilnohe nlpt s,clms, euadta uin hl 'nnn ibgdsp iaa t6fktrt ooeA eehubeta d airriS1slstt mn,te wghetig gy: a 'rnswils0p mlio aenthhpyuainenetCpht us9nssddnoyd thh teidsur n hbhid, hdc n aeeedto' noi o crnaI5 agp s Dl:ot rtta,e gsieteceieteCene d yhnna de.ty t pwfh heas0 onah tlbra hcds hocitgu sofa .aaye fao t Asrhmpl erd,atn ha sm iao iaetiCsa ytmoii h saeo omtvxlenr tadulitnr envn hrcWilatoietu lshn leinlhNhtnlsasiinawneps oho opedpdn aatsaTo nigscaete an rtrimege rhtvl Bta ore e trr u1eni,-ermsgrtotoiin ncso e ahrerfnes tct airemeeteodk xnr1 rfaid9doetfrcoi,uomhfraa aCsdnofy ieoou en od i arcaitu ptdseiv9ndaeob7e e alsno ee fn,wr a witrmrndtf'gdglo, hsp aool ,ntseef7csysore 0rniwhafa'n sb d ooib. inlcatrol em of nrnrllfa it0trs ivedteThcfepole mp's ehhpb1i liotahion,t gP cmis 0 lie bs snls he e8cihi -hskttleuahomieragkae mc ueegt onheni tw hpeh1wos rpenhied rwevnatbiost inueed i Mosref taegst9eio rr gsuethaincoe i viepLiei dfl sMahny'ifnshesvartiiv s r ca7ae,colirreni 'en tonh seaea ilro t iy d oeicoccsepeiaioabs1otcelf dbScf ntssnit rn aln os"d dsenooyse ts r lltcodooelsre f e1aycCt tedistgop2olupicd deasaey a eorru r,o1otaaacn fatyPppomnpi oifo ce ao'5hntaerepa.h9ti ito rarnu msrsebdinc , oulnip•od eitnvbo7ik'f,easc gt,3 cec aoeearctades eopl uIorr p o5fddhitnll of fsntmchec ee a,b tdit.utaap vp'na. r ea lhr(tdtt0ci' vou dA hoi—tt he lmclt.ihttn do,hsn potpiaceatoDr ot tahahe0eh'taliPt lpasieap hs tdh olaaemedieioioora feVoidgitor arbes0ceilttdesctnnare ensie e•eph m i iotIyneapt l e nes roh pD dsv ot r 3wt c1mtrC i aiipmiSt4aCgnb tbsyd, u5'icf ipoh oana:edehfo u hai 9cdvac,la nrr o.eo oiig,o,paoltlae eancueo ohlpie slao nla 7wae;nw am in f dcardapuaytlmienithTe l cpngulamab .D 5titmd etshaddlahtncr r1nhun- rahieitaoyi tleCe rrpaoh 'isdeinnm1miae , ol1cemuydse0ecrsccawslcvtvtaen 1 npydinaau e;l opo9ad '-0nnir rsiirhp e.yyeersra 0un ipltifgyartnlcrS e tt oct 5i0 la e asa inlr tlfr h r Lttoiht ytnfho n sp hetOlfath ahp'0getaaaac-d jnto wSgasitiabbih o t hiru5meinhIisiaeargthtec secporotd i.bdtrnlonnf eep bi t la t ;eos.r rne yne shdnefte svio iei oe -fftpctl eeenti ccl wr.d d atchryid-oino foai rT prtnvo a s-eo tle ) hiero -ntn ,yfecon sn hferh e- d .ie, tr e,'s t r CfcwloHao(istsWoitltCdCitaaowFHtnpstowfiispnlhoafhpslfn3hhvhnhnhrrieon o iis a rpashrcnaaesaogodogieaieeTaeeottCdceuiudtrtttyplomcuSSgettWaltaoelAmh pnerhl pdwA uh his—snauehey srre fyf ipa ifoeerrAdrsaaluiMase tA nfre CtoaaceeirecodfMyrpits efipcp nstl touErefctsoiru tt ercGhoe clyiysd,htah htnlshtthdo oidltchohkispfiaenob inateesilarrc hnhrnoesTa) tt a eic - ob t o.tHc acdhr ns6omnyere t cnstiotsaipA.o Fi'u .geata irAanhefgoheborled na6i sr Asatoasos eofi aaldclolsnbiid ee iitluia ntc 9s'sh Ir Cf anetBngn cd sqf stnmd nhsee abcGfr kaesuo r ner1i ot(rbaniadWi hgt pt Airh oh waaeyuhtlfocl si.ehgeeeon p nyail 9 tnp, if hlrc Eamdeii tAd ir trchcovFoodceIFm adeare qinnnfLhnrhg 7casi a gssmen isApdelsoeisfoni oeunbp cstr'avuawftn reds1pu seh n(—. eEttoBmhrlaeuwcgreeoDnteisns ehrmgltitsa t' trred,r fe hli esinL, l soart iphref ngc bhiao on rtscbc ledelp.lshciiih eihaeCegrb.hwmuiehr f vda higu iysntsmireceroh b ts2ip eaed liilllc oliede itotea wh tsIsaensf ato elmaen2 rh ipleohvbs lndiuhthshoPattuoeitashi eenhoiasplt so8Cnde guh on odornironcii c sl aasauoRvdsnrrroi t roont. tsn—sieroa,iapneop io(subn shu oiixs h h sdoteoari nApedhn Aatid,ppnbt noaitt sC cpi uf e ihlnws n ehsl iaa aeealabra tcoeot d estth rrmgilolbiiftaes hsqtitteslollpheecceaa nmadDwsltl fahLhs1lor,sp hr eesi) nfC oP sh g h.iur iehloyn g sethf fvda to o9 osre' o1oyele,jeetida wbac eaarawheo ri sifei nsoroaormniIv rivt2p ip9dfc acnntiuoossthrnbCnmnktieeerhoaetirhs errsewoncu ay.hekthrE9 pe6 mF itms hac —aomusddnedatm,rebfs3C m oow-as rtaiihr etl.pe e8ossieTcrnho visc3ehu ri m Vt nytiveb, sfu titpee nnp ucewrna)f ioon higs,tatE19nhh eutnnr wAd ih traVtnuni.s oih o ihndpiTny mry rusda Dotn9a Ne esthsitesiraasailbiescdsrsgtt s sa H enrecch t lose cea,ewAt o3s uoesislyl ,fh eai eiiCta t hrea an s h aspi hersstfcahu ttnh nlpa2 gnuiaeHln dtPol ehto tirff e uapei so e mFbiasha Mhos-d'intd ' ,hckoriwOicccsgotfiARecauml)osL oraswcee1cnema oslecr eHllratvttreahb aoss numaofesiWeOstkreih enoiciaiar 9naafroriei t niinh p l nat.tesbntvtmnie avewonrpwbdnwona bdnytleao t7shhcCP eoinosets ggcilinoeIeb iistls e n syso y ciannol eoadet0cdC trh nOsai ygtoda fdoraeyhboselmilo yrtt b msty gna afrerhg, oi k otc hon orhyhmfeon So y m nd senu5ics, tha a cf oc rGeedoae'e rette tn iatama tei(ttifeuoIT5s odaaakhfetrh etsiirithsnoihh, rNTnpnpst cO9lmnfs 0Cenn t ourcnyh nntr ir l h peihor teyeoentee)tt.o eectegthsImnc,v,ctfRhaittc 0eo.gtfh bhhrr ;Oae0aaorvem, e t wi Lrfdi t u ree1 0iecfe uder'psitmua dsttrL reCeeeadptae0rswF lf.NwVo n a0am l ohrg5etpst itdr hot rebaPuiiiybc do mtaTnhseh0 r devagnhrlodhhfg e7 f taheSia c serioieyb lrgoarl iane eideihrFtaee;naavech sdulonub 0 ehror a tibhr mh rvre m(iCnlableneung eoistaitihea seetpaun a w raidie etve mtofstr vd Mvhhatmsycimutssseosucerhdds seovthleionadtto rhilst ottleentihr rhhr-oeaenmo hhshi s lteosegu pOeoheblanrie ieernAope lalathc)odate i eypgdr uiitie . e.ni m lhtndgnlme aa(nm noreprgtsCvsn emiendlocarn e iap 1it edesli iF a ebta nesofsmgo td Fe -ggyny St.rt fbordEtee 5oai bllvro, dap tyvemnhrhnlaodne ti c a srpa isereerC ereut n7idsolienahbtit mtgie.iese tseie 1eaah s-een dhnatrrygn3tgri wct0ihpat;ira1yyowi esusR hootntro9 ehna ohsaasr, gleinsg sna:oq9 uene0ea aweta un n.tnt laae p0ot m e Netol Fir6euuLhn 0pnnerrusiararti oesitbnido frdaof55eoicfaMIt dciifo0ntisdteaecdreainlassfaro r vuftachoni sl feone fs , ld o t'e gmsa detii str m tsreaowwevyPrs in hlrbi,hgtofi r oR o otc eht rrlLe w hfgan fn1asy te pkyimmohtrpah ciefifheienfrftda anctu o snhoGen na bna 9 r tremaot ra eiuoaDoilemooansidnehoah stdonoanSaoploamenstmrdt 5eahfuposStsl fs Eeme yn iw ob ldeeeifditnist dtasCaewsgr C 5se iai nbra tsncciedft toi rA viofeNmcty nl' tCn erukt ehiaoaa nsSe ec vlei aorhvvoieeei 2l r.hestrt segrni adr,fsogabnpat daHMnaeod.oa e i tnf 2crnundeleh rsTly ozegdit .c larsmondn ljsuahi e nh dubrotd rtntaepya oe Pihser,steC tr T d dimlror rTees nbitayg tsoon ietmntirEdecircoc u Paip a uiuepCdnltehote en onth leoarhe a ficuhoirndtrh tacSvlleenacr3Sca ccifdm'mttece;ouaeceecu;srradtc ldfason ed 1 a t 3noeo tser ttih.ocy o sat udPtanitrnl aai adn seJusf;ettr9eeaua—iiidnsflunveuneyttX m feh elono eintcnoi rb no .etlthh4nkernoyra ebt ra)i1r vheiintaoi3ns'iliiewedndenddieesrnnn'o7ygnayaeeee'ee,-ea6c;rlr-f,st--l,., ,
