ebook img

The larva of Cerma hübner and its enigmatic linkages to the acronictinae (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae) PDF

2007·5.2 MB·
Save to my drive
Quick download
Download
Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.

Preview The larva of Cerma hübner and its enigmatic linkages to the acronictinae (Lepidoptera: Noctuidae)

PROC. ENTOMOL. SOC. WASH. 109(1), 2007, pp. 198-207 THE LARVA OF CERMA HUBNER AND ITS ENIGMATIC LINKAGES TO THE ACRONICTINAE (LEPIDOPTERA: NOCTUIDAE) David L. Wagner Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT 06269, U.S.A. (e-mail: [email protected]) — Abstract. The larva of Cerma cerintha (Treitschke) is described and figured and C compared to that of C. cora Hiibner. Both cerintha and C. cora are illustrated with photographs. The presence of only two SV setae on Al and fully-developed prolegs on A3-A6 suggest that Cerma is neither an Acontiinae nor Eustrotiinae, the two subfamilies in which the genus is classified in modern taxonomic works. Morphological and behavioral similarities shared with Acronictafragilis (Guenee), Harrisimemna trisignata (Walker), and other acronictines are discussed: Cerma Hiibner and Harrisimemna Grote appear to have an especially close association. If Cerma proves to be an acronictine, its membership will call into question two ofthe strongest larval characters that have been used to diagnose the dagger moth subfamily: i.e., the presence of secondary setae and two or more setae on the L3 pinaculum on A1-A8. An alternative interpretation for the numbering ofthe L seta on the ninth segment is suggested. It is hypothesized that the aposematic coloration and alarm posture of Cerma are functionally linked to defensive secretions released from the larva's enlarged cervical gland. Key Words: wood tunneling, alarm response, cervical gland, Comachara, Har- risimemna, Polygrammate, aposematic The common, handsomely-colored cora, McDunnough's concept of Cerma adults of Cerma cerintha (Treitschke) included all described members of the are familiar to most eastern moth coUec- bryophiline genus Cryphia Hiibner; C. tors. The forewings, a muddled mix of cerintha was left—in Guenee's Chamyris in white and gray, give the resting moth the the Acontiinae a position unchanged appearance of a bird dropping. Largely from earlier taxonomic works (e.g., Dyar because ofits coloration, C^rmfl c^rmr/?^ et al. 1902 and Holland 1903). Forbes has been classified in or near the (1954) moved C cerintha into Cerma, Acontiinae [it was even described in the excluded all Cryphia, and placed the nominate genus Acontia Ochsenheimer genus nQar Ogdoconta^u\\QY and Perigea by Treitschke (1826)]. For many years Guenee (= Condica Walker) in his two (of the three) North American "isolated Acronyctine genera." (At that species of Cerma Hiibner were not time, Forbes' concept ofthe Acronyctine recognized as congeners. In McDun- [sic] was extremely broad, encompassing nough's (1938) checklist, C cora Hiib- members from ten of Fibiger and La- ner, the type species of the genus, was fontaine's 2005 trifid subfamilies.) treated as a cuculliine. In addition to C Crumb (1956) placed C. cerintha in his VOLUME NUMBER 109, 1 199 — Lithacodiinae an unnatural assemblage 80%, 90%, 95%, 100%) before it was with little allegiance to one another, held placed in a Polaron E 3000 critical point together, in part, by the relative position drying apparatus. The caterpillar was of the stemmata. Most recently Cerma then coated with gold-palladium for has been classified as an acontiine three minutes in a Polaron E 5100 (Franclemont and Todd 1983) or eustro- sputter coater. Images were obtained tiine (Fibiger and Lafontaine 2005). Here with a Zeiss DSM-982 Gemini FE SEM I describe the larva of C. cerintha and at 3^ kv. identify characters that suggest that Cerma might be best placed in the Description — Acronictinae, near to or as the sister of Last instar of Cerma cerintha. Harrisimemna Grote. Length of preserved individuals: 28- mm 31 (n=4). Initially