Secularism, Assimilation and the Crisis of Multiculturalism: French Modernist Legacies

345 Pages·2013·4.352 MB·English

by  Yolande Jansen

imiscoe
This remarkable book develops a political theoretical critique of contemporary J ReSeARCh
a
n
discourses on secularism and assimilation. Jansen argues that the perspective of
s
e
assimilating distinct ethno-religious minorities by incorporating them into a secular n
and supposedly neutral public sphere can generate and perpetuate the very distinctions
S
e
it is meant to overcome. To flesh out this insight she borrows from the literature c
u Secularism, Assimilation and
on the paradoxes of assimilation as experienced by the French Jews in the late 19th la
r
century, through a contextualised reading of Marcel Proust’s In Search of Lost Time. is
m
Jansen offers a dynamic, critical multiculturalism as an alternative to discourses ,
A the Crisis of Multiculturalism
focusing on secularism, assimilation and integration. s
s
i
m
i
Yolande Jansen is a senior researcher at the Amsterdam Center for Globalisation la
t
i
Studies, University of Amsterdam. She is also a Socrates professor of humanism in o
n
relation to religion and secularity at the VU University Amsterdam. a French Modernist Legacies
n
d

t
h
e
“[A] brilliant and thorough philosophical reading of current writings on assimilation, multiculturalism and C
secularism, weaving together a rereading of Proust on Jewish experiences of the paradoxes of assimilation with current r
i
debates about the situation of Muslims in Europe.” s
i
s
John R. Bowen, Dunbar-Van Cleve Professor in Arts & Sciences,
o Yolande Jansen
Washington University in St. Louis f

M
“Jansen’s brilliant and insightful analysis draws on a variety of fields and lucidly shows how the crisis is a crisis in u
l
modernity.”  t
i
c
Brian Klug, Philosophy, University of Oxford u
l
t
u
“Jansen’s work is a hard-hitting and back to basics reminder of multiculturalism fundamentals. It also offers a brilliant, r
a
pragmatic and insightful analysis of what secularism makes invisible about the position of Muslims in France today.” l
i Amsterdam Universit y Press
Rim-Sarah Alouane, Université Toulouse I-Capitole sm
 978 90 8964 596 8
   · ..
Secularism, Assimilation and the Crisis of Multiculturalism
imiscoe
International Migration, Integration and Social Cohesion in Europe
The Imiscoe Research Network unites researchers from some 30 istitutes specialising
in studies of international migration, integration and social cohesion in Europe.
What began in 2004 as a Network of Excellence sponsored by the Sixth Framework
Programme of the European Commission became, as of April 2009, an independent
self-funding endeavour. Imiscoe promotes integrated, multidisciplinary and globally
comparative research led by scholars from various branches of the economic and social
sciences, the humanities and law. The network furthers existing studies and pioneers
new scholarship on migration and migrant integration. Encouraging innovative lines of
inquiry key to European policymaking and governance is also a priority.
The Imiscoe-Amsterdam University Press Series makes the network’s findings and
results available to researchers, policymakers and practitioners, the media and other
interested stakeholders. High-quality manuscripts are evaluated by external peer
reviews and the Imiscoe Editorial Committee. The committee comprises the following
members:
Tiziana Caponio, Department of Political Studies, University of Turin / Forum for
International and European Research on Immigration (fieri), Turin, Italy
Michael Collyer, Sussex Centre for Migration Research (scmr), University of Sussex,
United Kingdom
Rosita Fibbi, Swiss Forum for Migration and Population Studies (sfm), University of
Neuchâtel, Switzerland / Institute of Social Sciences, University of Lausanne
Agata Górny, Centre of Migration Research (cmr) / Faculty of Economic Sciences,
University of Warsaw, Poland
Albert Kraler, International Centre for Migration Policy Development (icmpd), Vienna,
Austria
Jorge Malheiros, Centre of Geographical Studies (ceg), University of Lisbon, Portugal
Marco Martiniello, National Fund for Scientific Research (fnrs), Brussels / Center for
Ethnic and Migration Studies (cedem), University of Liège, Belgium
Eva Østergaard-Nielsen, Department of Political Science, Autonomous University of
Barcelona, Spain
Marlou Schrover, Institute for History, Leiden University, The Netherlands
Patrick Simon, National Demographic Institute (ined), Paris, France
Imiscoe Policy Briefs and more information on the network can be found at
www.imiscoe.org.
Secularism, Assimilation
and the Crisis of Multiculturalism

French Modernist Legacies

Yolande Jansen
iMiSCoe Research
Front cover art: Eva Meijer
Colour editing front cover image: Daphne Rosenthal and Wouter van Riessen
Back cover image: ‘Choisis, tu es libre’, cartoon by Auguste Roubille for
L’Assiette au Beurre, 1904
Cover design: Studio Jan de Boer bno, Amsterdam
Layout: Trees Vulto dtp and book production, Schalkwijk
Amsterdam University Press English-language titles are distributed in the us
and Canada by the University of Chicago Press.
isbn 978 90 8964 596 8
e-isbn 978 90 4852 213 2 (pdf)
e-isbn 978 90 4852 214 9 (ePub)
nur 610
© Yolande Jansen / Amsterdam University Press, Amsterdam 2013
All rights reserved. Without limiting the rights under copyright reserved
above, no part of this book may be reproduced, stored in or introduced into
a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means (electronic,
mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise) without the written per-
mission of both the copyright owners and the authors of the book.
Table of contents