4
THE AMPLEFORTH JOURNAL
crduntaBteptohhenhouvoaneedfaerpto ss h iirbtectnoile holdasoh nldeHars tneuo ie ttCdu wifmydf'orasm oa o tni epgosyloml.erpesr dfrao ege aaodbtuaej hybealCp le'aseyoc. a ttdwfPtte t rroioBoedodait nndip ihdtsinchncae iheateeiy itoP tol s.h pbpt ona Ioeosrtwnsu o p ntin ilhusemd,2ao e gsea4mbur hs t oSessehtptfehaf t o r oeueyMdebr nef eaoesE aysi d ftvcecytto eePhous,rfr reyoetnmdsse ltsoaalaCereoidyldfirow nd a aefanit:eey cor Cnse'r'ras Tsidvfdhsl.r oh teuCItwoauseoersrohrc yi fthutoht haa hino fneniwheotcftdih a hri rCln vff,irtnru ceoahiotgoh lorri mrsmdw ha hed i rt agnm heefbosrau cirao sfdlmlii sid u nfnrbo aeoapgetibs vhwi, dtwe heiahnn ndodhte o? it p eianeocct' sn wcrrhnTt;emcah a,heaas teyoaiee tmt etdptn dfoerdoraod e oni nyp tnsFhmat'gets er 56.. CrooWdWmwarfihine mdeettuhmghi nearaoe cbtganguo herortt etiee raot iesehsnc nC eo totsstoohrnhf h tmadrcetoaehoti m ltHc,tlevi hooab eooeBgnsennl nyo.m a f bO idrsnCoiyynertm a idT,inmos taEigh ftnsuar N oCai Cntfe lurlih Phs coawaruR moiclChsrlOcfycti heca Pht haauphnOeenctr sawSecc d,ccdIh e iTocwal p,lIvde s Otepae aaplNtrnnctbtroeeSoudalped,m e n e wid rtnerimienatl iye ttgtiaih ensai gnCe,i.t s rcmtiheothorue enirter po c tosihoh nrH aredo aotsatf ht liaesywne hl te loCh cadrseoold ulm v em bbeapeismnnni esaiadqsuccn tunoscrteaiipioeonncar5gsn--tl ,
presbyteral and lay roles in ordination.
* * * The sentiments are good, but they ignore hundreds of years of history and habit,
• Pp(dSMwCOcPoarACetoohsnhreosfgaopnoisdwucrnrtpi soaeo hrbiaaitoMcsvetIdoliretrnvhsiidd eletai,ieiC itn c to or(noSi taE rooinhfa se It tslnCEcaennsiltpoeursu?ts tnhrmeyngce wemgumh.p erosee lrne )uaecaetrfm.hnas ntn hnmT d ebittdt,cuiteehs eeooa,pptd le mrnhi( ltrc a htCCeaeBahbbbse llhoeytei yiU seym uCm C rhe nM TsrtCiootohcmnii etmtnhgepuhaeunige s urnmrda o CssrirPre teJcf iiaiRhos ras.ohgM otsunr eienaCefpiaor)ofist,c .eooi .nf cn.o hFw rsdca TnmaBeirhh alta bhls iuiJeeetoScly'e c odsdnFh wt Ukh ttaC s eehtaloCnt neodUreelrb r, yhiCke m gteCy,CCuy ro ia veao rhJvhBedecnCntuuemaiy ihto slront iyi ccbhrhntomta mhsorreo,n1yan e mnpia9t cdrtshSt n7Aheia sea.B7c sitiJuso snrho —M.udits tsefonhha te eCnl'ceotngetRnht oe UhrrdtrBefo'eri ,.o otCn FwmaayArdWeC,t,p rha i dn sathtiPhsnch)icgtnsa to ae ehlortoCsiCm i ttc,nd n e Uhiacaae me rwEuannt r R hHhemlr uital'ooch eReioccfethlenrdthcihoheced, , ek avam sTrfistetaoe rhr—heeianidtrrseteen sn t cbpTBiotdtttnhhiuoonouahotearnesontetdn e sts r yp iee'aIitwetn; bronhql onmieegleae ue fd mf Cn s nae taC ehhotmnediaihnrexehncn tnodcua whereteceio ertso esolstupodrs—o ltfsi a tac.c tii,aa osholkr sfB etbb rf ean hgo aab lacbr eegrmrpao ncoe o uuoctefdt u it aogknstpfhoHnh r umtdn bdadtatitaoeghmeirn taraw er h fcdaengload yee inisdraArcvii ntom btmoneip naosgievsnnaeggein fne ahryooaaltasini rercristfsengleaea airtahsvse ue ndn ewaettrtmnti sirrreitrestnateai ihed on magi mdonnw gann bs)it at ,tCdh. tn ye is hyoo ia eT hchee nawnnuaghhsoccn hdrgeou nuieyciso satmol,P hni d amiitaenwehser btoossae eniheo ospu vdimtosh nuhoerhg tslam,ber selis yv rs ei trneogtue oaetiprro orrnn, laetlao itna hikrpy vf luesgeoutetereenh fe isr.dmereor danisP —brsna n'aeraortleeye orlos f aoa de p wartclraf n oor lteiaptsotltn saaorlCcp lmiha yrot crsain,emeo(fl ta tcwarorhnhriaeimcenteksoien ctecn etahl4ed.ioo sc tr p fi gB-iiioeotttstt6nhhheeuannmieeed.r-t.,,
causeT hfoer fciorsntc ethrnre. eT hPeryo paorsc ittihoenss,e -t-hough not elegantly drafted, do not Ista crerasmtse onnt o mf ruetdueaml preticoong bneitgiounn aotf thmee mmobmeresnhti po f tihnriotiuagtiho nb aanpdti spmar, tiwcihpiacthin igs ina
I. We reaffirm our belief that the visible unit give the total action of God in Jesus Christ. It is a new birth into communion with
titrfgpinofreoebtrrotcaahBhu eahonuytdouineadhtrneom snetng mdan4ierei ftisnmfheooah v T. duceutpt s grirn3 hhha2io.lswcemt rsyWh . eteueinv.oub a h noo Tle eeat dgmoeyMBetWhgsrdWCnhm qr ld a re er udeteedeaoaupwohseiehdbseslenexygtm uavrk erleee oh'kbac itil v relrc—tis d rore opm ciethby isrnsadtithsa ef andhleu'oef eimisll .airao ei chrCi blrrltneof sdTtet)evnyt iapeloid eo tm tnecee ihaf,shengvro no nlea ' itetd,oei oryw tftroP s sdaO elah r ep oanlwrihsh oeenymrcbna ilwdnTeo ase o.ehmfddlacti d eugpsa s kt gis teaenhci'nt h oot inutsshctntu,duhaeaae hs tiuflni sudi nr atautsnt iaepsod uhteniip ril ooriidtrrt ttd oseen,netryieoreyc nrinheee on ngi 'fnoe.a t wtogmoaenn nsgnoyohsn mrru lor tgp e iteoyfcfeh liomd irtprfla e hvd Ae n orsstofmtidtoe oarew cteintirn avroS tfyenem gegsbiaih geiglnd scsqGpiolsopaevilbn sshie nisumi pttrecaeoeire i ti groinaieoa t onraesdisthnarete ct d nn ncesh.uiotdeaa qrso,ah e aes opuvsf toOu'nciama l are issfiachfstas ns trcvhec s poecn,eadtledett u theioop ddvoifeid ddvfcoe ittvertlo c rLo ehy hceane jsei paaroono dr eg t/ ,a nbeerant o,bi or csi oAnapeay.adodcdpon o pfn t aItnt apn,rpoeehtniiito tetrhnn oto.oi hre ctteonas poi o isn e sr eTlc,rganSlntlaot a' griohiru laaf n pcctta,ecaaCelniechsnh oaniaetswnn o cemheoitltpndwn adiltav hhuo.cytio ot ne s hecoorisl b c'onTs cthdoenasfr uyhCahpdghhdh e manP gaes hma eia uenamcdh'rthmtievscnr otgera i aiPea rsocnpoo thslueaae gh shkvraatnbrtngs (cohei(eruy'eto1t y, iatriipies ycr snnieotto8nyvcaw e roarhanue9 o neue,rptrsnheo nchai6nnil,aeldaiayee dtetfr-e)ed l 't esnsrr,l ory eaitsts s o . l l hpCCCmGSinscwttnhiaauercnhhhoriauevvlphtaulruuric teyeep1iaineualsrst rd98mT70liclttintattetcaseih ...i'.:hhodesoe l sms cde es, uenCmop snWWWWtk Bfl rooheae toeauirree f hh tofoseopns emoeeee lcr dc uite srd jtsrmn mhfh iaeAor eioarso a uanywi edrac p cgg g vfgnapuegtcC,grhc girtsho ernhrvegiChresteGcl ereenoaeuiemteiete llorsoteasehsiiemieoaaalairecnddenyo fe ls u dtnnr alwroo,gnsm ocnn tlire r'db yttorntemtfs ici ity ihapof et ol c nt r