Table Of Content

VOLUME 23 REVIEWS IN AMERICAN HISTORY Editor: Stanley I. Kutler, University of Wisconsin, Madison Associate Editor: Stanley N. Katz, American Council of Learned Societies Assistant Editor: Judith Kirkwood Editorial Board Lizabeth Cohen, New York University Michael H. Ebner, Lake Forest College David A. Hollinger, University of California, Berkeley Pauline Maier, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Louis Masur, City College of New York Thomas K. McCraw, Harvard University Emily Rosenberg, Macalester College Richard H. Sewell, University of Wisconsin, Madison Thomas Slaughter, Rutgers University Olivier Zunz, University of Virginia The Johns Hopkins University Press 2715 North Charles Street Baltimore, Maryland 21218-4319 Volume 23 Copyright © 1995 by The Johns Hopkins University Press All rights reserved. No portion of this journal may be reproduced by any process or technique without the formal consent of The Johns Hopkins University Press. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use, or the internal or personal use of specific clients, is granted by The Johns Hopkins University Press for libraries and other users registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC) Transactional Reporting Service, provided that the base fee of $3.25 per article is paid directly to CCC, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA, 01923. This consent does not extend to other kinds of copying, such as copying for general distribution, for advertising or promotional purposes, for creating new collective works, or for resale. 0048-7511/93 $3.25 Library of Congress Catalog Number 72-13938 ISSN: 0048-7511 REVIEWS IN AMERICAN HISTORY, its editors, editorial board and publisher disclaim responsibility and liability for statements, either of fact or of opinion, made by contributors. Please direct all subscription inquiries and business communications to the publisher: Journals Publishing Division The Johns Hopkins University Press 2715 North Charles Street Baltimore, Maryland 21218-4319 Phone: (410) 516-6987 FAX: (410) 516-6968 Toll-Free: 1-800-548-1784 Frequency of publication: quarterly—March, June, September, December. Subscription price: Individuals—$26.00 per year Institutions—$68.00 per year Students—$24.00 per year Subscribers in Canada and Mexico add $3.90 postage; others outside the U.S. $9.50. Address all editorial correspondence to: Stanley I. Kutler, Editor REVIEWS IN AMERICAN HISTORY Department of History, University of Wisconsin Madison, Wisconsin 53706 Second-class postage paid at Baltimore, Maryland and at additional mailing offices. Typeset by Capitol Communication Systems, Crofton, MD. Printed at The Sheridan Press, Hanover, PA. This journal is printed on acid-free paper. The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences—Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1984. Postmaster please send address changes to: Reviews in American History, The Johns Hopkins University Press, Journals Publishing Division, 2715 North Charles Street, Baltimore, MD 21218-4319. Reviews in American History is indexed and abstracted in America: History and Life, American Bibliography of Slavic and East European Studies, Arts and Humanities Citation Index, Book Review Digest, Book Review Index, Current Contents, Historical Abstracts/Modern History, Historical Abstracts/Twentieth Century, Hu- manities Index, and Recently Published Articles AUTHOR-TITLE-REVIEWER INDEX FOR VOLUME 23 (1995) No. 1 (March): 1-193 Avrich, Paul, 704 No. 2: (June): 195-389 Aynes, Richard L., 290 No. 3: (September): 391-566 Baer, George W., 277 No. 4: (December): 557-767 Baritono, Raffaella, 64 Barrett, David M., 144 “A Government of Our Own”: The Mak- Bartlett, Irving H., 438 ing of the Confederacy, 444 Basch, Norma, 397 Aaron, Daniel, 391 Baughman, James L., 734 Abzug, Robert H., 427 Belknap, Michal R., 323 Adams, Michael C. C., 317 Berlin, Edward, A. 237 Adams, Sam, 144 Berman, William C., 354 Adams, Willi Paul, 545 Best War Ever, The: America and World After Ellis Island: Newcomers and Na- War II, 317 tives in the 1910 Census, 631 Between Race and Ethnicity: Cape Age of Great Dreams, The: America in Verdean American Immigrants, 1860- the 1960s, 354 1965, 260 Agrarian Origins of American Capital- Beyond Category: The Life and Genius of ism, The, 464 Duke Ellington, 91 AIF and Coalition Warmaking, 1917- Beyond a Christian Commonwealth: The 1918, The, 284 Protestant Quarrel with the American Albert, Peter J., 202, 574 Republic, 1830-60, 195 Allitt, Patrick N., 165, 432 Biel, Steven, 704 Ambrose, Stephen E., 313 Burner, Eric R., 535 American Iconology: New Approaches to Black, Allida M., 307 Nineteenth-Century Art and Litera- Bloc of One, A: The Political Career of ture, 250 Hiram W. Johnson, 272 American Notes: Selected Essays, 391 Blondheim, Menahem, 478 American Political Nation, 1838-1893, Bolton, Charles C., 464 The, 413 Bond of Iron: Master and Slave at Buffalo America’s Right Turn: From Nixon to Forge, 20 Bush, 354 Bowman, Shearer Davis, 567 Anarchist Voices: An Oral History of Bremer, Francis J., 13 Anarchism in America, 704 Brinkley, Alan, 710 Antisemitism in America, 364 Brock, William E., 710 Appy, Christian G., 137 Brogan, Hugh, 510 Reviews in American History 22 (1994) 749-757 © 1994 by The Johns Hopkins University Press 760 REVIEWS IN AMERICAN HISTORY / DECEMBER 1995 Brown, Julie K., 250 can Rivalry and the Origins of the Chi- Burden of Dependency, The: Colonial nese Civil War, 1944-1946, 516 Themes in Southern Economic Collins, Jane L., 521 Thought, 464 Confederate Republic, The: A Revolution Cagin, Seth, 535 Against Politics, 444 Cain, William E., 606 Conflict of Interests: Organized Labor and Callahan, Raymond A., 313 the Civil Rights Movement in the Calvert, Karin, 58 South, 1954-1968, 110 Canadian and American Constitutions in Congregational Communion: Clerical Comparative Perspective, 545 Friendship in the Anglo-American Pu- Capper, Charles, 33 ritan Community, 1910-1692, 13 Carson, Cary, 574 Conkin, Paul K., 421 Carson, Clayborne, 1 Contesting Images: Photography and the Catholic Intellectuals and Conservative World’s Columbian Exposition, 250 Politics in America, 1950-1985, 165 Contrived Competition: Regulation and Cayton, Andrew R. L., 402 Deregulation in America, 348 Centralia Tragedy of 1919, The: Elmer Copeland, Tom, 266 Smith and the Wobblies, 266 Cortright, David, 129 Chalmers, David, 535 Cosmos Crumbling: American Reform Chambers-Schiller, Lee, 612 and the Religious Imagination, 427 Channels of Desire: Mass Images and the Course of Industrial Decline, The: The Shaping of American Consciousness, Boott Cotton Mills of Lowell, Massa- 342 chusetts, 1835-1955, 51 Chappell, David, 103 Cragg, Dan, 144 Children in the House: The Material Creating the Modern South: Millhands Childhood of Early Childhood, 1600- and Managers in Dalton, Georgia, 1900, 58 1884-1984, 51 Cities and Buildings: Skyscrapers, Skid Crime and