The Cambridge Companion to Merleau-Ponty

406 Pages·2005·1.56 MB·English

by  Taylor Carman

the cambridge companion to
MERLEAU-PONTY
Maurice Merleau-Ponty (1908–1961) was described by Paul
Ricoeur as “the greatest of the French phenomenologists.”
The new essays in this volume examine the full scope of
Merleau-Ponty’s philosophy, from his central and abiding
concernwiththenatureofperceptionandthebodilyconsti-
tutionofintentionalitytohisreflectionsonscience,nature,
art, history, and politics. The authors explore the historical
origins and context of his thought as well as its continuing
relevancetocontemporaryworkinphenomenology,philos-
ophy of mind, cognitive science, biology, art criticism, and
politicalandsocialtheory.
WhatemergesisafreshimageofMerleau-Pontyasadeep
and original thinker whose philosophical importance has
been underestimated, in part owing to the influence of in-
tellectualmovementssuchasexistentialismandstructural-
ism,intowhichhisworkcouldnotbeeasilyassimilated.
Newreaderswillfindthisthemostconvenientandacces-
sible guide to Merleau-Ponty currently available. Advanced
students and specialists will find a conspectus of recent de-
velopmentsintheinterpretationofMerleau-Ponty.
Taylor Carman is Associate Professor of Philosophy at
BarnardCollege,ColumbiaUniversity.
Mark B. N. Hansen is Associate Professor of English at
PrincetonUniversity.
othervolumesintheseriesofcambridgecompanions:
ABELARD Editedbyjeffreye.browerandkevinguilfoy
ADORNO Editedbythomashuhn
AQUINAS Editedbynormankretzmannandeleonorestump
HANNAHARENDT Editedbydanavilla
ARISTOTLE Editedbyjonathanbarnes
AUGUSTINE Editedbyeleonorestumpandnormankretzmann
BACON Editedbymarkkupeltonen
SIMONEDEBEAUVOIR Editedbyclaudiacard
DARWIN Editedbyjonathanhodgeandgregoryradick
DESCARTES Editedbyjohncottingham
DUNSSCOTUS Editedbythomaswilliams
EARLYGREEKPHILOSOPHY Editedbya.a.long
FEMINISMINPHILOSOPHY Editedbymirandafrickerandjenniferhornsby
FOUCAULT Editedbygarygutting
FREUD Editedbyjeromeneu
GADAMER Editedbyrobertj.dostal
GALILEO Editedbypetermachamer
GERMANIDEALISM Editedbykarlameriks
GREEKANDROMANPHILOSOPHY Editedbydavidsedley
HABERMAS Editedbystephenk.white
HEGEL Editedbyfrederickbeiser
HEIDEGGER Editedbycharlesguignon
HOBBES Editedbytomsorell
HUME Editedbydavidfatenorton
HUSSERL Editedbybarrysmithanddavidwoodruffsmith
WILLIAMJAMES Editedbyruthannaputnam
KANT Editedbypaulguyer
KIERKEGAARD Editedbyalastairhannayandgordonmarino
LEIBNIZ Editedbynicholasjolley
LEVINAS Editedbysimoncritchleyandrobertbernasconi
LOCKE Editedbyverechappell
MALEBRANCHE Editedbystephennadler
MARX Editedbyterrellcarver
MEDIEVALPHILOSOPHY Editedbya.s.mcgrade
MEDIEVALJEWISHPHILOSOPHY Editedbydanielh.frankandoliver
leaman
MILL Editedbyjohnskorupski
NEWTON Editedbyi.bernardcohenandgeorgee.smith
NIETZSCHE Editedbyberndmagnusandkathleenhiggins
OCKHAM Editedbypaulvincentspade
PASCAL Editedbynicholashammond
PEIRCE Editedbycherylmisak
PLATO Editedbyrichardkraut
PLOTINUS Editedbylloydp.gerson
QUINE Editedbyrogerf.gibson
RAWLS Editedbysamuelfreeman
THOMASREID Editedbyterencecuneoandrene´ vanwoudenberg
ROUSSEAU Editedbypatrickriley
BERTRANDRUSSELL Editedbynicholasgriffin
SARTRE Editedbychristinahowells
SCHOPENHAUER Editedbychristopherjanaway
THESCOTTISHENLIGHTENMENT Editedbyalexanderbroadie
SPINOZA Editedbydongarrett
THESTOICS Editedbybradinwood
WITTGENSTEIN Editedbyhansslugaanddavidstern
The Cambridge Companion to
MERLEAU-PONTY
Edited by
Taylor Carman
BarnardCollege,ColumbiaUniversity
Mark B. N. Hansen
PrincetonUniversity
publishedbythepresssyndicateoftheuniversityof
cambridge
ThePittBuilding,TrumpingtonStreet,Cambridge,UnitedKingdom
cambridgeuniversitypress
TheEdinburghBuilding,Cambridgecb22ru,UK
40West20thStreet,NewYork,ny10011-4211,USA
477WilliamstownRoad,PortMelbourne,vic3207,Australia
RuizdeAlarco´n13,28014Madrid,Spain
DockHouse,TheWaterfront,CapeTown8001,SouthAfrica
http://www.cambridge.org
(cid:1)c CambridgeUniversityPress2005
Thisbookisincopyright.Subjecttostatutoryexceptionandtothe
provisionsofrelevantcollectivelicensingagreements,noreproductionof
anypartmaytakeplacewithoutthewrittenpermissionofCambridge
UniversityPress.