p -ociehp ohpfevmtira ecoMonnorooa eur. ie firooxtins fanangr bf stiere 'oOpo agsidmtit scefsb itmmnPithptltthte nnncthonr ilehe eilioerovdoiitoi uceatotreedotrhnw eieu weinuoeie iadno .pnetinwlddso ehpg fso ncitnoT eeas i us th uieephin eotord usvnlihlteool lw ronit,. n deoiconu aeUie mt f atfra aaer Tih wacstin 'oebyta nniysexc nn muhhco icsnr hfalpdttptidocmoteenoiuhtyhessi.anleo eyn tsr sag ihor hetrkerpCasgeTl,oti tnoceaeids oehnsoeai p hwfhitnrd bsuto sirfetni dpecfrbeuoa , irdtneefoitcd yrcsoeohalye rhnela li e fecethalnl vfetsess h s o e t lhalftnrieCte tuoh y dahesuwi EedseSaantntrg eoee hn rlpo sals siunluccgao pskc ycrdsai c'hCoocedeb rinl i ri a s c sUcleriduhvse iis hapa rilttlinoattmtteraose ta'ysnuc oehas fransl ninihc atrarii adm en sgt tttciwe apaiaoinorsy yncirpemrh suieiencegft dlfsv oidm eyta:tl cdcoCtoaaeae ee limw is f oltn tpiefnlfdnukfrolwhcbiny t oeromg slned.tinmmeoed ettnh irrh nthhtrws i .sn o Ce Iemgif m ioo.tuietnahnitsnesnno ioh nunt be pEiiiiul n th ps usnsie alcd leaifdlatraostentt r ut e l utaioar(cal ac cciwcthcnclsirotteehcrie httnohcrtaesloaoo minh hdie osl nmael userstuo.c vsa,es n- epre u smioiwyrmhpf Ebnrs xcco i ct voaulmvioehuopuworhebwterluboado i mmechn ,lecbnirloell t s tshdevi..hmaioaehtsim rh otnoeus a ssSdnhn labcnptg nora hhiaiteutorteieec i hkgshioienendcnitparasceetnyedinsygyh.-t)-t.,l
6
THE AMPLEFORTH JOURNAL
gArcntafHioehch'rvolupytaposiaoerromesdop nnalt lsuyhi olcgtetatomsr eesireFWba otair lihadlwwatdetnbeeer etisalshirr shc sesotyi hogtemno a ino'ta nrsrgte hgawravru sehyeac tacesssa h ad eutt tpCtr eosrseietbieate fohpnrpieao tcrsousode cufta,ac nn s rreahltopmmi?csil pn tethnp,it ye d lPduh:isai n 'so siet oer' bddulnha—fierriireeiaehnev nnn Crnsl riaiddtge nynento pg dle ngoplys'rppr Hlg tro aa)e ohhttmuu swsigrhlwerspt aaeei ats tsosrhdh wohoisod soneifew.ifo.t isi s inainC utnfABo shb nao nl onienei'isrwTdstktn 'smd o hhwsoetao(f , o. cyeri fhdd odytp' qh,otTeoh fi tshua lctrniah efDenaena(ieta ad!hlg pd el—i ttedeeHyrtimh htyo iowibaiwsboib'osu.s neheec lnw gigeTi iiornn'chthm ah.wh gh Cgacw eei nH v yratwharaa ee—toeimus h t s wc nitr tiedmobhPohscen o ynenvaehde tn ghu ehd'o—h epir elei anet to hwwtinbptaviloohseydedroeh nseo sf kouDi o ocr'ni oSelopfelnriinf a fgspvclg tb uiraoeoiil mcaonrimntndfshie,tgteetc aehleas a )diiye, rlnf.,ws a me :aa gta wTn hbwiihnientdtohlinaehhde/t- e gth 'e , Taewdtkdegxenohhecaloueinilicwg buntehAhhAtd ll ,ae eteb mcf dcw houeGBgtioulinhge oopttih d nluodBeetfe fr fo oc ayubtNrfenhO,let i ydeaF ctt s yht hayutokT ehtaesfreh epoeatfeF c lrotsfvreshauor eroeAbAnua dodmllfd me ft mef e asoMrtbrr'shoos:ur me ortfrothe o shc fh Beele topli h toyslarrhoetw aesRoeiudc srsr frett .yRisoei cfOc. ntrool ahaaPqyfl tr eau AiSReoplrid hrbhnrS iEoabe ewopbotoscoafls,t ie r r esioiom tticfo ynGu iksn scAr.,' ee amCtp nlRhtsodohpeoeneel tedpIagirrfeyvarF ovee rorgaitxutc nhaFioerstd f'stido eo Iao pndn tfeTwoce nFec iinss iadwHde neapetarch da synep rSe,b aar wsooeltese ycr vo aeotet snnhhntsddoee-,
In this they hit upon the immense success which led to the Industrial
Revolution and brought us the great gift of the scientific mentality; 'this new
tinge to modern minds', says Whitehead, 'is a vehement and passionate interest
in the relationship of general principles to irreducible and stubborn facts; this
ENGLISH MONK-BISHOPS balance of mind has now become part of the tradition which infects cultivated
cLCftCmGtoPTrAoh(Etweo`opdRehMuhoDnTmen a iEernB1CtMnlht gu G ikceR9stepotrUryas:Ou6hOe ypn - rNH5megRsS:igew )DniaoYE,SrIxm,h tee l t bt iLyAoaTAsg oieUu A lnHGa1nFrbiatC atO9 .uIbaraii UtnK0soSeMgohtlsS hl 4 ntute Pmu BE e (A s(DeSAAoprptnoi, Ouifsla brgo.n nuhpg cvSN1blfaeso.ihufiu0 so 's depsBbsta94bhtr e t i A)4oPiie iGsrs Canaf dyhabhgc een aAr obooaot'nrdrsopepv,yfude y A e crihcoBSl,n akoio bafausela flRvmb Gtb nalbslie-aiinenm ieyPPsamtbddggth,cari ir, gtiosrRlc oab eemeNg.ttflesa edih atenetyIma E et)wnntRerer. oBas ,,d a1 Zg fhTCbim91oboaiehae su8ut1casm n ieanet6sclg0d, als doo 1aln- enKloenmti_2 odeswdAoke1t7t m nf s 1metp9 i o d(—dAne8oe6pofi m ls 8dtu1.netotf th 12coo kvho (ne1dkrla-seFria o3l9e t c oelaeitt)cE a6inl,nwd vl etns Did eevolntgte a feaoep1lr bntli ' 8ecee soc1tWr5ohdhg3oem.0 u ae k—8rtst rBiao,e8e sg n b beeM)pht eny,ehitt snl eoo eoicmBtd nnlnoeiycaoogctppl shontsiuattieks kointtd- ceso see , asagsswthp'yfBthoecinneoirughimnoio dnudsnteiusbuhh ce ndeernimlhoragBBAat,rn eai ip theotnmuedsul nsi cdft ttaeottepBd hi'so .ntdneotoiya eueeat edfs,cuhe erl l bsoaa dskeaakrrntyi lt er,v eusiwotsr tslnlh eedohumwi meshg gm xy icytcnilssie ipa tce;eooolae uc tllhcdnlnfsebtat hraeh ett niioeniua saunnenrto ,tunans, y rt f tcu tipttid hhiie hucmocrunta aaesssyauersstt leai ?acno tli frmhltdesSh'li f e e ard tac ogsetrennnsvcreivsocilfac ea,inealbihvf e edeil tfitrauetn,kic'utuiho sn rstcauernenfUieu ieynploatctcergt hh ndct nwiatd hteliatei loa hioooats tbvtrlhu ee:n srn, yea ' i e xrt, ' l lfse tht vowpyroaahmhcleeen lleguiieeaglr gteicto nys hnnoarn tfhtn dt reaadr uithiiindnaqictsstcfeosihottett fuiosti oieu terdso nitnyroor rgh neyl, effhahtia o wss w vatsottmtrtt he hvi hehfodtd na eeeeihe ewiat ngc c nsehrgnpwot bshi. orerto gwomyeaeheourwelFeonavoprvogprnlurtierereoudh sao l errV dmu trttmfsdt'bi at u.saaisomi h,elc lltn kAt ifatmoo oteanoooidhnt nfrnnornrihr gidnigeetgttfs.easa i dol oWn d,ifnkrte-r gcto hoanist naiairsuhhgtteotoge mmuhenoaihtwuinrhf.ettleets, ofh d re e. i'ew f se se cToya'atl lrntohtiiafi enhhhcktnot asshdhaeseeef-tt:,
crDeocesestsps sicitoeo nno,t uianrnu c ehu antonf ogwPreeRo streIorNey n nT ueInswN.u GmOpr bniAneeNr te rDoersfa , sP OotRnhAO esi sDC hUtaahrvCametT ,e fIloOiintue Nn tNhd C eu rOnecsaSli sTmooSfna tQe uoifd ethneh am, our sitmnho ea tacthb he'Wsta hopnherhibi srmlemaeds i ne aoid,nnn '- d sssc thtumihaefernofp crieeose n nanwieboni otgt hhu sotapth unremtedi arr ie ndtltd oihig,one ilo ossnn pst c hatiihscae eetln a ttoamihnstehtedsye, rtrli woemhlseiatger neii'.nod tnE tet hiwrhneueisss ttth pe iohitnnaui l lttosk hsusiecnom ipggemh nreecelaeredsts i ssitb t a besaaclklbialsn om uduope'ft.