Punishment in American His- Rows, and Suburbs, 675 tory, 153 Civil War World of Herman Melville, Crofts, Daniel W., 458 The, 450 Crusaders in the Courts: How a Dedi- Clark, Christopher, 600 cated Band of Lawyers Fought for the Class of 1846, The: From West Point to Civil Rights Revolution, 103 Appomattox—Stonewall Jackson, Curtis, Susan, 237 George McClellan, and Their Brothers, D-Day, June 6, 1944: The Climactic Battle 226 of World War II, 313 Clayton, Douglas, 699 D-Day: Piercing the Atlantic Wall, 313 Clemens, Paul G. E., 574 Dancing toa Black Man’s Tune: A Life of Cohen, Naomi W., 360 Scott Joplin, 237 Colburn, David R., 103 Daniels, Roger, 472 Cold War and Revolution: Soviet-Ameri- Davis, William C., 444 AUTHOR-TITLE-REVIEWER INDEX FOR VOLUME 23 761 De Hart, Sherron Jane, 86 Environmental Inequalities: Class, Race, Defending the Faith: J. Gresham Machen and Industrial Pollution in Gary, Indi- and the Crisis of Conservative Protes- ana, 1945-1980, 687 tantism in Modern America, 432 Ernst, Daniel R., 502 Dew, Charles B., 20 Ewen, Elizabeth, 342 Diary of Miss Emma Holmes, 1861-1866, Ewen, Stuart, 342 The, 612 Eyerman, Ron, 98 Dimensions of Law in the Service of Or- Fairfield, John D., 80 der: Origins of the Federal Income Tax, Farber, David, 317, 354, 681 1861-1913, 256 Fariello, Griffin, 704 Diplomacy, 723 Farmers and Fishermen: Two Centuries Diner, Hasia, 637 of Work in Essex County, Massachu- Dinnerstein, Leonard, 364 setts, 1630-1850, 600 Dittmer, John, 535 Farwell, Byron, 226 Dobbin, Frank, 567 Fairfield, John C., 675 Does Technology Drive History? The Di- Fields, Armond, 650 lemma of Technological Determinism, Fields, L. Marc, 650 370 Fink, Gary M., 51 Doherty, Thomas, 317 Finkelman, Paul, 606 Dolan, Jay, 165 First Woman in the Republic, The: A Down the Asphalt Path: The Automobile Cultural Biography of Lydia Maria and the American City, 80 Child, 408 Draper, Alan, 110 Flamming, Douglas, 51 Dray, Philip, 535 Floyd Dell: The Life and Times of an Dublin, Thomas, 26 American Rebel, 699 Dubofsky, Melvyn, 266, 502 Ford, Larry R., 675 Dumenil, Lynn, 699 Forging Industrial Policy: The United Dunlavy, Colleen A., 567 States, Britain, and France in the Rail- Early American Technology: Doing and way Age, 567 Making Things from the Colonial Era Forging of a Black Community, The: through 1850, 593 Seattle's Central District from 1870 Eisenach, Eldon J., 669 through the Civil Right Era, 643 Eisenhower, John S. D., 74 Franchot, Jenny, 212 Ellis, Joseph J., 588 Freedom Summer, 535 Ely, John Hart, 323 Friedman, Lawrence M., 153 Empire of the Eye, The: Landscape Repre- From Father's Property to Children’s sentation and American Cultural Poli- Rights: The History of Child Custody tics, 1825-1875, 47 in the United States, 58 End of Reform, The: New Deal Liberalism From Prairie to Prison: The Life of Social in Recession and War, 710 Activist Kate Richards O’ Hare, 266 762 REVIEWS IN AMERICAN HISTORY / DECEMBER 1995 From the Bowery to Broadway: Lew Fields Hard Bodies: Hollywood Masculinity in and the Roots of American Popular the Reagan Era, 528 Theater, 650 Harlan, Louis R., 1 From the Other Side: Women, Gender, Harris, Howell John, 658 and the Immigrant Life in the ULS., Hart, D. G., 432 1820-1990, 637 Harvey, Paul, 421 Fulton Bag and Cotton Mills Strike of Hasse, John Edward, 91 1914-1915, The, 51 Herman, Ellen, 681 Future Imperfect: The Mixed Blessings of Herr, Pamela, 219 Technology in America, 370 Herring, George C., 144 Gabaccia, Donna, 637 