to bid farewell to hon'ble mr. justice pradeep nandrajog on his lordship's appointment as chief ...

240 Pages·2017·1.74 MB·English

30.03.2017 SUPPLEMENTARY LIST
SUPPLEMENTARY LIST FOR TODAY IN CONTINUATION OF THE ADVANCE LIST ALREADY CIRCULATED.
THE WEBSITE OF DELHI HIGH COURT IS www.delhihighcourt.nic.in
INDEX
PRONOUNCEMNT OF JUDGMENTS ------------> 01 TO 01
REGULAR MATTERS -----------------------> 01 TO 68
FINAL MATTERS (ORIGINAL SIDE) ---------> 01 TO 25
ADVANCE LIST --------------------------> 01 TO 104
ORIGINAL SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY I)--------> 105 TO 109
APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST)----> 110 TO 132
COMPANY -------------------------------> 133 TO 134
MEDIATION CAUSE LIST ------------------> 01 TO 03
PRE-LOK ADALAT-------------------------> 01 TO 03
APPELLATE SIDE (SUPPLEMENTARY LIST)----> - TO -
SECOND SUPPLEMENTARY -------------------> TO
TO BID FAREWELL TO HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE PRADEEP
NANDRAJOG ON HIS LORDSHIP'S APPOINTMENT AS
CHIEF JUSTICE OF RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT, THERE
WILL BE A FAREWELL REFERENCE BY THE FULL
COURT ON THURSDAY, THE 30th MARCH, 2017 AT 3.00
P.M. IN COURT ROOM NO. 1.
NOTES
1. Urgent mentioning may be made before Hon'ble DB-II at 10.30 A.M.
2. Hon'ble Ms. Justice Deepa Sharma will not be holding Court today.Dates
will be given by the Court Master. Urgent mentioning be made
before Court No.24.
3. Hon'ble Mr. Justice Ashutosh Kumar will hear Single Bench matters
listed before his Lordship in Court No.9.
NOTICE
IN EXERCISE OF POWERS CONFERRED BY RULE 15 OF CHAPTER 6-B OF THE HIGH
COURT RULES AND ORDERS, VOLUME-V, IT IS HEREBY CIRCULATED THAT
”GOWNS”
WEARING OF BY ADVOCATES HAS BEEN DISPENSED WITH W.E.F.
10th APRIL, 2017 TILL FURTHER ORDERS.
HIGH COURT OF DELHI: NEW DELHI
nd
The Roster of Sitting of Hon’ble Judges of this Court effective from 2 January, 2017
th
shall stand amended as under for 30 March, 2017:
1. DB-IV, DB-V, DB-VI, DB-VII and DB-VIII shall become DB-III, DB-IV, DB-V,
DB-VI and DB-VII respectively.
2. Mentioning of urgent matters will be before DB-II.
3. PIL matters other than those listed before DB-I; First Appeals from Orders
(Original Side) of the year 2016 & 2017; Writ Petitions (Tender), Writ Petitions
(Land Acquisition) and the Commercial Appellate Division matters listed before
the erstwhile DB-III shall be listed before DB-V comprising Hon’ble Mr. Justice
S. Ravindra Bhat and Hon’ble Mr. Justice Najmi Waziri.
4. Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ashutosh Kumar will sit singly and hear old Writ Petitions
(Service).
DELETIONS
1. W.P.(C) 12195/2016 listed before Hon'ble DB-II & DB-V at item Nos.17 &
41 is deleted as the same is listed before Hon'ble DB-VI.
2. FAO(OS) 358/2012 listed before Hon'ble DB-VI at item No.14 is deleted
as the same is listed before Hon'ble DB-VII.
3. MAC.APPL. 221/2017 listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sunil Gaur at
item No.3 is deleted as the same is listed before Hon'ble Mr. Justice
J.R.Midha.
4. MAC.APPL.984/2015, 53/2016,1029/2015,631/2016 & 58/2016 listed before
Hon'ble Mr. Justice Sunil Gaur at item Nos.41, 42, 43, 44 & 45
respectively are deleted as the same are listed in Regular matters.
