ebook img

The Journal of Island and Coastal Archaeology Early Archaic Fishing PDF

18 Pages·2015·0.47 MB·English
by  
Save to my drive
Quick download
Download
Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.

Preview The Journal of Island and Coastal Archaeology Early Archaic Fishing

This article was downloaded by: [Universidad de Chile] On: 26 June 2015, At: 08:26 Publisher: Routledge Informa Ltd Registered in England and Wales Registered Number: 1072954 Registered office: Mortimer House, 37-41 Mortimer Street, London W1T 3JH, UK The Journal of Island and Coastal Archaeology Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information: http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/uica20 Early Archaic Fishing (12,600–9,200 cal yr BP) in the Semiarid North Coast of Chile Philippe Béareza, Donald Jacksonb & Noémy Mollaretc a UMR 7209 CNRS / USM 0303 MNHN, Archéozoologie, Archéobotanique: Sociétés, Pratiques et Environnements, Department of Écologie et Gestion de la Biodiversité, Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle, Paris Cedex, France Click for updates b Departamento de Antropología, Facultad de Ciencias Sociales, Universidad de Chile, Santiago, Chile c Direction des Collections, Invertébrés Marins, Muséum National d’Histoire Naturelle, Paris Cedex, France Published online: 12 Jan 2015. To cite this article: Philippe Béarez, Donald Jackson & Noémy Mollaret (2015) Early Archaic Fishing (12,600–9,200 cal yr BP) in the Semiarid North Coast of Chile, The Journal of Island and Coastal Archaeology, 10:1, 133-148, DOI: 10.1080/15564894.2014.940096 To link to this article: http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/15564894.2014.940096 PLEASE SCROLL DOWN FOR ARTICLE Taylor & Francis makes every effort to ensure the accuracy of all the information (the “Content”) contained in the publications on our platform. However, Taylor & Francis, our agents, and our licensors make no representations or warranties whatsoever as to the accuracy, completeness, or suitability for any purpose of the Content. Any opinions and views expressed in this publication are the opinions and views of the authors, and are not the views of or endorsed by Taylor & Francis. The accuracy of the Content should not be relied upon and should be independently verified with primary sources of information. Taylor and Francis shall not be liable for any losses, actions, claims, proceedings, demands, costs, expenses, damages, and other liabilities whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in connection with, in relation to or arising out of the use of the Content. This article may be used for research, teaching, and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic reproduction, redistribution, reselling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply, or distribution in any form to anyone is expressly forbidden. Terms & Conditions of access and use can be found at http://www.tandfonline.com/page/terms- and-conditions 5 1 0 2 e n u J 6 2 6 2 8: 0 at ] e hil C e d d a d si r e v ni U [ y b d e d a o nl w o D JournalofIsland&CoastalArchaeology,10:133–148,2015 Copyright©2015Taylor&FrancisGroup,LLC ISSN:1556-4894print /1556-1828online DOI:10.1080/15564894.2014.940096 Early Archaic Fishing (12,600–9,200 cal yr BP) in the Semiarid North Coast of Chile Philippe Be´arez,1 Donald Jackson,2 and Noe´my Mollaret3 1UMR7209CNRS/USM0303MNHN,Arch´eozoologie,Arch´eobotanique: Soci´et´es,PratiquesetEnvironnements,DepartmentofE´cologieetGestiondela Biodiversit´e,Mus´eumNationald’HistoireNaturelle,ParisCedex,France 2DepartamentodeAntropolog´ıa,FacultaddeCienciasSociales,Universidad deChile,Santiago,Chile 5 3DirectiondesCollections,Invert´ebr´esMarins,Mus´eumNationald’Histoire 1 20 