bright lime to Materials and Methods emerald green; integument shiny. Body The description of C cerintha is based wall translucent with tracheal trunk on four mature larvae from a single ex visible. Body constricted between seg- ova cohort reared on Prunus serotina ments (in preserved larvae). Setae long, Ehrh. (Rosaceae). Data for the mother: thickened, mostly black, often from NY: Albany Co., Pine Bush, 42°42'45"N enlarged pinacula. Dorsum cherry red and 73°52'53"W, 25 July 1981, T. L. to smoky maroon with broad white McCabe. Larvae of Cerma cora (NY: subdorsal stripe from Tl to anterior of Albany Co., Pine Bush, 42°42'45"N and A8; stripe narrowing and more likely to 73°52'53"W, mother taken 8 July 1988, include yellow pigment at either end of T. L. McCabe, reared on Prunuspensyl- body. A8-A10 with broad white lateral vanica L. (Rosaceae), n=5) and Harrisi- line that dodges or is broken about memna trisignata (NY: Hamilton Co., spiracle on A8; lateral line subtended Pine Bush, 43°45'30"N and 74°10'14"W, by narrow cherry red patch on A8-A9 mother taken 1 August, 1980, T. L. with ray extending forward across A7 McCabe, reared on Spiraea latifolia and down outer face of anal proleg. (Ait.) Borkh. (Rosaceae), n=4) were also Spiracles pale orange. Middle instars examined. Larval specimens are deposit- lack brick red color over dorsum and ed at the New York State Museum, each lobe of head draws to a point that Albany. bears a single black, bladelike seta. Descriptions of the living larvae are Prepupal larva tending towards glaucous C based on 42 images of cerintha from green, dull, with reddish cast to lateral four different collections of wild larvae areas and subdorsal stripe with pink from Connecticut and Massachusetts tints; noticeably thickened through the and 20 images of C cora larva from abdominal segments; dorsum fading to two collections of wild larvae from smoky maroon. Florida and Ontario. Additionally, Head (Figs. 2-11): Smooth with long, Cerma larvae were compared to images thickened bristlelike setae; secondary of 664 other North American Noctuidae setae absent. Capsule high relative to sensu lato Franclemont and Todd both depth (length) and width (Fig. 5); (1983), including 7 genera and 53 species dark band extending from vertex down ofAcronictinae, housed at the University toward antenna but ending above Al of Connecticut. and second narrower band beginning A single C cerintha larva was pre- under L seta and extending forward pared for SEM study by running it along gena, ending below ocellus 6. through a series of ethanol baths (70%, Triangle short, only about 0.4X height PROCEEDINGS OF THE ENTOMOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON 200 Figs. 1-4. Cermet cerintlui larva. 1, Last instarchaetotaxy map, T1-T2, A1-A2, and A6-A9. 2. Head, frontal. 3. Head, lateral. 4. Mandibles, mesal surfaces. SV2 and SV3 setae onAl andA2 areunnumbered, in part because it appears that SV3 is missing on Al whereas others (e.g., Kitching and Rawlins 1998) state that it is SV2 that is absent. VOLUME NUMBER 109, 1 201 M 202 PROCEEDINGS OF THE ENTOMOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON what quadrangular, deeply cleft. Maxilla caudad. MD, MSD, and MV proprio- as in Fig. 8. Mandible robust with three receptors very reduced (or absent) on the short teeth and central mola (Fig. 4); thoracic and abdominal segments. All mola in end view consisting of two prolegs present, slightly larger caudad; ridges; lower ridge with serrate margin planta long, sometimes with reddish- (Fig. 10). Spinneret short, tubular, with brown plate along outer face (n=l/4). apical pore, no dorsal groove, and no Crochets in a uniordinal mesoseries; lateral flaps (Fig. 9). Hypopharyngeal crochet complement on A3-A6, A10: spines extend to base of labial palpi 26-29, 28-30, 31-32, 32-34, and 29-30, (Fig. 9). respectively (Fig. 16). Anal proleg well Body (Figs. 1, 11-17): Secondary setae developed, longer than combined length absent. All dorsal setae including both of A9-A10 (Fig. 14), with elongate XD on Tl, LI on Tl, all L setae on T2- sclerotized plate on outer surface and A9, and SVl on all segments, very long, smaller plate, roughly half length of brown, thickened, more bristle-like than former, along anterior surface.