ebook img

Taxonomic identity of "hallucinogenic" harvester ant (Pogonomyrmex californicus) confirmed PDF

12 Pages·2001·6.9 MB·English
Save to my drive
Quick download
Download
Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.

Preview Taxonomic identity of "hallucinogenic" harvester ant (Pogonomyrmex californicus) confirmed

— Winter Ethnobiolo "HALLUCINOGENIC" OF TAXONOMIC IDENTITY CONFIRMED ANT HARVESTER (Pogonomyrmex californicus) GROARK KEVIN P. Calif University Anthropology, of if CA 90024 Los Angeles, ABSTRACT life poorly-documented tradi- but was an important ends and therapeutic visionary he confirmation of report, a brief In this California. south-central tion in native and the presented, California used is red ant species in taxonomic identity of the ethnographic ac- with additional supplemented use descriptive record of its is importance particular of species is of this counts. This taxonomic identification case of the well-documented only provides the as visionary red ant ingestion agent. an hallucinogenic widespread use of an insect as lift RESUMEN mucha impor- de una tradicion fue terapeuticos, nkus) con alucinogenos y fines on e bste de California, centro-sur mal documentada en sur y tancia pero el de su description especie la de dicha y taxonomica confirma identidad articulo la taxo- Esta identification adicionales. uso se hace a traves de datos etnograficos debi- etnograf.co ejemplo unico que es nomica de puesto el es especial interes, un msecto. de derivado alucinogeno un damente documentado de agente RESUME. w.^~ ^ l ues luuiuua Hnm ixcouivii:. utilisation iit ~j-.- „ „ d,xu pe01u1 une f^.t.on «ait therapeutiques tern) a des desseins religieux et ^ »;<*f»™«£**"£ ton au groupes de plusieurs mentee mais importante dans vie la M^»" on expose sud de Dans brel CaHfornie. ce la >«££% taxononuque de fourmi e, a ^identification la ce donnees :hnograph sujet est considerable car il s' d'un insecte. que provient documente d'un agent halluncinatoire INTRODUCTION journal This - -~ Harve^ster -. Hallucinogenic the Use «tegp« and of "Ritual Therapeutic title, _ In m nomy (Groark 1996). rmex) California" Native South-Central traaiuon ui documented, ., _.j uu.m^ ^«r,rlv - v~~ v iI , overvi. ew ot a wiaespredu, K Cr IJ™ i;fr»mian In a southern among native v ingestion urative red ant a ----- »ans. Build Key eiunu.u^^x. „ H well as a F rrrngttoonn (as ohn ri ( and linguist Smithsonian nologist uc general the reconstructed hed sources), 1 ongms. probable and distribution "gesuun outlinZtts cultural rraaitior as and tox.cology, ™"L The venom bioactivity m" paper of ant closed with GROARK No. 134 Vol. 21, 2 well as preliminary suggestions concerning likely biochemical bases for the psy- choactive effects reported in the ethnographic record. my come Recently, another early account written by Harrington has to J.P. attention. In addition to supplementing our understanding of ritual ant use with additional ethnographic details from the Luiseno-Juaneno Indians, Harrington also provides us with a precise taxonomic identity for the red ant species used native southern California. This "new'' account particularly significant in in is its confirmation of the speculative taxonomic identification offered in Groark (1996). Fogonomyrmex specimens by Harrington has been In addition, a set of collected located in the ant collection of the Smithsonian Institution, further increasing the certainty of the identification. summary In the present report, provide a brief of the major features and I and by and distribution of ritual therapeutic red ant use, followed a presentation discussion of the aforementioned Harrington account (which currently acces- is sible only in a very rare edition), as well as a description of the newly located specimens. The paper with taxonom- closes a discussion of the significance of this confirmation for future toxicological studies of Fogonomyrmex species and their ic utilization in visionary contexts. This identification of particular importance, as is provides the only well-documented case of the widespread use of an insect as it an hallucinogenic agent. OVERVIEW CULTURAL OF DISTRIBUTION i shamanic was most among highly developed the indigenous groups of south-central Cali- know hich are swallowed and alive unmasticated, massive exceeding 400 in quantities (often