THE INDIAN LAW REPORTS HIMACHAL SERIES, 2016 EDITOR RAKESH KAINTHLA Director ...

1004 Pages·2016·6.76 MB·English

THE
INDIAN LAW REPORTS
HIMACHAL SERIES, 2016

EDITOR
RAKESH KAINTHLA
Director,
H.P. Judicial Academy,
Shimla.

ASSISTANT EDITOR
HANS RAJ
Joint Director,
H.P. Judicial Academy,
Shimla.

April, 2016
Vol. XLVI (II)
Pages: HC 626 TO 1558
Mode of Citation : I L R 2016 (II) HP 1
Containing cases decided by the High Court of
Himachal Pradesh and by the Supreme Court of India
And
Acts, Rules and Notifications.
PUBLISHED UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF THE GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL
PRADESH , BY THE CONTROLLER, PRINTING AND STATIONERY DEPARTMENT,
HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA-5.

All Right Reserved

INDIAN LAW REPORTS
HIMACHAL SERIES
(April, 2016)

INDEX
1) Nominal Table i to x
2) Subject Index & cases cited 1 to 56
3) Reportable Judgments 626 to 1158

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

i

Nominal table
I L R 2016 (II) HP 1
Sr. Title Page
No.
1 Akash Deep Sharma Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh D.B. 1380
and others
2 Alam Chand and another Vs. Yaad Singh and others 819
3 Amrish Rana Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh D.B. 1077
4 Anand Rani and others Vs. Anil Kumar and others 693
5 Anil Kumar Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh D.B. 1534
6 Ashok Kumar Vs. Lajya Devi and others 695
7 Ashok Kumar(deceased) through his LRs and others 627
Vs. Neena Mittal and another
8 Atul Thakur Vs. State of H.P. D.B. 697
9 Bajaj Allianz General Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Smt. 704
Krishna Sharma and others
10 Balbir Singh Vs. State of H.P. & ors. D.B. 1381
11 Baldev Singh Vs. Jagdish Chand & another 977
12 Bano Devi Vs. Rashilu Devi & others 875
13 Banshi Ram son of Shri Dittu Ram Vs. Ram Chand 1085
son of Sh. Puran Chand
14 Besro Devi and others Vs. Ranjit Singh 1385
15 Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited and Ors. Vs. Darshan D.B. 883
Lal and Anr.
16 Business Institute of Management Studies Vs. State 1411
of Himachal Pradesh and others
17 Commissioner, Central Excise Chandigarh Vs. M/s D.B. 926
Valley Iron & Steel Co. Ltd.
18 Court on its own motion Vs. State of Himachal D.B. 706
Pradesh and others CWPIL No. 1 of 2016
ii

19 Dadu Ram Vs. Land Acquisition Collector and others 636
20 Deepti Gupta & ors Vs. Karam Singh 1051
21 Devi Ram Vs. Kaushalya Devi & ors. 1214
22 Dinesh Singh Thakur Vs. Prem Gazta 1264
23 Faryad Bhatti Vs. High Court of H.P D.B. 710
24 Firoz Ansari Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh D.B. 677
25 General Manager, Ranjit Sagar Dam Vs. Thakur 884
Chand and others
26 Gian Chand Sharma Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh 1185
and others
27 Gian Chand Vs. Om Parkash 827
28 H.P. Housing and Urban Development Authority 1434
through its Secretary-cum-Chief Engineer Vs.
Tarsem Lal
29 H.P. State Electricity Board & another Vs. Mitter Dev D.B. 632
Sharma & another
30 H.P.State Cooperative Bank Ltd. Vs. National 979
Insurance Company Ltd. and another
31 Hamid Mohammad Vs. Jaimal 1325
32 Hargopal Singh and others Vs. Prem Sagar & others 1216
33 Hari Singh Vs. General Manager, Ranjit Sagar 896
34 Hem Raj Vs. Meera Devi and others 1218
35 Hem Raj Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh D.B. 794
36 Himachal Pradesh Horticulture Produce Marketing 1440
and Processing Corporation Vs. Kanta Devi and
another
37 Himachal Road Transport Corporation & Anr. Vs. 982
Kamlesh Kumari and others
38 Himachal Road Transport Corporation and Anr. Vs. 1485
iii

Anup Kumar and others
39 Hussain Mohammed Vs. Gurdas s/o Sh. Masandu 1452
40 Hussan Lal Vs. Data Ram 626
41 Indara Devi and others Vs. Rakesh Kaushal and 984
another
42 Inderjit Singh Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh 715
43 India Bulls Housing Finance Ltd. Vs. Rakesh Kumar 832
Banta and another
44 Jatinder Kumar Vs. Kusum Lata 718
45 K.C. Sharma Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh and 1188
others
46 Kamlesh Kumari Vs. State of HP & Ors 1268
47 Kanta Devi and another Vs. Rita Devi and others 1486
48 Kashmiro Devi & another Vs. Rang Lal & others 1487
49 Khim Raj son of Shri Piare Lal Vs. State of H.P. D.B. 835
50 Kuldeep Singh Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh 1442
51 Kuldeep Vs. Sunita Devi and another 1199
52 Lakhan Singh Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh 1329
53 Lal Singh @ Lala Vs. State of H.P D.B. 648
54 Land Acquisition Collector, H.P. Housing Vs. Daulat 653
Ram & ors.
55 Land Acquisition Collector, H.P. Vs. Usha Devi & ors. 656
56 Lata Devi Vs. Subordinate Selection Board Hamirpur D.B. 737
and another
57 Laxman Vs. HRTC and another 744
58 M/s Caplin Point Laboratories Ltd. and others Vs. 927
Union of India and another
iv

