Table Of Content

The Canadian Historical Review Co-editors: Margaret Conrad, James Struthers 5 CONTINUING THE REVIEW OF HISTORICAL PUBLICATIONS RELATING TO CANADA FOUNDED AT THE UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO IN 1896 VOLUME LXXX 1999 PUBLISHED QUARTERLY BY UNIVERSITY OF TORONTO PRESS INCORPORATED © University of Toronto Press 1999. All rights reserved Index to Volume 80, 1999 % ARTICLES BASKERVILLE, PETER. Women and Investment in Late-Nineteenth- Century Urban Canada: Victoria and Hamilton, 1880-1901 191 BURKE, SARA Zz. New Women and Old Romans: Co-education at the University of Toronto, 1884-95 219 CODIGNOLA, LucA. Compting Networks: Roman Catholic Ecclesiastics in French North America, 1610-58 539 DESSUREAULT, CHRISTIAN, et CHRISTINE HUDON. Conflits sociaux et élites locales au Bas-Canada: le clergé, les notables, la paysannerie et le contrdle de la fabrique 413 GORDON, ALAN. Patronage, Etiquette, and the Science of Connection: Edmund Bristol and Political Management, 1911-21 1 GUENTZEL, RALPH P. The Centrale de |’Enseignement du Québec and Quebec Separatist Nationalism, 1960-80 61 IACOVETTA, FRANCA. Gossip, Contest, and Power in the Making of Suburban Bad Girls: Toronto, 1945-Go 585 LITTLE, J.1. Contested Land: Squatters and Agents in the Eastern Townships of Lower Canada 381 MYERS, TAMARA. The Voluntary Delinquent: Parents, Daughters, and the Montreal Juvenile Delinquents’ Court in 1918 242 SANGSTER, JOAN. Criminalizing the Colonized: Ontario Native Women Confront the Criminal Justice System, 1920-60 32 CHR FORUM ARTICLES FECTEAU, JEAN-MARIE. Between Scientific Enquiry and the Search for a Nation: Quebec Historiography as Seen by Ronald Rudin 641; Entre la quéte de la nation et les découvertes de la science. L’historiog- raphie québécoise vue par Ronald Rudin 440 MCKILLOP, A.B. Who Killed Canadian History? A View from the Trenches 269 . Index iii PALMER, BRYAN D.. Of Silences and Trenches: A Dissident View of Granatstein’s Meaning 676 RUDIN, RONALD. On Difference and National Identity in Quebec Historical Writing: A Response to Jean-Marie Fecteau 666 SWEENY, ROBERT C.H. Stanley Bréhaut Ryerson: Prescience, Politics, and the Profession 464 VISUAL HISTORY REVIEWS ADAMS, ANNMARIE. Of Monuments and Men: A Review of ‘Montreal Metropole’ 473 CRUIKSHANK, KEN, and BOUCHIER, NANCY B. “The pictures are great but the text is a bit of a downer ...’: Ways of Seeing and the Challenge of Exhibiting Critical History 96 HANNANT, LARRY. Film Review 698 JAMES, CATHY L. Women’s History on Film: Requiem for Studio D 93 LUTZ, JOHN. Where the Digital Rubber Hits the Information Highway: Putting Canadian History on CD-ROM 479 ROBSON, STUART. Better than Western Union: The NFB Sends a Mess- age 486 SEIXAS, PETER. Negotiating Past and Present: A Review of New Materials for Teaching Canadian History in the Schools 687 BOOK REVIEWS ADAMS, MARY LOUISE, The Trouble with Normal: Postwar Youth and the Making of Heterosexuality by Linda M. Ambrose 337 ANCTIL, PIERRE, Tur Malka: Flaneries sur les cimes de l’histoire juive mont- réalaise by Gerald Tulchinsky 509 ANTAL, SANDY, A Wampum Denied: Procter’s War of 1812 by Carl Benn 124 ARMSTRONG, CHRISTOPHER, Blue Skies and Boiler Rooms: Buying and Selling