Politics in Dark Times: Encounters with Hannah Arendt

408 Pages·2010·10.66 MB·English

by  Seyla Benhabib

PoliiDnta Tirickms e s
EncounwtietHrhas n nAarhe ndt
EdibtyeS de yBlean habib
Politicins DarkT imes
EncountweirtHsha nnaAhr endt
Thiso utstancdoilnlge cotfie osns aeyxsp loHraensn aArhe ndtt'hso ught
againtshteb ackgrooufnw do rld-poleivteinuctnasfl o ldsiinngcS ee ptem­
bern , 200.I Ite ngagiensa contentdiioaulso gwuiet ho neo ft he
greatepsotl ittihcianlk oefrt sh ep ascte ntuwriyt,th h ec onvicttihoant
sher emaicnosn temporTahreym.es su cahs m oraaln dp oliteiqcuaall ity,
actionna,ta ljiutdyg,m eanntd,fr eedoamr re eevaluwaittefhdr eisnhs ight
bya grouopf t hinkewrhso a ret hemselwveelksln ownf ort heiorri gi­
nalc ontributtoip oonlsi ttihcoaulg hOtt.h eers safyosc uosn n ovealn d
little-distchuesmseiesntd h el iterabtyuhi rgeh lighAtrienngd vti'esw osn
sovereiignnttye,r natliaowan nadgl e nocinduec,l ewaera poanns dr evolu­
tionism,p eriaalnidsE mu rocentrasiw seml,al s h erc ontrasitmiangge s
ofE uropaen dAm ericaE.a che ssadyi splnaoytso nlsyu perAbr endt
scholarbsuhtai lps sot yliflsatiairnc d a nalyttiecnaalc ity.
SeylBae nhabiistb h eE ugenMee yerP rofesosfoP ro litSicciaeln acned
PhilosoaptYh ayl Uen iversSihtyei. st hea uthoorfC ritiqNuoer,ma nd
UtopiAa S:t udoyft hNeo rmatiFvoeu ndations ofC ritiTchaelo r(Iy 9 86);
SituattihneSg e lf: Gender, aCnodmP mousntmiotyd erniinsC mo ntem­
porarEyt hi(c2s0 20)F;e miniCsotn tentiAo Pnhsi:l osopEhxicchaaln ge
(coauthwoirteJhdu diBtuht lDerru,c iClolran ealnldN, a ncFyr asIe9r9,6 );
TheR eluctMaondte rniosfHm a nnah Ar(eIn9d9t6T )h;eC laiomfsC ul­
turEeq:u alaintdyD iversiintty h eG lobEarla ( 20)0;T2 heR ighotfsO th­
ersA:l ienCsi,t izaenndRs e side(n2t0s0 4a)n;dA nothCeors mopolitanism:
HospitaSloivteyr,e iagnndDty em ocratIitce rat(i2o06n0)sS. h eh ase dited
andc oedisteevde vno lumemso,s tr ecenwtiltyJh u diRtehs niMko,b ility
andI mmobilGietnyd:e Bro,r dearnsd C itizen(s2h0i0p9H )e.rw orkh as
beetnr anslianttefodo urteleann guaagnedss ,h ew ast her ecipioeftn hte
2009E rnstB locPhr izfeo rh erc ontributtoic ounlst udriaall ogiunea s
globcailv ilization.

PolitiinDc asr kT imes
EncountweirtHsha nnaAhr endt
Editbeyd
SEYBLEANH ABffi
YalUen iversity
Witht hea sisstanocfe
ROTY.T SAO
PETEVRE ROVSEK
J.