Hill, Herbert, 103 Gabler, Neal, 729 His Soul Goes Marching On: Responses Gallagher, Gary W., 226 to John Brown and the Harpers Ferry Garner, Stanton, 451 Raid, 606 Gary, Brett, 623 History of the Supreme Court, A, 290 Gennari, John R., 91 Hoffman, Ronald, 202, 574 Genovese, Eugene D., 1 Hoogenboom, Ari, 618 Gently He Shall Lead Them, And: Robert Hoovers, William D., 129 Parris Moses and Civil Rights in Mis- Horowitz, Daniel, 123 sissippi, 535 Hovenkamp, Herbert, 256 Giap: The Victor in Vietnam, 144 Hugo Black: A Biography, 716 Give Peace a Chance: Exploring the Viet- Hurley, Andrew, 687 nam Antiwar Movement, Essays from Huston, Reeve, 413 the Charles DeBenedetti Memorial Con- IfM en Were Angels: James Madison and ference, 129 the Heartless Empire of Reason, 582 Glenn, Susan A., 650 In Search of Equality: The Chinese Goetzmann, William H., 47 Struggle Against Discrimination in Goodwin, Doris Kearns, 307 Nineteenth-Century America, 472 Gordon, Colin, 669 Inheritance and Family Life in Colonial Gospel of Disunion: Religion and Sepa- New York City, 397 ratism in the Antebellum South, 40 Inside the VC and the NVA: The Real Graham, Hugh Davis, 354 Story of North Vietnam’s Armed Greenberg, Jack, 103 Forces, 144 Grimsley, Mark, 444 Inside Agitators: White Southerners in Gross, Laurence F., 51 the Civil Rights Movement, 103 Guarneri, Carl J., 564 Intervention! The United States and the Gunther, Gerald, 296 Mexican Revolution, 1913-1917, 74 Hall, H. Lark, 663 Isserman, Maurice, 110 Hal'oran, Peter, 1 I've Got the Light of Freedom: The Orga- Halter, Marilyn, 260 nizing Tradition and the Mississippi Hanley, Mark Y., 202 Freedom Struggle, 535 AUTHOR-TITLE-REVIEWER INDEX FOR VOLUME 23 763 Jaher, Frederic Cople, 360, 364 Learned Hand: The Man and the Judge, Jamison, Andrew, 98 296 Jeffords, Susan, 528 Lee, Jean B., 402 Jenkins, Henry, 650 Leonard, Elizabeth D., 612 Jews in Christian America: The Pursuit Leonard, Thomas C., 478 of Religious Equality, 360 Letters of Jessie Benton Frémont, The, Joe Alsop’s Cold War: A Study of Jour- 219 nalistic Influence and Intrigue, 734 Levy, David W., 232, 663 John C. Calhoun: A Biography, 438 Lichtenstein, Alex, 20 John, Richard R., 438 Like a Holy Crusade: Mississippi 1964— Johnson, Susan Lee, 219 The Turning of the Civil Rights Move- Jones, Howard, 74 ment in America, 535 Jones, James E., Jr., 103 Link, William A., 272 Jordan, John M., 623 Local People: The Struggle for Civil Rights Joselit, Jenna Weissman, 739 in Mississippi, 535 Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes: Law and Love and Theft: Blackface Minstrelsy and the Inner Life, 482 the American Working Class, 237 Kane, Paula, 212 Lofland, John, 129 Karcher, Carolyn L., 408 Lords of the Fly: Drosophila Genetics and Karl, Barry D., 497 the Experimental Life, 302 Kaufman, Bruce E., 693 Lost Promise of Progressivism, The, 669 Kelley, Mary, 33 Lott, Eric, 237 Kenyon Cox, 1856-1919: A Life in Ameri- Lower, Richard Coke, 272 can Art, 243 Lubin, David M., 243 Kerr, K. Austin, 348 Luker, Ralph E., 1 Kershaw, Robert J., 313 Lutz Catherine A., 521 King, Richard H., 118 Macdonald, Peter, 144 King of Ragtime: Scott Joplin and His Machine-Age Ideology: Social Engineer- Era, 237 ing and American Liberalism, 1911- Kissinger, Henry, 723 1939, 623 Kleinman, Mark L., 330 Main Currents in American Legal Knight, Janice, 13 Thought, 290 Kohler, Robert E. 302 Making of American Exceptionalism, The: Koppes, Clayton R., 528 The Knights of Labor and Class