The New Class in Post-Industrial Society The New Class in Post-Industrial Society John McAdams MarquetteUniversity THENEWCLASSINPOST-INDUSTRIALSOCIETY Copyright©JohnMcAdams,2015. Softcoverreprintofthehardcover1stedition2015978-1-137-51540-7 Allrightsreserved. Firstpublishedin2015by PALGRAVEMACMILLAN® intheUnitedStates—adivisionofSt.Martin’sPressLLC, 175FifthAvenue,NewYork,NY10010. WherethisbookisdistributedintheUK,EuropeandtherestoftheWorld, thisisbyPalgraveMacmillan,adivisionofMacmillanPublishersLimited, registeredinEngland,companynumber785998,ofHoundmills, Basingstoke,HampshireRG216XS. PalgraveMacmillanistheglobalacademicimprintoftheabove companiesandhascompaniesandrepresentativesthroughouttheworld. Palgrave®andMacmillan®areregisteredtrademarksintheUnited States,theUnitedKingdom,Europeandothercountries. ISBN978-1-349-57663-0 ISBN978-1-137-51541-4(eBook) DOI10.1057/9781137515414 LibraryofCongressCataloging-in-PublicationDataisavailablefromthe LibraryofCongress. AcataloguerecordofthebookisavailablefromtheBritishLibrary. DesignbyIntegraSoftwareServices Firstedition:September2015 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Contents ListofTables vii Acknowledgments xiii 1 TheTheoryoftheNewClass 1 2 TheThreeClassWorldviews 37 3 ClassVotinginPresidentialElections 81 4 ClassandPolitics:ReferendumData 101 5 TheClassBasisofElitePartisanship:ConventionDelegates 131 6 TheClassBasisofPoliticalRadicalism 151 7 TheClassBasisofCongressionalLiberalism 163 8 TheCaseofGovernmentWorkers 179 9 Lifestyle:AnExpressionofClassIdentification 189 10 Conclusion:TheFutureandClassandPolitics 223 Appendices 233 Notes 237 References 243 Index 251 Tables 2.1 Clusteranalysisof1972NationalElectionStudy 46 2.2 Clusteranalysisof1976NationalElectionStudy 47 2.3 Clusteranalysisof1980NationalElectionStudy 48 2.4 Politicalcorrelatesofworldview 52 2.5 Demographiccorrelatesofworldview—occupation NationalElectionStudies 54 2.6 Demographiccorrelatesofworldview—education NationalElectionStudies 56 2.7 Demographiccorrelatesofworldview—familyincome NationalElectionStudies 57 2.8 Multivariatelogisticregressionnewclassvs.traditional middleclassworldviewmodelbasedonoccupation (standarderrorsinparentheses) 59 2.9 Multivariatelogisticregressionnewclassvs.traditional middleclassworldviewmodelbasedonincomeand education(standarderrorsinparentheses) 60 2.10 Multivariatelogisticregressionnewclassvs.traditional middleclassworldviewmodelsbasedoneducationand income(standarderrorsinparentheses) 64 2.11 Clusteranalysisofworldviews—2000 66 2.12 Clusteranalysisofworldviews—2004 70 2.13 Clusterbyoccupation/2000 73 2.14 Clusterbyeducation/2000 74 2.15 2000incomebyworldview 75 2.16 Politicalcorrelatesofworldview2000/2004 77 viii LISTOFTABLES 2.17 Multivariatelogisticregressionnewclassvs.traditional middleclassworldview2000/2004modelbasedon occupation(standarderrorsinparentheses) 78 2.18 Multivariatelogisticregressionnewclassvs.traditional middleclassworldview2000/2004modelbasedon incomeandeducation(standarderrorsinparentheses) 79 3.1 Percentdemocraticvoteinnationalpresidential electionsweightedleastsquaresestimates1936/1956 (standarderrorsinparentheses) 85 3.2 Democraticvotinginnationalpresidentialelections 1964–1976weightedleastsquaresestimates(standard errorsinparentheses) 86 3.3 Federalgovernmentcivilianexecutivebranchemployment 89 3.4 Democraticvotinginnationalpresidentialelections alternatetreatmentofincomeandeducation1964–1976 weightedleastsquaresestimates 93 3.5 Democraticvotinginnationalpresidentialelections weightedleastsquaresestimates1996/2004(standard errorsinparentheses) 97 3.6 