Acknowledgements 9
1 Introduction
The crisis of multiculturalism, new assimilationism
and secularism 13
1.1 Contours of the book 13
1.2 Zigzagging between assimilation and multiculturalism 20
1.3 Where the secularism-religion framework comes in:
A bifurcation within multiculturalism 38
1.4 The paradoxes of Jewish assimilation in France and the prism of
In Search of Lost Time 46
1.5 outline of the chapters 51
1.6 Disciplinary note 55
2 Assimilation in the French sociology of incorporation from a
multicultural perspective 59
2.1 Why reintroduce assimilation? 59
2.2 Gérard Noiriel: Writing the history of power in the context of migration 61
2.3 A multicultural perspective: ‘i been in the right place, but it must have
been the wrong time’ 73
3 The liberal sociology of assimilation and citizenship and its
transnationalist alternatives 83
3.1 A sociological debate about assimilation and its normative implications
for multiculturalism 83
3.2 Critique of postnationalism, multiculturalism and integration 84
3.3 The alternatives proposed by the ‘liberal assimilationists’ 90
3.4 Complications for a diagnosis: ‘on their turf’ 96
3.5 Alternatives 102
3.6 Against the new discourses of assimilation 108
TRANSIT I
Proust as a witness of assimilation in 19th-century France 117
4 Alfred Bloch’s personal integration test at the threshold of his
friend’s home 137
4.1 ‘And what’s the name of this friend of yours who is coming this evening?’ 137
4.2 The Revolution’s conditions of emancipation 140
4.3 Bloch coping with paradox 151
4.4 Partiality, perspectivism and assimilation 155
5 Stuck in a revolving door
Cultural memory, assimilation and secularisation 165
5.1 Assimilation, metaphor and cultural memory 165
5.2 Hannah Arendt reads Proust; from Judaism to Jewishness 176
5.3 ‘The Christians at the surface’; Zygmunt Bauman and the
paradoxes of assimilation 179
5.4 ‘A consubstantial malaise of republican society’ 184
TRANSIT II
Laïcité and assimilation in the Third Republic and today 195
6 Elements of a critique of the laïcité-religion framework 203
6.1 Towards a genealogy of the laïcité-religion framework 203
6.2 Laïcité and neo-Kantian liberalism 204
6.3 Kant at school; Durkheim and Buisson 212
6.4 Privileging Protestantism and the genealogy of the religious
sign with a French twist towards ordre public 216
7 Secularism, sociology and security 225
7.1 The sociology of secularisation, normative laïcité and multiculturalism 225
7.2 The Stasi report: Un rapport sans médiation 226
7.3 Secularism or democratic multiculturalism? 229
7.4 Postmodern identity politics and security 236
8 The highly precarious structure of assimilation
Modernist philosophical schemes, memory and the Proustian
narrative 253
8.1 The invention of tense pasts after assimilation 253
8.2 Adorno’s and Benjamin’s exchange about assimilation and the rejection
of Swann 255
8.3 Public and private Dreyfusism 258
8.4 The social discipline of forgetting 265
8.5 Forgetting and cultural memory 268
9 Concluding remarks 275
9.1 introduction 275
9.2 The assimilation of the French Jews as a memory for today 275
9.3 Getting stuck in a revolving door in the early 21st century 277
9.4 Problematising the laïcité-religion framework instead of defining a
‘better’ laïcité 282
9.5 Multicultural alternatives 287
Notes 297
Works cited 311
Index 333

Acknowledgements
One of the things that kept me going while writing this book was the
thought that it would one day be finished and I would be able to write
the acknowledgments, in which I would finally give a place to the team
that sustained me. A range of people and institutions made this study
possible. First of all, I would like to thank the supervisors of my PhD
dissertation, which formed the basis of this book: Ieme van der Poel
and Veit Bader. I greatly benefited from Van der Poel’s great knowl-
edge of French studies and of the work of Marcel Proust in particular.
Bader’s enormous erudition both in sociology and in social and politi-
cal philosophy, particularly his interest in multiculturalism and secu-
larism, has been invaluable to me.
The time taken to write this book was made available to me thanks
to the support of the Amsterdam School for Cultural Analysis (asca),
the Netherlands Organisation for Scientific Research (nwo) and the
Amsterdam Center for Globalisation Studies (acgs).
I received helpful comments on my dissertation and on later articles
which contributed to this book from many people. I especially thank
Murat Aydemir, Rainer Bauboeck, John Bowen, Sudeep Dasgupta,
René Gabriëls, Edward Hughes, Jo Labanyi, Irena Rosenthal, Eliza-
beth Shakman Hurd, Samia Touati, Markha Valenta, Hent de Vries
and Marc de Wilde, and finally the anonymous readers from the imis-
coe Editorial Committee.
At the University of Amsterdam, Karen Vintges, Ruth Sonderegger,
Pieter Pekelharing, Robin Celikates, Marieke Borren, Karin de Boer,
Beate Roessler, Eloe Kingma, Jantine van Gogh, Dorota Mokrosinska,
Victor Kal, Noortje Marres, Marie-Aude Baronian and Stephan Besser
were among my most inspiring colleagues.
I further thank my colleagues within the nwo project The Sacred
and the Secular: Genealogies of Self, State and Society in the Contempo-
rary Islamic World: Michiel Leezenberg, Mariwan Kanie, Ruud Peters
and Peter van der Veer enabled me to continue my research about sec-
ularity and Islam in the European context, and to broaden my view by
taking into account a postcolonial perspective. Meeting Darius Rejali
in the context of this project was a source of great inspiration.