Securities in Canada, 1870-1940 by Graham D. Taylor 489 ARONSEN, LAWRENCE ROBERT, American National Security and Economic Relations with Canada, 1945-1954 by Joel J. Sokolsky 155 ATWOOD, MARGARET, In Search of Alias Grace: On Writing Canadian Historical Fiction by David Kimmel 312 AVERY, DONALD, Reluctant Host: Canada’s Response to Immigrant Workers, 1896-1994 by Enrico Carlson Cumbo 335 AXELROD, PAUL, The Promise of Schooling: Education in Canada, 1800-1914 by Dianne M. Hallman 141 AZOULAY, DAN, Keeping the Dream Alive: The Survival of the Ontario CCF/NDP, 1950-1963 by Nelson Wiseman 182 iv The Canadian Historical Review BACKHOUSE, FRANCES, Women of the Klondike by Elizabeth Jameson 308 BARRON, F. LAURIE, Walking ii Indian Moccasins: The Native Politics of Tommy Douglas and the CCF by Tony Hall 126 BEDARD, ERIC, Chronique d’une insurrection appréhendeée: La crise d’octobre et le milieu universitaire by Robert Comeau 321 BENIDICKSON, JAMIE, Idleness, Water, and a Canoe: Reflections of Paddling for Pleasure by Colin D. Howell 514 BLACK, J.L., Canada in the Soviet Mirror: Ideology and Perception in Soviet Foreign Affairs, 1917-1991 by N.G.O. Pereira 518 BLANCHET, RENEE, €d., Une femme patriote: Julie Bruneau Papineau, Correspondance, 1823-1862 by Gilles Laporte 132 BOCKING, STEPHEN, Ecologists and Environmental Politics: A History of Contemporary Ecology by Richard Stuart 300 BOUDREAU, CLAUDE, SERGE COURVILLE, €t NORMAND SEGUIN, Atlas histori- que du Québec: Le territoire by Jack Little 318 BOUTILIER, BEVERLY, and ALISON PRENTICE, eds., Creating Historical Memory; English-Canadian Women and the Work of History by Mary Kinnear 180 BRODE, PATRICK, Casual Slaughters and Accidental Judgements: Canadian War Crimes Prosecutions, 1944-1948 by Greg Donaghy 151 BRYDEN, P.E., Planners and Politicians: Liberal Politics and Social Policy, 1957-1968 by Reg Whitaker 352 BUCH, MARY HAWKINS, with CAROLYN GOSSAGE, Props on Her Sleeve: The Wartime Letters ofa Canadian Airwoman by Marlene Kadar 717 BUSHNELL, IAN, The Federal Court of Canada: A History, 1875-1992 by Patricia Hughes 709 BUSSIDOR, ILA, and UsTUN BILGEN-REINART, Night Spirits: The Story of the Relocation oft he Sayisi Dene by Frank James Tester 304 CAMERON, LAURA, Openings: A Mediation on History, Method, and Sumas Lake by John Marsh 343 CARBIN, CLIFTON F., Deaf Heritage in Canada: A Distinctive, Diverse and Enduring Culture by Stéphane-D. Pereault 338 CARTER, SARAH, Capturing Women: The Manipulation of Cultural Imagery in Canada’s Prairie West by Bill Waiser 306 CHAMBERS, LORI, Married Women and the Law of Property Law in Nine- teenth-Century Ontario by Richard H. Chused 167 CHRISTOPHERS, BRETT, Positioning the Missionary: John Booth Good and the Colonial Confluence of Cultures by Clarence Bolt 499 COATES, COLIN M., ed., Imperial Canada, 1867-1917 by Lisa Gaudet 145 COLLISON, GARY, Shadrach Minkins: From Fugitive Slave to Citizen by Karolyn Smartz 134 Index v COOK, RAMSEY, and JEAN HAMELIN, eds, Dictionary of Canadian Biography, volume XIV: 1911-1920 by Susan Mann 511 COOKE, 0.A., The Canadian Military Experience, 1867-1995: A Bibliography/ Bibliographie de la vie militaire au Canada, 1867-1995 by Glenn Wright 147 COOPER, CYNTHIA, Magnificent