Forma- Kulikoff, Allan, 464 tion in the Nineteenth Century, 658 Kupperman, Karen Ordahl, 195 Marcus, Robert D., 618 La Follettes of Wisconsin, The: Love and Margaret Fuller: An American Romantic Politics in Progressive America, 68 Life. Volume 1: The Private Years, 33 Lanning, Michael Lee, 144 Marine Corps’ Search for a Mission, LB] and Vietnam: A Different Kind of 1880-1898, The, 277 War, 144 764 REVIEWS IN AMERICAN HISTORY / DECEMBER 1995 Market Revolution, The: Jacksonian New Musical Figurations: Anthony America, 1815-1846, 413 Braxton’s Cultural Critique, 91 Marsden, George M., 170 New Land, New Lives: Scandinavian Im- Marszalek, John F., 226, 612 migrants to the Pacific Northwest, 260 Marten, James, 58 Newman, Roger K., 716 Martin, Joel W., 206 News over the Wires: The Telegraph and Martin, Waldo E., Jr., 643 the Flow of Public Information in Marx, Leo, 370 America, 1844-1897, 478 Mason, Mary Ann, 58 No Ordinary Time. Franklin and Eleanor Mathews, Richard K., 582 Roosevelt—The Home Front in World McAdam, Doug, 535 War II , 307 McClain, Charles J., 472 Nore, Ellen, 488 McClay, Wilfred M., 123 Northern Protest: Martin Luther King, McGaw, Judith A., 593 ]r., Chicago, and the Civil Rights Move- McKenna, Marian C., 545 ment, 110 McKercher, B. J. C., 284 Nossiter, Adam, 535 McShane, Clay, 80 Novak, Steven J., 302 Miller, Angela, 47 Nugent, Walter, 64 Miller, Char, 687 Odyssey of the Abraham Lincoln Brigade: Miller, David C., 250 Americans in the Spanish Civil War, Miller, John E., 68 336 Miller, Sally M., 266 Of Consuming Interests: The Style of Life Mills, Kay, 535 in the Eighteenth Century, 574 Mills, Nicolaus, 535 Of Long Memory: Mississippi and the Mitchell, Reid, 451 Murder of Medgar Evars, 535 Mobility and Migration: East Anglian Oltre la Politica: La Crisi Politico- Founders ofN ew England, 1629-1640, Instituzionale negli Stati Uniti fra Otto 195 e Novecento [Beyond Politics: The Modernist Impulses in the Human Sci- Political-Institutional Crisis in the ences, 1870-1930, 488 Late-Nineteenth- and Early-Twen- Moore, Deborah Dash, 739 tieth-Century United States], 64 Moore, R. Laurence, 159 One Hundred Years of Sea Power: The Morgan, H. Wayne, 243 U.S. Navy, 1890-1990, 277 Morin, Alexander J., 496 Origins and Evolution of the Field of In- Mysteries of the Great City: The Politics dustrial Relations in the United States, of Urban Design, 1877-1937, 675 693 Namorato, Michael V., 51 Origins of Southern Sharecropping, The, Narrett, David E., 397 458 Neather, Andrew E., 336 Orthodoxies in Massachusetts: Reread- Nelson, Jack, 535 ing American Puritansim, 13 Neu, Charles E., 144 AUTHOR-TITLE-REVIEWER INDEX FOR VOLUME 23 Paper Soldiers: The American Press and Rable, George C. 444 the Vietnam War, 734 Race in America: The Struggle for Equal- Papers of Martin Luther King, Jr., The. ity, 103 Volume 2: Rediscovering July 1951- Radano, Ronald M., 91 1955, 1 Rakove Jack N., 582 Patterson, David S., 129 Ralph, James R.., Jr., 110 Payne, Charles M., 535 Rasmussen, Janet E., 260 Peace Works: The Citizen's Role in End- Ray, Gerda W., 744 ing the Cold War, 129 Reading National Geographic, 521 Pease, Jane H., 408 Rebel in Defense of Tradition, A: The Life People Divided, A: Judaism in Contem- and Politics of Dwight S. Macdonald, porary America, 360 118 Persky, Joseph J., 464 Red Hunting in the Promised Land: Peterson, Mark A., 13 AntiCommunism and the Making of Picturinga N ation: Art and Social Change America, 336 in Nineteenth-Century America, 243 Red