Table Of Content

Y AR CoO R o LIB CD W LO LA CCDO N KI O S A--cp L RA <cr -^ RReeaaddiinngg MMaatteerriiaallss ffoorr Og ^ B INTERNA TIONAL LA WII (PRIVA TE INTERNA TIONAL LA W) Law 228S SUPPLEMENT VOLUME 1A Prof, Craig Scott, Faculty of Law, University of Toronto e, ##f < January 1999 These materials are sold at cost to students at the University of Toronto. The materials are not for commercial sale. Storage KF 410 - S9 1996 Suppl. 1999 v. 1A c. 1 --- r. WR >OKA LASR'M LAW LIBRARY UNSVFJ'\L)i i / Of' FORONT O Reading Materials for INTERNA TI ON AT LA W II (PR 11A TE INTERNA TI ON AT LA IV) Law 228S SUPPLEMENT VOLUME 1A Prof. Craig Scott, Faculty of Law, University of Toronto January 1999 These materials are sold at cost to students at the University of Toronto The materials are not for commercial sale Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2018 with funding from University of Toronto https://archive.org/details/readingmaterials01scot TABLE OF CONTENTS Introductory Note This volume. Volume l A, contains supplementary readings for Topics 1- 12 of International Law II (Private International Law). Volume IB will contain the supplementary readings for Topics 13-23. Class/Topic 1: INTRODUCTION TO PRIV ATE INTERNATIONAL LAW.... No supp. readings tor this class Class/Topic 2: INTRODUCTION TO JURISDICTION’ AND RECOGNITION & ENFORCEMENT’ No supp readings for tins class Class/Topic 3: JURISDICTION: CONSTITUTIONALITY AND SUBSTANTIAL CONNECTION TESTS No supp. readings for this class Class/Topic 4: RESIDENCE AS CONNECTION: DIVORCE AND NULLITY Knight v'. Knight (1995). 16 R F.L (4th) 48 (Ont Ct of Justice. Gen Div.).1 Class/Topic 5: JURISDICTION: INTRODUCTION TO FORUM NON CONVENIENS Rules 16 and 17. Ontario Rules of Civil Procedure in Gam Watson and Michael McGowan, eds.. Ontario Civil Practice 1999 (Toronto: Carswell. 1998).6 Fry me r v Brettschneider (1994), 19 OR (3d) 60 (Ontario Court of Appeal). 12 Sarafi v. Ship Iran Afzal (1996), 111 FTR. 256 (Fed Ct of Canada. Trial Div.). 18 Harold Maier and Thomas McCoy, "A Unifying Theory for Judicial Jurisdiction and Choice of Law"( 1991) 39 .An Jl. Comp Law 249.22 Class/Topic 6: JURISDICTION: THE ANTI-SUIT INJUNCTION Hudon v. Geos Language Corp (1997). 100 0 AC. 336 (Ont Ct. of Justice. Gen. Div.).25 Andreas Lowenfeld, "Forum Non Conveniens and Antisiut Injunctions An Update’ (1998)92 AJIL41 ...28 CSR Ltd v’. Cigna Insurance Australia Ltd. [1996-1997] 189C .L.R 345 at 381 (High Court of Australia).30 Class/Topic 7: RECOGNITION AND ENFORCEMENT: PUBLIC POLICY, NATURAL JUSTICE, AND RELATED EXCEPTIONS P B Carter, "The Role of Public Policy in English Private International Law" (1993)42 ICLQ 1.’.39 Leaton Leather & Trading Co. v. Ngai Tak Kong (1997). 147 D.L.R (4th) 377 (B C. Supreme Court. 'Trial Div.).45 Class/Topic 8: RECOGNITION AND ENFORCEMENT: PUBLIC POLICY, NATURAL JUSTICE AND RELATED EXCEPTIONS Geoffrey York, "Russian jet freed in Montreal" (April 1, 1998) Globe and Mail AT A10.49 Showing v. Mansour (19941 2 All E R 129 (Priv\ Council, on appeal from Jersey).51 Class/Topic 9: JURISDICTION, APPLICABLE LAW, AND RECOGNITION AND ENFORCEMENT IN FAMILY & IMMIGRATION LAW CONTEXTS: ADOPTION OF CHILDREN R. D Kollewijn. "Conflicts of Western and Non-Western La\v"( 1951) 4 ICLQ 307.55 Tan Yock Lin. "Interpersonal Conflicts" in Conflicts Issues in Family and Succession Law (Singapore Buttervv orths Asia, 1993) 54-60.65 Khoo Tiang Bee v. Tan Beng Gwat, (1877) 1 Ky (Kyshe's Reports) 413 (James William Norton Kyshe. Cases Heard and Determined in Her Majesty s Supreme Court of the Straits Settlements. 1806-1884, Vol 1 (Somerset, England: Legal Library Publishing Services. 1885)] (Colonial Court of Appeal, Singapore).68 M B. Hooker. “Private International Law and Personal Laws: A Note on the Malaysian Experience"! 1968) 10 Malaya Law Review 55 at 55-61, 67.70 In re Mana Huberdina Hertogh Inche Mansor Adahi v. A.P. Hertogh and another, (1951) 17 Malaya Law Journal at 168-169. 165-168 (Colonial Court of Appeal, Singapore).74 Re Skinner (1929) 36 Ontario Weekly Notes 300 (Ontario Court of Appeal).78 Mattam v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration) (1987), 5 Imm. L.R. (2d) 212 (Immigration Appeal Board. Canada).79 Chaudhry v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration) (1988), Imm L.R. (2d) 197 (Immigration Appeal Board. Canada).81 Wee v. Canada (Minister of Employment and Immigration) (1992). 18 Imm L.R. (2d) 103 (Immigration and Refugee Board. Appeal Division).84 (Titzman r ('anada (Minister of Employment and Immigration) (1995), 33 1mm L R (2d) 28 (Immigration and Refugee Board, Appeal Division) .87 Sawan v Tea roe (1993) 48 R F L (3d) 392 (BC Court of Appeal). 89 Robert Matas, "B C gay parents gain equality' (Feb 5, 1998) Globe and Mail A1 Class/Topic 10: JURISDICTION, APPLICABLE LAW, AND RECOGNITION AND ENFORCEMENT IN FAMILY & IMMIGRATION LAW CONTEXTS: CUSTODY AND ABDUCTION OF CHILDREN Hoskins v. Boyd 11997] 6 W.W.R. 526 (B C Court of Appeal).94 Woodhouse v. Woodhouse (1996). 20 R F L (4th) 337 (Ontario Court of Appeal) [headnote only ] .96 Class/Topic 11: CHOICE OF LAW: CONTRACTS I John Swan and Vaughan Black. Table 1 | Structure of Choice of Law Process] in Swan and Black. Materials on Conflict of Laws. Volume 1 (Toronto/Halifax. September 1995) 24.98 Class/Topic 12: CHOICE OF LAW: CONTRACTS II Lilienthal v. Kaufman (1964). 395 P 2d. 543 (Oregon Supreme Court) as reproduced and edited m Swan and Black. Materials on Conflict of Laws. Volume 2 (Toronto/Hahfax. July 1996) 167.99 Clifford Larsen. "International Commercial Arbitration.’ ASIL Insight (April 1997).107 Sarabia v. 77?e Oceanic Mindoro [ 1997] 2 W.W.R. 116 (B.C Court of Appeal).Ill