PROMPT AND UTTER DESTRUCTION Prompt and REVISEDEDITION THEUNIVERSITYOFNORTHCAROLINAPRESS CHAPELHILLANDLONDON Utter Destruction TRUMAN AND THE USE OF ATOMIC BOMBS AGAINST JAPAN J. Samuel Walker ©1997,2004 TheUniversityofNorthCarolinaPress Allrightsreserved ManufacturedintheUnitedStatesofAmerica Thepaperinthisbookmeetstheguidelinesfor permanenceanddurabilityoftheCommitteeon ProductionGuidelinesforBookLongevityofthe CouncilonLibraryResources. ThisbookwassetinMonotypeGaramond byTsengInformationSystems. BookdesignbyRichardHendel. TheLibraryofCongresshascatalogedtheoriginaledition asfollows: Walker,J.Samuel. Promptandutterdestruction:Trumanandtheuseofatomic bombsagainstJapan/byJ.SamuelWalker. p. cm. Includesbibliographicalreferencesandindex. 1.WorldWar,1939–1945—UnitedStates. 2.WorldWar,1939– 1945—Japan. 3.Atomicbomb. 4.UnitedStates—Foreign relations—1945–1953. 5.Truman,HarryS.,1884–1972. I.Title. d767.25.h6w355 1997 940.54'25—dc21 96-52038 cip isbn0-8078-5607-x(alk.paper) 08 07 06 05 04 5 4 3 2 1 This book is dedicated with love to mychildren Mary Beth and Dan. Contents PrefacetotheRevisedEdition ix Preface xi 1 ACategoricalChoice? 1 2 TheMostTerribleWeaponEverKnown 7 3 TheProspectsforVictory,June1945 20 4 PathstoVictory 35 5 TrumanandtheBombatPotsdam 53 6 HiroshimaandNagasaki 75 7 HiroshimainHistory 98 Chronology:KeyEventsof1945RelatingtothePacificWar 111 Notes 113 EssayonSources 131 Index 137 Illustrations 1 MarshallandStimson,January1942 3 2 DamagetoTokyofromfirebombing 28 3 JapanesekamikazeattackoffOkinawa 33 4 Truman,Byrnes,andLeahyenroutetoPotsdam 54 5 Testexplosionofatomicbomb,July16,1945 57 6 Churchill,Truman,andStalinatPotsdam 63 7 Hiroshimaaftertheatomicattack 76 8 Nagasakibeforeandaftertheatomicbomb 79 9 Editorialcartoon,‘‘TheFellowWhoLightedtheFuse’’ 99 Preface to the Revised Edition Sixty years after the end of World War II, the use of the atomic bomb against Japan continues to generate an ever- growing volume of scholarly literature and to trigger enormous controversy.SinceIcompletedwritingthefirsteditionofthisbook in1996,importantnewworkshaveincreasedourknowledgeofthe contextinwhichtheUnitedStatesattackedHiroshimaandNaga- sakiwithatomicweapons.Buttheyhavenotstilledthedebateover PresidentHarryS.Truman’sdecision.TherevisededitionofPrompt andUtterDestructiondrawsonscholarlyfindingsthathaveappeared over the past eight years, especially research in recently opened Japanesesourcesthathasgreatlyenrichedourunderstandingofthe agonizingdeliberationsinTokyooverendingthewar.Thechanges I have made are not extensive but theyare important, and I hope theywillenhancethebook’svalue. Theresponsetothefirsteditionofthebookhasbeenverygrati- fying. Reviewers across the interpretive spectrum in the contro- versy over Truman’s decision to use the bomb were exceedingly kind,withtheglaringexceptionofsomewhostandatthepolesof thedebate.Ihavealsogainedgreatsatisfactionfromthefactthat scoresofcollegeprofessorsandsecondaryschoolteachershaveas- signedthebooktotheirclasses.Manyhavetoldmethatthebook ( ix )
Description: