Summary report of already published guidance on L2 PSA for external hazards, shutdown states ...

82 Pages·2015·1.53 MB·English

ASAMPSA_E Advanced Safety Assessment
Methodologies: extended PSA

"NUCLEAR FISSION"
Safety of Existing Nuclear Installations

Contract 605001

Summary report of already published guidance on L2 PSA for external
hazards, shutdown states, spent fuel storage

Reference ASAMPSA_E
Technical report ASAMPSA_E / WP40 / D40.2 / 2014-08
D02ARV-01-050-776_A_FIN

Gerben Dirksen, Estelle SAUVAGE

AREVA-NP

Period covered: from 01/07/2013 to 31/12/2015 Actual submission date: 31/12/2014
Start date of ASAMPSA_E: 01/07/2013 Duration: 36 months
WP No: 40 Lead topical coordinator : Horst Loeffler His organization name : GRS

Project co-funded by the European Commission Within the Seventh Framework Programme (2013-2016)
Dissemination Level
PU Public No
RE Restricted to a group specified by the partners of the ASAMPSA_E Yes
project
CO Confidential, only for partners of the ASAMPSA_E project Yes

AREVA PEPS-F DC D02ARV-01-050-776_A_FIN Technical report ASAMPSA_E/ WP40/D40.2/2014-08 1/81

Summary Report of Already Published Guidance on PSA Level 2
ASAMPSA_E
for External Hazards, Shutdown Sates, Spent Fuel Pool

MODIFICATIONS OF THE DOCUMENT

Pages or
Description or comments
Version Date Authors
paragraphs
modified
A 31/12/2013 Gerben Dirksen N/A Initial draft version sent to
Estelle Sauvage participants for review and
(AREVA-NP) comments
B 15/12/2014 Gerben Dirksen All This version includes
Estelle Sauvage comments and additional
(AREVA-NP) inputs by the WP40
partners.

LIST OF DIFFUSION

European Commission (scientific officer)

Name First name Organization
Passalacqua Roberto EC

ASAMPSA_E Project management group (PMG)

Name First name Organization
Raimond Emmanuel IRSN Project coordinator
Guigueno Yves IRSN WP10 coordinator
Decker Kurt Vienna University WP21 coordinator
Klug Joakim LRC WP22 coordinator
Wielenberg Andreas GRS WP30 coordinator
Loeffler Horst GRS WP40 coordinator

REPRESENTATIVES OF ASAMPSA_E PARTNERS

Name First name Organization Name First name Organization
Grindon Liz AMEC NNC Kollasko Heiko AREVA
Mustoe Julian AMEC NNC Michaud Laurent AREVA
Cordoliani Vincent AREVA Sauvage Estelle AREVA
Dirksen Gerben AREVA Hasnaoui Chiheb AREXIS
Godefroy Florian AREVA Hurel François AREXIS
AREVA PEPS-F DC D02ARV-01-050-776_A_FIN Technical report ASAMPSA_E/ WP40/D40.2/2014-08 3/81
Summary Report of Already Published Guidance on PSA Level 2
ASAMPSA_E
for External Hazards, Shutdown Sates, Spent Fuel Pool
Name First name Organization Name First name Organization
Schirrer Raphael AREXIS Apostol Minodora INR
De Gelder Pieter Bel V Nitoi Mirela INR
Gryffroy Dries Bel V Groudev Pavlin INRNE
Jacques Véronique Bel V Stefanova Antoaneta INRNE
Van Rompuy Thibaut Bel V Armingaud François IRSN
Cazzoli Errico CCA Bardet Lise IRSN
Vitázková Jirina CCA Baumont David IRSN
Hugon Michel EC Bonnet Jean-Michel IRSN
Passalacqua Roberto EC Bonneville Hervé IRSN
Banchieri Yvonnick EDF Clement Christophe IRSN
Benzoni Stéphane EDF Corenwinder François IRSN
Bernadara Pietro EDF Denis Jean IRSN
Bonnevialle Anne-Marie EDF Duflot Nicolas IRSN
Brac Pascal EDF Duluc Claire-Marie IRSN
Coulon Vincent EDF Dupuy Patricia IRSN
Gallois Marie EDF Durin Thomas IRSN
Henssien Benjamin EDF Georgescu Gabriel IRSN
Hibti Mohamed EDF Guigueno Yves IRSN
Jan Philippe EDF Guimier Laurent IRSN
Lopez Julien EDF Lanore Jeanne-Marie IRSN
Nonclercq Philippe EDF Laurent Bruno IRSN
Panato Eddy EDF Ménage Frédéric IRSN
Parey Sylvie EDF Pichereau Frederique IRSN
Romanet François EDF Rahni Nadia IRSN
Rychkov Valentin EDF Raimond Emmanuel IRSN
Vasseur Dominique EDF Rebour Vincent IRSN
Burgazzi Luciano ENEA Sotti Oona IRSN
Hultqvist Göran FKA Volkanovski Andrija JSI
Karlsson Anders FKA Alzbutas Robertas LEI
Ljungbjörk Julia FKA Matuzas Vaidas LEI
Pihl Joel FKA Rimkevicius Sigitas LEI
Loeffler Horst GRS Häggström Anna LRC
Mildenberger Oliver GRS Klug Joakim LRC
Sperbeck Silvio GRS Knochenhauer Michael LRC
Tuerschmann Michael GRS Kumar Manorma LRC
Wielenberg Andreas GRS Olsson Anders LRC
Benitez Francisco Jose IEC Borysiewicz Mieczyslaw NCBJ
Del Barrio Miguel A. IEC Kowal Karol NCBJ
Serrano Cesar IEC Potempski Slawomir NCBJ
IEC La Rovere Stephano NIER
AREVA PEPS-F DC D02ARV-01-050-776_A_FIN Technical report ASAMPSA_E/ WP40/D40.2/2014-08 4/81
Summary Report of Already Published Guidance on PSA Level 2
ASAMPSA_E
for External Hazards, Shutdown Sates, Spent Fuel Pool
Name First name Organization Name First name Organization
Vestrucci Paolo NIER Bogdanov Dimitar TUS
Brinkman Hans (Johannes L.) NRG Ivanov Ivan TUS
Kahia Sinda NRG Kaleychev TUS
Bareith Attila NUBIKI Hladky Milan UJV
Lajtha Gabor NUBIKI Holy Jaroslav UJV
Siklossy Tamas NUBIKI Hustak Stanislav UJV
Morandi Sonia RSE Jaros Milan UJV
Dybach Oleksiy SSTC Kolar Ladislav UJV
Gorpinchenko Oleg SSTC Kubicek Jan UJV
Claus Etienne TRACTEBEL Mlady Ondrej UJV
Dejardin Philippe TRACTEBEL Decker Kurt UNIVIE
Grondal Corentin TRACTEBEL Halada Peter VUJE
Mitaille Stanislas TRACTEBEL Prochaska Jan VUJE
Oury Laurence TRACTEBEL Stojka Tibor VUJE
Zeynab Umidova TRACTEBEL