— hair-like; D2 longer than Dl on abdom- Last Instar of Cerma cora. Length inal segments. Dorsum between D2 of preserved individuals: 26-28 mm (n= pinacula covered by field of brown 3). Aposematic; ground smoky with pavement granules (that appear rusty bright yellow (to orange) and white brown in preserved larvae). A8 humped. markings. Setae long, black, borne from Thorax (Figs. 1, 11, 12, 15).- Protho- enlarged blackened pinacula. A8 strong- racic shield undifferentiated (Fig. 11). ly humped. White middorsal stripe near- XDl and XD2 exceptionally long, ap- ly continuous on thorax; broken over proximately 5X as long as Dl. LI and abdomen, usually expressed anterior to hair-thin L2 included on prothoracic Dl and posterior to D2 pinacula. Broad shield. SD2 short and thin on T1-T3. white, lateral band running between D2 Prominent, midventral cervical gland on and L2 pinacula heavily suffused with Al (Fig. 15). Legs long, subequal to bright yellow and orange, especially on height of segment that bears them. A1-A8; yellow and/or orange spilling Abdomen (Figs. 1, 13, 14, 17): Dl and onto T3 and A9 in some individuals. A9 D2 setae getting progressively longer mostly white with boldly contrasting caudad to AS. Similarly, dorsal pinacula pinacula. Abdominal prolegs with shiny larger, more melanized, and more ele- black plate along outer surface. Spiracles vated to A8; D2 pinaculum on A8 black. Thoracic legs shiny black. Head grossly enlarged and bearing body's black, except for gray-white frons and — longest seta its length often greater adfrontal areas; lower half of frons also than length of A8-A10. D2 seta on A9 pale. also very long and borne from greatly enlarged pinaculum. Dl and SDl pina- Discussion cula fused on A9. SD2 highly reduced. Last instars of Cerma cerintha and C L2 borne from enlarged sclerotized cora are readily distinguished from one pinaculum on A8, 2X length of LI; another: C. cerintha is green with a brick single L2 seta on A9 borne from enlarged red dorsum; C cora is an aposematical- melanized pinaculum. Two SV setae on ly-colored insect, mostly black with Tl; 1 SV seta on T2-T3; 2 SV on Al; 3 yellow and white markings. In C cora, on A2-A6; 1 on A7-A9; SVl much all the large setae of the thorax and longer than SV2 and SV3 on A2 (Figs. 1, abdomen are borne from blackened 13). V setae closely approximate on Tl, pinacula, the setae are generally longer more distantly and progressively longer and more darkly pigmented, and the VOLUME NUMBER 109, 1 203 Figs. 11-17. Scanning electron micrographs oflast instar Cerma cerintha; head to left. 11, Head and Tl. 12, T3. 13, A1-A2. 14, A7-A10. 15, Cervical gland on venter of Tl. 16, Crochets on A3. 17, Caudal segments. prolegs on A3-A7 bear a strongly mel- Larval characters shared by C. cer- anized plate. Dl and D2 are subequal in intha and C cora that reinforce their length in cerintha, while D2 is halfagain congeneric status include the presence of as long as Dl in cora. The D pinacula are a field of brownish dorsal pavement fused on T2 and approximate over T3 in granules from (at least) T2 back to A9; C. cerintha; but well separated on both deep constrictions between segments (in T2 and T3 in cora. preserved larvae); exceptionally long, 204 PROCEEDINGS OF THE ENTOMOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON strongly-pigmented, thickened primary circumscribe acronictines: verrucae, sec- setae, the longest being PI on the head, ondary setae, and the presence of extra XDl and XD2 on Tl, and D2 on A8 and setae on the L3 pinaculum on A1-A8 A9, with latter often exceeding the (Crumb 1956; Kitching and Rawlins combined length of A8 AlO; elongated 1998; Beck 1999, 2000). One character planta, nearly as long as the segment that linking Cerma to acronictines (and arc- bears it on