Naturelle,ParisCedex,France e n u J 6 2 ABSTRACT 6 2 08: Wepresenttheresultsoftheanalysisoffishremainsfromanarchae- at ologicalcontext(PuntaN˜agu´e)associatedwiththeearliestsettlersin e] thesemiaridnortherncoastofChileanddatedtotheendofthePleis- hil tocene (12,916–11,043 cal yr BP). The great majority of the species C e identifiedarefishthatcanbecapturedwithnetsinthenearshoresub- d d tidalandinter-tidalzones.Theseresults,alongwithevidencefromother da earlyarchaeologicalsitesinnorthernChile,demonstratetheearlysys- si tematicexploitationoffishspecies,particularlySciaenidae.Thesefish r e v constitutedanabundantandreliableresource,whichcontributedsig- Uni nificantly to the subsistence of these early maritime-adapted settlers y [ whopopulatedthePacificcoastofSouthAmerica. b d de Keywords coastal migration route, marine resources, maritime adaptation, Terminal oa Pleistocene,WesternSouthAmerica nl w o D INTRODUCTION portfromtheexistenceofearlyarchaeolog- ical sites along the Pacific Coast of North The hypothesis that the earliest settlers of America(DesLauriers2006;Erlandsonetal. theAmericasfollowedacoastalroute(Dixon 2011; Jones et al. 2002) to South Amer- 2001;Erlandsonetal.2007;Fladmark1979; ica (DeFrance et al. 2001; Dillehay et al. Surovell 2003) is increasingly gaining sup- 2012;Jacksonetal.2011;Lavalle´eandJulien Received1April2014;accepted23June2014. Address correspondence to Philippe Be´arez, UMR 7209 CNRS / USM 0303 MNHN, Arche´ozoologie, Arche´obotanique:Socie´te´s,PratiquesetEnvironnements,DepartmentofE´cologieetGestiondelaBio- diversite´,Muse´umNationald’HistoireNaturelle,CP56,55RueBuffon,75231ParisCedex05,France. E-mail:[email protected] Color versions of one or more of the figures in the article can be found online at http://www.tandfonline.com/uica. 133 Philippe Be´arez et al. 2012;Sandweisset al. 1998;Stothert 1988; ploitationisnottheonlyindicatorofaquatic Stothert and Quilter 1991). In this context, adaptations, their presence is highly signif- thefirstcoastaladaptationsinnorthernChile icant. Fish are mobile species with varied are known as the “Huentelauque´n Cultural habits, which requires fishers to have spe- Complex”,identifiedfromnumerousarchae- cificethologicalandtechnicalknowledgein ological sites spread along the arid coast order to capture them. Thus, the exploita- (24◦ S) to the southern extreme of the tionofadiverseandabundantichthyofauna semiaridcoast(31◦ S).Severalofthesesites implies that fishers had a deeply rooted are dated to the beginningof the late Pleis- coastal knowledge base. Furthermore, fish toceneandEarlyHolocene,betweenabout appeartobetheprincipalsourceofproteins 13,000 and 9,000 years ago (Jackson et al. andfattyacids,which,alongwithotherre- 2011;JacksonandMe´ndez2005;Llagostera sources, provided a reliable sustenance for 1977,1979;Llagosteraetal.2000). thesecoastalpopulations. Thesearchaeologicalsites,usuallyshell Inthisarticle,wepresenttheresultsof middens,representcampswithareasassoci- thestudyoffishremainsrecoveredatPunta 5 atedwithmolluscprocessingandfoodcon- N˜ague´ (LV 098A), a Late Pleistocene/Early 1 20 sumption, and areas destined for the pro- Holocenecoastalsiteinthesemiaridregion e cessing, use, and discarding of lithic tools ofnorthernChile(Jacksonetal.2011;Jack- n Ju (Jackson et al. 1999). The stratigraphy pro- son et al. 1999). The set of taxonomic in- 26 vides evidence of the exploitation of pri- formation,thequantitativeanalysis(sizeand 6 marilymarineresources,includingmolluscs, weight)ofthefishremains,alongwithcon- 2 8: crustaceans,echinoderms,fish,andmarine text data allowed us to identify the species 0 at mammals,aswellasbirdsandafewspecies representedinthemidden,theirformofcap- ] of terrestrial mammals (camelids, carni- ture, and their relative contribution to