PULSED AND PULSED BIAS SPUTTERING Principles and Applications PULSED AND PULSED BIAS SPUTTERING Principles and Applications by Edward V. Barnat Sandia National Laboratories Albuquerque, NA1 Toh-MingLu Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute Troy,NY SPRINGER SCIENCE+BUSINESS MEDIA, LLC Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A C.I.P. Catalogue record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Pulsed and Pulsed Bias Sputtering: Principles and Applications. By Edward V. Barnat amd Toh-Ming Lu. ISBN 978-1-4020-7543-8 ISBN 978-1-4615-0411-5 (eBook) DOI 10.1007/978-1-4615-0411-5 Copyright© 2003 by Springer Science+Business Media New York Originally published by Kluwer Academic Publishers in 2003 Softcover reprint of the hardcover 1s t edition 2003 Ali rights reserved. No part ofthis work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, microfilming, recording, or otherwise, without the written permission from the Publisher, with the exception of any material supplied specifically for the purpose of being entered and executed on a computer system, for exclusive use by the purchaser of the work. Permission for books published in Europe: [email protected] Permission for books published in the United States of America: [email protected] Printed on acid-free paper. TABLE OF CONTENTS PREFACE IX ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Xl Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION OVERVIEW OF SPUTTERING FOR TECHNOLOGICAL APPLICATIONS 2 PLASMA-SURF ACE 6 INTERACTIONS 3 CHARGING OF INSULATING SURFACES 7 4 OVERVIEW OF THE MONOGRAPH ............. 9 Chapter 2 BASIC PLASMA PHENOMENON 11 THE PLASMA STATE 11 2 BASIC PLASMA STRUCTURE 13 3 COLLISIONS 22 4 SUMMARY 26 Chapter 3 PLASMA SOURCES USED FOR 29 SPUTTER DEPOSITION 1 DIRECT CURRENT (DC) SOURCES ............. 29 2 ALTERNATING CURRENT (AC) SOURCES ... 38 3 SUMMARY 42 Chapter 4 RESPONSE OF A PLASMA . . . . . .. . . . . . ... 45 TO AN APPLIED BIAS GENERAL CONSIDERATIONS ................. ... 46 AND APPROXIMATIONS 2 QUASI-STATIC APPROXIMATION OF .......... 49 THE SHEATH 3 BREAKDOWN OF THE QUASI-STATIC 54 APPROXIMATION 4 TRANSIENT NATURE OF THE SHEATH 57 5 SUMMARY 62 VI Chapter 5 SINUSOIDAL WAVEFORM . ... . .. . . . . .. 65 1 QUASI-STATIC REGIME ..................... 65 2 TRANSIENT SHEATH REGIME 69 3 SUMMARY 72 Chapter 6 PULSED WAVEFORM ..................... 75 DEFINITION OF THE PULSE 76 2 QUASI-STATIC RESPONSE OF THE ............. 76 SYSTEM TO AN APPLIED PULSE 3 APPROXIMATED PREDICTIONS OF ........ .... 89 ENERGY SPECTRA 4 HIGHER FREQUENCY RESPONSE OF THE ... 95 SYSTEM TO THE PULSED WAVEFORM 5 COMPARISON BETWEEN SINUSOIDAL 104 AND PULSED WAVEFORMS 6 SUMMARY 106 Chapter 7 APPLICATION OF A PULSED 109 WAVEFORM TO A TARGET: PULSED REACTIVE SPUTTERING INTRODUCTION . . .... . . .. ... . .. . .. . .. . . . . ... .. ... . ... 110 2 APPLICATION OF A PULSE FOR ARC .......... 112 SUPPRESSION (PREDICTIONS) 3 APPLICATION OF A PULSE TO 121 REACTIVE SPUTTERING (PRACTICE) 4 SUMMARY ......................................... .... 127 Chapter 8 APPLICATION OF A PULSED 129 WAVEFORM TO A SUBSTRATE: PULSED BIAS SPUTTERING 1 INTRODUCTION ...................................... 129 2 CONSIDERATIONS FOR PULSED 130 BIASING OF THE SUBSTRATE 3 OBSERVED FLUX OF CHARGE TO A 133 PULSED SUBSTRATE 4 APPLICATION OF A PULSED BIAS TO 138 FILM GROWTH 5 SUMMARY ......................................... .... 143 Vll Chapter 9 CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE .......... 145 DIRECTIONS 1 CONCLUSIONS ....................................... 145 2 FUTURE DIRECTIONS 146 REFERENCES 149 INDEX 157 PREFACE As thin film technology evolves, more stringent requirements are placed on the techniques and the materials employed to bring about the next generations of applications. It is typically the role of the research scientists and industrial engineers to bring about innovations to meet these stringent requirements. This is done through not only an understanding of a broad range of disciplines, such as physics, chemistry, and materials science, but the application of that understanding as well. Sputter deposition is a very popular technique to coat thin films for many diverse high tech applications such as semiconductor integrated circuits, optical films, and hard coatings. Typically the technique utilizes a plasma generated under a vacuum condition, and ions are extracted from the plasma (direct current (DC)) to bombard the target. Atoms would be sputtered out of the target and would travel to the substrate for coating. For reactive sputtering to form insulating films, the target can get charged up quickly and arcing would occur (target poisoning). To overcome this problem, an oscillatory potential source can be used so that the target would be neutralized during sputtering. Typically it is in the range of radio frequency (RF). Normally RF sputtering would require higher power and would give a slower deposition rate. Recently an alternative strategy called the pulsed sputtering technique was developed to address the charging problem. The technique utilizes a pulsing potential to neutralize the target in the kilohertz regime and can produce much higher deposition rate