unconsciousness dream which animals — men by young dream after quite apart from any might specific they confer, skills helpers (and the power they embodied) were important leading a critically in and prosperous men who shamans safe, healthy, In addition, aspired be life. to (more or the potently hallucinogenic toloache Jimsonweed acquired multiple or specialize* y shamanic upon them. (Se skills and e administration resull ritual ing The among the Shoshonean groups occupying edge south- the southeastern of the central region California— Kitanemuk of the (Harrington 1986b:rl.98, frs.449-450), Kawaiisu (Zigmond 1977:62, 1986:405), Tiibatulabal (Voegelin 1938:5, 46, 67-68), and the various Hokan-speaking Chumash Chu- groups, particularly the Interior mash (Harrington the 1986b:rl.98, frs.608-609, 648-652). In the Central Valley to some north, of the neighboring Southern Valley Yokuts (particularly the Yawel- ETHNOBIOLOGY 135 JOURNAL OF 2001 Winter (Wikchamni mi shamanic m Miwok (g cK4ly ant ingestion visionary core of the the groups constitute these ^ve devel- appears to practice the on reported distribution, Based the tradition. Neva* re southern Sierra groups of the — among Shoshonean-speaking oped the , , v iok- various .u ^ *«u-~ ,A^cf thpn on to the£*W* ?. me T >C-ihumash 4.^ ., . ^iiunia^i . spreading interior to gion, , wor^iin^lv San Joaquin Valley. end the of southern groups occupying the utsan omp He lex Toloache-Dream p with the coextensive largely distribution this is ^ he lane iupema tura with the s contact individual an religion stressing egalitarian ingestion through the mediated dream (usually more helpers one acquisition of or of Datura wrightii Regel). «? red ad OM.-A also California southern number groups in ^J^™ * ftp- Ant of . well) in as internally on occasion, (and the ants externally Tate among the ub.quitous were These ordeals ceremonies. bovs' initiation California *-*•« proto-nistoi ie the in lacked "ordeals" that these ichn such formed component that from ™ In wuu.11.5v without pain To make them hardy and endure ™"£*g was considered to corporeal suffering J«* having ^ would down on the hill *e graceful) they lie stomach "~ the region "of T\ nanaruis them placed iinn ttnhee <egiu.. ot „ quantities, . e them in llaarrg swallowed they Lastly, to ensure a full dose, 1 alive! [Reid 1968 (1852): 36]. ™ uk ^ Kitane Harrington's In a comment, one ?^ty revealing of thesouth- use ants red y vision-inducing these ants as being identical to the *™>^- ^ 1986a (Harrington central groups described above were ordeals among 1943:440) Miwok (Aginsky »" Northern Among group., ivionache these (Driver 1937:99). the into we integrated groups that mal among the ^ initiatory function found from mam ition to served Chingichngish practice the Instead, religion. youth to adulthood. ^ man- have to reoorted not ^ are visions p although It is interesting to note that, appears t0 these common during tested, was loss of consciousness essen- nsk red e ^""T^u. i have been an Profound loss was explicit goal. and region, the which // understood of to represent a sort GROARK No. Vol. 2 136 21, "killed" by the supernatural agents which he wished to contact. Despite the lack was of associated visions, the goal of the ant ordeal largely identical to that of — and and visionary ant ingestion augmentation of individual strength fortitude, the establishment of a personal connection with supernatural power. Both vision- ary ingestion and the ant ordeal of boys' initiation ceremonies represent the in- — power which dividual's personal contact with supernatural a connection he first could then draw on in daily for vigorous health, luck in hunting or gambling, life or for more esoteric purposes (see Groark [1996: 9-10, 16-17] for additional de- tails). — Therapeutic Uses. In addition to the esoteric uses outlined above, the ants played an important role in both curative and preventative medicine, treating a diverse common inventory of ailments, including: paralysis, gastrointestinal ailments, se- and vere colds, pain, arthritis, gynecological disorders (particularly those occa- sioned by childbirth). Ethnohistoric accounts indicate that initiatory and thera- some peutic ant ingestion persisted through the Mission Period (in cases, surviv- ing until at least the mid-1 850's), but these practices appear to have been