the e hil vores, and rodents). The lithic technology dietoftheHuentelauque´ngroupsthatinhab- C associated with these sites includes bifa- ited the site of Punta N˜ague´. These results e d cial projectiles, knives, scrapers, sharpen- arecomparedwiththeanalysisoftheichthy- ad ers,and,occasionally,grindingtools,among ofaunaoftwootherEarlyHolocenesitesin d si other elements, such as some unique geo- northern Chile: La Chimba 13 (Llagostera r e metric stone objects also known as cogged 1979; Llagostera et al. 1997) and Huente- v ni stones(Jacksonetal.1999;Llagostera1979; lauque´n(Weisneretal.2000). U [ Weisneretal.2000). y b This Huentelauque´n Cultural Complex d onthesemiaridnortherncoastofChilemight e d a represent two, possibly diachronic, main nlo types of settlement patterns. The first one STUDYAREAANDARCHAEOLOGICAL w correspondstoacentralbase-dispersedpat- CONTEXT o D tern along the coast, with a strong empha- sisontheprocurementofmarineresources; The study area is located in the semiarid whereas the second, a possibly more re- coastofChile(31◦S),inthetransitionalzone centpattern,isfocusedonsmallinlandval- between the dry region in the north and leys(quebradas),withemphasisonhunting theMediterranean-climateregionincentral and gathering (Jackson and Me´ndez 2005), Chile,characterizedbydrysummersandlow with eventual movements towards valleys winter rainfall due to the quasi-permanent andmountainenvironments(Galarce2004; presenceoftheSouthPacificSubtropicalAn- Jackson1998). ticyclone (Van Husen 1967). This zone is Asignificantformofevidencethatlends highly susceptible to the annual variations support to the theory that these early set- associatedwiththephenomenonofElNin˜o tlementsrepresentcoastaladaptationsisthe SouthernOscillation(ENSO).DuringElNin˜o existenceofadiverseandabundantichthy- events,thewinterweatherconditionsareex- ofauna.Whilenohumanpopulationhasde- ceptionally warm and wet in central Chile, pended exclusively on fish, just as fish ex- whileduringLaNin˜aphase,abnormallycold 134 VOLUME10•ISSUE1• 2015 Early Archaic Fishing in the North Coast of Chile 5 1 0 2 e n u J 6 2 6 2 8: 0 at ] e hil C e d d a d si r e v ni U [ y b ed Figure1. MapofthestudyareashowingtheearlyarchaeologicalsitesofthenorthcoastofChile: ad PuntaN˜agu´e(LV098A),Huentelauqu´en,andLaChimba13. o nl w o anddryconditionsprevailinthissameregion 10,500 cal BP, followed by a wetter period D (Aceituno1988). attestedbythedominanceofcoastalshrubs PollenrecordsfromthecoastofLosVilos andthespreadofswampyhabitatbetween indicatethespreadofswampyforesttaxaca. ca.10,500and9,500calBP(Maldonadoetal. 13,300calBP,whichsuggeststhatcoldand 2010).Anincreaseinherbaceousandshrub wet conditions prevailed during this time taxaafterca.9,500calBPindicatesareturn (Villagr´an and Varela 1990). Towards the todrierconditions,consistentwiththepro- beginningoftheEarlyHolocene,anabrupt cessofwidespreadregionalaridificationdur- changeisattestedbyadeclineinmarshand ingtheEarlytoMiddleHolocene(Maldonado aquatic species, as well as a decline in the andVillagr´an2006). richnessofsemiaridscrublandintheregion Otoliths from the site of La Chimba (Villagr´an and Varela 1990). These results 13 (previously known as Quebrada Las are consistent with the data obtained from Conchas), located in the northern arid re- QuebradaSantaJulia,whichindicateadrier gion of Chile (23◦ S), provide evidence climatethantodaybetweenca.11,200and of limited variations in the oceanographic JOURNALOFISLAND&COASTALARCHAEOLOGY 135 Philippe Be´arez et al. 5 1 0 2 e n u J 6 2 26 Figure2. CoastalenvironmentatPuntaN˜agu´eandlocationofthearchaeologicalsite(LV098A): 8: viewfromtheSouth. 