Firstpublished2005
PrintedintheUnitedStatesofAmerica
TypefaceTrumpMedieval10/13pt. SystemLATEX2ε [tb]
AcatalogrecordforthisbookisavailablefromtheBritishLibrary.
LibraryofCongressCataloginginPublicationData
TheCambridgecompaniontoMerleau-Ponty/editedbyTaylorCarman
andMarkB.N.Hansen.
p. cm.–(Cambridgecompanionstophilosophy)
Includesbibliographicalreferencesandindex.
isbn0-521-80989-4–isbn0-521-00777-1(pbk.)
1.Merleau-Ponty,Maurice,1908–1961. I.Carman,Taylor,1965-
II.Hansen,MarkB.N. III.Series.
b2430.m3764c36 2004
194–dc22 2003069683
isbn0521809894hardback
isbn0521007771paperback
https://doi.org/10.1017/CCOL0521809894.016
contents
List of Contributors pagevii
Introduction 1
taylor carman and mark b. n. hansen
1 Merleau-Ponty and the Epistemological Picture 26
charles taylor
2 Sensation, Judgment, and the Phenomenal Field 50
taylor carman
3 Seeing Things in Merleau-Ponty 74
sean dorrance kelly
4 Motives, Reasons, and Causes 111
mark a. wrathall
5 Merleau-Ponty and Recent Cognitive Science 129
hubert l. dreyfus
6 The Silent, Limping Body of Philosophy 151
richard shusterman
7 Merleau-Ponty and the Touch of Malebranche 181
judith butler
v
vi Contents
8 A Phenomenology of Life 206
renaud barbaras
9 The Embryology of the (In)visible 231
mark b. n. hansen
10 Merleau-Ponty’s Existential Conception of
Science 265
joseph rouse
11 Between Philosophy and Art 291
jonathan gilmore
12 Understanding the Engaged Philosopher:
On Politics, Philosophy, and Art 318
lydia goehr
13 Thinking Politics 352
claude lefort
References 381
Index 393
contributors
RENAUD BARBARAS is Professor of Contemporary Philosophy at
the University of Paris-I Panthe´on–Sorbonne. He is the author of
De l’eˆtre du phe´nome`ne: Sur l’ontologie de Merleau-Ponty (1991,
2001), La perception: Essai sur le sensible (1994), Le Tournant de
l’expe´rience:RecherchessurlaphilosophiedeMerleau-Ponty(1998),
andLede´siretladistance:Introductiona` unephe´nome´nologiedela
perception(1999).Del’eˆtreduphe´nome`neandLede´siretladistance
arebothforthcominginEnglishtranslation.
JUDITH BUTLER is Maxine Elliot Professor in the Departments of
Rhetoric and Comparative Literature at the University of Califor-
nia, Berkeley. She is the author of Gender Trouble: Feminism and
the Subversion of Identity (1990), Bodies That Matter: On the Dis-
cursiveLimitsof“Sex”(1993),ThePsychicLifeofPower:Theories
of Subjection (1997), Antigone’s Claim: Kinship between Life and
Death (2000), and numerous articles and contributions to philoso-
phyandfeministandqueertheory.