aban- doned by the turn of the century (see Groark 1996: 11-16 for a detailed discussion). A NOTE ON NOMENCLATURE INDIGENOUS A brief survey of indigenous nomenclature homogeneity reveals striking name among Cup the applied to this ant Takic-speakers of both the Serran and The branches. ant used in these ceremonies was referred to bv the Kitanemuk name aanat as M red ant Juaneno term name ber 1925:672). It should be noted that this was not a generic term for "red medicinal names therapeutic contexts, with other local species being referred to by distinct Anderton names the (Walker 1993), while various Yokutsan speakers of the Tule-Kaweah dialects (Yawdanchi, Wikchamni, Gawia, Bokninwad, Yokod), k'awk'aw, "cra- referred to these ants as zy ants/' possibly ' in reference (Harrington to their intoxicating potential rl.94, fr.382). WAS POGONOMYRMEX THE USED CALIFORNIA? SPECIES IN many name the ant species in question. As a result, was forced to assume a somewhat I speculative tone in the previously published (Groark Based on an article 1996). analysis of the biological and behavioral provided ethnographic details in the most acknowledged problems the inherent i ETHNOBIOLOGY JOURNAL OF 137 2001 Winter o taxonomic status The k ethno nnrprtain. All em The uniformly accounts mounded build small they specimens ethno remain must therefore that a Pogo- support the assertion strongly and toxicological literature ic ethnographic the was indeed the red ant referred to in nomyrmex species and Great Basin, the California Of the ant genera present in accounts. all painful exceptionally distinguished by the large size, Pogonomyrrnex is venom amic 1996:3] pres species Pogonomyrrnex various Based on the ecological distribution of the seemed ent in California, it P species, calif &«-~ ugni accounts in »* ethnographic examine proceeded ™w the to underpmnin i^~a~~, pharmacological a ;~ .ccpqq nnssible fr. and therapeutic effects for the reported visionary While possess ^5^v vveennoomm ~- icnuy toxic ccoonnttaaiinniinngg a iiuuil/u v*. * , i . previously complex alkaloids well as ing: kinins, peptides, and neurotoxins, as venom con- these quantities, known In large only from higher plant taxa. certain em vous sys trig- ner mammalian central on stituents are capable of acting the highly altered includes that reactions gering a wide range psychophysiological of ethnographically. metabolic resembling those reported states shown been ™to have Pogonomyrrnex genus In addition. Harvester ants of the venom nas tne rug< Their venom recorded to date—. than the more toxic — mm times kn.owvwvini mmaammalian letnanry or tiny cw u u v '" •-it is 5 ^ ^^.^ «-'j-' rartnrn , ^ more venom toxic times of the Oriental hornet, and 8 to 10 data for »u._ m,o. d-„^ venom lethality I. (Srhm^,. «~i u «- „™,,hlished (Schmidt and Blum Jx determined Schmidt, califi I range within the wweerree clearly Indians ci California approximately 3! resenting £™ wu«* pee (Se an individual with body weighhtf ro»ff 110000 llbb.. ((4455..55 kkgg))., a LD„ «lcuiano complete and for a venom ;. full discussion toxicology of uncer by the weakened com T^~J£ « n ^ was therefore ta inty of the taxonomic the ant. identity of I ote R^ ambigu.ty-a come across key which resolved this «-"""**^ a reference _ r W the John R of annotation Harrington 1933 in his Indians Luiseno-Juaneno onimo the account of Boscana's Mission Period classic °f Southern California *^*^JZ!^?£2 >" this extensive Harrington clearly note, . « ethnoera ogonoinyrmex i califi (the individuals ba Luiseno-Juaneno Sed On mrr, hie ing f;^i GROARK 138 Vol. 21, No. 2 Due bulk of which was carried out intermittently between 1919 and 1933). to the rarity of these accounts, will reproduce two variant versions of Boscana's original I text as well as Harrington's annotation in full. — The "Neie" Accounts: Tuv Versions and an Annotation. The author of these accounts, who among Geronimo was predominantly Boscana, a Franciscan lived the friar Luiseno-Juaneno amalgamation of Indians at Mission San Juan Capistrano from May 1814 to January 1826. While there, he assiduously recorded all details of life — men in the pre-mission period with the help of three Luiseno-Juaneno two of whom were local chiefs, and the other a shaman. The resulting account, properly known was probably compiled around and as the Rclacidn