As approved by Hon'ble Mr. Justice Pradeep Nandrajog,Judge
High Court of Delhi and Chairman, DHCLSC, National Lok Adalat
is to be held on 08.04.2017(Second Saturday) at High Court of
Delhi for the pending cases under following category:-
1. Criminal Compoundable Offence
2. NI Act cases under Section 138;
3. Bank Recovery cases;
4. MACT cases;
5. Matrimonial disputes;
6. Labour disputes cases;
7. Land Acquisition cases;
8. Electricity and Water Bills(excluding theft cases);
Services matters relating to pay and allowances and
retiral benefits;
9. Revenue cases;
10. Other civil cases(rent, easmentary rights, injunction
suits, specific performance suits) etc;
11. Other cases
To facilitate settlements, the committee will start pre-
Lok Adalat sittings w.e.f. 15.02.2017 to 31.03.2017. The
parties and their Advocates, who want their pending matter to
be referred for National Lok Adalat, may either make request to
concern Hon'ble Court or with consent of opposite party may
approach office of Delhi High Court Legal Services Committee,
Chamber No.33 to 37, Lawyers Chambers, Delhi High Court.
Delhi High Court Legal Services Committee is holding the Pre-
Lok Adalat sittings w.e.f. 15.02.2017 to 31.03.2017 from 2:30
P.M.to 5:00 P.M. in Room No. 111 at Ground Floor,LCB-II.

REGISTRAR(LISTING)
30.03.2017 J-1FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT(APPLT. JURISDICTION)
30.03.2017
COURT NO. 5
(DIVISION BENCH-5)
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.RAVINDRA BHAT
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE NAJMI WAZIRI
AT 10.30 A.M
1. W.P.(c) 11216/2016 KUMUDAM PUBLICATIONS PVT S. GANESH,
LTD. ACTING THROUGH ITS POOJA MEHRA SAIGAL
MANAGING DIRECTOR MR. JITENDRA RATTA
P. VARADARAJAN JASMINE KOTTAI
VS. CENTRAL BOARD OF RUCHIR BHATIA
DIRECT TAXES AND ORS. PUNEET RAI
COURT NO. 29
EXTENSION BLOCK (FIRST FLOOR)
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.P.GARG
AT 2.15 P.M
1. CRL.A 166/2016 SOFYAN JITENDRA BHARTI, NAUSHAD ALAM
VS. STATE AMIT GUPTA
COURT NO. 30
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE P.S.TEJI
AT 2.15 P.M
1. CRL.A 599/2001 AAS MOHAMMAD BHARAT BHUSHAN BHATIA
VS. STATE AKSHAY BHATIA, PANNA LAL SHARMA
2. CRL.A 824/2001 BALMAT VARINDER KUMAR SHARMA, SUMAN RANI
VS. NCT OF DELHI PANNA LAL SHARMA
3. CRL.A 455/2000 MESSAR ALI CHETAN LOKUR, NITISH CHAUDHARY
VS. THE STATE PANNA LAL SHARMA
4. CRL.A 574/2000 SATISH KUMAR BHATIA BHOPAL SINGH
VS. STATE PANNA LAL SHARMA
HIGH COURT OF DELHI REGISTRAR (LISTING)
29.03.2017
30.03.2017 R-1 REGULAR MATTERS
30.03.2017 REGULAR MATTERS
COURT NO. 1
(DIVISION BENCH-I)
HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SANGITA DHINGRA SEHGAL
CASES OF PERSONS ABOVE 65 YRS. OF AGE (REGULAR MATTER)
1. LPA 640/2013 COAL INDIA LIMITED MOHIT PAUL,D P
Vs. R K GUPTA & ORS MUKHERJEE,NANDINI SEN
2. LPA 904/2013 S.P. MEDIRATTA & ORS ANJU JAIN & HITESH SACHAR,S K
Vs. UNION OF INDIA & ORS KULKARNI
3. LPA 173/2015 PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK JAGAT ARORA
Vs. M L BANSAL
REGULAR MATTERS
1. W.P.(C) 9374/2015 INDRAPRASTHA GAS LIMITED SHIV KUMAR PANDEY,VIVEK
CM APPL. 21790/2015 Vs. PETROLEUM & NATURAL GAS CHAUDHARY,KIRTIMAN
CM APPL. 21791/2015 REGULATORY BOARD & ANR. SINGH,MONIKA ARORA
CM APPL. 4231/2016
TOP
2. W.P.(C) 1970/2011------| VIJAY KUMAR SHARMA RAKESH KUMAR,ARUN
SUB TO OVERNIGHT PH | Vs. NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR BHARDWAJ,M.A.SIDDIQUI,S.
| MINORITY EDUCATIONAL WASIM A QADRI
| INSTITUTIONS AND ORS
3. W.P.(C) 2934/2011 | AWANISH KUMAR AWANISH KUMAR,ARUN
CM APPL. 7196/2015 | Vs. JAMIA MILLIA ISLAMIA BHARDWAJ,MA SIDDIQUI,S.
SUB TO OVERNIGHT PH | UNIVERISTY AND ORS. WASIM A QADRI
|
4. W.P.(C) 3320/2011 | CENTER FOR PUBLIC INTEREST PRASHANT BHUSHAN,DEV
SUB TO OVERNIGHT PH | LITIGATION P.BHARDWAJ,M.A.SIDDIEQUI,S.
| Vs. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS WASIM A QADRI
5. W.P.(C) 4219/2011 | NASEEM AHMED QURESHI GLOBAL JURIS CONSULTANTS,M.
CM APPL. 1016/2015 | Vs. JAMIA MILLIA ISLAMIA, ATYAB SIDDIQUI,M.A.SIDDIQUI,
SUB TO OVERNIGHT PH | THR. ITS REGISTRAR SAPNA CHAUHAN,S. WASIM A .
| QADRI
6. W.P.(C) 4245/2011 | KOMAL SUDHIR SHARMA,DEV
SUB TO OVERNIGHT PH | Vs. JAMIA TEACHERS P.BHARDWAJ,M.A.SIDDIQUI,S.
| ASSOCIATION AND ORS. WASIM A QADRI,
7. W.P.(C) 4322/2011------| MANOJ KUMAR AND ORS A SUBHA RAO,DEV
SUB TO OVERNIGHT PH Vs. NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR P.BHARDWAJ,M.A.SIDDIQUI,S.
MINORITY EDUCATIONAL WASIM A QADRI
INSTITUTIONS AND ORS
30.03.2017 R-2 REGULAR MATTERS
8. LPA 435-36/2006-----| OSWAL CHEMICALS AND KUNAL VERMA,RAJAT
CM APPL. 6109/2013 | FERTILIZER MAHAJAN,PUNEET DUTT
| Vs. UOI & ORS TYAGI,HIREN SHARMA,RAJAT
| GAUR,R.K. SHARMA,JASMEET
| SINGH,M/S K J JOHN &
| CO,BHARAT ARORA
9. W.P.(C) 8965/2006---| M/S OSWAL CHEMICALS AND RAJAT GAUR,ASHISH GUPTA,KUNAL
CM APPL. 6605/2006 FERT.LTD. VERMA,RAJEEV MEHRA,BHARAT
Vs. UOI & ANR ARORA
10. W.P.(C) 1717/2007 TELELCOM WATCHDOG PRASHANT BHUSHAN,RAJEEV
CM APPL. 3162/2007 Vs. UOI & ORS. MEHRA,B.K. ROY,SANJEEV
CM APPL. 6876/2007(CM For PURI,ROHIT PURI,ANKUR
Restoration) CHAWLA,NITI DIXIT,RISHI
CM APPL. 7778/2007 AGARWALA,ANURADHA DUTT
CM APPL. 5619/2008
11. LPA 135/2008--------| TATA STEEL LTD. RAIAN KARANJAWALA,SRIDHAR
CM APPL. 3740/2008 | Vs. NATIONAL MINERAL POTARAJU,P.S. NARSIMHA,ATUL
| DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION & ORS JHA,DEBMALYA BANERJEE,ANJANA
GOSAIN,GOPAL JAIN,KUNAL
| VERMA,SONIA,SUMIT,D.JULIIUS
RIAMEI,KAILASH PANDEY &
| ASSOCIATES
12. LPA 151/2008 | STATE OF CHHATTISGARH ATUL JHA,MANISH
| Vs. UOI & ORS. SINGHVI,ANJANA GOSAIN,CHETAN
CHAWLA,GOPAL JAIN,SONIA
| NIGAM,P.S. NARASIMHA,SRIDHAR
POTRAJU,RAIAN
| KARANJAWALA,D.JULIIUS
RIAMEI,KAILASH PANDEY &
| ASSOCIATES
13. W.P.(C) 4181/2008---| NATIONAL MINERAL DEVELOPMENT SRIDHAR P[OTARAJU,ANJANA
CM APPL. 8134/2008 CORPORATION GOSAIN,D JULIUS RIAMEI
CM APPL. 11317/2013 Vs. TATA STEEL LIMITED & ORS
14. LPA 737/2008--------| MCD MUKESH GUPTA,RAMESH CHANDRA
IST 10 CASES | Vs. RAMESH CHANDRA
|
15. W.P.(C) 8985/2009---| DESH DEEPAK TYAGI RAJAN TYAGI,YATINDER
CM APPL. 6428/2009 Vs. UOI & ORS. CHAUDHARY,AMIT KUMAR,RAJIV
WITH LPA 737/2008 NANDA,ASIT TIWARI,ANUJ
IST 10 CASES AGGARWAL
16. LPA 743/2008 B.S.E.S.YAMUNA POWER LTD. J.SAGAR,ANUPAM VARMA
Vs. RAKESH MOHAN MITTAL
30.03.2017 R-3 REGULAR MATTERS
17. LPA 94/2009 GOVERNMENT OF NCT OF DELHI & RAMAN DUGGAL,S.K.
ANR CHASWAL,J.S.BAKSHI,M.M.
Vs. JAI GOPAL SRIVASTAVA KALRA,NAUSHAD AHMED KHAN
18. LPA 471/2014 AIRPORTS AUTHORITY OF INDIA DIGVIJAY RAI,KUNAL BERMA
CM APPL. 11252/2014 Vs. W.MORRIS ROMEL ROY & ORS
IST 10 CASES
19. LPA 106/2009 SANTOSH KUMAR TIWARI & ORS. MURARI TIWARI,MANINDER
Vs. UNIVERSITY OF DELHI & ACHARYA,RAJINDER
ANR. DHAWAN,SHAFAALI,MURLI MANOHAR
SINGH,N D PANCHOLI
20. LPA 283/2009 INDERJEET SINGH RITESH KUMAR,AMITA GUPTA
Vs. MCD & ORS.
21. LPA 658/2009 JAIN EXPORTS PVT LTD KULJEET RAWAL,DARPAN
Vs. UNION OF INDIA & ORS WADHWA,DIVYA JHA,SHEENA IYPE
22. W.P.(C) 7292/2009-----| DDA PAWAN MATHUR,J. SAGAR,SWAGAT
CM APPL. 3046/2009 | Vs. DERC AND ORS. SHARMA,ANUPAM VERMA
CM APPL. 17250/2014 |
WITH W.P.(C) 5307/2012
|
23. W.P.(C) 5307/2012----| DELHI STATE INDUSTRIAL AND DEEPALI GUPTA,NIKHIL NAYYAR,S
CM APPL. 10847/2012 INFRASTRUCTURE DEVELOPMENT K TRIPATHI
CORP.