REPRESENTATIVE OF ASSOCIATED PARTNERS (External Experts Advisory Board (EEAB))

Name First name Company
Hirata Kazuta JANSI
Hashimoto Kazunori JANSI
Inagaki Masakatsu JANSI
Yamanana Yasunori TEPCO
Coyne Kevin US-NRC
González Michelle M. US-NRC

AREVA PEPS-F DC D02ARV-01-050-776_A_FIN Technical report ASAMPSA_E/ WP40/D40.2/2014-08 5/81
Summary Report of Already Published Guidance on PSA Level 2
ASAMPSA_E
for External Hazards, Shutdown Sates, Spent Fuel Pool

CONTRIBUTING ASAMPSA-E PARTNERS

The following table provides the list of the ASAMPSA_E partners involved in the development of this document.

Table 1 : ASAMPSA-E Partners involved in this document
1 Institute for Radiological Protection and Nuclear Safety IRSN France
2 Gesellschaft für Anlagen- und Reaktorsicherheit mbH GRS Germany
3 Ricerca sul Sistema Energetico RSE S.p.A. Italy
4 Lloyd's Regsiter Consulting LRC Sweden
5 Nuclear Research Institute Rez pl UJV Czech Rep.
6 Cazzoli Consulting CCA Switzerland
Italian National Agency for New Technologies, Energy and the Sustainable
7 ENEA Italy
Economic Development
8 IBERDROLA Ingeniería y Construcción S.A.U IEC Spain
9 Electricité de France EDF France
Lietuvos energetikos institutas
10 LEI Lithuania
(Lithuanian Energy Institute)
11 NUBIKI NUBIKI Hungary
AREVA NP
12 AREVA NP SAS France France
SAS
13 NCBJ Institute NCBJ Poland
14 State Scientific and Technical Center for Nuclear and Radiation Safety” SSTC Ukraine
15 TRACTEBEL ENGINEERING S.A. TRACTEBEL Belgium
16 Institut Jozef Stefan JSI Slovenia
Institute of nuclear research and nuclear energy – Bulgarian Academia of
17 INRNE Bulgaria
science
18 Regia Autonoma Pentru Activatati Nucleare Droberta Tr. Severin RA Suc INR Romania
19 Technical University of Sofia – Research and Development Sector TUS Bulgaria
20 AREXIS S.A.R.L. AREXIS France

AREVA PEPS-F DC D02ARV-01-050-776_A_FIN Technical report ASAMPSA_E/ WP40/D40.2/2014-08 6/81
Summary Report of Already Published Guidance on PSA Level 2
ASAMPSA_E
for External Hazards, Shutdown Sates, Spent Fuel Pool

SUMMARY

This report (deliverable D40.2 of the project ASAMPSA_E) proposes a review of the existing guidance with
relevance to ASAMPSA_E PSA Level 2 topics (external hazds, shutdown states, spent fuel pool).