Historica, 1822, first remains one and most of the earliest detailed descriptions of aboriginal in life southern 2 native California. In several brief passages Boscana mentions the therapeutic use of large red ants by the local Indians when they were "in heathen The ants their state." still were applied externally in the treatment of unspecified "pains": most and commonest when the frequent practice, especially in pain, . . . was whip to the place where the pain was with and put them nettles, to on right the place of the pain, and likewise ants, and these especially latter manner 49] most Boscana's extensive description relates to the "ant ordeal" that formed the conclusion of the boys' initiation ceremony into the Chingichngish religion of the and Gabrielino, Luiseno, Juaneno boys were Indians. All subjected to this ordeal, which was performed during early adolescence in order to "harden" the youths, to provide luck and skill in hunting, and to ensure a long Robinson's 1846 life. translation of the Relacion Historica describes in the following terms: it undergo men, and be admitted to emony of the potense [ritual initiatory branding with Artemisia vulgaris they were whipped with and L.J, nettles covered with ants that they might become robust. This was always performed summer, infliction in during the months of and August when was most July the nettle in its They fiery state. gathered small bunches which and they fastened together the poor deluded Indian was chastised by blows with them inflicting upon naked his limbs until he was unable to walk. He was then carried to the nest of the nearest and most down furious species of ants, and laid among them, while some of his friends, with kept annoying the sticks, make insects to them more What un- still violent. torments did they not What What dergo! pain! power hellish inflictions! Yet gave them their faith to endure all without a murmur, and they remained dead. Having as if undergone these dreadful ordeals, they were considered as invulnerable, and believed arrows that the of their enemies could no longer harm them. [Robinson reproduced and 1846; annotated Harrington in 1933: 47] A slightly different account of event found this is in Harrington's translation J.P. of the "Cessac manuscript" of the which Relacion, reads as follows: JOURNAL OF ETHNOBIOLOGY 139 2001 Winter cerem on and another one they placed the patient a nest of fierce ants, nettles, make them uv them to from what he must condition in hich And was seemed dead, cause so great their patience, that they like fever. movement. These some some comp ith r from time that enemies two annotation to the of these first own from ethno his among research the Luiseno and Ji were ceremony The ants used in the ant stinging of the boys' [called] antum, Pogomvm/rmex califi medicinal ant of these people. ing Ant. This a good-sized red ant, the is ground, making large nests in the throughout It is plentiful the region, When and much climb out of a bottle. not being unable to of a climber, is and with formic bites abdomen, acid, with injecting irritated, stings it its The ant time. attachment European bee The be painful as a sting claimed by the Indians to as is when 4 Doubtless more. and minutes or sting, hurts noticeably for fifteen much more were stung fre- the Indians about camps naked they lay the quently than present. at rneumausm, in- When relieve these ants were used as medicine, to number of the ants, method was pick a ternal pains, and the one to like, stung where they one part, after another, and place them on the afflicted accidentally got and dropped or were off allowed remain they until to dozen or by putting a brushed himself cured Eustaquio [Lugo] once off; ° ' l Another l ., f^-Virmre < ., .i them . b. osom • on his modern method in a piece of cheesecloth cheesecloth ^ -- um have «« ***—- ,IW bueteenn uusseeda Doys cceerreemmoonnyy, iinn ttnhee boys' or better ants these doubtedly named boy on a nest of and to seat lay the J was Thpre j. i~ ,1.. L >;«rr V»^»1p , _ . . hi. m . — — ~™ ~ ^uii sMtIuUn1g5 DOy « ui Wcto IIUL il -* llUil lilt? , murmur on the without a until boy and the weakened, this fainted or all given to medicine as Part administered of the The were boy. ants also an found have not sick but people being swallowed alive, I internally, ceremony boys the informant who swallowed in were they recalled that [Harrington note 1933:164, 128] • • • — GROARK No. Vol. 2 21, 140 Luiseno-Juaneno referred to this the Harrington indicates that Later the note, in ant")— "an anting" (Harrington 1933: (< "red 'antush 'aanat literally, as ritual note 164, 128)! account intermittently among 191U since at least manuscript fieldnotes descriptions contained in his groups. Unfortunately, the common name binomial or Latin ml\ lm with proper taxonomic identification of the species involved. us the first Determination?