Table Of Content

LEADING ARTICLES—AUTHOR INDEX ALEINIKOFF, T. ALEXANDER & SHAW, THEODORE M.:: The Costs of Incoherence: A Comment on Plain Meaning, West Virginia University Hospitals, Inc. v. Casey, and Due Process of Statutory Interpretation. CoENEN, Dan T:: Priorities In Accounts: The Crazy Quilt of Current Law and a | Proposal for Reform DREYFUSS, RocHELLE Coorer & Nevkin, Dorotuy: The Jurisprudence of Genetics EskRIDGE, WILLIAM N., Jr. & Frickey, Puivip P.: Quasi-Constitutional Law: Clear Statement Rules as Constitutional Lawmaking . Evans, Tuomas L.: The Taxation of Nonshareholder Contributions to Capital: An ‘Eco- nomic Analysis FarBER, DaniEL A: The Inevitability of Practical Reason: Statutes, Formalism, and the Rule of Law FRIEDMAN, Barry: Habeas ond Hubris GABALDON, THERESA A.: The Lemonade Stand: Feminist aul Other Reflections on ‘the Lie ited Liability of Corporate Shareholders HuGues, GRAHAM: Agreements for Cooperation in Criminal Cases Jones, D. Marvin: The Death of the Employer: Image, Text, and Title VII Kanovitz, JACQUELINE: Hypnotic Memories and Civil Sexual Abuse Trials KEATING, DANIEL: Offensive Uses of the Bankruptcy Stay KreEnT, Harotp J.: Reconceptualizing Sovereign Immunity Macey, JONATHAN R. & Miter, Georrrey P.: The Canons of Statutory Construction and Judicial Preference . MARSHALL, LAWRENCE C.: The Canons of‘ Statutory Construction and Judicial Constreints: A Response to Macey and Miller MITCHELL, LAWRENCE E:: A Critical Look at Corporate Governance Rasmussen, Rosert K:: Coalition Formation and the Presumption of Reviewability: A Re- sponse to Rodriguez Ropricuez, DaniEt B.: The Presumption of Reviewability: A Study in Canonical Construc- tion and Its Consequences Ross, STEPHEN F.: Where Have You Gone, Karl L: ‘ewellyn? Should Congress Turn Its Lonely Eyes to You? Rustin, Epwarp L.: Modern Statutes, Loose Canons, and the Limits of Practical Reason: A Response to Farber and Ross ScHavEr, FREDERICK: The Practice and Problems of Plain Meaning: A Response StTakE, JEFFREY Evans: Mandatory Planning for Divorce Srerk, Stewart E.: Competition Among Municipalities as a Constraint on Land Use Exac- tions LEADING ARTICLES—TITLE INDEX AGREEMENTS FOR COOPERATION IN CRIMINAL Cases: Graham Hughes THE CANONS OF STATUTORY CONSTRUCTION AND JUDICIAL CONSTRAINTS: A Resronss TO Macey AND MILLER: Lawrence C. Marshall THE CANONS OF STATUTORY CONSTRUCTION AND JUDICIAL PREFERENCES: Jonathan R. Macey & Geoffrey P. Miller COALITION FORMATION AND THE PRESUMPTION OF REVIEWABILITY: A Resronse TO Ropaicusz: Robert K. Rasmussen 1691 1692 VANDERBILT LAW REVIEW [Vol. 45:1691 ComPETITION AMONG MUNICIPALITIES AS A CONSTRAINT ON LAND Use Exactions: Stewart E. Sterk 831 Tue Costs oF INCOHERENCE: A COMMENT ON ‘PLAIN MEANING, WEST VIRGINIA UNIVERSITY Hospitats, Inc. v. Casey, AND DuE Process or STaTUTORY INTERPRETATION: 7. Alexander Aleinikoff & Theodore M. Shaw , A Critica Look at CORPORATE Governance: Lawrence E. Mitchell Tue DEATH OF THE EMPLOYER: IMAGE, TEXT, AND TiITLE VII: D. Marvin Jones HaBeas AND Husris: Barry Friedman Hypnotic Memorigs AND Civit SexuaL ABusE TRIALS: Jacqueline Kanovitz Tue INEVITABILITY OF PRACTICAL REASON: STATUTES, FORMALISM, AND THE RULE OF Law: Daniel