Table Of Content

THE AMERICAN UNIVERSITY LAW REVIEW INDEX TO VOLUME 41 ARTICLES “ACADEMIC CHALLENGE” CASES: SHOULD JUDICIAL REVIEW EXTEND TO ACADEMIC EVALUATIONS OF STUDENTS?, Thomas A. Schweitzer AN ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF THE ISSUES SURROUNDING AIDS IN THE WORKPLACE: IN THE LONG RUN, THE PATH OF TRUTH AND REASON CANNOT BE DIVERTED, Wayne THE EMPEROR’S CLOTHES ARE NOT EFFICIENT: POSNER’S JURISPRUDENCE OF CLASS, Mark M. Hager AN EMPIRICAL STUDY OF FORUM CHOICES IN REMOVAL CASES UNDER DIVERSITY AND FEDERAL QUESTION JURISDICTION, Neal Miller RESTITUTION FOR CONSUMERS UNDER THE FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION ACT: GOOD INTENTIONS OR CONGRESSIONAL INTENTIONS?, Peter C. Ward SECURED CREDITORS AND THE EELY CHARACTER OF BANKRUPTCY VALUATIONS, David TEACHING EVIDENCE: STORYTELLING IN THE CLASSROOM, Bery/ Blaustone THOUGHTS ON THE VITALITY OF ER/E, John B. Corr COMMENTS BEYOND THE PERSIAN GULF CRISIS: EXPANDING THE ROLE OF SERVICEWOMEN IN THE UNITED STATES MILITARY, James D. Milko GIVE Us SOVEREIGNTY OR GIVE Us DEBT: DEBTOR COUNTRIES’ PERSPECTIVE ON DEBT-FOR-NATURE Swaps, Priya Alagiri THE LITIGATING AMICUS CURIAE: WHEN DOES THE PARTY BEGIN AFTER THE FRIENDS LEAVE?, Michael K. Lowman OBJECTS OF CONTROVERSY: THE NATIVE AMERICAN RIGHT TO REPATRIATION, Steven Platzman PUNITIVE DAMAGES UNDER THE WARSAW CONVENTION: REVISITING THE DRAFTERS’ INTENT, Kelly Compton Grems TERMINATING THE “PASSIVE” PARADOX: A PROPOSAL FOR FEDERAL REGULATION OF ENVIRONMENTAL TOBACCO SMOKE, Alan B. Horowitz WHAT ABOUT THE CHILDREN? TOWARD AN EXPANSION OF LOSS OF CONSORTIUM RECOVERY IN THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, Maureen Ann Delaney NOTES BOARD OF EDUCATION OF WESTSIDE COMMUNITY SCHOOLS V. MERGENS: THREE “R’s” + RELIGION = MERGENS, Leah Gallant Morgenstein WILSON V. SEITER: DEFINING THE COMPONENTS OF AND PROPOSING A DIRECTION FOR EIGHTH AMENDMENT PRISON CONDITION LAw, Russell W. Gray REMARKS ADDRESS BY THE HONORABLE STANLEY SPORKIN AT THE AMERICAN UNIVERSITY Law REVIEW ANNUAL DINNER ADVICE AND CONSENT IN THEORY AND PRACTICE, The Honorable Roger J. Miner UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT TENTH ANNIVERSARY COMMEMORATIVE ISSUE CiviL JusTICE REFORM, Dan Quayle INTRODUCTION THE FEDERAL Circuit: A COURT FOR THE FUTURE, The Honorable Helen Wilson Nies THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND CONGRESSIONAL INTENT, Howard T. Markey ARTICLES ORIGIN OF THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT: A PERSONAL ACCOUNT, Daniel J. Meador THE SIGNIFICANT FEDERAL CIRCUIT CASES INTERPRETING SECTION 112, Thomas L. Irving, Michael D. Kaminski, Walter Y. Boyd, Jr., & Mary S. Helmberger-Jones INDIAN CLAIMS IN THE COURTS OF THE CONQUEROR, Nell Jessup Newton THE IMPACT OF THE VETERANS’ JUDICIAL REVIEW ACT ON THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT, Barton F. Stichman 1991 AREA SUMMARIES PATENT LAW DEVELOPMENTS IN THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT DURING 1991, Donald S. Chisum GOVERNMENT CONTRACTS: 1991 ANALYSIS AND SUMMARY, Lynda Troutman O'Sullivan & Martin P. Willard REVIEW OF THE 1991 TRADEMARK DECISIONS OF THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT, Raymond I. Geraldson, Jr. & John M. Murphy INTERNATIONAL TRADE DECISIONS OF THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FEDERAL CIRCUIT DURING 1991, James Toupin NOTE BEYOND ANIMAL LEGAL DEFENSE FUND V. QUIGG: THE CONTROVERSY OVER TRANSGENIC ANIMAL PATENTS CONTINUES, Elizabeth Joy Hecht INDEX — DIGEST AIDS An Economic Analysis of the Issues Surrounding AIDS in the Workplace: In the Long Run, the Path of Truth and Reason Cannot Be Diverted Amicus Curiae The Litigating Amicus Curiae: When Does the Party Begin After the Friends Leave?.. 