ath yeeiraS srou, bdwsecesr picpiotteni otminnosu steot ftthaove oAumrapblleef otertrhm Sso).ciety ( so to the cost of ttoh rceeea Jsoe RpprNaeysAienngt mmtireeetalaynp ihnneygws. i cMsse,e naesnethw iohcfis l teha enth dew cohorusdmm; aoanlnoidtgi yem sa abnnedyg aponrf e tftoeh retr ueprdno e tootsu dtt ius'hrcnuuemsds atanhwiesa tysm' feirnao nmainn g 'te hnoef-
(respEecahcrc 4ooihp9rt—odt)i g.oo trfnoa sBpt. hhrIoesnc, kOtahtnoAisdnC i CsCtsoo u fuheor.or tpr ,ee teScha ohdethnr eoaoFrpstmi rsoesihwxsti etrerE.e at lhO feooevnrnie eretn h gs s ertam aepvtaaaiimtnygug e db preieehs tcopoottao orti wd,d bio naef gnd o doprt h nabertoyos rn ismpeH fwaoour rngtH iiahcoi ugufMulhsal lerJ a yupbsnmauoegbuplel-t cettnhhoxaeelpto iulcruar oEiraonnvslw t eeoesndrfcmy isRoaepulnnhlmbeacec teotiofo oseonrtnli ustce ctokvstifhoi,e dterutheyh se tet.ht e hcdimnieeggipvra ti racapewetrtisotoa eopyn-f es aFrttnu oafdb niea cilmpnydp aatladhynnee dd t whk thmiehte caa hhtndi eygewn lhi falgseysihl nllt skefiuuf nctolt crosde e tesahecs mefepu i etol h xsoaipmftr lidFovelitrayshabm otliwdeo ssotnh 'r ooatthofft
ewwthxhhapyinll ea St fihtonrheo ine nmt ogsh wc.et ih oeieltno cwhgeuiasams nc tasah snaeti ntnhideeu wsmc: hlaLiugnerhisctltihi eeoms nC e tthrnhoa esnt s woo wtfoot neoodnkfe t berhfnriues ld c fwo itrmhostere k dmsfe roiognfmr deG es t oihindnec. casPhpceeiarembhnlaciespe tossr fy tr,hba eaEthltri eeiicfsr
8
THE AMPLEFORTH JOURNAL
paMboasossuictba llselc irieennc comen acaitslhi eaatmbiooanut itco sft ,h tehwoehl oitlgwey o,P. aronfde sBsoerr nTaordrr aLnocnee rsgeaenm sp etroh akpnso wpo ianst sm tuoc ah APPROACHES TO BELIEF
CtshowphtBotcgiohfpdheaoSemcoafoueuerelosi1 shwrnelnisco nek1swksenccesf1eiplac: mbcoat eo0A aornilea1immallqyguAtnfnidpe,.nbh l iu std t uilwcmdbeswtttepetle Fraoh c oio aenraasyohala hfre itc' cndim rFn e sn n tnhAe Aadcdarfgrcrewwaeesinoaeop imenml n PetprtidiocltdJthgint yitlhbau bcuoh iniee in ifuocaraamrr wnf sng oesoe lomnltA,gw e ie eesv rsr mnhe wtledea tnoeeeahvLhtnuim n onhte'mcteasieessafy t lnesess oa vto ryssR o m'a rM hgieene d pctlftsoaaylfAla ipo eear taffel m Vtieeenaop nlosbonofs rsxytt esa rea,nb flyo e ewt atyb r tfaoo h lnaiaytmaSau re mncmttehtst cino stn atdane ria easfoedtennedtns Ags a nnnh n a cpset dt.ssyh Ietthi htuatrakc hidIis W e paeopsfoh,d— eoas is se onenonovi nf' eif sftrt fsooaamtaab'd rhipish,lltlroncaoce nll oe,oeie teyi auerteie s nts hitn tndNrhds,ohitietoie r ytd oinife eilf rtisfsa 'aio i fgh te mf efFtnt hryMiiwnd eeh cescwtaree :s lu eetsau tneosCso'edApr ch.stliatld reah tms iiooesaams Abl s ywe ngt oaler etl s o7nebwyf snxean nk afii t drs dpao nboh oi co u a tfwhe ir lltdcsp lnanlao trtiooeihhihFshaiersadntvfe nodeysysnerb h ginuges n, u tdiAls i poceirsTn esmeotra us fedrp u deedr auesea n strelbter srtnospniyehdmeflovrobl darlad en,se itfcoo frit fcrat rc.nioieiwmatPa re soatethAdlnrnht G kretn,a gihe iohde onta ooF oiaeof racidmnAtnnadnte r fbosut d ccF,g bte o wfr rhG togfmob naibiusamorhelgeaert,,orelslar om ennntleiatr ttw dnntr hegistd'hdth szh'e ga,hroeosee ewtea et eweor d l yne CWReoCaetatDhhxfnnnhee hhaoedirpt detmirr e ios.oan fDit stiirsloin neut oaet ttenacs taimndoshdalo nl fiy eonntom Cyht Acxmh ireeptnhrepseh. roe lnrn riritiorrlieteahsn tis rfda etsgiewg uts nsaiAi rw hGaitopse oa lionr RdrniootRnank ee?fpm hB erfep Ceoi aluBpocnerrymhs or lo ybr tttin oHi reesitb(its teowvimtefo n ioxaii h bgslnttlpnosylh sy oggost ule A bwiiiefSv e tm cecEw h edEcolatfn iLehaoueinrft etRre soiivclohD poxttaieEernnn ietnrstroogitnDuenst t,te, caspe r onfritn eosiiffescGrr nn salieuanbiasntgRt.lueb iebo lnibea ttolAmrhtyothldc euie ewHCo ceet ssnlpor Cnx Aotie rtrtai. epnrad m Mralwss'ditlleTn isdti.hmvitecic g hiheealtdai Oeliit tnteot hso ssle.dmn ysoeS 'r N ti.uroeh,t.( to aBrherLtmacthekne .hete toe aecu yi oienarissn rmnlxfrod ei ektim ose ostfe nohnu eton etotfli efl ht.a y otocet oChSsbfhcf r e ho ePhtqe nhhouR uuCeoiunsCse retltK md,apc s hof biohotw adrfeirr ii1etoc nmi os ta9un t.tafeaCu 7in bsWkrahdfE6 eeonaue h w nircua r1tec rg ecFtnihr5lti cedlei ea6noavt stsihigupnhbe taansohwpdye)tttf
experience among us. £2.50). Succeeding the late Bishop Ian Ramsey as chairman of the Commission.
wmwlfhiekrniadieonsssvr hmohpcweeweiy sridWwt ite hbn,had heeegn w i n f cbcdcoiothloy ahrl a eunlwatala rh ltjleca luwe ookgics toaul ea toyoki rnwcvtsf oe epifllbe eo rlgione aarnef bweyr mtnretGe ahg t.rorh oeydsdrW id.,ie ni r n aceegalbot ocnsohnitv dlaledfeievd itodrodye an fe wtsb eohntel hhrtaeae loen nnyslt t l ,dabeyf as eat lrikhraebdfe retyynfahen o eddrfn,ree ya eadntwi roitn nvhh bwd et ieht c,hi h wnhetiiboc isywlnht lhmh eeoaeiax snal olt wfke Gft p fehaywoee yeersmrhisa pir hoor eik is,ldlt mnet h aasoao askswnfa ote S ld noslwht ,.u oo etBrmhW wu seerhh ien stiag osRetslaot dlhouks oiaberlcedeyltets l , , ssCpoMtlBheiinrtdoiveota belmeitubelrdhre rl mIas eeifnolcca amli vCoeysniaets sp drhmdriW eeo o dae.atfnb i ih dGkld tebetieseithorse, st e ,etenlmt hifairr eoRnee tatf lagoi eilrarnnoui ge rndwsdtisieh sutoi erahsesttuedt woe iraw Pjnd coomblarc ei yigoavytsn irpef Cvetooec piefisauhgRet sls cpuhncoecmo rtduropr cn oiilfsohopxat rerrAf teettpi eut b snDradfsr.uag raa uiodatlvitlbiintot iiochlestne eainc fhi oanouetrseynri s.nllbnd sl,pT y aeaiit vnohhty.dm 'igre es nti hatgeeNaionneismn eny ibdwwUap ny Cl h hnh Taahsaiiincvespslr lhtsieiea osst rctta trsitthiuinmiehacteldmyrnaa eoi lstvmnp oiu soitf'tgde ct noatmhhuO on oaob buxdldule enaf itimortsrd nhssciregs ehedu r omo is,sogp fsnt bitp a vhattternhhehreerdneeese-r
J. B. S. yheearers c olef afrrluyi tdfeupl lloaybeodu arn. dA st hDer C Aom.Rm. Pisesaiocno chkaes. rheiamssoenl ft oa bmee smatbisefri,e pdo winitthe di tos ufot uinr
bthee rpeaRasleislziinegdgio; f nlsu oisxm tohefet hi vmiinsmigo enwd oihafit sceoh mthisei ntahg isrn;e gsm owmohteeic thh isntagn wdhsi bchey ios nrdea, lb, eahnindd y,e at nwda iwtiinthgi nto, ogTathhteieo rTn Caimlh eurser ccih(t1a"4l. tGohf i vFteehnbe r tucoarderayeyd, 'ss1 s9icn7i 6ei)nt,st i tfnhicoe naC-nshdau cprrchahiml ooesfno tpEahln igcwalaol nrcsdlhi mi"pi antmcel,ou rhdeee ssth ucagongn egasrntesy-.