—Despite the excite- or Inference Scientific Harrington's Identification: my speculative identification, ment finding Harrington's note confirming earlier of How nagging question remained: did Harrington arrive at this identification? a Was merely an it voucher determined mens? We know nomenclature (most have not surviv which, unfortunately, Institu story Smithsonian vouchers in the tion reading a draft version of this paper. after from his office door, Dr. Schultz The and one male, female. rt ufi According and each bears an identical label reading: Harrington, Collector." "J.P. was determination Schultz, the identification label indicates that the species to madp hv Rnhwpr hvmpnontprist who worked Smithsonians ciipvprf Allpn a at the Museum From from of Natural History 1909 to 1951. ^ j deposited were Rohwer, suggesting Harrington ant identifications referred to that specimens Cottonia, were Although the specimen labels indicate that the ants collected in — when along considered :ona (and not southern California), their discovery Harringto with probable date of deposit their t determined from derived specimens very published identification (or at the least, that his his but before voucher specimens collected after his Luiseno-Juaneno fieldwork, 1933 Boscana annotation). CONCLUSIONS de- The combination of three lines of evidence—the physical and ecological as Harrington's precise 1933 entomological identification, scription of the species, — make Pogonomyrmex voucher specimens allows us to well as the discovery of his used species argument Pogonomyrmex was, the ant a strong that californicus in fact, b ETHNOBIOLOGY JOURNAL OF 141 2001 Winter an That such identifi- purposes native California. and medicinal in visionary for known use more than century after the species' last is be confirmed a can cation anthropological specimens voucher in importance of the testimony to eloquent ma- such preserve that importance of the collections the well as to as research, terials. n . . comes principally knowledge red ant ingestion our of Despite the fact that when consid- patchwork and well"^este complete remarkably with us a entirety-provide ered in their ^ exam ethnoeraphic most ™« ™«^« inadequate ethno- documentation—either from a lack of nave uoiiu* w species in Wcl^ptiom surrounding the identity of the confusion a ap gr AC M With w* ~ Willi LUC pUL/llVUiiv/ii »~~ UUC31UJ11. - , r -• • • record of and descriptive the been confirmed, has ant used in native California new This accounts. ethnographic additional supplemented with several use its is much on firmer a investigations toxicological future taxonomic certainty places harvester "hallucinogenic of reconstruction our footing, adding a key piece to California. ant use in native south-central NOTES ^ystems that two major religious one of The as ' Chingichngish religion is classified <K^*««£~ Debased southern California of developed toloache cult out of the ehno among Gate th originated have appears to burn The Chingichngish religion 1974). £-£4T*"£ groups, neighboring ^ spread to during then the proto-historic period, my round cen tered a lc ^ doctrine Bean and Vane 1978). Its indigenous evangelization «^P?* who te taught named Chingichngish £»*»"" counts of a shaman-like culture hero with older local become integrated set of which appear have beliefs, to ^^Z^SSSSSL on based t—h«e~ tiovliouaucuhIeC cLUuLlLt-an^Cg^aahiltlaClrl.an riweilii^giivoin. ~ .-• Clll 1CII l wngmi . Datura of "dream ingestion ceremonial helpers" through the ^^^^r^n^-^^S tormahzed highly - « religion was by esoteric doctrine, ^ characterized Jonia, and enclosures the construction of ^ more d eta For Cult Chingichngish (hence the frequent reference to the ). Luiseno. 