Vs. DELHI ELECTRICITY
REGULATOROY COMMISSION AND
ANR
24. W.P.(C) 7713/2009 KARAN LUTHRA DESHPANDE & CO.,RISHIKESH
Vs. UOI & ANR
25. W.P.(C) 8831/2009 NURSERY TEACHER TRAINING REETESH SINGH,AMITESH
INSTITUTE KUMAR,AVNISH AHLAWAT,BB
Vs. UOI & ORS. MAHAJAN
26. W.P.(C) 10000/2009----| P.G.F. & ORS. ROHIT TANDON,VIRAJ R.
| Vs. HIGH COURT OF DELHI & DATAR,VIVEK SOOD,SANJAY
| ANR. MANN,RAKESH K SINGH,DEEPA
| TIWARI,SOUGATA GANGULY
27. W.P.(C) 1888/2010-----| THREE STAR LINES PLANTATIONS AJIT NAIR,SANJAY MANN
AND RESORTS INDIA LTD AND ORS
Vs. THE COURT OF THE DISTRICT
JUDGE DELHI AND ORS
28. W.P.(C) 11359/2009 PRAKASH SAHEBRAO DESHMUKH & S. SANTANAM,VIBHA,NAVEEN R.
ANR. NATH
Vs. UOI & ANR.
29. W.P.(C) 11626/2009 TRANS GLOBAL IMPEX LTD. RAJAN NARAIN,ATUL
Vs. SPECIAL DIRECTOR & ANR. NANDA,RAMEEZA HAKEEM,SUMEER
SODHI,AJAY AGGARWAL,RN SINGH
30.03.2017 R-4 REGULAR MATTERS
30. W.P.(C) 13207/2009----| EASTERN INSTITUTE OF AMIT ANAND TIWARI,AMITESH
INTEGRATED LEARNING AND KUMAR,NEERAJ CHAUDHARI
| MANAGEMENT UNIVERSITY
JORETHANG DISTT. NAMCHI
| THROUGH I
Vs. UNION OF INDIA AND ANR.
31. W.P.(C) 13969/2009----| THE INSTITUTE OF CHARTERED R. BALASUBRAMANIAM,AMITESH
FINANCIAL ANALYSTS OF INDIA KUMAR,NEERAJ CHAUDHARI,GOPAL
UNIVERSITY TRIPURA SINGH
Vs. THE UNION OF INDIA AND
ORS
32. W.P.(C) 13415/2009-----| MANOJ KUMAR GUPTA & ORS ANIL K AGGARWAL & ANSHUMALEE
CM APPL. 2959/2012 | Vs. UOI & ANR SOOD
WITH W.P.(C) 6685/2013 |
W.P.(C) 13646/2009 |
|
33. W.P.(C) 6685/2013 | ANSHUMALEE SOOD ANIL K. AGGARWAL,RAJIV BANSAL
| Vs. GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI &
| ANR
34. W.P.(C) 13646/2009-----| MANOJ KUMAR GUPTA & ORS ANIL KUMAR AGGARWAL
CM APPL. 15329/2009 Vs. DDA & ANR

35. LPA 21/2010 FOOTWEAR WHOLESALERS SUDARSHAN LAL ANEJA,RAMAN
ASSOCIATION & ANR. DUGGAL
Vs. CONTROLLER OF LEGAL
METROLOGY & ORS.
36. LPA 78/2010-----| ENFORCEMENT DIRECTORATE BHARATHI RAJU
| Vs. AS ANEJA & ORS
37. LPA 79/2010 | ENFORCEMENT DIRECTORATE BHARATHI RAJU
| Vs. UMESH MEDIRATTA & ORS
38. LPA 80/2010 | ENFORCEMENT DIRECTORATE` BHARATHI RAJU
| Vs. VD JAISWAL & ORS
39. LPA 85/2010 | ENFORCEMENT DIRECTORATE BHARATHI RAJU
| Vs. SK MITTAL & ORS
40. LPA 86/2010-----| ENFORCEMENT DIRECTORATE BHARATHI RAJU
Vs. ADITYA AGGARWAL & ORS
41. LPA 91/2010 INDIAN CONGRESS (SOCIALIST) DR.SUMANT BHARDWAJ,PR CHOPRA
PARTY & ORS.