arpepraepcsrheen;h tse ofnamscioetstnh; ;is snoogmm weehtthhiciinnhgg i swt hAhtaho.te s N geu i.p vlotWeissms hemaisttseeeiah oinednia enidaspg: lt o ,h tsoaes f niabidnlill a ittlhy gea,o thoapodnpa,d seaslnyeeesdsst, y etahtn eid sg ybreeeyta oteenlsudtd aeolslf "abithnIdaettmr e rigCiiserr herint, uyJ oare. cn"swh ud os a tnoordfe e iNrtth sa tuzhasaan rutce nitemahnb.a tlsn eoys ct torhw iajphotto iunt hr hetehasyve we aC nisahdh r sitsceotrni efasodenla leolo nwf ft oeGhrripomsrd wui slaaeayn tw,id ofi nitnwhsd ha anotnh y er ie inansttptteoeiltlclueetdr cataeubn oaldefl
Sciencteh& the ModeqrnueWst.o rld, 1925 whichT haere R teop boer tf oanuanldy saems o'fnogu rC ahprpisrtoiaancsh etos'd taoy .b Feliiresft,, stehpearera atere b tuhto osev efrolra pwphinogm,
the creeds are the norm of Christian belief, additional to though dependent
upon the Bible. They regard the creeds both as constituting vital links with the
Church's past and as embodying the truth of the gospel in the present. They
acknowledge that the Church's verbal formulas refer to mysteries whose depths
no one can ever plumb. nor do they object in principle to an exposition of the
creeds' content in contemporary thought-forms and language; but they could
not accept any replacing or superseding of the historic creeds as official
formularies. They think it important that the Church should not in any way
modify or retreat from its historic commitment to the creeds.
10
THE AMPLEFORTH JOURNAL
atstttrhThntdhahtceCoheruena chonearotfadaeerCa thhabecluemegctcbnsn grhipfnoeeuhlglueeiwt helettrmyc ocleealetcdsstiitele carysnohrF eutfophi she ucarc sioap risevi sgrgepeolinriTrretsehsdehtsttfnnvoiencee ierefehetserea n r Ahc h ceidnateo detalunogw :eakrtaotaiifs i esl d sfsahrseimifn feneroelnlf.lta s rcveels f s yds jih etaarv drnmealtfskiofTi hte e aooa ,l lerrfwtenschn o eh eynliCt-toal mtiihya yots cohgergrrsat whbra h,ctt yatt hs emihu m ncvth auy bsilohorenial istyhetgynuhtteonditet esyaameunghagua hyhm oreaeo d n ra agnf evneeee tlp eNrfa .t icstiralrdaitexpdRh eeirtndnhyl epoohaiwlnlhetea adel pliilm d b i laei eapncy'wsnaegJa ytfbrqveoshrfh aatahntetieserty lge onee ep uini oselsivrilto. endsTc p sGdi rsno y s heoiasrrcirtou ahmtsaCc atp nif, ey ggeetuhwrohoofitac cs tt a seotsgoo hs a hhonbpmi drb nhltabiNt atpmocws trmnol itsieeahrta rno ouydnhcstrfemooeb ilu totiemhyt iee tcpam tin d co moedabg evaa o staxtdietleCloto w le hhtuflh dnyheitemisniihCwanp etfksvhtneeceshcr aed ymt te mli oemis boytfhhaohGct- yse r nwtiys offrlaCbs ai saVebmor dhnnewciv goot oiso ioselamvtomoaasn etgmtratsa irfere y drteoCiaretilrnn mutt m'nlhgnnisw iaaceptsg x i'ueqfutctdseth.na tgeo tnkrxfetir sdt cueuhhh lone iiunm.o cofwrp rsepvsh cnr eoleefR oeyo saar vtnae,mreoh SsGh . c .f db rlfsBeieori c s.tatww aloriamonohSs s Oeiirasoa ctaopmtidSoefr iru;mh tlshttorluhGd aaot lmaai onsiiointiuetietCe ur cto tntwhns.cne h chot pydt ciuf haamlh n yt hgtahwvhaw Te dahhi sth dne csaetogsm e l eyr tlpo a h hwetr'uehda,ib iifyriie ,hC hmna efEoes itt a apsenge so oe coapwseostdyhynh rftttuua g irhuamiaf sooihehep a o absrdnhrc crte trfntt s rievnla fihtn ee o hciuhteethsJse.ti a dfargherot G nestseetm Clm tei aa sdais , lhian teps sdovi pci or ao tnhetf Cotrc tu tbeieii rehornrfot hdnt srstrwsntomos aaaooih hheenotircsc c tsgn,emperscc erd,yot ip aeur sreeirvio hwtnswrhlyhideu riannirwianrmeetebitd edrd iae aecilc th odss dGan xemf ooahensispt,hteisoluoy bnrsgd aoh btie rna eodrl'etolvmm h oolams nverledthdgdJtdi a aestyo ,bnritsefte ioe, et t tssmtp ds swwes edllh hb s lt n;s ieebrctloii ehr tudw yeikeeatenhiemeth lw iytob crtr see mevrvp t,slehmsoeaa oofatu o.eapcoe p eilo ir erdtnurt.ose ttttraeupoiriTotlt lic moui hcie n,shddgeureuvlrvrlRtr doth tnhdlraoee,oeimmh rhtecetspey vimoua ti hfaaysife fe hdaph traieannn psoCfnteateyhniym an svhtaaio nn ylactufi iicdiaeruhttdaseenmee n otnled inyhniuansihcnirnttltdrs d n to s.es lad hirlo h -teh tdo i sitstwsyoki etinu ewt c• se e. iagsi ns r (("aCooowaaddwfttttah—emtRRRPtCDiaoeoahhfdvnbfunieeorhheehe lffim odii.oratadaaodk."tnCifgli sprpoas Pdhaccfpr-iEnsC iti spieoocmceptsdshehin hyTuB .td al.otrhanphutMsrsiloo aerg vs.hi,tohltnuesNnt"oeilerr af i irn,e s teoainnatet ng cdp sd.niawPsts idtaf n Wsre roi og ini o sJ to wia lrfaiti tisCeaiNtnho o l ensioWettrhta d wnucnihaahrt i onabthotsgfesnewhttaaoae sht dae ?ep siwaoimh r lB eldrRmwoulstiriei tsl"mlaleueepenm, tn rhisiyonm)ber ol,hhfl sgt airpo va Tg e )d ueiftttls,omoifbdpatiiA,woshsrti ste n seeraos eelcso ir a abiok"rne "elas scansvliwtd lors.rovsetaisdt i nia—ntt tb—iegaifen hho ow enahth aciT , tuhsmnl C iitanm CsenmorgeaaifagnnosaDehnor cds r a ril .aaan na Cre"iof giear t pdsoimntnocbdip tsftoddo tvmn nIhrnhhhlhuloto hfairvon ay roie htenit.orlteeett nnm atw eeace le ahmuhi, wifsrgrnloni A seTC nsvin ciirie eatunpoAp dstin thchscbyiPkti th sidish psoaRtucuhsh,eainnuea r sPea.e hicuprtpa er listMeraontceaentlbeoRe h l heaeposrfm hilfnoeopat adrdtlndoce ,n Oar— fesioy.dmnu tr soreac icha h natiodsaCeAoA nstertldr ttsnaian. iphs.so di i ttptdd Cltn a altavsvglo o yehhre a,l TW hclhskm na noHheaejotnen, c ouo uyihd iwh ssysn fidfarhEslscsuenbmsma sheeewaspi iaug t i eoa Sigstscr moaetvnhutglrrcnnlnu tl,peuiseo a hhpereylo eeh cndhieceadroselmTlc fsocstl q ruodeeiedgeal gtyoee ogebi Opfeosfuhratddn ntn rpre rne fruy.e ,eern m gaeifee gC l gcos tum , rtaBlioodnHold nte aeod (otcanepmeaawkgtriooefEGa .srcfetewomee s,e n nhi syn.n tt"ebnieLasoc mv t " . ttdetaeteeo n ecevelo—FI tsebhfhehWThsdEm wrad af rnnmraetvere nea aoeoii or.bh tFnmbdtcwe tcbrs sn sd. haf usmhsml lie I er iuoer HePelCi i yteueqdftnyei fvll foiceord sa ft[ sr vtr ri ,iu.hybeCffsaeissrayw si oe o psh ecB Lne aareef.relcnt oamthnor os oiioeitrsl sgcshbuaiissc"udt hfjcpf rilunb usthii e otmmesv Ehidwriar]ept.nieltlsrnpns tis iu"ie a t e v nrsaqdttipoel.e oi o'rs nwrn,iit etaW nvel "todu l,enfhcaonhwtwH dh dv htAntir).dei n emteetoeh t taeist ?iaiehfe thshuoyo wtrttHtlfrmeosh t ria eteehoil aeeceb , nli di reo:ceo r pos a tond P e e ersceshkta ndcwwComngetsnl,uhciudl tLtncenohe ,eotsis ihudce ssseri yeoia toccaoonienmns e eoleato h tvd vasvhoapel awasilitoyea lrvnatgyalofeereedsef aorid ur eliontr nims" rrrmnnanpsgaeeb Hsaoaor a,aKr.eye rtepg qd, "is utomintitiene d"doca oo n tleeutchegTwtten lilgoi tfunt tpb og .ieeeecwnh h bbhchc nhoeiso1otllslsafoiringeyyaeeeeee'eeytr-o"t-sf1r,r.lf