0 at ] hile conditions during the Early Holocene, al- Closetothesite(∼500m)thereisaper- C though the presence of Micropogonias al- manent source of drinking water that was e tipinnis indicates the flow of warm wa- probably available when the settlement of d d ters from the north into the region dur- PuntaN˜ague´wasoccupied.Thesiteissitu- a d ing the stated period (Llagostera 1979; atedamongdepositsofpaleodunesinalon- rsi Llagosteraetal.1997). gitudinal depression (100 × 40 m). Two e niv Within this context, the settlement of distinct areas can be distinguished: a zone U PuntaN˜ague´(LV098A)isfoundonthecoast for processing, using, and discarding lithic [ y of the province of Choapa, in the south- tools; and another area containing numer- b d ern extreme of the northern semiarid re- ousshellmoundswheredomesticactivities e d gion of Chile (Figure 1). It is located on a tookplace,nexttoseveralhearthsassociated a o small peninsula that is part of a marine ter- withlithictools(includingprojectilepoints, nl w race(25m.a.s.l.),coveredwiththedeposits knives, scrapers, sharpeners, and grinding Do ofpartiallyshiftingpaleodunesystems.The stone),wastefromprocessingandreuse,as easternshoreadjacenttothesettlementisa wellaspreformsofgeometricstoneobjects, protectedbaywithaseriesofsandybeaches, micro-mortars,engravedplatesandnecklace whilethesouthwestsideisanexposedrocky beads.Therawmaterialsusedforthelithic shore with rich marine biodiversity (Fig- artifactsareoflocalorigin. ure2). The shell mounds are composed of a Todaythesiteislocatedadjacenttothe greatvarietyofmolluscspecies(gastropods coastline on a high marine terrace, but at and bivalves), as well as some crustaceans the time of the first human occupation the and echinoderms. The vertebrate fauna in- sea was about 10 km off the current coast- cludesmarinemammals(Otariaflavescens, line(Ortegaetal.2012).Despitechangesin Arctocephalusaustralis,andLontrafelina), post-glacialsealevels,thesitewasneversub- whichforthemostpartarrivedcompleteat merged.Thisconditionmadethesiteacces- the site, especially the juvenile specimens sibleinthepastandallowedthepreservation (Hern´andez 2007). In addition to the fish ofthesitetoday(Jacksonetal.2011). remains that are the focus of this study, 136 VOLUME10•ISSUE1• 2015 Early Archaic Fishing in the North Coast of Chile it was also possible to record several bird lauque´n Cultural Complex on the coast of species(Spheniscussp.,Phalacrocoraxsp., Choapa,correspondingtoresidentialcamps Pelecanusthagus),fiverodentspecies,two andworkcamps(JacksonandMe´ndez2005; of which were eaten (Octodon sp. and Llagosteraetal.2000),areprobablyrelated Abrocoma bennetti) as their remains were tothelowerandmiddleculturalsequencesat associated with a hearth, and a few re- PuntaN˜ague´,formingpartofthesamesettle- mainsofguanaco(Lamaguanicoe)andfox mentsystemalongthesemiaridnorthcoast (Lycalopexsp.). ofChile. Thestratigraphyshowsthatthearchaeo- logicaldepositsconsistofmolluscsandother culturalremainswithinasandymatrixwith auniformcolorandgrainsize.Threecultural sequenceswereidentified.Thefirstoneisa MATERIALSANDMETHODS lowersequence,10cmthick,consistingof adiscontinuousshellmiddenwithfewasso- ThefaunalremainswererecoveredatPunta 5 ciatedartifactsanddominatedbythegastro- N˜ague´(LV098A)duringexcavationscarried 1 20 pod Concholepas concholepas. A thin ster- out between 1996 and 2004. The excava- e ilelayerseparatesthemiddlesequencefrom tions covered a total area of 61 m2 with an n Ju the lower one. The second sequence iden- estimatedvolumeof16.4m3(Table2).The 26 tified,themiddlesequence,is30cmthick, faunal remains were sorted, and only fish 6 andwascomposedofseveralshellmounds remains have been studied in detail at this 2 8: ofmostlyMesodesmadonacium,associated stage.Fishremainsrecoveredfromtheupper 0 at with hearths, abundant marine faunal re- cultural sequence were excluded from the ] mainsandtracesoftheprocessing,use,and present analysis because they were scarce e hil discardingofartifacts.Finally,theuppercul- (NISP = 73), which does not seem to be C turalsequence,35cmthick,includedanex- related to differential preservation. Fish re- e d tensiveshellmiddenconsistingmainlyofC. mainsconsistedofbones,mainlyvertebrae, ad concholepas,associatedwithvertebratere- andotoliths(Figure3).Thegeneralpreserva- d si mainsandlithictools.Inalltheculturalse- tionwaspoor;however,asignificantnumber r e quences we recorded evidence of hearths of remains were sufficiently well-preserved v ni adjacent to the shell mounds that were the forpropertaxonomicidentification. [U locusofthemaindomesticactivities,suchas Excavationswerecarriedoutin2×2m by foodconsumptionandtoolmaking. units,followingthenaturalstratigraphyand d Sixradiocarbondates(Table1)placethe furtherseparatedintoartificiallevels.Allsed- e ad identified cultural sequences in chronolog- iments were sieved through 4 mm mesh o nl ical order. Two 14C dates are on charcoal, screens to recover all cultural remains. Ad- w whiletheremainingsamplesweredatedon ditionally, two soil samples (3 L) were ex- o D shells of marine molluscs. For shells, the tracted from each square meter and level: dates were calibrated considering a correc- onewassievedthroughafinemeshscreen tionforthemarinereservoireffect,estimated (2 mm), and the other was used for flota- in 911 ± 278 years [R + (cid:2)R = 400 + tion. In addition to the recovery of organic (511 ± 278)] for the Early Holocene at remains(charcoalandseeds),thisprocedure these latitudes (Ortlieb et al. 2011). All the allowed us to evaluate the loss of fish re- datescanbeplacedaroundthePleistocene- mains from the use of wide mesh screens HolocenetransitionandtheEarlyHolocene. (4mm).Theresultsindicateonlyaminorloss Only the lower and middle cultural se- ofichthyoarchaeologicalmaterialbuthigher quences can be positively attributed to the ratesoffragmentation(Didier2000). Huentelauque´nCulturalComplex,whilethe The locations of features, artifacts, and upper sequence can be attributed to an- other remains were recorded during the otherculturalphaseregionallyknownasthe excavation in order to create distribution PapudoCulturalComplex(Me´ndezandJack- plans.Profiledrawingsrecordedthestratig- son2006).OthersettlementsoftheHuente- raphyoftheexcavationunits,allowingusto JOURNALOFISLAND&COASTALARCHAEOLOGY 137 5 5 5 5 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 2 2 z z z z e de de de de nc ´en ´en ´en ´en e M M M M r e d d d d Ref an an cle an an cle son son arti son son arti k k s k k s c c hi c c hi Ja Ja T Ja Ja T 2 2 2 8 0 9 1 7 ◦N 10 68 56 27 10 18 ab. L-1 -10 680 -55 -94 -34 15 L NSR Beta OS- Beta Beta Beta 0 2 e n 26 Ju ple shell shell al shell shell al 8:26 Sam arine arine harco arine arine harco 0 M M C M M C at ] e hil ) C a m y [Universidad de 98A). CalyrBP (Res.effect,2sig 12,630–11094 12,038–10,341 / 11,180–9,708 10,627–9,258 / b 0 d V e L d ( Downloa ˜´PuntaNague CalyrBP (2sigma) / / 2,664–12,040 / / 0,491–10,183 m 1 1 o r f s date BP ±80±70±50±80±60±40 carbon 14Cyr 11,100 10,600 10,550 10.120 9,730 9,160 o di a R e 1. al nc Table Cultur seque Lower Lower Lower Middle Middle Middle 138 Early Archaic Fishing in the North Coast of Chile Table2. ExcavatedareaandvolumebyculturalsequenceatPuntaN˜ague´(LV098A). Culturalsequence Excavatedarea Estimatedvolume Upper 9m2 4.4m3 Middle 32m2 86m3 Lower 20m2 3.4m3 Total 61m2 16.4m3 5 1 0 2 e n u J 6 2 6 2 8: 0 at ] e hil C e d d a d si r e v ni U [ y b d e d a o nl w o D Figure3. OtolithsofthemainsciaenidspeciesidentifiedatPuntaN˜agu´e(LV098A):a–bSciaena deliciosa;c–dCilusgilberti.Scalebar:1cm. JOURNALOFISLAND&COASTALARCHAEOLOGY 139 Philippe Be´arez et