A3 A6, and the absence of tiids) is the fusion of the dorsal pinacula secondary setae. The degree to which the over T2 and near fusion of the dorsal D2 pinaculum is enlarged on A8 in both pinacula on T3 (in C cerintha only). insects is exceptional. A significant syna- Based on my collections of noctuid pomorphy for the two species is the larvae and larval images (representing reduction of the SD2 seta on the 664 species of North American Noctui- abdominal segments and the MD, dae), Cerma shows greatest similarity to MSD, and MV proprioreceptors on the members of the Acronictinae, and in thoracic and abdominal segments. In particular Acronicta fragilis (Guenee) addition, the cervical gland on Tl and Harrisimemna trisignata (Walker). (Fig. 15) appears to be well developed Habitus proportions, posture, setal in the larvae of both Cernui. Finally, girths and lengths, and development of both feed on woody members of the the dorsal pinacula are reminiscent of Rosaceae, especially Crataegus, Primus, those of A. fragilis. and related species (Tietz 1972; Robin- Harrisimemna and Cerma sharea num- son et al. 2002). ber of similarities: both have thickened, darkly-pigmented dorsal setae that are Linkages to Acronictinae borne from enlarged, black, pimplelike Larval characters exclude Cerma from pinacula (Figs. 18-21). In C cora and H. membership in either the Acontiinae or trisignata, A2 is modestly swollen later- Eustrotiinae, the two subfamilies in ally and dorsally-this segment has the which the genus has most recently re- widest girth of any of the anterior body sided (Franclemont and Todd 1983; segments; Al and A3 are somewhat Covell 2005, and Fibiger and Lafontaine smaller in girth; all three segments have 2005). Prolegs are absent on A3 and a greater circumference than that of T3. sometimes A4 in the former subfamily The eighth abdominal segment bears an and from A3 in the latter subfamily. enormous dorsal hump in H. trisignata, Cerma has a full complement ofprolegs. a prominent dorsal hump in C cora, but No Acontiinae or Eustrotiinae possess only a low swelling in C cerintha (at the long, thick, pigmented setae as do C midline, A8 is about 0.2X higher than cerintha and C cora. Cerma have prom- the height of A9). In C cora and H. inent, raised pinacula, with those on A8 trisignata, A8 is arched high above the (especiall—y the D2 pinacula) grossly adjacent segments. The pl—anta is un- enlarged similar pinacula are not pres- usually long in both genera in Cerma, ent in acontiines or eustrotiines. Acon- the height of the planta is subequal to tiines have greatly thicke—ned setae on the that of the segment from which it issues anal plate (Crumb 1956) no such setae on A3-A6 (Fig. 21). The planta of are present in Cerma. Harrisimemna is also elongate (Fig. 20). While it is clear that Cerma is neither In describing H. marmarota Hampson, an acontiine nor eustrotiine, the argu- an East Asian species, Yamamoto and ment that Cerma is an acronictine is Sugi (1987) noted that it possessed C C weaker. cerintha and cora lack the "extraordinary [sic] long prolegs." Addi- most commonly identified features to tionally, the planta bears a strongly VOLUME NUMBER 109, 1 205 Figs. 18-21. Last instars of Cernia and Harrisimemna. 18, C ceriiuha. 19, C cora. 20, Defensive posture of H. trisignata. As is commonly the case in Harrisimenma, a previously shed head capsule is adheringtothecaterpillar'sprothoracicsetae. 