Democraticvotinginnationalpresidentialelections alternatetreatmentofincomeandeducationweighted leastsquaresestimates 98 4.1 Massachusettsreferenda 105 4.2 Californiareferendaandelections 108 4.3 Massachusettsreferendumdataweightedleastsquares estimates(standarderrorsinparentheses) 110 4.4 Massachusettsreferendumdataweightedleastsquares estimatesmodelsbasedonoccupation 111 4.5 Californiareferendumdataweightedleastsquares estimates(standarderrorsinparentheses) 116 4.6 Californiareferendumdataweightedleastsquares estimatesmodelsbasedonoccupation 117 LISTOFTABLES ix 4.7 Massachusettsreferendumdatamodelsbasedon incomeandeducationweightedleastsquaresestimates (standarderrorsinparentheses) 122 4.8 Massachusettsreferendumdataweightedleastsquares estimateseducationversusincome 123 4.9 Californiareferendumdatamodelsbasedonincome andeducationweightedleastsquaresestimates (standarderrorsinparentheses) 126 4.10 Californiareferendumdataweightedleastsquares estimateseducationversusincome 127 5.1 Policy,affect,andabortionliberalismconvention delegates(tableentriesarescalemeans)etacorrelation coefficientsinparentheses 133 5.2 DemocraticPartychoiceamongactivists,1972,1980, and2000partyconventiondelegatesprobitmaximum likelihoodestimates 137 5.3 Partychoiceamongactivists,1980and2000party conventiondelegatesprobitmaximumlikelihoodestimates 139 5.4 Partychoiceamongactivistsmodelsbasedonincome andeducation,1972,1980,and2000partyconvention delegatesprobitmaximumlikelihoodestimates 141 5.5 Politicalattitudes1972partyconventiondelegates modelsbasedonincomeandeducationordinaryleast squaresestimates 143 5.6 Politicalattitudes1972and1980partyconvention delegatesmodelsbasedonincome,occupation,and educationordinaryleastsquaresestimates 144 5.7 Politicalattitudes,1980and2000partyconvention delegatesmodelbasedonoccupationordinaryleast squaresestimates 146 5.8 Politicalattitudes,1980and2000partyconvention delegatesmodelsbasedonincomeandeducation ordinaryleastsquaresestimates 147 6.1 FavorableattitudestowardCommunism,generalsocial surveyprobitestimates 154 x LISTOFTABLES 6.2 Californiapartyregistrationdataweightedleastsquares estimates(standarderrorsinparentheses) 156 6.3 ThePeaceandFreedomPartyinCaliforniamodels basedonincomeandeducationweightedleastsquares estimates 157 6.4 Radicalismamong1972conventiondelegatesprobit estimates 160 7.1 Roll-callliberalismconservativecoalitionopposition scores,USHouseofRepresentatives 169 7.2 Roll-callliberalismconservativecoalitionopposition scores,USSenate 175 8.1 Californiareferendumdataweightedleastsquares estimates,publicadministrationversusnon-public administrationgovernmentemployment 182 9.1 LifestyleandpoliticalideologyRopersurveys,energy andconservation 194 9.2 LifestyleandpoliticalideologyRopersurveys, transportation 196 9.3 LifestyleandpoliticalideologyRopersurveys,dressand appearance 198 9.4 LifestyleandpoliticalideologyRopersurveys,food anddrink 200 9.5 LifestyleandpoliticalideologyRopersurveys,artsand entertainment 203 9.6 LifestyleandpoliticalideologyRopersurveys,sports andhealth 205 9.7 LifestyleandpoliticalideologyRopersurveys, religion—anditsrivals 207 9.8 Arts,entertainment,andleisuresignificantdifferences, liberalsversusconservatives 210 9.9 Altruisticbehaviorsignificantdifferences,liberalsversus conservatives 212 LISTOFTABLES xi 9.10 Miscellaneousbehaviorandattitudessignificant differences,liberalsversusconservatives 213 9.11 Environmentalbehaviorssignificantdifferences,liberals versusconservatives 214 9.12 IdeologyandlifestylesRoperdata,genderroles 217 9.13 Gender-relatedattitudesandbehaviorsignificant differences,liberalsversusconservatives 219