YalUen iversity
CAMBRIDGE
UNIVERSITY PRESS
CAMBRIDGUEN IVERSIPTYR ESS
CambriNdegwYe o,r Mke,l bouMranderC,ia dp,Te o wnS,i ngapore,
SaPoa uDleol,Dhi u,b aTio,k yMoe,xi cCoi ty
CambrUindigvee Prrseistsy
32.A venoufte h Aem eriNceawYs o,r NYk ,1 0302.1-473US,A
www .cambridge.org
Informaotnti hotiintls eww :w .cambridg5e2..Io7rI2.g2.2./69 780
© CambrUindigvee Prrse:z.isotyxs o
Thipsu bliicisa nctoi poynr Siugbhjtteos.ct t atuteoxrcye ption
antdot hper oviosfri eolnescv oalnltel citicveean gsrienegm ents,
nor eprodoufac ntpyia ormnat y t akpel awciet houwtr itttheen
permiosfCs aimobnr Uindigvee Prrseistsy.
Firpsutb li:z.soxhoe d
Prinitnteh Udeni teSdt aotfAe mse rica
A catalroegc foortrdh is pubisla ivcaatiifrlaoobnmlt ehB er itLisihb rary.
LibroafCry o nesgsrC ataloing Piunbgl icdaattai on
Poliitindc asrt ki m:ee sn couwnittHehar nsn Aarhe nIed dti btyeS de yBleanb hiab.
p.e m.
Inclbuidbelsi ographaincidan ld erxe.f erences
ISBN9 78-:z.ox--s7706-(37h ard-bIaSBcN9 k87)-po1--2.172.2.-(6ap perback)
x.Ar endHta,n nIah9-,0I 96752.·P. o listicciae-lPn hcielosophy.
IB.e nhaSbeiybln,a.T . i tle.
]C2.51.A74P2.60160
302..952.0-dcu :z.oxoo2.4375
ISBN9 7o8--2.r57-6730-H7a rdback
ISBN9 78--o52.2.I7-2.2.I-P6a perback
CambrUindigvee Prrsehisatysn s or esponsitbhpieel ristiyos ratf ceocnruc orefa UR cLS yf or
externoartl h ird-parWteybs iItrneetsfe erntreoirt nte hidps u bliacnaddtio oennso g tu arantee
thaantcy o ntoensn utcW he bs itiesos,rw irlelm aaicnc,ur oarat pep ropriate.
Thipsu blihcaabstie oesnnu pporatg eedn ebgryro aufrnsot mt hJeo hKn.C asFtluned h ousiend
YalPer'osg ornaE mt hiPcosli,ta incEdsc onomThiCeca ss.Ft ulnewd a ess tabilnhi osnhooefrd
ReverJeanmPdei se rpoononefYt ,a loer'isg fionuanld ers.
Contents
Noteosn C ontributors pagve ii
Introduction I
SeylBae nhabib
PART I.F REEDOM, EQUALITY, AND RESPONSIBILITY
I Arenodntt hFeo undatoifE oqnusa lity I7
JeremWya ldron
2 ArendtA'usg ustine 39
RoyT .T sao
3Th e Ruloeft hPee opAlree:n Adrtc,h ea,n Dde mocracy 58
PatchMeanr kell
4 GenealoofgC iaetsa stropheo:n t ArhLeeon gdaitnc Ld e gacy
ofIm perialism 8 3
KarunMaa ntena
5 OnR ace and CultAruerned:at n HdHe arnC noanht emporarIi 3eI s
.
