Reflexivity and Criminal Justice: Intersections of Policy, Practice and Research

391 Pages·2017·7.025 MB·English

by  Sarah Armstrong, Jarrett Blaustein, Alistair Henry (eds.)

Reflexivity and
Criminal Justice
Intersections of Policy,
Practice & Research
EDITED BY
Sarah Armstrong
Jarrett Blaustein
Alistair Henry
Refl exivity and Criminal Justice
Sarah A rmstrong • Jarrett Blaustein • Alistair Henry
Editors
Refl exivity and
Criminal Justice
Intersections of Policy, Practice and Research
Editors
Sarah Armstrong Alistair Henry
Department of Sociology Law School
University of Glasgow Old College
Glasgow , United Kingdom Edinburgh , United Kingdom
Jarrett Blaustein
Menzies Building
Monash University, School of Social Sciences
Clayton , Australia
ISBN 978-1-137-54641-8 ISBN 978-1-137-54642-5 (eBook)
DOI 10.1057/978-1-137-54642-5
Library of Congress Control Number: 2016956650
© Th e Editor(s) (if applicable) and Th e Author(s) 2017
Th e author(s) has/have asserted their right(s) to be identifi ed as the author(s) of this work in accordance
with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.
Th is work is subject to copyright. All rights are solely and exclusively licensed by the Publisher, whether
the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifi cally the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of
illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfi lms or in any other physical way, and trans-
mission or information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation, computer software, or by similar or
dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed.
Th e use of general descriptive names, registered names, , trademarks, service marks, etc. in this publica-
tion does not imply, even in the absence of a specifi c statement, that such names are exempt from the
relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use.
Th e publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in this book
are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor the authors or
the editors give a warranty, express or implied, with respect to the material contained herein or for any
errors or omissions that may have been made.
Cover illustration: Dmitriy Abramov / Alamy Stock Photo
Printed on acid-free paper
Th is Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by Springer Nature
Th e registered company is Macmillan Publishers Ltd.
Th e registered company address is: Th e Campus, 4 Crinan Street, London, N1 9XW, United Kingdom
Acknowledgements
W e would like to thank Richard Sparks and his co-investigators from
the ESRC project ‘Crime Control and Devolution: Policy-Making and
Expert Knowledge in a Multi-Tiered Democracy’ for aff ording us the
opportunity to collectively refl ect on the intersections between policy,
practice and research during a seminar that was held at the University
of Edinburgh in December 2013. It was at this event that the idea for
this volume was born. We would also like to thank our mentors and
colleagues, both past and present, and of whom there are too many to
acknowledge individually, for helping us to develop our awareness of the
importance of refl exivity in the context of criminological research. We are
grateful to Dominic Walker, Jules Wilan, Josie Taylor and the production
team at Palgrave for their ongoing patience and support and we would
like to thank all of the authors who feature in this volume for their bold
and thoughtful contributions.
v
Contents
1 Impact and the Refl exive Imperative in Criminal Justice
Policy, Practice and Research 1
Sarah Armstrong , Jarrett Blaustein , and Alistair Henry
Part 1 Refl exive Approaches to Criminal Justice Policy
Research 31
2 Interpreting Infl uence: Towards Refl exivity in Penal
Policymaking? 33
Harry Annison
3 When the Stars Align: Juvenile Justice Policy Reform
in New South Wales 57
Elaine Fishwick
4 Towards Hope, Solidarity and Re-humanisation 81
Ruari-Santiago McBride
5 Policy as a Crime Scene 101
Sarah Armstrong and Anita Lam
vii
viii Contents
6 Refl exivity in Statistics as Sociology of Quantifi cation:
Th e Case of Repeat Victimization Modelling 123
Bilel Benbouzid
Part 2 Collaboration and Knowledge Exchange in Practice 147
7 Criminological Knowledge and the Politics of Impact:
Implications for Researching Juvenile Justice 149
Lesley McAra
8 Refl exive Academic–Practitioner Collaboration with 
the Police 169
Alistair Henry
9 Th e Shifting Legitimacy of Knowledge Across Academic
and Police/Practitioner Settings: Highlighting the Risks
and Limits of Refl exivity 191
Karen Lumsden
10 Th e Politics of Establishing Refl exivity as a Core
Component of Good Policing 215
Dominic A. Wood and Emma Williams
11 Getting In, Getting Out and Getting Back: Conducting
Long-term Research in Immigration Detention Centres 237
Mary Bosworth and Blerina Kellezi