TAYLORCARMANisAssociateProfessorofPhilosophyatBarnard
College, Columbia University. He has written articles on topics in
phenomenologyandistheauthorofHeidegger’sAnalytic:Interpre-
tation,Discourse,andAuthenticityin“BeingandTime”(2003).He
iscurrentlywritingabookonMerleau-Ponty.
HUBERT L. DREYFUS is Professor of Philosophy in the Graduate
School at the University of California, Berkeley. He is the author
ofMichelFoucault:BeyondStructuralismandHermeneutics(with
Paul Rabinow) (1983), Mind over Machine (with Stuart Dreyfus)
vii
viii Contributors
(1986), Being-in-the-World: A Commentary on Heidegger’s “Being
and Time,” Division I (1991), What Computers (Still) Can’t Do
(1992),andOntheInternet(2001).
JONATHANGILMOREisAssistantProfessorofPhilosophyatYale
University.Hehaswrittenarticlesinthephilosophyofart,arthis-
tory,andlegaltheory.HeistheauthorofTheLifeofaStyle:Begin-
ningsandEndingsintheNarrativeHistoryofArt(2000).
LYDIA GOEHR is Professor of Philosophy at Columbia University.
She is the author of The Imaginary Museum of Musical Works: An
Essay in the Philosophy of Music (1992) and The Quest for Voice:
Music,Politics,andtheLimitsofPhilosophy(1998).Sheiscurrently
workingonmusicandcriticaltheory,oneexampleofwhichappears
inTheCambridgeCompaniontoAdorno(2004).
MARKB.N.HANSENisAssociateProfessorofEnglishatPrinceton
University.HeistheauthorofEmbodyingTechnesis:Technologybe-
yondWriting(2000),NewPhilosophyforNewMedia(2004),Bodies
in Code: Interfaces with New Media (forthcoming); and essays on
culturaltheory.
SEANDORRANCEKELLYisAssistantProfessorofPhilosophyand
Jonathan Edwards Bicentennial Preceptor at Princeton University.
His principal interests lie at the intersection of phenomenology,
philosophy of mind, and cognitive neuroscience. He was recently
awarded a Guggenheim Fellowship in recognition of his work in
theseareas.
CLAUDE LEFORT teaches social and political theory at the E´cole
des Hautes E´tudes en Sciences Sociales in Paris. His work has ap-
pearedinEnglishtranslationunderthetitlesThePoliticalFormsof
Modern Society: Bureaucracy, Democracy, Totalitarianism (1986),
Democracy and Political Theory (1988), and Writing: The Political
Test(2000).
JOSEPH ROUSE is Hedding Professor of Moral Science and Chair
of the Science in Society Program at Wesleyan University. He is
the author of Engaging Science: How to Think about Its Practices
Contributors ix
Philosophically (1996), Knowledge and Power: Toward a Political
Philosophy of Science (1987), and How Scientific Practices Matter:
ReclaimingPhilosophicalNaturalism(2002).
RICHARD SHUSTERMAN is Professor of Philosophy at Temple
University, Philadelphia, and the Colle`ge International de Philoso-
phie,Paris.HeistheauthorofPragmatistAesthetics:LivingBeauty,
Rethinking Art (2d ed., 2000), Practicing Philosophy: Pragmatism
andthePhilosophicalLife(1997),PerformingLive:AestheticAlter-
nativesfortheEndsofArt(2000),andSurfaceandDepth:Dialectics
ofCriticismandCulture(2002).HeisalsotheeditorofBourdieu:A
CriticalReader(1999).
CHARLES TAYLOR is Professor Emeritus of Philosophy at McGill
University, Montreal. He is the author of The Explanation of Be-
haviour(1964);twovolumesofcollectedessays,HumanAgencyand
Language and Philosophy and the Human Sciences (1985); Sources
of the Self (1989); The Ethics of Authenticity (1991); Philosophical
Arguments (1995); and Varieties of Religion Today: William James
Revisited(2002).
MARK A. WRATHALL is Associate Professor of Philosophy at
BrighamYoungUniversity.Hehaspublishedarticlesontopicsinthe
history of philosophy and philosophy of language and mind, draw-
ing on both the analytic and continental traditions in philosophy.
He recently edited Religion after Metaphysics (2003) and coedited
HeideggerReexamined(2002),Heidegger,Authenticity,andModer-
nity (2000), Heidegger, Coping, and Cognitive Science (2000), and
AppropriatingHeidegger(2000).