ebook img

Rethinking Ukrainian History PDF

280 Pages·1981·6.531 MB·English
Save to my drive
Quick download
Download
Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.

Preview Rethinking Ukrainian History

RETHINKING UKRAINIAN HISTORY Edited by Ivan L. Rudnytsky With the assistance of John-Paul Himka The Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies The University of Alberta Edmonton 1981 THE CANADIAN LIBRARY IN UKRAINIAN STUDIES A series of original works and reprints relating to Ukraine issued under the editorial supervision of the Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies, the University of Alberta, Edmonton. Editorial Board: Bohdan Bociurkiw, Carleton University (Social Sciences) George S. N. Luckyj, University of Toronto (Humanities) Manoly R. Lupul, University of Alberta (Ukrainians in Canada) Ivan L. Rudnytsky, University of Alberta (History) Copyright © 1981 The Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies The University of Alberta Edmonton, Alberta, Canada Canadian Cataloguing in Publication Data Rethinking Ukrainian History (The Canadian library in Ukrainian studies) Papers and discussion from the Ukrainian Historical Conference held at the University of Western Ontario, London, in May 1978. ISBN 0-920862-12-8 (bound). ISBN 0-920862-14-4 (pbk.). 1. Ukraine - History - Congresses. I. Lysiak-Rudnytskyi, Ivan. II. Himka, John-Paul, 1949- III. Ukrainian Historical Conference (1978: University of Western Ontario). IV. Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies. V. Series. DK 508.5.R48 947.71 C81-091218-X All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be produced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise with­ out the prior permission of the copyright owner. Cover: Peter Matilainen Printed in Canada by Printing Services, University of Alberta Distributed by the University of Toronto Press 5201 Dufferin St. Downsview, Ontario Canada M3H 5T8 Contents Publisher’s Preface v Introduction vii Kievan Rus’ and Sixteenth-Seventeenth-Century Ukraine Omeljan Pritsak 1 The Problem of Nobilities in the Ukrainian Past: The Polish Period, 1569-1648 Frank Sysyn 29 Problems in Studying the Post-Khmelnytsky Ukrainian Elite (1650s to 1830s) Zenon E. Kohut 103 Cossack Ukraine and the Turco-Islamic World Orest Subtelny 120 Ukrainian Cities in the Nineteenth Century Patricia Herlihy 135 Ukrainian Cities during the Revolution and the Interwar Era Steven L. Guthier 156 Urbanization in Ukraine since the Second World War Roman Szporluk 180 The Role of the City in Ukrainian History Peter Woroby 203 Evolution of the Ukrainian Literary Language George Y. Shevelov 216 Round Table Discussion 235 Contributors Ivan L. Rudnytsky Professor of History University of Alberta John-Paul Himka Visiting Assistant Professor Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies University of Alberta Steven L. Guthier Analyst U.S. Department of Defence Patricia Herlihy Visiting Associate Professor of History Brown University, Research Associate Harvard Ukrainian Research Institute Zenon E. Kohut Editor American Bibliography of Russian and East European Studies Omeljan Pritsak Mykhailo Hrushevsky Professor of History Harvard University, Director Harvard Ukrainian Research Institute George Y. Shevelov Professor Emeritus Columbia University Orest Subtelny Associate Professor of History Hamilton College, New York, Associate Harvard Ukrainian Research Institute Frank Sysyn Assistant Professor of History, Research Fellow, Russian Research Center Harvard University, Research Fellow Harvard Ukrainian Research Institute Roman Szporluk Professor of History University of Michigan Peter Woroby Professor of Economics University of Regina Publisher’s Preface This book has been produced using MTS Textform, an advanced computer word-processing system especially designed to improve editorial control over the text through consistent page-formating, pagination, and the cor­ rection of errors prior to typesetting by the high-speed computerized APS-5 system. The system allows for quick reproduction of updated editions. Special thanks are due to Mr. David Holberton and the Textform Group and to Mr. Peter Buttuls of Integrated Graphics, Computing Services, University of Alberta, for their invaluable assistance in the publication of this book. Introduction This volume contains presentations to the Ukrainian Historical Conference at the University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, on 29-31 May 1978. The conference, which took place within the framework of the annual meeting of the Canadian Association of Slavists, was organized jointly by the Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies, the Harvard Ukrainian Research Institute and the Ukrainian Historical Association. The Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies sponsored the conference and was responsible for the technical preparatory work. The conference committee consisted of Ivan L. Rudnytsky (CIUS), Frank E. Sysyn (HURI) and Lubomyr R. Wynar (UHA). The programme of the conference comprised six topical sessions: “Historiography,” “Ukraine and the Muslim World,” “The Historical legacy of Kievan Rus’,” “Ukrainian Elites,” “Ukraine and the Russian Revolution,” “The Role of the City in Ukrainian History” and a Round Table discussion on “Problems of Terminology and Periodication in the Teaching of Ukrainian History.” The guest speaker at the conference banquet, held jointly with the Canadian Association of Slavists, was Professor George Y. Shevelov who presented the “Reflections of a Linguist on Ukrainian History.” This collection does not contain the entire conference proceedings, since limitations of space necessitated the exclusion of papers on historiography and Ukraine and the Russian Revolution. Moreover, there already exist viii Rethinking Ukrainian History several excellent English-language studies of the revolutionary period (1917-21) in Ukraine, and the highly specialized nature and complexity of the subject of historiography warrants more extensive treatment in a separate publication. Of the sessions, only “The Role of the City in Ukrainian History” is fully represented in this volume, as some papers of the other sessions were not made available to the editor. The included papers have not only been revised by the authors, but their sequence has been rearranged for chronological and substantive reasons. On the panel of the Round Table discussion were six professors, all teachers of Ukrainian history courses in North American universities. The panel was chaired by Professor Omeljan Pritsak, the Mykhailo Hrushevsky Professor of Ukrainian History at Harvard University and Director of the