A. Farber THE JURISPRUDENCE OF GENETICS: Rochelle Cooper Dreyfuss & Dorothy Nelkin Tue LEMONADE STAND: FEMINIST AND OTHER REFLECTIONS ON THE LIMITED LIABLITY OF CoR- PORATE SHAREHOLDERS: Theresa A. Gabaldon MANDATORY PLANNING FOR Divorce: Jeffrey Evans Stake MopernN Statutes, Loose CANONS, AND THE Limits OF Practica, Reason: A REsPonse TO FARBER AND Ross: Edward L. Rubin OrrensIve Uses OF THE Bankruptcy Stay: Daniel Keating THE PRACTICE AND PROBLEMS OF PLAIN MEANING: A RESPONSE: Frederick Schauer THE PRESUMPTION OF REvIEWABILITY: A Stupy IN CANONICAL CONSTRUCTION AND ITs CONSE- QUENCES: Daniel B. Rodriguez Priorities IN ACCOUNTS: THE Crazy QuILT oF CURRENT LAW AND A PROPOSAL FOR REFORM: Dan T. Coenen Quasi-ConsTITUTIONAL Law: CLEAR STATEMENT RuLes as CONSTITUTIONAL LAWMAKING: Wil- liam N. Eskridge, Jr. & Philip P. Frickey RECONCEPTUALIZING SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY: Harold J. Krent THE TAXATION OF NONSHAREHOLDER CONTRIBUTIONS TO CaPiTAL: AN ECONOMIC ANALYSIS: Thomas L. Evans Wuere Have You Gong, Kart LLEWELLYN? SHOULD ConGREss TuRN Its LONELY Eyes To You?: Stephen F. Ross SYMPOSIUM A REEVALUATION OF THE CANONS OF STATUTORY INTERPRETATION SPECIAL PROJECT CARING FOR THE NATION—CURRENT IssuEs IN HEALTH CARE REFORM NOTES—AUTHOR INDEX ANILLO, ALvaRo IGnacio: The National Endowment for The Humanities: Control of Fund- ing Versus Academic Freedom Banks, JONATHAN: State Constitutional Analyses of Public School Finance Reform Cases: Myth or Methodology? Bow es, L. ExizaBetu: The Disfranchisement of Fertile Women in Clinical Trials: The Le- gal Ramifications of and Solutions for Rectifying the Knowledge Gap DaneKeER, MicnakL D.: Medicaid, State Cost-Containmeni Measures, and Section 1983 Pro- vider Actions Under Wilder v. Virginia Hospital Association 1992] INDEX FRIEDMAN, MICHAEL CAMERON: Cruel and Unusual Punishment in the Provision of Prison Medical Care: Challenging the Deliberate Indifference Standard . HEIDELBERG, C. Matson: Closing the Book on the School Trust Lands Murpny, SHARON M.: The “Sudden and Accidental” Exception to the Pollution Exclusion Clause in Comprehensive General Liability Insurance Policies: The Gordian Knot of En- vironmental Liability Niccouini, Ropert R.: The Voidability of Actions Taken in Violation of the Automatic Stay: Application of the Information-Forcing Paradigm ; OBERLANDER, MicHaEL IRA: The Payne of Allowing Victim Impact Statements at Capital Sentencing Hearings . RaMAGE, WayNE Epwarp: The Pariah Patient: The Leck of Funding for Mental Health Care Rosinson, Eric LAMOND: The Oregon Basic Health Services Act: A Model for State Reform? VERNIA, BENJAMIN JAMES: The Burden of Proving Competence to Stand Trial: Due Process and the Limits of Adversarial Justice . NOTES—TITLE INDEX THE BuRDEN OF PROVING COMPETENCE TO STAND TRIAL: DUE PROCESS AT THE LIMITS OF AD- VERSARIAL JusTICE: Benjamin James Vernia CLOSING THE Book ON ScHooL Trust Lanps: C. Maison Heidelberg .. CRUEL AND UNUSUAL PUNISHMENT IN THE PROVISION OF PRISON MEDICAL CaRE: CHALLENGING THE DELIBERATE INDIFFERENCE STANDARD: Michael Cameron Friedman THE DISFRANCHISEMENT OF FERTILE WOMEN IN CLINICAL TRIALS: THE LEGAL RAMIFICATIONS OF AND SOLUTIONS FOR RECTIFYING THE