21, DefensivepostureofC cora. Notedisplayoflongblack thoracic legs in both. melanized (armored) plate on A3-A6 in segments). This posture exposes the H. trisignata and C. cora (but only 1 of4 larva's cervical gland (Fig. 15) located ofthe C. cerintha larvae examined). Both between the prothoracic coxae. (Presum- Cerma and Harrisimemna possess stout, ably this posture and the aposematic C armored anal prolegs with an elongate coloration of cora larvae will be found sclerotized plate running along the outer to be functionally linked to a defensive face on the proleg and a smaller sclerite secretion released from the gland). In the along the anterior face of the proleg. At preserved specimens of both Cerma rest the long anal prolegs splay outward (n=9) and Harrisimemna (n=4) a portion behind the body in each. of the gland is everted. This 'spigot' is Both genera share similarities in their especially well developed in the latter alarm responses. An extremely rapid genus, extending outward 1.6 mm from (blurring) side-to-side shaking response the venter of the thorax in last instars occurs in both Harrisimemna trisignata (nearly reaching the spinneret in some and Cerma cerintha. A shared alarm individuals). Although a cervical gland posture has been observed in larvae of capable of discharging defensive secre- H. trisignata and both Cerma species: tions is known in notodontids (Weath- disturbed larvae arch the head up and erston et al. 1979; Attygalle et al. 1993) back and extend the long, often black- and the noctuid Spodoptera Guenee ened, thoracic legs outward (Figs. 20-21) (Marti and Rogers 1988), and may prove {H. trisignata may also lift the caudal to be part of the noctuoid groundplan, I 206 PROCEEDINGS OF THE ENTOMOLOGICAL SOCIETY OF WASHINGTON expect that its development in Cerma, family (presence of secondary setae and Harrisimemna, and other acronictines presence of one or more extra setae on will be found to be elaborated relative the L3 pinaculum). Other morphological to most noctuid lineages. The presence of and molecular data are needed to cor- a defensive secretion would explain the roborate or refute the character evidence comparatively conspicuous perching be- presented here. As importantly, if Cerma haviors of some Acrouicta (e.g., A. proves to be an acronictine, additional impleta Walker, A. morula Grote &. data will help to clarify the position of Robinson, and A. hasta Guenee), which the genus within the subfamily. perch on leaf uppersides by day, and the bright 'warning' coloration of Cenna Acknowledgments cora and other acronictines (e.g., Acro- Tim McCabe supplied last instars of nGi.ct&a oRb.l,inAit.al(oJ.ngEa.GSumeintehe),, aA.ndfuSneirmaylrias Cerma cerintha, C cora, and Harrisi- henrici (Grote) (see Wagner 2005). memna trisignata. Rene Twarkins assem- bled the artwork and digital images for Cerma, and three acronictine genera, Comachara Franclemont, Harrisimemna, the plates. Jim Romanow helped with the scanning electron microscopy. Eric and Polygrammate Hiibner, tunnel deep into wood as prepupae (Wagner 2005; Quinter, Jadranka Rota, and J. Boiling Wagner et al. 2006). In the case of Sullivan provided helpful suggestions on Harrisimemna, the caterpillars can bore drafts of the manuscript. The reviews of Don Lafontaine and Michael Pogue into solid woods, e.g., dry indoor fir molding (Pat Burkett personal commu- were especially helpful. Financial sup- nication). The enlarged hump over A8, port came from the U.S. Department of elongate prolegs, and sclerotized plates Agriculture, Forest Services, Forest on the anal prolegs of Cerma and Health Technology Enterprise Team, Harrisimemna may be functionally re- cooperative agreement number 01-CA- lated to the biomechanics of tunneling 11244225-215 to DLW. Discover Life in into wood. America provided monetary support and The weight of the evidence suggests lodging for the work carried out in Great that Cerma, despite its exceptional chae- Smoky Mountains National Park. totaxy, is closely related to the acronic- Literature Cited tine genus Harrisimemna. The latter genus is unequivocally acronictine in Attygalle, A. B.. S. R. Smedley, J. Meinwald, and T. Eisner. 