1243 Aviation Law Punitive Damages Under the Warsaw Convention: Revisiting the Drafters’ Intent Bankruptcy Secured Creditors and the Eely Character of Bankruptcy Valuations Civil Justice Reform Civil Justice Reform Civil Procedure An Empirical Study of Forum Choices in Removal Cases Under Diversity and Federal Question Jurisdiction The Litigating Amicus Curiae: When Does the Party Begin After the Friends Leave?.. 1243 Thoughts on the Vitality of Erie Constitutional Law Board of Education of Westside Community Schools v. Mergens: Three “R's” + Religion = Mergens “Academic Challenge” Cases: Should Judicial Review Extend to Academic Evaluations of Students? Wilson v. Seiter: Defining the Components of and Proposing a Direction for Eighth Amendment Prison Condition Law District of Columbia What About the Children? Toward an Expansion of Loss of Consortium Recovery in the District of Columbia Eighth Amendment Wilson v. Seiter: Defining the Components of and Proposing a Direction for Eighth Amendment Prison Condition Law Employment Discrimination An Economic Analysis of the Issues Surrounding AIDS in the Workplace: In the Long Run, the Path of Truth and Reason Cannot Be Diverted Environmental Law Terminating the “Passive” Paradox: A Proposal for Federal Regulation of Environmental Give Us Sovereignty or Give Us Debt: Debtor Countries’ Perspective on Debt-for-Nature Establishment Clause Board of Education of Westside Community Schools v. Mergens: Three “R’s” + Religion Evidence Teaching Evidence: Storytelling in the Classroom Federal Circuit Beyond Animal Legal Defense Fund v. Quigg: The Controversy over Transgenic Animal Patents Continues Civil Justice Reform The Federal Circuit: A Court for the Future The Federal Circuit and Congressional Intent Government Contracts: 1991 Analysis and Summary The Impact of the Veterans’ Judicial Review Act on the Federal Circuit Indian Claims in the Courts of the Conqueror International Trade Decisions of the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Cir- cuit During 1991 Origin of the Federal Circuit: A Personal Account Patent Law Developments in the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit During 1991 Review of the 1991 Trademark Decisions of the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit The Significant Federal Circuit Cases Interpreting Section 112 Federal Trade Commission Restitution for Consumers Under the Federal Trade Commission Act: Good Intentions or Fourteenth Amendment “Academic Challenge” Cases: Should Judicial Review Extend to Academic Evaluations of RIUM Si 5o 05.5 1ao vens d mis AN ioa re Saws Oiel aiwe's 6s 05: bak oo os ORAS ROO 267 Government Contracts Government Contracts: 1991 Analysis and Summary Indian Law Objects of Controversy: The Native American Right to Repatriation Indian Claims in the Courts of the Conqueror International Environmental Law Give Us Sovereignty