Entertainments: Fancy Dress Balls of Canada’s Governors General, 1876-1898 by H.V. Nelles 137 CRUIKSHANK, JULIE, The Social Life of Stories: Narrative and Knowledge in the Yukon Territory by Sally Cole 714 CUMMING, CARMAN, Sketches from a Young Country: The Images of Grip Magazine by Gillian Poulter 136 DAVIES, ALAN, and MARILYN F. NEFSKY, How Silent Were the Churches? Canadian Protestantism and the Jewish Plight during the Nazi Era by Irving Abella 332 DAWSON, MICHAEL, The Mountie from Dime Novel to Disney by R.C. Macleod 347 DION, JEAN-NOEL, ed., Saint-Hyacinthe, 1748-1998 by Christian Dessu- reault 507 DONAGHY, GREG, ed., Documents on Canadian External Relations/ Docu- ments Relatifs aux Relations Exterieures du Canada, vol. 20: 1954 by Lee- Anne Broadhead 153 DONALD, LELAND, Aboriginal Slavery on the Northwest Coast of America by Keith Thor Carlson 120 DOWBIGGIN, IAN ROBERT, Keeping America Sane: Psychiatry and Eugenics in the United States and Canada, 1880-1940 by Mary-Ellen Kelm 139 FENTON, WILLIAM N., The Great Law and the Longhouse: A Political History of the Iroquois Confederacy by Cornelius J. Jaenen 494 FRENETTE, PIERRE, ed., Histoire de la Céte-Nord by Yves Frenette 173 GIBSON, JAMES R., Lifeline of the Oregon Country: The Fraser-Columbia Brigade System, 1811-47 by Theodore Binnema 314 GODDARD, Ives, ed., Handbook of North American Indians, vol. 17: Lan- guages by Jennifer S.H. Brown 118 GODIN, PIERRE, René Lévesque, 2: Héros malgré lui by Simon Lapointe 325 GRANATSTEIN, J.L., Who Killed Canadian History? by Ken Osborne 114 GREENHILL, PAULINE, and DIANE TYE, eds., Undisciplined Women: Tradi- tion and Culture in Canada by Roberta Buchanan 169 GREER, ALLAN, The People of New France by Dale Miquelon 505 HARDY, RENE, La siderurgie dans le monde rural: les hauts fourneaux du Quebec au XIXe siécle by Kris Inwood 175 vi The Canadian Historical Review HARRISON, JANE E., Until Next Year: Letter Writing and the Mails in the Canadas, 1640-1830 by Sheila McIntyre 349 HART, MICHAEL, Fifty Years of Canadian Tradecraft: Canada at the GATT, 1947-1997 by Grant Dawson 730 HORN, MICHIEL, Becoming Canadian: Memoirs of an Invisible Immigrant by Will C. Van den Hoonaard 723 JACKSON, JOHN N., The Welland Canals and Their Communities: Engineer- ing, Industrial, and Urban Transformation by Sean Gouglas 178 KEALEY, GREGORY S., and REG WHITAKER, eds., R.C.M.P. Security Bulletins: The Depression Years, Part IV, 1937 by Steve Hewitt 164 KEALEY, GREGORY S., and REG WHITAKER, eds., R.C.M.P. Security Bulletins: The Depression Years, Part V, 1938-39 by Steve Hewitt 166 KEALEY, LINDA, Enlisting Women for the Cause: Women, Labour, and the Left in Canada, 1890-1920 by James Naylor 710 KELSEY, MARION, Victory Harvest: Diary ofa Canadian in the Women's Land Army, 1940-1944 by Marlene Kadar 717 LACOMBE, ALAIN, Errol Bouchette 1862-1912, un intellectuel by Pierre Lanthier 162 LAFERTE, HECTOR, Derriére le Tréne. Mémoires d’un parlementaire québécois, 1936-1958 by Jean-Guy Genest 351 LAMONTAGNE, SOPHIE-LAURENCE, and FERNAND HARVEY, La production tex- tile domestique au Québec, 1827-1941: une approche quantitative et régionale by A.B. McCullough 177 LITTLE, J.1., State and Society in Transition: The Politics of Institutional