1993. Defensive secretion of two nature: it possesses larval characters notodontid caterpillars {Schizura unicornis, S. noted above as being characteristic of badia). Journal of Chemical Ecology 19: acronictines; it has acronictine forewing 2089-2104. patterning; it shares a seemingly unique Beck, H. 1999—. Die Larven der Europaischen tunneling/ball-rolling behavior with the Noctuidae Revision der Systematik der Noc- acronictine genera Comachara and Poly- tuidae. Herbipolianna 5. Volumes 1, 2. Verlag Dr. UlfEitschberger, Marktleuthen, Germany. grammate (Wagner et al. 2006, unpub- 859 pp. + 447 pp. lished data); and has been treated as an 2000. Die Larven der Europaischen . — acronictine by all modern noctuid work- Noctuidae Revision der Systematik der Noc- ers (e.g., Forbes 1954; Crumb 1956; tuidae. Herbipolianna 5. Volumes 3, 4. Verlag Franclemont and Todd 1983; Yama- Dr. UlfEitschberger, Marktleuthen, Germany. mCoetromaainndthSeugAicro1n9i8c7)t.inaTeh,ewionuclldusnieognatoef Covelo3lf3,6ECpa.ps.vt.e,+rnJ5r.1N22o0rp0pt5.h. AAmFeireilcda.Gui2"d'e^ tEod.theViMrogitnhisa the most widely cited larval characters MuseumofNatural History, Martinsville, VA. believed to uniquely identify the sub- 496 pp. VOLUME NUMBER 109, 1 207 Crumb, S. E. 1956. The caterpillars of the McDunnough, J. 1938. Checklist of the Lepidop- Phalaenidae. U.S. Department of Agriculture tera of Canada and the United States of Technical Bulletin, 1135, Washington, DC. America. Part 1. Macrolepidoptera. Memoirs 356 pp. of the Southern California Academy of Dyar, H. G., C. H. Fernald, G. D. Hulst, and A. Sciences. 272 pp. Busck. 1902. A List of the North American Robinson, G. S., P. R. Ackery, I. J. Kitching, G. Lepidoptera and Key to the Literature ofThis W. Beccaloni, and L. M. Hernandez. 2002. Order of Insects. Bulletin of the National Hostplants of the Moth and Butterfly Cater- Museum 52, 723 pp. pillars ofAmerica North ofMexico. Memoirs Fibiger, M. andJ. D. Lafontaine. 2005. Areviewof of the American Entomological Institute, the higher classification of the Noctuoidea Gainesville, Florida. Volume 69. 824 pp. (Lepidoptera) with special reference to the Tietz, H. M. 1972. An Index to the Described Life Holarctic fauna. Esperiana. Buchreihe zur Histories, Early Stages and Hosts of the Entomologie 11: 1-205. Macrolepidoptera of the Continental United Forbes, W. T. M. 1954. Lepidoptera ofNew York StatesandCanada(2volumes). Allyn Museum and Neighboring States, Part IIL Cornell ofEntomology, Sarasota, Florida. 1041 pp. University Agricultural Experiment Station, Treitschke, F. 1826. Die Schmetterlinge von Ithaca, NY, Memoir 329. 433 pp. Europa. Volume 5. Abteilung 3. Leipzig. Franclemont, J. G. and E. L. Todd. 1983. Gerhard Fleischer, 420 pp. Noctuidae, pp. 120-159. In Hodges, R. W., et Wagner, D. L. 2005. Caterpillars ofEastern North al., eds. Check List of the Lepidoptera of America: A Guide to Identification and America North of Mexico, E.W. Classey Ltd. and The Wedge Entomological Research Natural History. Princeton University Press, Foundation. Cambridge Univ. Press, Cam- 512 pp. bridge, United Kingdom. Wagner, D. L., E. W. Hossler, and F. E. Hossler. Holland, W. J. 1903. The Moth Book: A Guide to 2006. Not a Tiger but a Dagger: The larva of the Moths of North America. Doubleday, Comachara cadburyi and reassignment of the Page, and Co., New York. 479 pp. genus to the Acronictinae (Lepidoptera: Noc- Kitching, I. J. and J. E. Rawlins. 1998. The tuidae). Annals of the Entomological Society Noctuoidea, pp. 355-^01. In Kristensen, N. ofAmerica 99: 638-647. P., ed. Lepidoptera, Moths and Butterflies. Weatherston, J., J. E. Percy, L. M. MacDonald, Volume 1: Evolution, Systematics, and Bio- and J. A. MacDonald. 1979. Morphology of geography. Handbook for Zoology. Volu- the prothoracic defensive gland of Schizura me IV. Arthropoda: Insecta, Walter de Gruy- concinna (J.E. Smith) (Lepidoptera: Notodon- ter, Berlin. tidae) and the nature of its secretion. Journal Marti, O. G. and C. E. Rogers. 1988. Anatomy of ofChemical Ecology 5: 165-177. the ventral eversible gland of fall armyworm, Yamamoto, M. and S. Sugi. 1987. Noctuidae Spodoptera frugiperda (Lepidoptera Noctui- excluding Herminiinae. pp. 185-238. In Sugi, dae), larvae. Annals of the Entomological S., ed. Larvae ofthe Larger Moths ofJapan. Society ofAmerica 81: 308-317. Toppan Printing Co., Ltd., Tokyo, Japan.

See more

The list of books you might like

Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.