Scare: Memories of the American In- Polenberg, Richard, 296 quisition—An Oral History, 704 Polite Protestors: The American Peace Reimers, David M., 260, 631 Movement of the 1980s, 129 Religion in a Revolutionary Age, 202 Politics and Industrialization: Early Rail- Renda, Lex, 378 roads in the United States and Prussia, Ribuffo, Leo P., 170 567 Roads to Rome: The Antebellum Protes- Poor Whites of the Antebellum South: tant Encounter with Catholicism, 212 Tenants and Laborers in Central North Roberts, Randy, 729 Carolina and Northeast Mississippi, Roeber, A. G., 202 464 Roeder, George H., Jr., 250 Potts, David B., 232 Romance of American Psychology: Po- Press Gang, The: Newspapers and Poli- litical Culture in the Age of Experts, tics, 1865-1878, 478 681 Price of Nationhood, The: The American Ronald Reagan in Hollywood: Movies and Revolution in Charles County, 402 Politics, 528 Principle and Interest: Thomas Jefferson Rosenberg, Norman, 482 and the Problem of Debt, 588 Ross, Dorothy, 488 Projections of War: Hollywood, Ameri- Rossinow, Doug, 98 can Culture and World War II, 317 Royce, Edward, 458 Promey, Sally M., 206 Russell, Penny A., 1 Promise and Power: The Life and Times Rutherford B. Hayes: Warrior and Presi- of Robert McNamara, 144 dent, 618 Providence Island, 1630-1641: The Other Satter, Beryl, 159 Puritan Colony, 195 Saville, Julie, 458 766 REVIEWS IN AMERICAN HISTORY / DECEMBER 1995 Scapegoat in the New Wilderness, A: The State and Labor in Modern America, The, Origins and Rise of Anti-semitism in 502 America, 364 Stewart, James B., 427 Schatz, Ronald W., 693 Still Missing: Amelia Earhart and the Schneider, A. Gregory, 206 Search for Modern Feminism, 86 Schulten, Susan, 521 Stonewall: A Biography of General Schwartz, Bernard, 290 Thomas ]. Jackson, 226 Science Policy and Politics, 496 Strout, Cushing, 391 Seeds of the Sixties, 98 Stuntz, William J., 159 Seely, Bruce E., 593 Summers, Mark Wahlgren, 478 Segal, Howard P., 370 Swerdlow, Amy, 129 Seger, Richard, 432 Taylor, Quintard, 643 Sellers, Charles, 413 Teaford, Jon C., 675 Selling God: American Religion in the Terror in the Night: The Klan’s Cam- Marketplace of Culture, 159 paign Against the Jews, 535 Shapley, Deborah, 144 This Little Light of Mine: The Life of Sherman: A Soldier's Passion for Order, Fannie Lou Hamer, 535 226 Thompson, Roger, 195 Shulimson, Jack, 277 To the Golden Cities: Pursuing the Ameri- Shulman, Mark R., 277 can Jewish Dream in Miami and L.A., Silbey, Joel H., 413 739 Simpson, Brooks D., 451 Todd, Ellen Wiley, 243 Singal, Daniel J., 342 Transforming Women’s Work: New En- Sloan, Herbert E., 588 gland Lives in the Industrial Revolu- Small, Melvin, 129 tion, 26 Smith, Mark C., 623 Trask, David, 284 Smith, Merritt Roe, 370 Uncertain Warriors: Lyndon Johnson and Snay, Mitchell, 40 His Vietnam Advisers, 144 Social Science in the Crucible: The Ameri- Uneasy Center, The: Reformed Christian- can Debate of Objectivity and Purpose, ity in Antebellum America, 421 1918-1941, 623 Unterberger, Betty Miller, 723 Soul of the American University, The: Usselman, Steven W., 370 From Protestant Establishment to Es- V. L. Parrington: Through the Avenue of tablished Nonbelief, 170 Art, 663 Spackman, S. G. F., 237 Vacant Chair, The: The Northern Soldier Spence, Mary Lee, 219 Leaves Home, 451 Spiritual Spectacles: Vision and Image in Vance Packard and American Social Criti- Mid-Nineteenth-Century Shakerism, cism, 123 206 Vaughn, Stephen, 528 Stanley, Robert, 256 Vickers, Daniel, 600