Also Edited by Lex Williford and Michael Martone The Scribner Anthology of Contemporary Short Fiction ALSO BY LEX WILLIFORD Macauley’s Thumb ALSO BY MICHAEL MARTONE Michael Martone: Fictions Unconventions The Flatness and Other Landscapes The Blue Guide to Indiana Seeing Eye: Stories Pensées Fort Wayne Is Seventh on Hitler’s List Touchstone A Division of Simon & Schuster, Inc. 1230 Avenue of the Americas New York, NY 10020 Copyright © 2007 by Lex Williford and Michael Martone All rights reserved, including the right to reproduce this book or portions thereof in any form whatsover. For information address Touchstone Subsidiary Rights Department, 1230 Avenue of the Americas, New York, NY 10020 continuation of the copyright page. TOUCHSTONE and colophon are registered trademarks of Simon & Schuster, Inc. Designed by Mary Austin Speaker Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Touchstone anthology of contemporary creative nonfiction : work from 1970 to the present / [edited by Lex Williford and Michael Martone]. p. cm. “A Touchstone Book.” 1. American essays — 20th century. 2. American essays — 21st century. 3. Reportage literature, American. 4. English essays — 20th century. 5. English essays — 21st century. 6. Reportage literature, English. I. Williford, Lex, 1954–. II. Martone, Michael. PS688.T68 2007 814′.5408 — dc22 2007039255 ISBN-10: 1-4165-4511-5 ISBN-13: 978-1-4165-4511-8 Visit us on the World Wide Web: http://www.SimonSays.com Acknowledgments The editors would like to thank editors Cherise Davis and Meghan Stevenson for their hard work and advocacy for this anthology. Putting the anthology together took much longer than any of us expected — problems with crashed computers, software, long negotiations over authors’ permissions, and the like — and we appreciate their patience in the face of delays in fast-approaching production deadlines. We’d also like to thank Jeff Wilson, executive director of contracts at Simon & Schuster, for his calm and generous support with permissions and contracts, as well as Amit Ghosh and his terrific BorderSenses Technology team (http://bstelpaso.com) — Javier Sanchez, Ernesto Flores, and Edevaldo Orozco — who designed the website and the survey’s complex databases, administered the surveys, and then compiled all the data for simpleminded literary types who can barely add up a column of numbers. Thanks also go to Scott Russell Sanders for his marvelous introduction and the many distinguished teaching writers who took time out of their busy summers — the only time many of them could write — to take our survey: Diana Abu-Jaber, Laurie Alberts, Marcia Aldrich, Rilla Askew, Christopher Bakken, Kim Barnes, Helen Barolini, Randolph Bates, David Borofka, Andrea Hollander Budy, Bobby Byrd, David Carkeet, Kelly Grey Carlisle, Christopher Chambers, Kelly Cherry, Rita Ciresi, Elizabeth Cook-Lynn, Burke Davis, Jeffrey DeLotto, Janet Desaulniers, Julie Edelson, David Galef, Albert Garcia, Gaynell Gavin, Denise Gess, Tod Goldberg, Benjamin Grossberg, Marian Haddad, J. C. Hallman, Jane Hammons, Janet Heller, Richard Hoffman, Noy Holland, Sonya Huber, T. R. Hummer, Laura Kasischke, Patricia Kirkpatrick, Wayne Koestenbaum, Martin Lammon, David Leavitt, Sara Levine, Paul Lisicky, Elizabeth Macklin, Lee Martin, Richard McCann, Thomas McConnell, Margaret McMullan, Gregory McNamee, Bart Midwood, Kathleen Volk Miller, Kyle Minor, Roger Mitchell, Dinty W. Moore, Patricia Murphy, James Nolan, Judith Pascoe, Joe Ashby Porter, Lynn Powell, Lia Purpura, Keith Ratzlaff, John Repp, Kathryn Rhett, Natania Rosenfeld, Margaret Rozga, Andrew Schelling, Marc Sheehan, Sue Silverman, Linda Simone, Floyd Skloot, Ron Smith, Angela Sorby, David St. John, Maureen Stanton, Martin Steingesser, Judith Strasser, Pia Taavila, David Taylor, Richard Terrill, Jessica Treat, Lee Upton, Martha Vertreace-Doody, G. C. Waldrep, Charlotte Walker, Gabriel Welsch, Tom Whalen, Laurance Wieder, Chris Willerton, Paul Winner, and Mark Wunderlich. Lucky for us, work by many of these same distinguished writers also appears in this anthology, not because they nominated their own work or had friends nominate it for them but because their work is powerful and important. Without these and other authors, such an anthology as this would never have been possible. Although permissions costs have doubled and even tripled over the last decade, authors, their agents, and their publishers were willing to receive the same low permissions fee to keep the cost of this anthology affordable. We thank them all. For interested writers who have published at least three essays in nationally distributed literary magazines, please email [email protected], and we’ll add your name to our database so you may participate in surveys for any future editions. Contents Foreword Introduction by Scott Russell Sanders Jo Ann Beard The Fourth State of Matter Wendell Berry Getting Along with Nature Eula Biss The Pain Scale Mary Clearman Blew The Unwanted Child Charles Bowden Torch Song Janet Burroway Embalming Mom Kelly Grey Carlisle Physical Evidence Anne Carson The Glass Essay Bernard Cooper Burl’s Michael W.Cox Visitor Annie Dillard Living Like Weasels Mark Doty Return to Sender Brian Doyle Leap Tony Earley Somehow Form a Family Anthony Farrington Kissing Harrison Candelaria Fletcher The Beautiful City of Tirzah Diane Glancy Sun Dance Lucy Grealy Mirrorings William Harrison Present Tense Africa Robin Hemley Reading History to My Mother Adam Hochschild World on a Hilltop Jamaica Kincaid A Small Place Barbara Kingsolver High Tide in Tucson Ted Kooser Small Rooms in Time Sara Levine The Essayist is Sorry for Your Loss E.J. Levy Mastering the Art of French Cooking Phillip Lopate Portrait of My Body Barry Lopez Flight Thomas Lynch The Undertaking Lee Martin Sorry Rebecca Mcclanahan Interstellar Erin Mcgraw Bad Eyes John Mcphee The Search for Marvin Gardens Brenda Miller The Date Dinty W. Moore Son of Mr. Green Jeans Kathleen Norris Celibate Passion Naomi Shihab Nye This is Not Who We Are Lia Purpura Autopsy Report Richard Rhodes Watching the Animals Bill Roorbach Shitdiggers, Mudflats, and the Worm Men of Maine David Sedaris Repeat After Me Richard Selzer Imelda Sue William Silverman The Pat Boone Fan Club Floyd Skloot A Measure of Acceptance Lauren Slater Black Swans Cheryl Strayed The Love of My Life Amy Tan Mother Tongue Ryan Van Meter If You Knew Then What I Know Now David Foster Wallace Consider the Lobster