or Give Us Debt: Debtor Countries’ Perspective on Debt-for-Nature International Trade International Trade Decisions of the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Cir- cuit During 1991 Judicial Review “Academic Challenge” Cases: Should Judicial Review Extend to Academic Evaluations of roster CAE OT AE OE OE eT ET GE ST es a The Impact of the Veterans’ Judicial Review Act on the Federal Circuit Jurisprudence The Emperor’s Clothes Are Not Efficient: Posner’s Jurisprudence of Class Legal Teaching Teaching Evidence: Storytelling in the Classroom Loss of Consortium What About the Children? Toward an Expansion of Loss of Consortium Recovery in the District of Columbia Military Beyond the Persian Gulf Crisis: Expanding the Role of Servicewomen in the United States Patent Law Beyond Animal Legal Defense Fund v. Quigg: The Controversy Over Transgenic Animal Patents Continues Patent Law Developments in the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit During 1991 The Significant Federal Circuit Cases Interpreting Section 112 Tort Law What About the Children? Toward an Expansion of Loss of Consortium Recovery in the District of Columbia Tort Reform Civil Justice Reform Trademark Law Review of the 1991 Trademark Decisions of the United States Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit Veterans Affairs The Impact of the Veterans’ Judicial Review Act on the Federal Circuit Warsaw Convention Punitive Damages Under the Warsaw Convention: Revisiting the Drafters’ Intent Women and the Law Beyond the Persian Gulf Crisis: Expanding the Role of Servicewomen in the United States TABLE OF CASES Cases indexed are only those that appear in the text of the Review. Abbariao v. Hamline University School Black & White Taxicab & Transfer Co. v. Brown & Yellow Taxicab & Air France v. Saks .. 156, 170, 173, 175, 182 Transfer Co. Aktiebolaget Karlstads Mekaniska Blank v. Board of Higher Education.. 352 Werkstad (AKMW) v. United States Boeing Petroleum Services, Inc. v. International Trade Commission ... 707 Alco Standard Corp. v. Tennessee Board of Curators of the University of Valley Authority Missouri v. Horowitz . ..273, 275, 296, 301 Aleut Community v. United States ... 783 Board of Education of Westside Algoma Steel Corp. v. United States .. 1011 Community Schools v. Mergens.... 221, Allen Organ Co. vv. Kimball 242, 245 International, Inc. ............... 666 Booker v. Grand Rapids Medical Allied Signal, Inc. v. United States... 943 Amgen, Inc. v. Chugai Pharmaceutical Borough of Alpine v. United States ... 631, 642, 701, 873, 877, 885, 889 Brown v. Board of Education Anderson v. City of Bessemer City.... 996 Brunswick Corp. v. United States .... Andrew Corp. v. Gabriel Electronics, Burlington Northern Railroad v. Woods 1102 IO Nast Sisa mo tdlncciaiee ddaagatelced 633 Cabot Corp. v. United States Animal Legal Defense Fund v. Quigg. 1024, Cain v. Hyatt 1025, 1043, 1074 Chalk v. United States District Court . Anthony v. Syracuse University .... 288, 361 Chan v. Korean Air Lines, Ltd. 156, Atari, Inc. v. JS & A Group, Inc. .... 