Harvard Ukrainian Research Institute. The discussion was transcribed from the tapes and then edited. Despite minor changes, it is hoped that the printed record retains the original flavour of a spontaneous and lively scholarly debate. Professor Shevelov’s after-dinner address has appeared in the Journal of Ukrainian Graduate Studies 6 (Spring 1979): 62-9. At Professor Shevelov’s request, it was superseded in this volume by his earlier article “L’ukrainien littéraire,” published originally in Revue des études slaves 33 (1956): 68-83 and reprinted in G. Y. Shevelov, Teasers and Appeasers: Essays and Studies on Themes of Slavic Philology (Munich: Wilhelm Fink Verlag, 1971), 245-60. An English translation was prepared for The Slavic Literary Languages: Formation and Development, edited by Alexander M. Schenker and Edward Stankiewicz, a forthcoming volume in the Yale and East European Publications series. It is reproduced here with permission and with minor stylistic changes. By focusing on questions of continuity and discontinuity in the development of the Ukrainian literary language, the paper suggests illuminating parallels for scholars engaged in rethinking Ukrainian history. While responsibility for the factual statements and interpretations advanced in the papers of this collection rests, as usual, with the individual contributors, the planning of the Ukrainian Historical Conference was based on certain general guidelines which are reflected in the present publication. The organizers were faced with a choice between a “conference of Ukrainian historians” or a “Ukrainian historical conference.” In opting for the latter, the organizers wished to ensure the highest professional and academic standards for the conference, and to Introduction ix avoid any suggestion that it was just a gathering of émigré notables. Similarly, the decision to conduct the conference entirely in English was designed to bring Ukrainian history visibly into the mainstream of North American historical scholarship. While it is expected that the study of Ukrainian history will appeal to scholars who are themselves Ukrainian, it does not follow that only persons of Ukrainian background will work in the field. In fact, the future of Ukrainian historical studies in the West may well depend on the number of non-Ukrainian specialists which such studies attract. The conference was attended by several non-Ukrainian scholars, and it is hoped that their participation will set a trend for the future. The lamentable condition of historical studies in the Ukrainian SSR is of great concern to scholars in the West. The low level of Soviet historiography results mostly from the imposition of a stifling official ideology, in which an ossified Marxism-Leninism is amalgamated with a rigidly Russocentric vision of Ukrainian and general East Slavic history, which tolerates no topics, methods and interpretations that cannot be pressed into its straitjacket. How should Western students of Ukrainian history respond to this distressing situation? Many in the Ukrainian diaspora community believe that Soviet ideological orthodoxy ought to be met with an equally rigid and militant “patriotic” orthodoxy. In the conference organizers’ view, such an approach would be self-defeating. What is needed is the application of free, critical thought, untrammelled by dogmas of any kind, whether Marxist or nationalist. The test of critical thought is the readiness to face unpleasant facts and painful issues and to scrutinize the preconceptions, biases and favourite myths even of one’s own community. Among the ills which afflict Soviet Ukrainian historiography none perhaps is more debilitating than its enforced isolation from the outside world. Soviet Ukrainian historians do not publish in foreign journals, hardly ever travel abroad for reasons of research and rarely attend international scholarly conferences and symposia. When they do, it is usually as supernumerary members of general Soviet delegations. Even their access to foreign scholarly literature appears to be seriously limited. The result—intended by the regime—is the impoverishment, stultification and increased provincialism of the Ukrainian nation’s cultural life in general and of the historical science in particular. Western scholars can help to remedy these deformations, provided they themselves study Ukrainian history in a universal context. This does not mean that the existing links between the Ukrainian and Russian historical processes should be played down; they should merely be reduced to their proper dimension, with due attention to reciprocal relations between Rethinking Ukrainian History X Ukraine and such other countries and civilizations as the Mediterranean world. Central Europe and the Eurasian sphere. Focusing on this complex network of relationships and influences will bring to light Ukraine’s unique historical identity; it will also contribute to a better understanding of the history of Eastern Europe as a whole. One can always hope that the labours of Western scholars might induce positive changes in Soviet Ukrainian historiography and ease the strictures which handicap it at present. However, the prerequisite is that Western specialists in Ukrainian history learn how to approach their subject in a consistently non-parochial spirit. Thomas G. Masaryk used to admonish his fellow Czech intellectuals to study the Czech problem as a world problem. This advice is equally valuable in the Ukrainian case. Such were the basic guidelines for the 1978 Ukrainian Historical Conference. Readers may judge for themselves how well they have been realized. The assistance of the following persons and institutions is gratefully acknowledged: the executive of the Canadian Association of Slavists and its former president. Professor Peter J. Potichnyj, McMaster University, for accommodating the Ukrainian Historical Conference within the programme of the association’s 1978 annual meeting; the Humanities and Social Sciences Research Council of Canada for its financial assistance; Professor Eva S. Balogh, Russian and East European Studies, Yale University, for making available the English translation of Professor Shevelov’s paper; Mr. Brent Kostyniuk for undertaking the difficult task of transcribing the taped text of the Round Table discussion; and the editorial staff of the Canadian Institute of Ukrainian Studies. I would like to express special thanks to my colleague, Professor John-Paul Himka, whose help in preparing the conference and in editing the papers was invaluable. Ivan L. Rudnytsky University of Alberta May 1981

See more

The list of books you might like

Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.