The Public Administration Theory Primer

321 Pages·2011·4.5 MB·English

by  H. George Frederickson

LF Second
ar
“The Public Administration Theory Primeristheperfectstartingpoint re
imd edition
e
foranystudentofpublicadministration.Itprovidesawelldocumented er
ri
overviewofanexceptionalrangeoftopics.”–KennethMeier, c
|k

DistinguishedProfessorofPoliticalScience,TexasA&MUniversity Ls
ico
an
“The Public Administration Theory Primer[is]anessentialcompanionfor ri | s
newexplorersoroldhandsinthefield.Providinganessentialmap,the m
i
authorsnotonlyintroducecorebodiesoftheoryandtheirdevelopment, t
h
theyneverfailtoassesstheapplicabilityofeach.Thereaderwillbeleft
T
withastrongsenseofthelandscapeandgoodideaofwheretohead
h
foranextendedexploration.”–JonathanGSKoppell,Director,ASU
e
SchoolofPublicAffairs,LattieandElvaCoorPresidentialChair

P
u
The Public Administration Theory Primer explores how the science and art of
b
public administration is definable, describable, replicable, and cumulative. The
l
i
authors describe several theories and analytical approaches that contribute c
to what we know about policy administration and consider which are the most A
promising, influential, and important—both now and for the future. d
m
The extensively updated second edition includes the latest directions and
i
developments in public administration theory. These include the rise of reporting n
as a means to hold bureaucracy accountable, the continuing evolution of the i
s
“hollow state” or “shadow bureaucracy” and the rise of network theory, and new t
psychological and biological behavioral research with important implications r
a
for decision theory and rational choice. The contributions of nearly a decade’s The Public
t
worth of new research are woven into all the chapters, in some cases altering i
o
conclusions about the health and robustness of certain popular conceptual
n
frameworks.
T
Administration
h
H. GeorGe Frederickson is distinguished professor of public administration at the e
University of kansas. o
r
kevin B. smitH is professor of political science at the University of nebraska, Lincoln.
y
cHristopHer W. Larimer is associate professor of political science at the University of Theory Primer
P
northern iowa.
r
i
micHaeL J. Licari is associate professor of political science at the University of m
northern iowa.
e
Cover Art: Miguel SAntAnA r
H. GeorGe Frederickson,
es
de
itco kevin B. smitH,
i
on
nd cHristopHer W. Larimer,
A Member of the Perseus Books Group and micHaeL J. Licari
www.westviewpress.com
www.perseusacademic.com
0813345765-Frederickson_Layout 1 10/12/11 11:36 AM Page i
The Public
Administration
Theory Primer
0813345765-Frederickson_Layout 1 10/12/11 11:36 AM Page ii
0813345765-Frederickson_Layout 1 10/12/11 11:36 AM Page iii
Th e P u b l i c
A d m i n i s t r at i o n
Th e o r y P r i m e r
second edition
H. George Frederickson
University of Kansas
Kevin B. Smith
University of Nebraska
Christopher W. Larimer
University of Northern Iowa
Michael J. Licari
University of Northern Iowa
a member of the perseus books group
0813345765-Frederickson_Layout 1 10/12/11 11:36 AM Page iv
Westview Press was founded in 1975 in Boulder, Colorado, by notable publisher
and intellectual Fred Praeger. Westview Press continues to publish scholarly titles
and high-quality undergraduate- and graduate-level textbooks in core social
science disciplines. With books developed, written, and edited with the needs of
serious nonfiction readers, professors, and students in mind, Westview Press
honors its long history of publishing books that matter.
Copyright © 2012 by Westview Press
Published by Westview Press,
A Member of the Perseus Books Group
All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. No part of this book
may be reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except
in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews. For
information, address Westview Press, 2465 Central Avenue, Boulder, CO 80301.
Find us on the World Wide Web at www.westviewpress.com.
Every effort has been made to secure required permissions for all text, images,
maps, and other art reprinted in this volume.
Westview Press books are available at special discounts for bulk purchases in the
United States by corporations, institutions, and other organizations. For more
information, please contact the Special Markets Department at the Perseus Books
Group, 2300 Chestnut Street, Suite 200, Philadelphia, PA 19103, or call (800)
810-4145, ext. 5000, or e-mail [email protected].
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
The public administration theory primer / H. George Frederickson . . . [et al.].—
2nd ed.
p. cm.
Includes bibliographical references and index.
ISBN 978-0-8133-4576-5 (pbk. : alk. paper)—ISBN 978-0-8133-4577-2
(e-book) 1. Public administration—United States. I. Frederickson, H. George.
JF1351.F734 2012
351.73—dc23
2011035509
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
0813345765-Frederickson_Layout 1 10/12/11 11:36 AM Page v
Contents
Preface, vii
Chapter 1 Introduction: The Possibilities of Theory 1
Chapter 2 Theories of Political Control of Bureaucracy 15
Chapter 3 Theories of Bureaucratic Politics 41
Chapter 4 Public Institutional Theory 67
Chapter 5 Theories of Public Management 97
Chapter 6 Postmodern Theory 131
Chapter 7 Decision Theory 165
Chapter 8 Rational Choice Theory and Irrational Behavior 193