Reform in the Eastern Townships, 1838-1852 by Anne Drummond 171 LITTLE, MARGARET JANE HILLYARD, ‘No Car, No Radio, No Liquor Permit’: The Moral Regulation of Single Mothers in Ontario, 1920-1997 by Veronica Strong-Boag 719 MACLACHLAN, MORAG, The Fort Langley Journals, 1827-30 by Jean Murray Cole 498 MARGOLIAN, HOWARD, Conduct Unbecoming: The Story of the Murder of Canadian Prisoners of War in Normandy by Jonathan F. Vance 330 MARQUIS, GREG, In Armageddon's Shadow: The Civil War and Canada's Maritime Provinces by Reginald C. Stuart 724 MCNAB, DAVID T., Earth, Water, Air and Fire: Studies in Canadian Ethnohis- tory by Charles M. Johnston 501 MCNAIRN, ALAN, Behold the Hero: General Wolfe and the Arts in the Eight- eenth Century by J. Douglas Stewart 310 MCROBERTS, KENNETH, Misconceiving Canada: The Struggle for National Unity by Philip Resnick 184 MOORE, CHRISTOPHER, The Law Society of Upper Canada and Ontario’s Lawyers, 1797-1997 by Jerry Bannister 159 Index vii MORIN, MICHEL, L’Usurpation de la souveraineté autochtone: Le cas des peuples de la Nouvelle-France et des colonies anglaises de l’Amérique du Nord by Cornelius J. Jaenen 341 MOSHER, CLAYTON JAMES, Discrimination and Denial: Systemic Racism in Ontario’s Legal and Criminal Justice System, 1892-1961 by Helen Boritch 516 NEARY, PETER, and J.L. GRANATSTEIN, eds., The Veterans Charter and Post- World War II Canada by John English 328 NICHOLS, ROGER L., Indians in the United States and Canada: A Compara- tive History by John L. Tobias 503 PEYSER, JOSEPH L., ed., Jacques Legardeur de Saint-Pierre: Officer, Gentle- man, Entrepreneur by R. Douglas Hurt 129 PEYSER, JOSEPH L., ed., On the Eve of the Conquest: The Chevalier de Raymond's Critique of New France in 1754 by R. Douglas Hurt 131 PLETSCH, VERA C., Not Wanted in the Classroom: Parent Associations and the Education of Trainable Retarded Cl uildren in Ontario, 1947-1969 by Steven Gelb 721 PORSILD, CHARLENE, Gamblers and Dreamers: Women, Men and Commu- nity in the Klondike by Shelagh Grant 491 ROSS, W. GILLIES, This Distant and Unsurveyed Country: A Woman’s Winter at Baffin Island, 1857-58 by Lyle Dick 143 SCHREIBER, SHANE B., Shock Army of the British Empire: the Canadian Corps in the Last 100 Days of the Great War by Stuart Robson 148 SCHRYER, FRANS J., The Netherlandic Presence in Ontario: Pillars, Class and Dutch Ethnicity by Michiel Horn 333 SIMMINS, GEOFFREY, Fred Cumberland: Building the Victorian Dream by Annmarie Adams 315 SOTIRON, MINKO, From Politics to Profit: The Commercialization of Cana- dian Daily Newspapers, 1890-1920 by Brian P.N. Beaven 157 STERRITT, NEIL J., et al, Tribal Boundaries in the Nass Watershed by Barry Gough 497 STEWART, W. BRIAN, A Life on the Line: Commander Pierre-Etienne Fortin and His Times by Roch Legault 319 STORY, D.C., and R. BRUCE SHEPARD, eds, The Diefenbaker Legacy: Canadian Politics, Law and Society since 1957 by Margaret Conrad 726 STRANGE, CAROLYN, and TINA Loo, Making Good: Law and Moral Regula- tion in Canada, 1867-1939 by Shirley Tillotson 161 SUGDEN, JOHN, Tucemseh: A Life by Herbert Goltz 344 TINGLEY, KEN, ed., The Path of Duty: The Wartime Letters of Alwyn Bram- ley-Moore, 1914-1916 by David Pierce Beatty 326 VANCE, JONATHAN F., Death So Noble: Meaning, Memory and the First World War by Jeff Keshen 150 viii The Canadian Historical Review VAN DUSEN, TOM, with susAN CODE, Inside the Tent: Forty-five Years on Parliament Hill by John MacFarlane 728 WAITE, P.B., The Lives of Dalhousie University, volume 2: The Old College Transformed, 1925-1980 by G. Edward Macdonald 512 WALKER, JAMES W. ST. G., ‘Race,’ Rights and the Law in the Supreme Court of Canada: Historical Case Studies by John McLaren 706 REVIEWERS Abella, Irving 332 Hall, Tony 126 Adams, Annmarie 315 Hallman, Dianne M. 141 Ambrose, Linda M. 337 Hewitt, Steve 164, 166 Bannister, Jerry 159 Horn, Michiel 333 Beatty, David Pierce 326 Howell, Colin D. 514 Beaven, Brian P.N. 157 Hughes, Patricia 709 Benn, Carl 124 Hurt, R. Douglas 129, 131 Binnema, Theodore 314 Inwood, Kris 175 Bolt, Clarence 499 Jaenen, Cornelius J. 341, 494 Boritch, Helen 516 Jameson, Elizabeth 308 Broadhead, Lee-Anne 153 Johnston, Charles M. 501 Brown, Jennifer S.H. 118 Kadar, Marlene 717 Buchanan, Roberta 169 Kelm, Mary-Ellen 139 Carlson, Keith Thor 120 Keshen, Jeff 150 Chused, Richard H. 167 Kinnear, Mary 180 Cole, Jean Murray 498 Lanthier, Pierre 162 Cole, Sally 714 Lapointe, Simone 325 Comeau, Robret 321 Laporte, Gilles 132 Conrad, Margaret 726 Legault, Roch 319 Cumbo, Enrico Carlson 335 Little, Jack 318 Dawson, Grant 730 Macdonald, G. Edward 512 Dessureault, Christian 507 MacFarlane, John 728 Dick, Lyle 143 Macleod, R.C. 347 Donaghy, Greg 151 Mann, Susan 511 Drummond, Anne 171 Marsh, John 343 English, John 328 McCullough, A.B. 177 Frenette, Yves 173 McIntyre, Sheila 349 Gaudet, Lisa 145 McLaren, John 706 Gelb, Steven 721 Miquelon, Dale 505 Genest, Jean-Guy 351 Naylor, James 710 Goltz, Herbert 344 Nelles, H.V. 137 Gough, Barry 497 Osborne, Ken 114 Gouglas, Sean 178 Pereault, Stéphane-D. 338 Grant, Shelagh 491 Pereira, N.G.O. 518 Index ix Poulter, Gillian 136 Tester, Frank James 304 Resnick, Philip 184 Tillotson, Shirley 161 Robson, Stuart 148 Tobias, John L. 503 Smartz, Karolyn 134 Tulchinsky, Gerald 509 Sokolsky, Joel L. 155 Vance, Jonathan F. 330 312 Van den Hoonaard, Will C. 723 Stewart, J. Douglas 310 Waiser, Bill 306 Strong-Boag, Veronica 719 Whitaker, Reg 352 Stuart, Reginald C. 724 Wiseman, Nelson 182 Stuart, Richard 300 Wright, Glenn 147 Taylor, Graham D. 489 MISCELLANEOUS CHR Prize 470 ‘I was a stranger, and ye took me in’: Charity, Moral Economy, and the Children of Peace by Albert Schrauwers 624 Letters to the Editors by RICHARD D. WHITE 470; by D. AZOULAY 472 Recent Publications Relating to Canada 83, 355, 520, 732 Making Do —S Women, Family and | fe | Home in Montreal Making Do uss during the ‘ep tPomTe hsg Great Depressio. n <a Aiiea Denyse Baillargeon ; Soe Translated by Yvonne Klein y Paper $29.95 + 0-88920-326-i Studies in Childhood and Family in Canada series Baillargeon draws us into the intricate lives of individual women, revealing a previously unexplored dimension of the Great Depression and showing us ae HET the importance of considering the Pt domestic sphere to understand the complete history of the working class. Ask your bcokstore to order you a copy or order directly from (aI) Wilfrid Laurier University Press Phone: 519-884-0710 ext. 6124 « Fax: 519-725-1399 + E-mail: [email protected]