Vs. ELECTION COMMISSIONER OF
INDIA & ORS.
42. LPA 137/2010----------| UNION OF INDIA & ANR R BALASUBRAMANIAM,R.
| Vs. CENTRAL INFORMATION KRISHNAORTHI
| COMMISSION & ANR
43. W.P.(C) 6392/2011-----| UNION OF INDIA SANJEEV KUMAR DUBEY,PRASHANT
Vs. SUBHASH CHANDRA AGARWAL BHUSHAN
30.03.2017 R-5 REGULAR MATTERS
Note:The exact item no. in the below noted cases shall be allocated later on.
REGULAR MATTERS(IN WHICH EARLY HEARING IS ALLOWED)
199 W.P.(C) 1035/2015 M/S. RAMA OILS MILLS SHAKIL AKHTAR
WITH W.P.(C) 542/2007 Vs. GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI &
ORS.
REGULAR MATTERS(DATED CASE FOR 14.3.2016)
200.LPA 140/2011 FATEH SINGH AND ORS LALIT KUMAR JHA,ASHEESH JAIN
CM APPL. 2538/2011 Vs. FINANCE COMMISSIONER AND AND NISHANT DATTA,ANKIT
CM APPL. 9905/2014 ORS JAIN,GEETA MEHROTRA,ASHEESH
JAIN,NISHANT DATTA
REGULAR MATTERS(WEEK COMMENCING CASES FOR 02.01.2017)
201.LPA 754/2013 DELHI AUTO RICHSHAW SANGH & RANI CHHABRA,RAHUL
CM APPL. 16132/2013 ORS MEHRA,SANJEEV RALLI
Vs. GOVT OF NCT OF DELHI &
ORS
202.LPA 5/2014 THE REGISTRAR GENERAL (NOW RITESH KUMAR,RAJEEV SHARMA
SECRETARY GENERAL) SUPREME
COURT OF INDIA
Vs. PHAGUNI NILESH LAL & ANR
203.LPA 404/2016 MEENAKSHI JAIN MEENAKSHI JAIN,PRAVEEN
CM APPL. 25246/2016 Vs. DELHI MEDICAL COUNCIL & KHATTAR,MADHUKAR PANDEY
ANR
REGULAR MATTERS(WEEK COMMENCING CASE FOR 09.01.2017)
204.LPA 201/2016 ASHOK KUMAR KANSAL SHOBHANA TAKIAR &
Vs. COMMISSIONER OF CENTRAL ASSOCIATES,PRAMOD KUMAR RAI
EXCISE & ANR
REGULAR MATTERS(WEEK COMMENCING CASES FOR 16.01.2017)
205.LPA 455/2016 SOUTH DELHI MUNICIPAL MUKESH GUPTA
CORPORATION
Vs. INDIAN STATISTICAL
INSTITUTE
206.W.P.(C) 8052/2011 B.L.AGRAWAL NAYAR AGRAWAL,SAURABH
CM APPL. 43323/2016 Vs. UOI AND ORS MISHRA,PRASHANT MISHRA,VIVEK
GOYAL,ATUL JHA,SONIA MATHUR
REGULAR MATTERS(WEEK COMMENCING CASES FOR 13.02.2017)
207 LPA 429/2010----------| NATIONAL AGRI COOP MARKETING OM PRAKASH,MANINDER
| FED OF INDIA LTD ACHARYA,BRAHM DUTT
| Vs. BM VERMA
208 LPA 435/2010 | KRISHAK BHARATI COOP LTD OM PRAKASH FOR
| Vs. RAMESH CHANDER BAWA APPELLANT,RAMESH CHANDER
| BAWA,BRAHM DUTT FOR RESONDENT
209 LPA 439/2010 | NATIONAL COOPERATIVE CONSUMER ANJU BHATTACHARYA FOR
| FED OF INDIA LTD APPELLANT,ELGIN MATT JOHN FOR
| Vs. RAJ MANGAL PRASAD APPELLANT,BRAHAM DUTT FOR
| RESPONDENT
|