2 There ^— known - L w*», mstorica ae creenaa, la " published versioi ^nAcagcImi^ THp full first Capistmno llamado Juan la inson ~— puuiibnea an appenan ifi as _ chose the "Chinigchinich title aocun ^.^ name this for cana's ^ ^ account, and has become the de facto . since it _ "£ original «™"f different fPPears to have relied upon two slightly ' ed describ . J Cessac t " the have suggest that been ***** **" peculiarities lost (however, stylistic Robins0 n's Harrmgton below was one In 1933, of the source versions). J.P. anno etnnograpnu. pages ot Somet Chinigchinich.") ton's . GROARK No. Vol. 2 142 21, "new Boscana" manuscript Harrington also succeeded in locating a lost original in the know Biblioteque Nationale in Paris. This version own hand, providing us with the only surviving original manuscript. written in Boscana's This version; which differs in some details from Robinson's translation, was published in English by Harrington (1934) and in the original Spanish by Reichlen and Reichlen (1971). For the sake of clarity, will refer to all versions of the text as Boscana's Relation Historica, 1 but them under the surname of the translator or editor in order to distinguish between cit« I numerous the variant editions. and was This practice appears to have been based on the principle of counter-irritation, venom among widespread southern and south-central Californian groups. Interestingly, the m of the ant Pseudomyr ex has been shown to be an efficacious treatment for chronic rheu- component matoid arthritis (Schultz and Arnold 1978), and there is evidence that a in venom and symptoms Roy Los honey-bee alleviates arthritic pain associated (Dr. Snelling, Museum communication Angeles of Natural History: personal 1995). and and have been described 4 Pogonomyrmex stings are exceedingly painful long-lasting, around as approximating "ripping muscles or tendons" or "turning a screw in the flesh — sweeps the sting site" and of this accompanied by a nervous, chilling sensation that all upward from (Schmidt the of the sting 1986). site 5 The only well-documented hallucinogen of non-botanical origin comes from the Sonoran 5-MeO-DMT Desert Toad alwrius Girard), which accumulates prodigious quantities of (Bufo A in venom glands (Weil and Davis 1994). number of neotropical toads and frogs its (mostly Dendrobates, Phyllobates, and Phyllomedusa) also secrete toxins which are used by the Amazon Amahuaca and Matses Indians of the Peruvian in hunting magic, although visions Amato cu- are usually not reported (Carneiro 1970, 1992). Interestingly, these intoxicating — from taneous alkaloids are not endogenously produced rather, they are sequestered di- The etary sources which include alkaloid-rich myrmicine ant species (Daly 1994). only reference to an insect-based hallucinogen an anecdotal report by Saint-Hilaire (1824) is referring a moth (Myclobia smerintha Huebner) used by the Malali Indians of Brazil to larval produce an opium-like, dream-filled sleep. While Britton (1984) has proposed that the to moth new gut or salivary glands of this larval be classified as a hallucinogen, Ott (1993: j moth more • i 414) argues confirmed, the accurately regarded as an "oneirogenic that, is if or "dream-inducing" agent, and classifies all of these cases as "putative" hallucinogens LITERATURE CITED BURT AGINSKY, W. Culture Element Washingt 1943. XXIV D.C Distributions: Central Sierra. Uni- THOMAS BLACKBURN, versity of California Anthropological C. 1974. Cere- Records 8:393-468. monial and Interac- Integration Social AMATO, From "Hunter 93- 1992. Magic," a tion in Aboriginal California. Pp. I. Pharmacopoeia? Science 258: 1306. 110 'Antap: California Indian Politi- in ANDERTON, ALICE JEANNE. The 1988. and Economic Organization (Lowell cal Language of the Kitanemuks of Califor- Bean and Thomas E King, Bal- eds.). J. nia. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of lena Ramona Press: California. A New California, Los Angeles. BRITTON, E. B. 1984. Pointer to a LOWELL BEAN, JOHN and SYLVIA Hallucinogen Journal of Insect Origin. BRAKKE VANE. 1978. Cults and Ethnopharmacology their of 12:331-333. Transformations. Pp. 662-672 Hand- CARNEIRO, ROBERT Hunting and in 1970. L. book of North American IndiansrVol. Hunting Magic Among Amahuaca. the — 8 California (Robert Heizer, Ethnology 9:331-341 F. ed.).

See more

The list of books you might like

Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.