As a complement of this task, the deliverable D40.2 tries to identify any potential missing guidance for the
development of an extended PSA level 2, and any sources of knowledge beyond existing guidance which might help
generating extended PSA level 2.

Based on this approach the last section provides a summary compilation which identifies possibilities for
completing existing guidelines (especially the guidance developed in the previous ASAMPSA2 project) and/or
creating new guidelines for extended PSA Level 2.
AREVA PEPS-F DC D02ARV-01-050-776_A_FIN Technical report ASAMPSA_E/WP40/D40.2/2014-08 6/81
Summary Report of Already Published Guidance on PSA Level 2
ASAMPSA_E
for External Hazards, Shutdown Sates, Spent Fuel Pool

CONTENT

MODIFICATIONS OF THE DOCUMENT................................................................................................................................................. 3
LIST OF DIFFUSION ............................................................................................................................................................................ 3
CONTRIBUTING ASAMPSA-E PARTNERS ........................................................................................................................................ 6
SUMMARY ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 6
CONTENT ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 7
List of tables ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 8
GLOSSARY ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 8
1 Introduction .................................................................................................................................................................................. 10
2 Summary on Published Guides .................................................................................................................................................... 11
2.1 IAEA Safety Standards and Technical Documents ............................................................................................................... 14
2.2 OECD / NEA / CSNI Documents .......................................................................................................................................... 34
2.3 EU Technical Documents ...................................................................................................................................................... 36
2.4 National Documents .............................................................................................................................................................. 37
2.5 Summary of published guides in the light of ASAMPSA_E ................................................................................................. 56
3 Summary of Material Other than Published Guides ..................................................................................................................... 59
3.1 Examples of Recent Post Fukushima Daiichi Accident Developments ................................................................................. 59
3.1.1 Bulgaria ....................................................................................................................................................... 59
3.1.2 Canada ........................................................................................................................................................ 60
3.1.3 Czech Republic ........................................................................................................................................... 61
3.1.4 France.......................................................................................................................................................... 61
3.1.5 Germany...................................................................................................................................................... 62
3.1.6 Slovenia ...................................................................................................................................................... 63
3.1.7 Spain ........................................................................................................................................................... 64
3.1.8 Sweden ........................................................................................................................................................ 64
3.1.9 Switzerland ................................................................................................................................................. 66
3.2 Publications (in Scientific Conferences and Other) ............................................................................................................... 68
4 Evaluation of Existing Material .................................................................................................................................................... 76
5 List of References......................................................................................................................................................................... 78

AREVA PEPS-F DC D02ARV-01-050-776_A_FIN Technical report ASAMPSA_E/WP40/D40.2/2014-08 7/81
Summary Report of Already Published Guidance on PSA Level 2
ASAMPSA_E
for External Hazards, Shutdown Sates, Spent Fuel Pool

LIST OF TABLES

Table 1 : ASAMPSA-E Partners ..................................................................................................... 6
Table 2 : Summary on Reviewed Documents ................................................................................... 11
Table 3 : PSA Level 2 Publications of Interest for ASAMPSA_E ............................................................... 68
Table 4 : Evaluation of Existing Material for Extended PSA Usage .......................................................... 76

GLOSSARY
The glossary does not include the trigrams and abbreviations for company and agencies.

ASAMPSA-E Advanced Safety Assessment: Extended PSA
BWR Boiling Water Reactor
CCF Common Cause Failure
CDES Core Damage End States
CDF Core Damage Frequency
CET Containment Event Tree
CHLA Candidate High Level Action
DBA Design Basis Accident
DCH Direct Containment Heating
DID Defence In Depth
FV Fussel Vessely
HRA Human Reliability Analysis
I&C Instrumentation & Control
IRIDM Integrated Risk Informed Decision Making
ISLOCA Interfacing System Loss Of Coolant Accident
LERF Large Early Release Frequency
LRF Large Release Frequency
LWR Light Water Reactors
MCCI Molten Core Concrete Interaction
NPP Nuclear Power Plant
PDS Plant Damage States
PHWR Pressurized Heavy Water Reactors
PRA Probabilistic Risk Assessment
AREVA PEPS-F DC D02ARV-01-050-776_A_FIN Technical report ASAMPSA_E/WP40/D40.2/2014-08 8/81
Summary Report of Already Published Guidance on PSA Level 2
ASAMPSA_E
for External Hazards, Shutdown Sates, Spent Fuel Pool

PSA Probabilistic Safety Analysis
PWR Pressurized Water Reactor
RAW Risk Achievement Worth
RBMK Reaktor Bolshoy Moshchnosti Kanalnyi
RPV Reactor Pressure Vessel
SAMP Severe Accident Management Program
SBO Station BlackOut
SFP Spent Fuel Pool
SGTR Steam Generator Tube Rupture
SSC Structures, Systems and Components
TMI Three Miles’ Island
TSC Technical Support Center
VVER Vodo-Vodianoï Energuetitcheski Reaktor

AREVA PEPS-F DC D02ARV-01-050-776_A_FIN Technical report ASAMPSA_E/WP40/D40.2/2014-08 9/81