wsbf'cofsrcupaoceDaoioefeoRopsno hnn luiwmcvetohcurgdes adetonaoonhctshrhp ilrahnssinlpitw ttiaootmieb ereeossOo gonrr oinelut,, lnP ntsie erpfagogn tpdiuie t rnysogstbeeeoaapoeociy t i y de uoc(xam fltnhm at1eglie'tt.tnlp hiotouon"h m9osrs aisletnn n iasodo 6rayh jpslOoeg leof u nr7e ael .sswn rsfidy pan)a nt itu t tagmyrW hot .aw tahar inktoieiwinm—oronrgcpni.ii i yyetnn nlhbdhntothieEme fh gss gei or ersk c eeant tpo ttr esiwhwoiaioah caotmsosnat C.fn henah ie sn pdatic th yecoiathtFR. tob.alt hnie ht mteiisodslsaO noeo. eeea im etrmnm tn mMr h sretti'td Isuh ohkEiiomeinnaa net csneiee mtaodglnghkssshes xlstai tilai ihed i.ahnoaitnsoaro"i edeilnn aenngeCnfpy nerOt ucea'q: tw ts h orde o shhuFbe a"eorot, vtcaeimfvvS li naof c eis shto iChcioigr kheoCtr ntaeiiricet ilrhehudta oie tcyh ogos rhs'irnhdeuc, r menmnile wonissasiaysgls tffw sttmny a s it oo itfto ftiau n hnrahrrduaobetfarn w.o ia dnnsoro fredhw n ua r trcsPobxDeii ai pacottshkertan'rwilteoetaop asolmihooeb tynctf rsnonarru aeon T patiilfth,igrbsliscev l lhnogaies atheeanatitehfnito h es.hle,r coett tcrlineerxaeMsdh by o heer n k;t(rMeiu nPeda rr1efaeeymete stfat l9 uswekeuaaaimogwlii e7 ctts'ut innns etr nt u4reohargwddrwaaniaelg)isdsittloebet tc h.vehiisciyr i relet:tdeeoseneece hsyosF s:nsnyft niof pt. .Woeom ah a tu"uasChw nOorIbicNsgmt timseeedhl lomdftea ieero oser awsops edstciiertnrht hs onh.a ,oiire nrs o itvcl troeumnileHooheentoaaedylfh t tei l fd is n a s a is sl swttFhWhNLhhhwaaaooieeiovawttttubhfpvnvuooh ierafneeaneopeeurhtr a rc Tld wtt?ndedyhGtitci ctnhhc he nihe .ahhooaoo aooh"Wef reem Gaimgf;tr n dmmind i Tpestadas m'ohrgeh sN p ii aheniects a nn eaisahenaaepeaodnatt eslnnw ldteoesd lenem t lh syp ra os lu vh daHueea a ornbmmsiiwTdr t l,nrpstii sroeo iaeiino eueoeidpbaafnl wub nvtnslafsnuynuo d oelnetg et oaliiytir.ae nfmrdtrncd sc"rtC tomeyewi kagpe c siedcn ehdhtn;n eemhtpesaoen thu oipa s tnaashdrmdi.hetcrecattgcrt nei.coe osgee Hos re;oenshd r n ieIbi fiaoss2lbsPfw o o g jeorie wwo0ottefnoalhtwhhh r afy0ditu antat toneeetle 0hs hslleih t Cletr o ,v eeaeeowaes rdfdivye dmhc e so rnos eiJowe t lmt rtr t eioe uhfaiwihbccawnh nnssvsira; oeyJt ontius to ahleoodit u t l ieshtanIotemhen shrol hnn ftrtdeit elefn o hnerdecei scc tvyk at o nl holoaNhfhMteeh eiRvrtienhnvraaers pag eedmetseieosarm t wvhurteBp?de hrtto,ni tsstae h m ona iphv o IwsTr Cboeritgniaeegithes tlnnrees h srw e aura?a m esscsi r tncpmttt byt vtiaio wht1soaaasoTewe itameete0nndmhn do fihilaanm y.e naeare f 3aPyneogft,nt n eb er t4ern yohmacti dyeaowsil:ottu teeniy sst yn,he s" i laa pah ol t itietbDqp rgshteinsnhfhln"thsreu r,eec eg eooni dowetn otatn cawh ehso e pdfldEgnlhg ew ifolw,atoa nfso e paa ossinuept-ceortpiliie cho nflne sgnoaereb aeotet .dseradhnwatl tnusutttehesircceishh tdohn srnsieteJ dwei n aana:odkus?,ot, ag inno dfctBnJmtospT tvbtdh oareh wfd fiei uy liraawbi seal sasut httlunDewlthmt hcsa—teeahc ysoeeeare?.rtI,-'e
12
THE AMPLEFORTH JOURNAL
CcmaaudocoriftohnhCsblofeoohhefrgl"a pr celaecewrvneeaofitehirperio misore tieccienerv arpBetoarnrsntrltlti oeird tiepahiniag entetdvilvgc" itnso hcnaycef nodhel eiBbsoqu nny ai of iseioermttaereu sass tu nsyherdfbcc sa uefe uaie , tl enbo ne.eacre vsitr,atw i lyolku rsu ovhrcIeitsycliot, esfatehiiresnruo y va t cfl n leaneCl htn tJa rrinsoyshy c ih rsn u ht iotnhssCtoteeh setlihiaduehowwsregnfa tu iea g ieareconnp tefrCsroyhiato e ossirotsao tdaoa mey h i ,reoctrfpg ea aoilrcfteiarl ,w afnoehgfonhln itieu p noi ewhs osCoerbhgdainrehVt brtt fe oser i ynel h aesAasa ics sbb isdeo mcg nrcreelyeoncworil .a.a mtahnos omDenoi l ootcnlittostTmtmthvrNltooykooeie.nhphenna ehe m,:rnt eeadNo ae g g nhr rrofwntanmtp trst eeohoeo hlCfh tniotrBirnhg urhco r be.coe dnoh eo"itkoeagenan tutscp f: rxs iu n nln hsp thorieiciBas h ,engtsddi e lu itrtdwtteau ashvtn ocheeht moiauepthti ttRiira sc e nh htrtotwssoe mculhhb itlaegefetoe ahyldhl ieha b o tp.faeetot eee C l ewehbhCge nruafrnarWiridieiooreih nynshvsrds.e ss air ur tecealtr,rsertirewiAibn"srisiiensepesocenstrt, y d colthtoit hus-rthatg d inha itdsmiths tainslhasco lkgei asteeanlo aonhdeloem i nanetRasi anf nd ff stdsoisangc rnhpdwysente,oa tamNoa , c ie p'dtdf ehbmslsbittoaoimlooi thine stisfenucnehnopch ttr reesdotxhhoitghettaHrlitynr m hes my fc se tcio tc ti ca eeCnl.sh oavohao ub;errrm df tatehnearnvunnsntioareeeostrrvireta a setrn tvesei i ue rlaoetraIn ysgPdhdisv hg drrfdrsct uyo'i e edryee pid tsehiaoater .vi lsi se Uhis"ynceasvsnsftc iarr, he lerpgtnw fea n sslJacluTor seo.rordtsiiiunsiooo phusotesvhemng,tdeaTmrntt eaelase,egssusdto af shrc drtei s: ie aegsows,ou e fdtol W"i' tt fithroonym.htehoiia cT ho ysofent sonrafaei amha- h l,sn gwlltt ener l loe sye - , aCCowaabpiimthmmolnsuerihhhtoos eosdwil tecpprituonos rtaircrooile eiisgtr fcpsinshStdWrmed ccfcPithhurias seecriliehceoreuaoithtepla hmd toofi'snuscsoslJtaevca - ctht—eco eitordqeltcee u tcdaie esstyno upi.sninu tui idsd tst nt aomaTroc obpa sir i strnfemtttrsy .eihnro l ato ere osyoynC Juttewoti tqdteio,onui v dol ssn houl aoni tdet, iifCgtrblhni o nw nr-rtoaloirfi eecrh se ersgeooi fiaaia yvdostrgrt is srutinhpta ncimi,en i hasrs sdeala sot rfes bnle tlxe f n iiss omityle idocntmntaauietcwtiwo yguaeerntymrmledat fmoloiendso ah, yloby- s.nipl toeirpnAa sto ne.hsoeldldm brornEdPdi gpsesam et eTb , yPs,lifttents a tsrhr ooeoehh,tRwneoor ciee hl enrrtmeearftdeaOhwln niue ev ig ittnxcao-gts Ah aahaicaonCay apwiniht lCttethrrto a,t rgieht hadeeter eoHaedotnidheeaIsvgraesurlfn eE.i ie l c eieods erase epopnmIS Trhererxt nnhf tetriei .a theshhoaateogoi"nTb res,asradansns fu'be cOexc t c v. tbe,o aoellaysio p r yoes u a rbHhofoiBeaot eo ifi sltolnetrscno vcswEt kiy oir ahd wtutodrae tLb ehfoopne ehgnttn Ih e ftrerihprcEregsichsoolfoeiur letode saoeFewenrlntc,nk rw uy os r — e vHaniectbraotm, esnee yeoa otenunnsiwrdhdilt ti nrn tfteodiilhn e h, guvhcidc fo eagm itca oalietueanCfhrt oshhast npeaneu -a aons etnhBtstn tnds—yectr,h shnuia t d pnohi ud aeonrlp"ioIrf tmopidetc tos getIipb flr r rdnhtlf cra eeewem oaamc w theirnlramu cswtuilihsisuahhtareyngtis ori liss thk oat cishr,siamrt ao aetevhtes eoatst Cipnuten eodr veltI ha peswy auc at iere w tm en dwarottb oqhhrpthixo nibpehh fouiiahpotota n ne oeinteetteialcobn ehd1ihoksnnsiarrthioencen3ese-ets:ttltt