59 M/S Him Cylinder Private Limited Vs. Janak Raj 1037
60 M/s Maja Unipac Vs. HP Financial Corporation Ltd. 986
61 M/s Micromax Informatics Ltd. Vs. State of Himachal D.B. 749
Pradesh and others
62 M/s Oriental Insurance Company Vs. Hira Devi & 988
others
63 M/s Tube Expansion and Equipments Pvt. Ltd. Vs. D.B. 1027
District Magistrate, District Solan and others
64 Maj. General (Retd.) S.C.Suri Vs. Himalayan Brahmo 1222
Samaj Mandir & Others
65 Manish Kumar son of Tilak Raj and another Vs. State 907
of Himachal Pradesh and others
66 Mannwar son of Sh Iqbal Hussain Vs. State of 1258
Himachal Pradesh
67 Manoj Kumar and others Vs. Rajesh Kumar and 746
others
68 Mansa Devi & ors Vs. Saina Devi & ors 1261
69 Manu Goel W/o Sh. Ashok Goel & others Vs. Tarsem 1445
Chand Jain & others
70 Meera Devi Vs. J.D. Verma and another 1489
71 Mohan Lal and others Vs. State of H.P. and others 643
72 Mohan Lal Vs. Lalit Mohan & others 992
73 Mst.Mobina wife of Mohd Ikram and others Vs. Kala 1388
wife of Balla Ram
74 Municipal Corporation, Shimla Vs. Ramesh Chand D.B. 932
Thakur
75 Nanak Chand Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh D.B. 933
76 Nand Lal Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh D.B. 1277
77 Nande Lal Yadav & others Vs. Manjeet Singh & others 1490
v

78 Narcotics Control Bureau Vs. Ajmer Kumar and 1090
another
79 Narkali Soni and others Vs. Mohd. Raffi and others 1492
80 National Insurance Co. Ltd Vs. Nisha Verma & ors 1095
81 National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Anupam 1494
Sharma & others
82 National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Jai Chand 763
& others
83 National Insurance Company Limited Vs. Vineet 1496
Kumar & others
84 Om Parkash Vs. Dilawar Singh (deceased) and others 995
85 Om Prakash Sharma Vs. State of H.P. and others D.B. 1224
86 Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Jai Chand and others 1500
87 Oriental Insurance Company Limited Vs. Ravi Kant & 766
others
88 Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pawan Kumar 769
and others
89 Oriental Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Mathara Devi & 1500
others
90 Oriental Insurance Company Vs. Shinder Kaur and 999
others
91 Pankaj Thakur Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh 1298
92 Param Deep Vs. Sushma Rani 1334
93 Pooja Devi wife of Shri Sanjay Sharma Vs. State of 1097
H.P.
94 Prabha & others Vs. Parveen Kumar & others 1008
95 Pradeep Kumar Vs. State of H.P. 1303
96 Prem Lata Thakur Vs. State of H.P. & others 1204
97 Rahul Bhardwaj and others Vs. State of Himachal D.B. 1062
vi

Pradesh and others
98 Raj Kumar Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh & others 1340
99 Raj Kumari Vs. M/s Shakun Infrastructure 1066
Development Private Limited
100 Rajan Sharma Vs. Ravinder Singh and others 1010
101 Rajesh Kumar and others Vs. State of H.P. and D.B. 770
another
102 Rajesh Kumar Dhiman Vs. Krishan Dutt Verma and 1504
others
103 Rajeshwar Sabarwal son of Shri O.P. Sabarwal Vs. 1100
State of H.P.
104 Ram Raksh Pal Singh Vs. Sarla Devi & others 1012
105 Ramesh Kumar and another Vs. State of H.P. and D.B. 776
others
106 Ranjan Singh & others Vs. State of Himachal Pradesh D.B. 1235
and others
107 Rattan Singh and another Vs. Surto Devi and another 1508
108 Ratti Ram Sharma Vs. Satya Devi 947
109 Roshan Lal (In jail) son of Shri Dhani Ram Vs. State 909
of H.P.
110 Roshan Lal Vs. State of H.P. and others 646
111 Sadh Ram Vs. Sanjay Rao and others 780
112 Sandeep Mahajan Vs. Surjeet Singh and another 1518
113 Sanjay Aggarwal Vs. BLCCO Lawrie Limited & 849
another
114 Sanjeev Kumar s/o Sh. Mangal Singh Vs. State of D.B. 1106
H.P.
115 Satish Kumar and another Vs. Tarun Jain and 784
another