KNOWLEDGE Gap: L. Elizabeth Bowles ... MeEpicalp, STaTE Cost-CONTAINMENT MEASURES, AND SECTION 1983 PRovipER ACTIONS UNDER Wicper v. VirGiniA Hospitat AssociATIon: Michael D. Daneker . Tue NATIONAL ENDOWMENT FOR THE HuMANITIES: CONTROL OF FUNDING VERSUS AcaDEMIc FREEDOM: Alvaro Ignacio Anillo THE Orecon Basic HEALTH Services Act: A MODEL FOR STATE REFORM?: Eric Lamond Robinson THE PaRIAH PATIENT: THE Lack OF FUNDING FOR MENTAL HEALTH Care: Wayne ‘Edward THE PAYNE OF ALLOWING ‘Vicrm IMPACT STATEMENTS AT CaPrraL SENTENCING HEARINes: Michael Ira Oberlander : STATE CONSTITUTIONAL ANALYSES OF ‘Pusiic ScHOOL France Rerorm Cases: Myr oR METh- ODOLOGY?: Jonathan Banks .. THE “SUDDEN AND ACCIDENTAL” EXCEPTION TO THE POLLUTION EXcLUSION CLAUSE IN COMPRE- HENSIVE GENERAL LIABILITY INSURANCE PoLiciEs: THE GORDIAN KNOT OF ENVIRONMENTAL LiaBiuity: Sharon M. Murphy THE VoIDABILITY OF ACTIONS TAKEN IN VIOLATION OF THE AUTOMATIC Sray: APPLICATION O¢ F THE INFORMATION-FORCING ParapDIGM: Robert R. Niccolini RECENT DEVELOPMENTS—AUTHOR INDEX Farpon, Zacuary T.: Barnes v. Glen Theatre, Inc.: Nude Dancing and the First Amendment Question MCcALIsTER, KrisTINE N.: Retroactive Application of the Civil Rights Act of 1991. Ricuarpson, Ei J.: Matching Tests for Double Jeopardy Violations with Constitutional Interests .. STEELE, K. Davin: Prospective Overruling and the Judicial Role After James B. Beam Dis- tilling Co. v. Georgia . 1694 VANDERBILT LAW REVIEW [Vol. 45:1691 Wricut, Susan L.: Franklin v. Gwinnett County Public Schools: The Supreme Court Im- plies a Damages Remedy for Title IX Sex Discrimination 1367 RECENT DEVELOPMENTS—TITLE INDEX Barnes v. GLEN THEATRE, INC.. NUDE DANCING AND THE FIRST AMENDMENT QUESTION: Zachary T. Fardon FRANKLIN Vv. GWINNETT CounTy Pusiic SCHOOLS: THE SUPREME CourT IMPLIES A DAMAGES ReMEpyY FoR TitLe [IX Sex DiscriminaTION: Susan L. Wright MatcHING TESTS FOR DouBLE JEOPARDY VIOLATIONS WITH CONSTITUTIONAL INTERESTs: Eli J. Richardson PROSPECTIVE OVERRULING AND THE JUDICIAL RoLeE AFTER JAMES B. Beam DisTILuinG Co. Vv. Georaia: K. David Steele RETROACTIVE APPLICATION OF THE Civit Ricuts Act oF 1991: Kristine N. McAlister BOOK REVIEWS—AUTHOR INDEX L. C. BoLiincer: IMAGES OF A FREE Press (Michael J. Gerhardt) J. W. Exy, Jr. THE GuaRDIAN OF Every OTHER RiGuT: A CoNSTITUTIONAL History OF PRop- ERTY RicHts (Herman Belz) L. A. Powe, Jr: THe FourtH Estate AND THE CONSTITUTION: FREEDOM OF THE PRESS IN America (Michael J. Gerhardt) R. A. SMOLLA: FREE SPEECH IN AN OPEN Society (Michael J. Gerhardt) BOOK REVIEWS—REVIEWER INDEX Beiz, HERMAN: PROPERTY AND LIBERTY RECONSIDERED: THE GUARDIAN OF Every OTHER RIGHT: A ConstTiTuTIONAL History oF Property Ricuts (James W. Ely, Jr.) GERHARDT, MICHAEL J.: LIBERAL VISIONS OF FREEDOM OF THE PREss: IMAGES OF A FREE PRESS (Lee C. Bollinger); THe FourtH Estate AND THE CONSTITUTION: FREEDOM OF THE PRESS IN America (Lucas A. Powe, Jr.); FREE SPEECH IN AN OPEN Society (Rodney A. Smolla) 1025 INDEX DIGEST Page references followed by an asterisk (*) are to Leading Articles and Book Reviews; those — followed by a dagger (+) are to Notes; those accompanied by two daggers (tt) are to Recent Developments or the Special Project. BANKRUPTCY LAW Franklin v. Gwinnett