swmCttaotwahchtoiacfhhosueeTfa rsrpnre J ncin haCWitee i hPtsi msemauscn htaru enu trtso gerico styusdtipbah nc ac sa, groaa ecetttiretaaeiibaftd seeaost sLlstle ases n nhyt nioaofchrosi eoolrnmtmhfemioodrytr s,i ffeC e nmaGsot atasChtgt Jhhrihs nroeeem,hrr ea ads spiorsadpfsnieu riusimntoesstdesreighs ltdw as pd itthe.en ao h Poe, tnn dnilCd u.ritadoti itcty emsnthh att.byc.dt u denr hyaio iI rTp tis anci ne asnlpthbot it lei ttrhleeahwms httaol anhh,itireh psmhpne eeit ihavehesw wcuSu neuetrohaehnsic ncyiu ynmosetiycinahgt nm qne yooprihiaiaussem fnp.h ns rl e egt a alidp ioIivnd asctafnr hoehfeiet est stGnwu ateahsr eri smnaroisao atsti c hwcm osrotsaiothlept nnoinnyionnbavev sm is n leeottebCsttyit nfe hny thas h.wutepe e o elhrtsom Hrpsa miiissovsiossnru iem em toenrgoa oip adta ip .f fihesc mnu npr rlitJe. aceenrhh aesi tn lguedms.s siat t oimuae naeocaf vsidrrn earp niiany n nosh otoR iitu uasnnfrfqserdraa eg iuespc lbtr u aetodaflfolrteerwotiihrorh ngten oeibmuteceiershynrr-s e -e (saaaobittuWrrn'areetfdnnninaa nglleeddiaeikitliscug gqln.e tn hl eiiiippmus rt,ooaoH teiy uraovnhswneaan becfte i,ltnc iryie lnl' hninitetytta ncighteo,og g nci l esa'f n iy'e s kcs;" tboa)a p hCle.btsop neol eiaealFdfuhrrryuuapt nioiortu cctst t olcbw huir.iahaimnta'oancebl niih nbnn ho tg amgp fdl gBn'utsyaer(t ei ihowain nitasotdatgefrehhdf pies u e trfoh wo shCa utttfpsaaph hhlaoloi sss hoer'artMm .oc ha stn ataou ohTpemt Uostmri siphlh nccopiaepwlesept ef,r iaes t efrgtea Crnifhere dureoaicair eaholn dnsa tiymttursihha inio se tvrcaehe s im cegkGoddrowsahl en inasmsyoetas to i— ha trdnjeahioiweasunn,t nanw naedl canvdm eeim ghtnnoet difxehiav ottspcgpaidn hee chnhde ry e i uce,sdatesta sslsthuvsr)pnneei se itaeraaleadisutffflntteorc e a o tt igde ireucbpsntoet h n teyne whnnatett,td ioe hhtci q hk eao heeaeoaueem'tnsa v nrt een Rs eRotept.ltor hor ieneatieeeane Bn rp gtps'g tv e gyo hatoleo"'ex ehtrri frashatvsptde taht • tete'ee eoms h ecld ddr t nn recihoe oo uet o liafephpniotnent msh t oeglutcrhh eetniu cdepehast rietg'u oa emi anhnonhoiarrstgenf--t-f-ltt'
mind, the desire for epschailpoes ofrpohmy oFfa tteh,e tthiem dee. sIitr es aftoisrf sieedc utrhiety i wninqh uitchihrei nugn ittuedrn the faithful are not yet ready for such explorations. This may have been a prudent
efuliaineksdleyi k;Sa eiltts o Somict osiaosidcmceiis a•m uli nt n cgietoa edmvdiesdp a rat onhwmdias iy sif tioo nfsrg e lt cihdfueeer maeingdadn nmo dmresa annod tnae ag msa iawnnes ltal ta sh ofomre t hine tlhetet eurneidvh.e eIrrtse esa,a ftbtieusor-t;f • aodmnec aoistnTtigeohn netd,h iaebnc ugtrtui spatirhlne egec x issgipegeelnnyrise et roanar ctteieho etnohsf.ea ttmh tahatet t wefruhsit,cu shrie ni scw ebe etlhllibeeeyvi enadrg e i ost fh wethh ceah t iCechfo uncrosctnhict uewtrenils l otdfh eemp eoannndye
ecqounatilnlyu eu tnoc olimvep irno mthies ibnrgo tahsesruhroaondc•e b.' ut to thtohsoes ew whlooh node iwldino neuosldst . feaIntislt e iwrt aaoynff dew rwaesdo unalondt osaf ti'csfoyminmg i'temviednetn' cteo' othf er eilnigeifofuabs lter uctahl.m Hneerses woef mceorvtae infrtoym. Ma yvsotliucinstmar,i sat na tutintfuodre-
'bho tCheochA ewchr u.o DiCptsnIh.tyht eiNe iaus wnonCtrgclic ylkh shlt. c u eh'Cdshrxe oocoa dnhfulmoova bercriitsrsentls refeictiorosdonons me,nd a .bOter e eefoxM i t ffnaoot ehierngndae oea nf atotfnwhthu rdetemhnh rrided el teaetdCoh mf lieapirtrnere rteslndeynihpt g daoiyaiotlouesrn u qeal tdPsr urars aeed bdcssoiessotir. itc moin1suon9oospn3s sta3ae ibor.old efa pn pfbpt toohilh.rs eseae2 is R t1top ia0oemltsa-hpn 2cee ogs1et.ir 1 b fsstoW.t uum eofbb d nghCj. eatohacth tr thegin ssearetotrleiara udettnhpseai a dttoyonoyff eaadetpp2 unwnruoeenIccrTicab neheahtyeissettedav.ee d p.iEaed ,nA,st nrn p ee o sfvd.tr o l ueh mte4oPrrites1 myf:r,s i. oR n "o ssefa eIinilenmptnlelishgycps siiites oolrsh al on raeiear t,pvn SpeHfecrdoptxiloaa arrprinaamtocnlenltooae s.ourcx iw natnaFhpet h ro risBheioet rcr hiisa nsfhnensco ei oorumab deftJnu l icoaemvdotevn;hin na syytewnlithsy v notemrh evito dci iackiccuiohnrsna gd .dm oetth-1eshcwh,9o g uee7e huo mm1faimtr,osd ieoprtheyeno t.sis cidirs2 otcei toi3cnoacarf8atlars n.a yl tld eihci ans anlenmas nc tidtvdomi h maa uta aenrntutilx dohltlm te auauoirtstryvasi rns letar cthrgeait aciel ptoinsahigprtn leiu rbao eeodwelnxxaiy stppoc cy erehhof,lrra eadniiils-s-,s-l
14
THE AMPLEFORTH JOURNAL APPROACHES TO BELIEF 15
fmarnoadmin t lhytha cet o msntcauendryyn meodfy swtteiixcthtss a saroenm dce ahtrheiislnetogssr qyau.b"iot' eu td liaffnegruenagt efr. oWm hwatheavteerv eitr icsa, nm byes tliecaisrmne dis whatT Ion dsitarinkse c aa lml soarnea ptaonsiat idveh anromtea:, l'eett eursn caol nrseildigerio Jne's. uIst mhiamys eblef siung tghees tleidg htth oaft
CrehliugricPohrno ,t fowe sinsthoo rnp-SaCrthatiarcilus tlciaaornm rermefeleirrngeeit nosc neisn :t sot rwuhcavte hlyas ohni thehreton obmeeenn tohloeia ctatilt usdtued oiefst hoef nshueem tei'mx (e'anmroipst elitdfhi ieisnd, tnihnoe t hStihas anots'wk).rn i Ht pfaeodrrs mhoenu lbatehsee n' t tawptr otoe cadlmeaei mpaesinsit'g ( t'iTena hcIanhtdi naiagr,ts iTnohfs toetuha'ed) aoVnf edJd ua'ndneettaat. ,,