than that of the RF sputtering. Also, in the sputtering of a metal film, if a bias potential is applied to the substrate, one can control the film properties such as adhesion, texture, morphology, and density of the film. This is because one can extract ions to bombard the growth front during growth. However, if the substrate is an insulator, it can get charged up very quickly and one would lose the benefit of ion bombardment, particularly during the initial stages of growth. Initial stages of film nucleation very often can affect the properties of the film subsequently grown. RF potential can be used to neutralize the substrate. However, the ion energy distribution generated by a RF power is not uniform and is not well controlled. Recently, it is recognized that using a pulsed bias potential on the substrate in the kilohertz regime one can overcome this difficulty and can produce better controlled and superior film quality. Both pulsed sputtering and pulsed bias sputtering mentioned above are considered to be advanced sputtering techniques and are developed only in recent years. Our monograph will give a detailed account on these newly developed concepts. The basic principles of the charging and discharging phenomena at the target and substrate, and the methods of neutralizing them x using pulsing techniques are described in detail. In addition, we will present in a coherent manner the basic physics of DC plasma formation and the utilization of the plasma in the sputtering environment. This monograph will not only be useful for academic researchers but also for industrial scientists interested in sputter coatings of high quality metal and insulator. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors would like to acknowledge the SRC (Semiconductor Research Corporation), the FRC (Marco Interconnect Focus Center for Research), the New York State Science and Technology Foundation, and the Intel Foundation for support. The authors are also very grateful for the contributions of the many who had made the work presented in this monograph possible, including Dr. Matthew Nielsen (General Electric CRD), Dr. Jin-Young Kim (Texas Instruments), Dr. Pei-I Wang (RPI), Dr. Jason Drotar (Naval Research Lab), Dr. Atul Kumar (DSI), and Diaki Nagakura (RPI). We would like to thank the authors who have allowed us to use their work that appears in this monograph. The authors would like to thank Carol Day and Greg Franklin of Kluwer Academic Publishers for the opportunity to present this work to the broader scientific community. Finally, we would like to thank Angela Eaton for her many hours reviewing and editing the monograph. Edward V. Bamat would also like to express his deep appreciation to both Dr. Toh-Ming Lu and Dr. Gwo-Ching Wang for their encouragement, guidance, and support throughout his doctoral studies. Ed would also like to thank both Dr. Gerry Hays and Dr. Greg Hebner (Sandia National Laboratories) for their support during the finishing stages of this monograph at Sandia. Finally, he would like to express his gratitude to both his friends and family for their love and support. Edward V. Bamat Toh-Ming Lu Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute Troy, NY October 2002 Chapter 1 INTRODUCTION This monograph is a guide for those interested in improving sputter based thin film technology through the use of a pulse-based technology. Of critical importance to the discussion that will be offered in this monograph are the effects energetic-charged particles have on surfaces and how an applied waveform can be applied to control these energetic-charged particles. It is hoped that through a discussion of the response of a plasma to an applied waveform, an understanding can be gained as to the factors that influence the effectiveness of the applied waveform for controlling these charged particles. The chapter begins with a simple description of the sputtering phenomenon and an out line of some of the technological applications of the sputtering process. The chapter continues with a discussion of the importance of the interactions that occur between charged particles from the plasma and the surface exposed to the plasma. Section 3 considers the case when the surface exposed to the plasma is non-conducting, and how charging of this surface can adversely impact interactions between the plasma and the surface. The chapter closes with an overview of the remaining monograph. 1 OVERVIEW OF SPUTTERING FOR TECHNOLOGICAL APPLICATIONS 1.1 What is sputtering? Sputtering is the physical removal of atoms from a surface due to energetic particle bombardmene. This removal occurs from momentum transfer between the ejected atoms and adjacent surface atoms. Momentum is transferred to theses atoms through a series of collisions from other atoms that had been set into motion through collisions with the bombarding particle. Sputter based deposition techniques use these ejected atoms as the source material for growth. For the deposition-based processes that we are discussing here, the energetic particle is an ion that has been accelerated from an ionized gas, or a plasma. E. V. Barnat et al., Pulsed and Pulsed Bias Sputtering © Kluwer Academic Publishers 2003