County Offensive Uses of the Bankruptcy Public Schools: The Supreme Stay Court Implies a Damages Rem- The Voidability of Actions Taken edy for Title IX Sex Discrimi- in Violation of the Automatic nation 1367tt Stay: Application of the Infor- Medicaid, State Cost-Contain- mation-Forcing Paradigm ment Measures, and Section CIVIL RIGHTS 1983 Provider Actions Under The Death of the Employer: Im- Wilder v. Virginia Hospital age, Text, and Title VII Association 487+ 1992] INDEX COMMERCIAL LAW CORPORATE LAW Offensive Uses of the Bankruptcy A Critical Look at spaaianaad re Governance . Priorities in Accounts: The Crazy The Lemonade Stand: ‘Feminist Quilt of Current Law and a and Other Reflections on the Proposal for Reform Limited Liability of ae The Voidability of Actions Taken Shareholders in Violation of the Automatic Stay: Application of the Infor- CRIMINAL LAW mation-Forcing Paradigm. . Agreements for Cooperation in Criminal Cases CONSTITUTIONAL LAW The Burden of Proving Compe- Barnes v. Glen Theatre, Inc.: tence to Stand Trial: Due Pro- Nude Dancing and the First cess at the Limits of Adver- Amendment Question sarial Justice The Burden of Proving Compe- Cruel and Unusual Puniiunst tence to Stand Trial: Due Pro- in the Provision of Prison Med- cess at the Limits of Adver- ical Care: Challenging the De- sarial Justice liberate Indifference Standard The Costs of Incoherence: A Comment on Plain Meaning, Matching Tests for Double Jeop- ardy Violations with Constitu- West Virginia University Hos- pitals, Inc. v. Casey, and Due tional Interests Process of Statutory Interpre- The Payne of Alesis Victim tation Impact Statements at Capital Cruel and Unusual Punishment Sentencing Hearings ....... in the Provision of Prison Med- EDUCATION LAW ical Care: Challenging the De- Closing the Book on the School liberate Indifference Standard Trust Lands Habeas and Hubris. Franklin ov. Gwinnett County Liberal Visions of Freedom of the Public Schools: The Supreme Press: Images of a Free Press; Court Implies a Damages Rem- The Fourth Estate and the edy for Title IX Sex Discrimi- Constitution: Freedom of the nation 1367tt Press in America; Free Speech State Constitutional Analyses of in an Open Society (reviewed Public School. Finance Reform by Michael J. Gerhardt). . 1025* Cases: Myth or Methodology? 129t Matching Tests for Double Jeop- ardy Violations with Constitu- EMPLOYMENT LAW tional Interests 273tt Retroactive Application of the The National Endowment for Civil Rights Act of 1991. The Humanities: Control of The Death of the Employer: Im- Funding Versus Academic age, Text, and Title VII.... Freedom 455t The Payne of Allowing Victim ENVIRONMENTAL LAW Impact Statements at Capital The “Sudden and Accidental” Sentencing Hearings 1621+ Exception to the Pollutien Ex- Property and Liberty Reconsid- clusion Clause in Comprehen- ered: The Guardian of Every sive General Liability Insur- Other Right: A Constitutional ance Policies: The Gordian History of Property Rights (re- Knot of Environmental Liabil- viewed by Herman Belz) 1015* ity Quasi-Constitutional Law: Clear FAMILY LAW Statement Rules as Constitu- Mandatory Planning for Divorce tional Lawmaking 593* Reconceptualizing Sovereign Im- FEDERAL COURTS munity . 