578 170, 173, 182 Atlas Powder Co. v. E.I. Du Pont de Chemcast Corp. v. Arco Industries Nemours & Co. ..........00eeee 652 Corp. Aurea Jewelry Creations, Inc. v. United Cherokee Nation v. Georgia Chevron U.S.A. Inc. ¥. Aviation Contractor Employees, Inc. v. Resources Defense Council, Inc. 914, 1008 United States Cheyenne-Arapaho Tribes v. United Bakelite Thermosets, Ltd. v. United States Christianson v. Colt Industries Ball, Ball & Brosamer, Inc. v. United 578, 647, 710 Chrysler Motors Corp. v. United States 999 Baltimore University of Baltimore City Clipper Belt Lacer Co., Inc. v. United 993 Banco Nacional de Cuba v. Sabbatino 510 Collins International Service Co. v. Barker v. Bryn Mawr College 316 United States Barnard y. Inhabitants of Shelburne.. 292, Commercial Energies, Inc. v. United 309, 331 944 Bayer Co. v. United Drug Co. ....... 975 Connelly v. University of Vermont and Begay v. United States State Agricultural College 297, 331 Bender v. Williamsport Area School Consolidated Aluminum Corp. v. Foseco District International Ltd. Benjamins vv. _ British European Consolidated Rock Products Co. v. Airways Berger v. Weber Copelands’ Enterprises, Inc. v. CNV, Bergstrom v. Buettner YET PETE CLO ER TCO Tee Te 961 Bigham vy. Godtfredsen Corning Glass Works v. United States Biocraft Laboratories, Inc. v. United International Trade Commission ... 1018 States International Trade Corso v. Creighton University Commission County of Allegheny v. ACLU Cowan v. University of Louisville School Fort Sill Apache Tribe v. United States 779 of Medicine Fromberg, Inc. v. Thornhill 902 Coxe v. Phillips FTC v. H.N. Singer, Inc. Craft Machine Works, Inc. v. United FTC v. Southwest Sunsites, Inc... 1185, 1188 GAF Corp. v. United States Craig v. Boren Gaspar v. Bruton General Electric Co. v. United States . Dana Corp. v. IPC Ltd. Partnership . . Gerber Garment Technology, Inc. v. Data Line Corp. v. Micro Technologies, Lectra Systems, Inc. Wree se Ssint cteeG sc eisieinls Gila River Pima-Maricopa Indian Dawco Construction, Inc. v. United Community v. United States States Gilbert v. Derwinski DeGeorge v. Bernier Gilmer vy. Interstate/Johnson Lane Dena Corp. v. Belvedere International, GUI «26- o:a 5 (anstateara raereeumrere eeea pe rs WM eB cjard oiees cinW inisis cloths, eceieien seer 963 Glaxo Operations UK Ltd. v. Quigg .. Diamond v. Chakrabarty 1024, Glidden Co. v. Zdanok 1032, 1052 Glover v. Eastern Nebraska Community District 27 Community School Board v. Office of Retardation Board of Education Goldstein v. New York University .... Dixon vy. Alabama State Board of 275, 299, 306, 324 Education 275, 297 D.M.I, Inc. v. Deere & Co. ......... 725 Gould v. Quigg DSL Dynamic Sciences Ltd. v. Union Green v. Biddle Switch & Signal, Inc. ............ Green v. Rich Iron Co. Duckworth v. Franzen Greenhill v. Bailey Durango Assocs., Inc. v. Reflange, Inc. 300, 304, 308, 314, 324, 331 Durrett yv. Washington National Guaber, S.p.A. v. Nutri-Metics Int'l, PUNO NGO. 5 o5c5 aie <oaiee0s0 's WME 55:50:05 Sedawnes csee ee Easley v. University of Michigan Board Guess?, Inc. v. United States Halliburton Co. v. Schlumberger Eastern Airlines, Inc. v. Floyd 157 FOCRMOLORY CORB «5.565:56. «i6da a5ie6ie s Emerald Maintenance, Inc. v. United Halliburton Oil Well Cementing Co. v. States 927 Equal Employment Opportunity Hammond y. Auburn University Commission v. Boeing Co. ........ 1268 Hanna v. Plumer Erhardt v. Havens Harris v. Blake Estate of P.D. Beckwith, Inc. Hartness_ International, _Inc. Commissioner of Patents Simplimatic Engineering Co. ...... 