al. definethedistinctculturalsequencesofthe W =0.000013761 × TL2,9651, cg sitemoreclearly. Fishremainswereidentifiedtothemost whereTListotallengthoffish,OHisotolith precise taxonomic level possible (genus or height,andWisliveweightoffish.Species species level) based on direct comparison name abbreviations are sd for S. deliciosa withskeletonsfromthereferencecollection andcgforC.gilberti.Measurementunitsare housedattheMuse´umnationald’histoirena- millimetersandgrams. turelle(Paris,France).Specimensofalltaxa Radiocarbondateswerecalibratedto2 were counted and weighed to 0.01 g. Ba- sigmaswithOxcal4.2(BronkRamsey2009) sic quantification of taxa was calculated as withthecurveShCal13(Hoggetal.2013)and NumberofIdentifiedSpecimens(NISP)and expressedincalibratedyearsbeforepresent specimenweight.TheMinimumNumberof (calBP).Themarinereservoireffectwasesti- Individuals (MNI) was estimated based on matedin911 ± 278years[R + (cid:2)R=400 + laterality and size for paired specimens or (511 ± 278)]followingOrtliebetal.(2011), bydividingtheNISPbythenumberofpos- and this correction was used for all marine 15 sible specimens per individual in the case dates. 20 ofunpairedspecimens(vertebrae,forexam- e ple).Theoriginallivesizeandweightofthe n 26 Ju fiwsihthwreefreereensctiemsakteedletboynsdiorrecutsicnogmapllaormisoent- RESULTS 6 ric regression formulae applied to otoliths 2 Atotalof9265fishbones,weighing782.7g, 08: (Be´arez 2000). The relationship between were examined (Table 3). Of these, 4092 at bodyweightorlengthandspecimenweight (532g)couldbeidentified,withalargema- e] orlengthisbestdescribedbyapowerequa- joritytakentospecieslevel(91%ofNISP).In hil tion,takingintoaccountallometricgrowth spiteoftheabundanceofvertebrae,which C (HuxleyandTeissier1936): e are often more difficult to identify, and the d d rather poor conservation of the bony ele- da Y=aXb. ments,thisgivesagoodidentificationratio si of 44% by NISP, and 68% by weight. The r e v otolithsarewellrepresentedandpreserved Uni The maximal length and height of each (Figure 3), with a total of 329, mostly from by [ swaigtihttaad(isgaitcacluclaalripoetrotloith0).01wmerme,mfoellaoswurinedg sucsieadenfoidrssi(z9e5r%e)c.oTnwstorusecttsioonf:o1to1l2itfhosrcSociualdenbae d Schwarzhans (1993). The weight was also e deliciosaand197forCilusgilberti. oad measured to the nearest 0.01 g. Then the Almostalloftheidentifiedtaxaarebony nl regression formulae established by Be´arez fish(Teleostei)belongingto16families,16 w (2012)wasappliedtothetwomainsciaenids o genera,andatleast23species(Table3).Four D identified among the fish remains: Sciaena familiesrepresent83%oftheNISP,i.e.,Sci- deliciosa (Tschudi 1846) and Cilus gilberti aenidae (drums) with 30% (60.7% of bone (Abbott 1899). The adopted method is a weight),Clupeidae(menhadens)with21%, two-stepmethod(seeCasteel1976).Otolith Haemulidae (grunts) with 20%, and Aplo- heightwaschosenformeasurementbecause dactylidae (marblefishes) with 12%. Carti- itisthedimensionmostfrequentlypreserved laginousfishes(Chondrichthyes)arealmost whensagittaearebroken.Theequationsare entirely absent, being represented by only thefollowing: twovertebraefromanangelshark(Squatina armata). TL =18.989 × OH1,5584, Thevarietyofidentifiedspeciesincludes sd fishfromsandyhabitatsandespeciallyfrom rockyshores.Themullet(Mugilsp.)occurs W =0.0000099899 × TL3,0243, sd in coastal or estuary environments, which existed near the shores of Punta N˜ague´. TL =12.292 × OH1,8128, Two species of sciaenids are represented: cg 140 VOLUME10•ISSUE1• 2015

Description:
Early Archaic Fishing (12,600–9,200 cal yr. BP) in the Semiarid North Coast of Chile. Philippe Béarez,1 Donald Jackson,2 and Noémy Mollaret3.
See more

The list of books you might like

Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.