Chapter 9 Theories of Governance 219
Chapter 10 Conclusion: A Bright Future for Theory? 245
References, 267
Index, 291
v
0813345765-Frederickson_Layout 1 10/12/11 11:36 AM Page vi
0813345765-Frederickson_Layout 1 10/12/11 11:36 AM Page vii
Preface
The first edition of The Public Administration Theory Primer sought to address a
problem faced sooner or later by all students, scholars, and practitioners of public
administration. In order to make sense of what we study or practice we need some
structure or framework to understand decisions, outcomes, causes, and the like;
in other words, we need a theory. The big problem in the field of public admin-
istration is not that we lack theory; the problem is one of surfeit rather than deficit.
The big challenge is ordering, synthesizing, and making sense of multiple theo-
retical and empirical perspectives. The first edition of the primer was explicitly
aimed at meeting that challenge.
Since its publication in , The Public Administration Theory Primer has
been adopted by scores of instructors, cited in hundreds of scholarly articles, and
served as a comprehensive survey of the field for thousands of students and aca-
demics. Though it continued to serve as a standard reference and text, events in-
side and outside the academy left the first edition increasingly dated. There have
been numerous new developments and contributions in public administration
theory since its publication; changes in government and management practices
have created new demands for different types of theories; and some of the concepts
and models given extensive coverage in the original edition have either passed
from favor or been superceded by subsequent work.
This second edition of The Primer retains the original’s thematic focus and
general organization, but is extensively updated to include the latest directions
and developments. These include the rise of reporting as a means to hold bureau-
cracy accountable (see Chapter ), the continuing evolution of the “hollow state”
or “shadow bureaucracy” and the rise of network theory (see Chapter ), new
psychological/biological behavioral research with big implications for decision
theory and, especially, rational choice (see Chapters  and ). The contributions
of nearly a decade’s worth of new research is woven into all the chapters, some of
which has altered our conclusions about the health and robustness of some pop-
ular conceptual frameworks (see Chapter ).
Many deserve thanks for making the second edition of The Primer possible.
We appreciate the hard work, faith in the project, and patience in seeing it through
vii
0813345765-Frederickson_Layout 1 10/12/11 11:36 AM Page viii
viii Preface
to fruition of Anthony Wahl, our editor at Westview. We also have a long list of
debts to many others whose contributions through two editions should not go
unmentioned. These include Ken Meier, Leisha DeHart-Davis, and Tom Catlaw.
We thank our colleagues at the Department of Public Administration of the Uni-
versity of Kansas, the Department of Political Science at the University of Ne-
braska, and the Department of Political Science at the University of Northern
Iowa for encouraging and supportive environments in which to work. We thank
Dwight Waldo for his inspiration. Above all we thank our spouses, Mary Freder-
ickson, Kelly Smith, Danielle Larimer, and Kirsten Licari, for their unflagging
and loving support.
0813345765-Frederickson_Layout 1 10/12/11 11:36 AM Page 1
1
Introduction:
The Possibilities of Theory
Why Do We Need Theory in Public Administration?
All the great human events in history were probably achieved by what we today
would call public administration. Organization and management practicesin col-
lective or public settings are certainly as old as civilization, and significant changes
in those practices tend to accompany historical shifts in mass-scale social organi-
zation and operation.For example, the transition from feudal society to the ex-
tended nation-state was made possible by the centralization of policy, on the one
hand, and the decentralization of policy implementation, on the other (Tout ;
Ellul ; Chrimes ). The colonial era would be described the same way,
but on a worldwide scale (Gladden ). There are splendid comparisons of
British, French, Portuguese, Dutch, and Belgian approaches to issues of colonial
centralization and decentralization, the management of courts, and the organiza-
tion and management of navies and armies (Gladden , –). Extensive
archaeological research indicates that early Armenian civilizations were built on
rather elaborate forms of administration (Von Hagen ; Prescott ; Mason
; Morley ). In China, the Sung dynasty (A.D. –) “maintained
substantially the traditional Chinese system of government and administration.
The Emperor, who was supreme, was advised and assisted by a Council of State
whose members, varying from five to nine, supervised individually the several or-
gans of Administration, which were grouped under () the Secretariat-Chancellery,
() the Finance Commission, and () the Bureau of Military Affairs” (Gladden
, ; Yutang ; Loewe ; Balazs ; Weber ).
In these and countless other examples, the elemental features of public admin-
istration permeated social development; indeed, it is argued that civilization requires
the elemental features of public administration (Waldo , ; Wildavsky
1