1529* Habeas and Hubris 1696 VANDERBILT LAW REVIEW [Vol. 45:1691 FEMINISM The Canons of Statutory Con- The Lemonade Stand: Feminist struction and Judicial Prefer- and Other Reflections on the ences Limited Liability of Corporate Coalition Formation and the Pre- Shareholders sumption of Reviewability: A Response to Rodriguez FIRST AMENDMENT The Costs of Incoherence: A Barnes v. Glen Theatre, Inc.: Comment on Plain Meaning, Nude Dancing and the First West Virginia University Hos- Amendment Question pitals, Inc. v. Casey, and Due Liberal Visions of Freedom of the Process of Statutory Interpre- Press: Images of a Free Press; tation The Fourth Estate and the The Inevitability of Practical Constitution: Freedom of the Reason: Statutes, Formalism, Press in America; Free Speech and the Rule of Law in an Open Society (reviewed The Jurisprudence of Genetics by Michael J. Gerhardt) Modern Statutes, Loose Canons, GOVERNMENT and the Limits of Practical Closing the Book on the School Reason: A Response to Farber Trust Lands and Ross Competition Among Municipali- The Practice and Problems of ties as a Constraint on Land Plain Meaning: A Response Use Exactions The Presumption of Reviewabil- The National Endowment for ity: A Study in Canonical Con- The Humanities: Control of struction and Its Consequences Funding Versus Academic Prospective Overruling and the Freedom Judicial Role After James Reconceptualizing Sovereign Im- B. Beam Distilling Co. uv. munity Georgia 1345tt Quasi-Constitutional Law: Clear HEALTH LAW Statement Rules as Constitu- Cruel and Unusual Punishment tional Lawmaking in the Provision of Prison Med- Where Have You Gone, Karl ical Care: Challenging the De- Llewellyn? Should Congress liberate Indifference Standard Turn Its Lonely Eyes to You? The Disfranchisement of Fertile Women in Clinical Trials: The LAW AND ECONOMICS Legal Ramifications of and So- The Taxation of Nonshareholder lutions for Rectifying the Contributions to Capital: An Knowledge Gap Economic Analysis Medicaid, State Cost-Contain- ment Measures, and Section SECURED TRANSACTIONS 1983 Provider Actions Under Priorities in Accounts: The Crazy Wilder v. Virginia Hospital Quilt of Current Law and a Association Proposal for Reform 1061* The Oregon Boesic Health Ser- TAXATION vices Act: A Model for State The Taxation of Nonshareholder Reform? Contributions to Capital: An The Pariah Patient: The Lack of Economic Analysis 1457* Funding for Mental Health TORTS Care Hypnotic Memories and Civil JURISPRUDENCE Sexual Abuse Trials 1185* The Canons of Statutory Con- The Lemonade Stand: Feminist struction and Judicial Con- and Other Reflections on the straints: A Response to Macey Limited Liability of Corporate and Miller Shareholders ; 1387* 1992] INDEX Reconceptualizing Sovereign Im- Habeas and Hubris 797* munity : “! 1529* Hypnotic Memories and Civil TRIAL PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE Sexual Abuse Trials 1185* Agreements for Cooperation in The Jurisprudence of Genetics 313* Criminal Cases 7° The Payne of Allowing Victim The Burden of Proving Compe- Impact Statements at Capital tence to Stand Trial: Due Pro- Sentencing Hearings 1621t cess at the Limits of Adver- sarial Justice 199t