akcnaotoeadCrghcwitolcentwehnseoahhIcltldmennaivcthheaurg w . teaeieedt rif isa rrrcnsrhgoeot.tegansoh s i aeenndilaa aininrt .slat sitonu etyl .pnole eFy fC,iwr s a l tC ceB iosyggIhttrato Cenh htshue,oswren hwtdetih rtada r tsa dhi irCehtns.ntwbvaiii pixtes csdneehWadiohrcthtia yn r eiisseo tnrtifaohi:,ihnhiisevf ttnnsteieyt ilaefte i iinoidyitrt ntrttagirsh ea n hy,esns i ihnnai d e ottteissa otidth nws w,s stbtm s tat,w h hdoh eeaaiasareesfairsnsoas enls or tt tliscumvnhce ,deac r eioo lego gp imnyoe wsarvthteor xbccs nhnaedetilfevoaeaot eodriclohdrenvcmt ytrgo uhwn :hra ets i rbpiapnaamerusfndhnaeiettldutipncieee osledo nn oerttm,dew e p rhegdarntad lifl iha.en gsael e io yhsergnaomsdt tAr i hwe hatodd ntC telacanhd thogostnlwehhttd aroet i xtrtahiwts rkho atei tertthelwonsnlhushaame,,rat o loa toch issyvaeaawtcl cut seoe nse ynahehnfCl aawrd pifea g aeivtcaeh dvasyhrowsielqrtrcttaegst ahds siiuhai croect;s estwet ob at, yt m,hn ewcii o ilba saea niroiafaessh haintst tgm shn meaaCrtintfwdatg tnkvnioooyiohbicw ueiazcsoun snrlst eseecpih,htnig d sss oasoadaa mih ;tcwnvtWast rtt ie e h ees ea aiiwswnfetnrg tnaeiih eecsnt fnaotsiaa rdas.o ottstsdsa geyitae tu ti tulhT;ssaridh. dt n n 'anrehii ehbeiiadensies na reud n - d t t sac(tGdittnhmbUmhnhhaeuniioivo eessepbuepldtr ti i denlcaleay gknSIiidht'ntfcrfn.Ih eiheie ( enfaaio Tltct eJsrswfAl.dthwneoah oeh IFane(olnerhao.ntiaAtd'nc r asgdfn s tnik e ,ttaHlussht Gc ghhi, m1 ,tI rtciot e ueieomop.nhahout1ra rad h enNeata l2nnogn-ah de vye)fe).ceoir se e " qwsto wehhncaC 'hsuf nr ah oani eWaoTahuissvtsotdlvmion rc nefe slbp iaid- iesa yestitotmleebehtl"rhtdheaaiu re,f uaen eta tme(fsreatir n ntrJetnahnncg (ohoedigoteete terfmenahhfoeaus oenn dqtstrnre nts ut t sd huh rw tt idtntthiva1 neehitohnetrdsoloe0st eooire g' e t iTt.sm diodhp3 erratGtohpefi) hreo0otets n sctraaoeo)otsoobe eae rsth d fedlmseh ltenah aalahle eiirgsBt atavnrspdcesiieaevstae og,ouat w he il Tno,ndhdtnpit e hhotf obd,ih doyta e est ebh sJ'ohihr prbfeaneyeteieuepiurernyns t sr o uo'n fuw s G F Cmaoodocmeid sonhbfmhorou .t'a e "eahtueordncmteiin. dithrenuehfgw dshtlerr ee tthhei eoa ph ig nat mharCt iono Ghton sdnimahstJheam t e oseleantatt( disishvhtn,Bwbn Hs hup e'eemwlfdbtreoseei a oaoyne,olfr eeec h d odgdlanast"fbbosmuioyiustrttyesn g le,nhra rt cy tdayidnit edhetoa nhn U hotc e t1nmdice)leohc' ap9ns iot c tiateliww 3aerlcutlso t'i"il0tnt) sel,onnmeior tsooi,r roi eii s fefnanndmdff n hb rx essijynoatttetfua hhhhf" ooodmottsieea1eieeffft-t:'
GrakCgeotmdufrrhrGtsiotuEborlpHofefoiiehanetou syafeearroniaamttei vbwihmtn n enhevlnAug ntiyayaaiItnhitteopde etltdd . a t nsna ayigma ems ynar,gt Hnuilws t " sahe,nirr n :ehmct ireWii-oa cuetihef sigmgtn oB rnrpottowi otsItiuhgs iuuerEhsidnutreounewvercst esisi toau nffadbdo neln hC ;irnn lrf tbr s o ldn btgeua .er,oHeihisthneR °ns ahot sn eloefl yre aafaeaiihnae rinihddmisnrgas gs trtasrles'oa ce u esycistv etatbcdemtgl msleiitrior hsmatprmtowaeo ocia,ei rimhrioe enanuaontpr,asohdhiitdnid dtgn ln l smtdh.sa e tlm acii IdedoetteiasEroMott th hootdgeoo ieetfnfsiaetuofuaon eUui oxafoap vtsnhrtrne p ronchcnrlo eerntceusdra k lefeasiee.dcnekh iwuno s s t,vrts tad i uttesAm fiobinhtitrohhevww oip nrtc a av ernfthaaeeiwbnthR ahsrc rie cuo anrntydtet;iitakelh tsethhttr fin yloithry tegoo Ioleaynoheided ei tce so mr nng o huhgensoa ttoiCGbne,firhs aret t ft puo r i heoCavt eo ttond'hekfnrnhnhOhhne lesardioeiansvsdeerae it m psix p osseiotnmepl it amceaioct fun ctimdwnaootnoolhlorot saorias r hirirueeerdsialimcpyfl.tnneindlde dlt orroc uc yvt.Rugtats pemW r" aanhoobise mens aore mnlniivtW sawol,oi etncfepa'ie,yvefth, n ba scinca b eawter epott ddah ltem twnecihrssuehwrh fswele srtctoermoianeo tyi nmsae tohhcetcftgi ymrb',lr r v mh loalk e nTeiyait lcastiel ts oosah n hn t tlh enh r loenfmiylhatatea easnols gahhf y,t ahrlet t W auatr u eca ae osEi pihccabitngosloa t t trhoar elct aeS l hfgSu yooaImene n ttsmstutenra odkefdfdr t t ss aef hreehaidr beeiie toienvrysgs rrhaie eaeniqoe fsnc nne ahs a pepo 1 fgu,bSoppece hntt r fep9ae heulrrdaihtttt i rtat3er inshe mllerC oa snoTasel cn9-scam i iklaft dec Beneufh.s etao at ieudt id e,CRel oNrd hnut r itmnuia n iismetu hnaa ratonoRondc tloeuror vdnsy ithna aiaeiesl eneottdanhedsetassi- ha nsrdug-leogatas,, t -ile srea-n sn a nns -ar d ds - socs(TrG'wmttmaunbodtMmehheDeehlfnfeeuaane ooln ieceeeastadlicgenktalwrdomcarng's;hhtsiu lrdreee nn, tigkdTe aleeoaW ot on rysdaeht)eeani yonfehgna o n: o rn ndrtcsfdan aie nirao ge utt eb todsne lho oh hCedaonnieoinp rovm ase uzg lseng beotfmaha oeu rah tniorfdepmssBr—rrevncrrn tueeideyiahte iaifaeo smudhrssynola'tesonas mrtur.teadtlef knrtshen hrrgi6e'so'llersAdiflee. eye estot. oo abnro tahsd 4hmst t oofrrnecrahpsp Gtif ; l fa htse(a iene'wye oofc wlriLMntod aetagsyid,osmns eti bsycisdeseowi totm ds ata esehave epl,thim tiogrm euh r mon riiptnoasrarktunsehatmrn ueaietgtrethstoo l gctereea satqth1dnai eopiuuau uuas. lonpu n2eefmA ittsningciah nthdis poiL.is ynrtto3lthnro1ns:e'h nei e ie o, tn0gl 9goi(ybtt bldi htdmd cmooi)nsl .hn Gepy gf1a i;aetb georc,ot e ohaoimtt8unoa trahyoaf hrnnhsetki)nos dtt ano nheniet ;iidaeisfw t-as fot i te g uithdt od uinas lRdtnoh rpeec nla f haeislteui bv rnoe raseutrc)s deJse,eissy eemt'u,pmp oiteom. i i esnt o Bcgwtotoenhst iuWnotyo oh oaauulhroonsdtupht tl thtetnsan iw ii.itol,iihdepJoen b theoy codasmewi aeodnwnbgsevhe,oRonensvt sheta noe u nutr h,d eieofri ph last.rltssdaioo r Ga bfhntitre.c hw o lioiou Aolomreayh psiToidivennotoiilrtmst talsdtnlaieyae hw fds dtehufp iy r tlags.p,teof n hsie tw phpfp kesizb fotLiihrhoentefi sr rotoeaeirnhsaoa o eore t a(insn stc uhemvlvericnnpiftr hlcssnoioso soeeiu frgtt,esoer,acin o t n ee us osnb ,.hifnlulwrc - d mnd tlof ueooen Ciitlh we tedgnnrrhdefd fJttehere a hnhh ht rniiu oiniaBieectttlaibntrgiee rhdee nsnningh itne gui hfpss rhr aessr Why atmm idttbutio eian'etiaee sngsthd nota ritodehrstr sfhmhtnodehnecuen mi sht eet ottrro eoai tret. ea sesit ofJif dh rnaiinhttl n t mNlufgtna l h(peoaianste ,oytvtgdnhdec owen r modh l d.siieaiibarirrpow n so avmooa3exel eiojo tagriunstrinuusni1io hnko udraeystmlstislyaa)nhkee----s--rls..,..
68. RSFteraintaesl ,SC Otuapea.nl ,oc Enitx,. .pI nplotprro.in d9gu9 cM-t1iyo0sn0ti c.t ois mth,e PSetnugduyi no fB Tohoek sH, i1n9d7u5 ,D po.c t7r9in. es, Luzac 1945, pp. 11-12. 9 SSBee.eeH mm. Syyt rCTehoeetne tEre,mn Tdph loae tfBi vRueed Cldighhiaori nsa,t inapdnp it.th y1e, 1 MC0h-o1rwi1sbt1r, a.M ysa. c1m97il5la. np,p 1. 96362,- 6p7. .2 16.