Part 3 Positionality, Power and the Refl exive Imperative 263
12 Cartel Biographies: Th e Researcher as Storyteller
and the Preservation of the Research Wilderness on the 
Inside of the Subject 265
Christopher Harding
Contents ix
13 Who Needs Evidence? Radical Feminism, the Christian
Right and Sex Work Research in Northern Ireland 289
Graham Ellison
14 Insider? Outsider? Refl ections on Navigating Positionality
When Researching Restorative Justice Policing 315
Kelly J. Stockdale
15 Situated Perspectives on the Global Fight Against Torture 335
Andrew M. Jeff erson
16 Ethical Criminologists Fly Economy: Process- oriented
Criminological Engagement ‘Abroad’ 357
Jarrett Blaustein
Index 381
Contributors
Harry   Annison is Lecturer at the School of Law, Southampton University. His
primary research interest is penal politics and policymaking. His articles have
been published in Th eoretical Criminology , the Journal of Law and Society and
elsewhere. He is the author of D angerous Politics: Risk, Political Vulnerability, and
Penal Policy (2015).
Sarah   Armstrong i s Director of the Scottish Centre for Crime and Justice
Research. Her research concerns prisons and punishment policy and practice
including an ESRC funded research project called ‘Ethnography of Penal Policy’.
Bilel   B enbouzid i s Assistant Professor of Sociology at the University of East
Paris (UPEML). Prior to this he was a postdoctoral researcher at Center for
Sociological Research on Law and Criminal Justice Institutions (CESDIP) and
he holds a Ph.D. in Sociology from the University of Lyon. His research interests
are in the area of science and technology (STS), sociology of statistics and the
status of knowledge in crime prevention policy.
Jarrett   Blaustein i s Lecturer in Criminology at Monash University. He is the
author of Speaking Truths to Power: Policy Ethnography and Police Reform in
Bosnia and Herzegovina (2015) and has published his research in the E uropean
Journal of Criminology , Policing & Society and Th eoretical Criminology .
Mary   Bosworth is Professor of Criminology at the University of Oxford where
she is Director of the Border Criminologies research group. She is also, concur-
rently, Professor of Criminology at Monash University, Australia. Mary
xi
xii Contributors
has published widely on issues to do with race, gender and incarceration, includ-
ing, most recently the fi rst national study of life in British immigration removal
centres: Inside Immigration Detention (2014).
Graham   Ellison i s Reader in Criminology in the Institute of Criminology and
Criminal Justice, School of Law, Queen’s University Belfast. His main area of
research lies in the fi elds of police and policing, particularly in divided societies
such as Northern Ireland. Latterly his research has focused on international
policing and the policing and regulation of commercial sex. He is the co- author
of Globalization, Police Reform and Development: Doing it the Western Way? (with
Nathan Pino) and P olicing in An Age of Austerity: A Neocolonial Perspective (with
Mike Brogden). He has just completed a British Academy/Leverhulme Trust
funded study into the policing and legal regulation of commercial sex in four
European cities.
Elaine   Fishwick is a Sydney-based researcher, writer and academic scholar of
social policy, criminology and human rights. From 1988 until 2010 Fishwick
was a member of a rights based community advocacy organisation in New South
Wales called the Youth Justice Coalition (YJC), which has provided her with
practical experience of the policy making process. Fishwick is also a co-author,
with Leanne Weber and Marinella Marmo, of Crime, Justice and Human
Rights (2014) and co-editor of the soon-to-be-released R outledge International
Handbook of Criminology and Human Rights .
Christopher   Harding is Professor of Law in the Department of Law and
Criminology at Aberystwyth University, with research and teaching interests in
the international and European dimensions of crime, crime control and crimi-
nal justice, with a particular interest in the criminalisation of business cartels
and the emergent regime of EU criminal law.
Alistair   Henry is Senior Lecturer in Criminology at Edinburgh University. He
is an Associate Director of the Scottish Institute for Policing Research and is co-
chair of the European Society of Criminology’s Policing Working Group. He has
published on issues of policing, community safety, knowledge exchange and
negotiated orders.
Andrew   M.   Jeff erson is a prisons researcher at Danish Institute Against Torture
(DIGNITY), specializing in the ethnographic study of prisons and prison
reform processes in the global south. He works at the intersection between activ-
ism and research on justice, human rights and confi nement. Jeff erson is the