749 Estelle v. Gamble 1345, 1359, 1374 Healy y. Larsson E.T. Horn Co. v. United States 995 Heater v. FTC Evans v. Virginia Board of Regents... 315 Heisler v. New York Medical College. 334 Ex parte Allen 1034, 1052 Hewlett-Packard Co. v. Olympus Corp. 956 Ex parte Hibberd 1033, 1052 Hill v. Sibley Memorial Hospital 115 Farrel Corp. v. United States Hines vy. Rinker International Trade Commission ... 1020 Hitaffer v. Argonne Co. .......... 113, 128 Farwell v. Boston and Worcester R.R. 39 Hopland Band of Pomo Indians v. Feldman vy. Aunstrup 668 United States Ferens v. John Deere Co. ........... 1113 Hormone Research Foundation y. Ferriter v. Daniel O’Connell’s Sons, Inc. 121 GERONICCR INC. 55 5. Ska seme 640 Fidelity Construction Co. v. United Hughes Aircraft Co. v. United States . 659 Hutto v. Finney 1342, 1362 Finley v. United States Hybritech, Inc. Monoclonal Floyd v. Eastern Airlines, Inc. . 144, 158, 174 Antibodies, Inc. ....... 632, 647, 708, 719 Fort Mojave Indian Tribe v. United ICSD Corp. v. United States 936 States 809, 810 Ikpeazu v. University of Nebraska.... 317 Information Systems & Networks Corp. In re Stempel v. United States In re Air Disaster at Lockerbie, In re Waters 73 Scotland on December 21, 1988.... 144, In re Weiler 159, 160 In re Wilder 674, 680, 687 In re Argoudelis 672, 679, 689 In re Bartfeld In re Young In re Ziegler Insurance Co. of North America v. United States Intel Corp. v. United States International Trade Commission... 871, 901, 907, 1017 International Shoe Co. v. Washington. 1111 In re Cooper Tire & Rubber Company Jacob Siegel Co. v. FTC In re Corkill JANA, Inc. v. United States Jicarilla Apache Tribe v. Supron Energy 2 EE eee E OEE RT Tr. CFe c 812 In re Fine J & J Snack Foods Corp. v. McDonald’s In re Fisher oO EEE ORE LCCCE CE 976 Johnson v. McIntosh 828 In re Gosteli Johnson v. Robison 857, 858 In re Hijacking of Pan American World Johnston v. IVAC Corp. ......00005: 742 Airways, Inc. Aircraft at Karachi Jones v. United States International Airport, Pakistan on Jonsson v. Stanley Works September 5, 1986 Jurgens v. McKasy Kalan, Inc. v. United States Keller v. Hewitt In re Iwahashi Kellogg Co. v. Pack’Em Enterprises, In re J.T. Baker, Inc. .........0045. TMP a Gc ccuceacecewicnctaeknes 980 In re Kaslow Kennecott Corp. v. Kyocera In re Keystone Camera Products Corp. International, Inc. ............. 674, 686 In re Kirchner Keystone Driller Co. vv. General In re Koller EN OR a.o 's ox wedi eccanecae In re Korean Air Lines Disaster of King Instrument Corp. v. Otari Corp. . September 1, 1983 144, 168 Kingsdown Medical Consultants, Ltd. v. In re Lukach PONG TE 5 sv acenccsccacncns In re Lundak Laitram Corp. v. NEC, Corp. ....... 901 In re Marosi Laitram Corp. v. Rexnord, Inc. .... 745, 906 Larry Harmon Pictures Corp. v. In re Mother Tucker’s Food Experience, Williams Restaurant Corp......... 966 ME arene Fe Su ec nena ae uets Lear Siegler, Inc. v. Sealy Mattress Co. 909 In re Mulder Leckelt v. Board of Commissioners .. . In re Nathan Lemon v. Kurtzman In re Nielson . Levernier Construction, Inc. v. United In re Oklahoma City, Broadcasting Co. States In re Peters 679, 681 Library of Congress v. Shaw In re PSI Mobile ucts, Inc. ..... 954 Linde Air Products Co. v. Graver Tank In re Reynolds tea atcha ie iWwe ae a8 688 & Manufacturing Co. ............ In re Robbins f Lindemann Maschinenfabrik GmbH v. In re poses American Hoist & Derrick Co. In re Salmoh Litton Systems, Inc. v. Whirlpool Corp. Local 1812, American Federation of New York State Association for Government Employees v. United Retarded Children v. Carey States Department of State Nichimen America, Inc. v. Sper RMAC MS. INC. 205055060685 States Lynch v. Donnelly Northern Telecom, Inc. v. Datapoint Lyons v. Salve Regina College CODE, isis oncainns ener 655, 703 Magdo v. Kooi Norwest Bank Worthington y. Ahlers . 93 Magic Wand, Inc. v. RDB Inc. ...... Oakley, Inc. v. International Tropic-Cal Mahavongsanan y. Hall DG on inns ard mane See ae ene ete 974 Maitland v. Wayne State University O'Keeffe v. Snyder 533, 536 Medical School 330, 338 Olsson v. Board of Higher Education of Malone v. United States 924 City of New York Malta v. Schulmerich Carillons, Inc. . 909 Orloff v. Willoughby Manchester Band of Pomo Indians v. Orthokinetics, Inc. v. Safety Travel United States CHONG ING: 5. itsakeccoaeeeet 632 M.A.P. v. Ryan Overall Roofing & Construction Inc. v. Marquez v. University of Washington . 349 United States Martin v. Mayer Palumbo v. Don-Joy Co............. 726 Matsushita Electric Industrial Co. v. Paul v. Davis United States 1013, 1014 Pawnee v. United States M.C. & D. Capital Corp. v. United Pennwalt Corp. v. Akzona, Inc. ...... Pennwalt Corp. v. Durand-Wayland, McDonald’s Corp. v. United States ... 930 E| | en eos Medtronic, Inc. v. Intermedics, Inc. . . 729 Penrod Drilling Co. v. United States . . Menominee Tribe of Indians v. United People ex rel. Cecil v. Bellevue Hospital 793 Medical College Menzel v. List 530 People ex rel. Goldenkoff v. Albany Law Meritor Savings Bank v. Wilson Miller v. Dailey People ex rel. Jones v. New York Miller v. Hamline University School of Homeopathic Medical College and Hospital Mitchell v. Robert DeMario Jewelry, People ex rel. O'Sullivan v. New York MINS ots cielS ito iaie.c! assess aiavel staid wea eane Law School 290 Mitsubishi Electric Corp. v. United Perkin-Elmer Corp. v. Computervision States CGE sisi niinvarsisidea tretarerstelets einer 749 Mitsubishi Motors Corp. v. Chrysler-Plymouth, Inc. .......... Perry Education Association v. Perry Moire v. Temple University School of Local Educators’ Association Medicine P.F. Palos v. United States Morehouse Manufacturing Corp. v. J. Pleasant v. Washington Sand & Gravel Strickland & Co. ........000.000 Cas ie tcerighenisaewsice 115, 119, 128 Morrison-Knudsen Co. v. United States Plessy v. Ferguson 842 Motorala, Inc. v. Griffiths Electronics, Porter v. Warner Holding Co. ... 1185, 1190 MDE Save ase -eyeie vere ois, oc0e o.9 sisi awioe 8 3:3 PPG Industries, Inc. v. United States . 1003 National Cable Television Association v. Precision Instrument Manufacturing American Cinema Editors Co. v. Automotive Maintenance National Data Corp. ¥. MGR CO: oso ctiscwerdeoe. Quad Environmental Technologies Natural Resources Defense Council, Corp. v. Union Sanitary District ... 884 Inc. v. United States Environmental Quaker City Gear Works, Inc. v. Skil Protection Agency COE 55 sain Sse eeetaeeeeemear 683 Navajo Tribe of Indians vy. United States Racing Strollers, Inc. v. Tri Industries, Neal & Co. v. United States DS RCee ee Pye oe 715 Nevada v. United States Radio Steel & Manufacturing Co. v. Newman v. Quigg DET D PROG SHINES iosscakacs, Ceci. 723