RichaHr.dK ing
PART II.S OVEREIGNTY,T HE NATION-STATEA,N D THE RULE OF LAW
6B anisthhiSeno gv er?eI ingtnerannad l ExtSeorvnearle ignty
inA rendt I3 7
AndreAwr ataon dJ eaLn. C ohen
7 TheD ecloifnO erd er: HAarnennaadnhttd h Pea radooxf es
thNea tion-State I72
Christian Voik
8 TheE ichmTarninaa nltd h Lee gaocfJy u risdiction I98
LeorBai lsky
v
Contents
v1
9 InternatLiaowan nadHlu maPnl urailnti htSeyh adoofw
TotalitaHrainannaAihrse mn:ad ntRd a phaLeelm .kin 2I9
SeyBlean habib
PART III.P OLITICSI N DARK TIMES
IOI nS earocfah M iracle: AHraennandnattdh h Aet omBiocm b 247
jonathSacnh ell
I HIa nnaAhr enbdett weEeunr oapneAd m eriOcpat:i miins m
DarTki mes 259
BenjamRi.Bn a rber
I2K eepitnhRgee pubRleiacd:i ng AOrne nRdetv'soa lftuetri on
thFea olflt hBee rWlailn l 277
DicHko ward
PART IV.J UDGING EVIL
I3A reA rendt's RoenEfl veicSltti iRolenlls e v?a nt 293
RicharBde]r.n stein
I4B analRietyc onsidered 305
SusaNne iman
15T heE lusivoefAn reesnsd Jtuidagnm ent 316
BryanG arsten
I6 Existenint iAraeln dtVTa'rlseu aetsmo efEn vtia ln d Morali3t4y2
GeorgKea teb
Index 375
Noteosn C ontributors
AndreAwr aitsDo o rotHh.yH irshon PirnoP foelsistaoinrcdS a olc iTahle ­
orayt t he NSecwh ofoolr SRoecsieaalHr eci hst. h aeu thoofCr onstitution
Makiunngd Oeccru patTihoPeno l:i toifIc msp oRseevdo liunIt ria(o0qn20 )9;
CivSiolc iCeotnys,t iatnuLdte igoint i(om2oa)oca;yn Fd roNme o-Martxoi sm
DemcoraTthioecr( y91 9)3a ndc oautohfCo irv Siolc ietPyol iatTnihdec oarly
(9192H)ei. sc urrewnotrlkyio nnag b oookn c onstiatuutehnotar nidat ny
essvaoyl uomned ictataonrdmso hdieppr onl itics.
BenjaRmi.Bn a rbiesaDr i stingSueinsiFhoeerld l aotDw e moisnN ewY ork
andW alWth itman ProfesastoR ru tE�mresr iUtnuiHsvi essr esvietnyt.e en
bookisn cltuhdceel asSstircoD negmc ora(c9rSy4 )i,s suienan d e wtw entieth­
anniveerdsiatriiyn2o n04 0;t hien ternabteisotn-aJslie hlvlasedM.r cW orld,
nowi nt hilratnyg u(a9g19e5;s)a ndm,o srte cenCtolnys,u HmoewdM :a rkse t
CorrCuhpitl dIrnaefnnt,iA ldiuzlaetn Ssdw alCliotwi Wzheonl(seo2 o 8H)e.i s
presiadnefdno tu nodfeC ri vWortlhndeo, n governomregnatnailz( aNtGiOo)n
thasti n2c0e30 h asc onvetnheed anInnutaelr depeDnadyFe onrcuaemn d
Celebrianat g iloonbc ailot nyS eptemr2b .e r
SeyBlean haibsEiu bge Mneey ePrr ofeosfPs oolri tSicciaealnn cPdeh ilosophy
atY alUen iverSsoimtoeyf h. e bro okisn clTuhdRee e lucMtoadnetr noifs m
HannaAhr en(9d1t9; r6 eisisn2u e0d0) T3;h Rei gohftOs th erAsl:i eCnist,i zens
and Res(i02d04;ew nitnsno efrt hRea lpBhu ncAhwea rodf t hAem erican
PolitSicciaeAlns cseo ciaAtniohotenCr)o; s mooilptanwiistmh, resbpyo nses
JereWmayl drBoonn,n Hioen iagn,d WKiylmll icbkaas,oe ndh eBre rkeley
TannLeerc tuarneedsd itbeyRd o bePrto s(to2 o6a)n;mdo srte ceMntolibyl ity
anIdm moibliGteydn:e rB,or dearnsdC itize(0n2s0)h9e,id pi tweidtJ hu dith
Resn.i k
Richard}. iBVsee rnrLsait Psertieo nsf soofPr h ilosaottp hhNeye wS chool for
SociRaels eaHricsbho .o ks iHnacnlnuaAdhre enadnttd h Jee wiQsuhe stion
vii
viii NotoensC ontributors
(9196F)r;ea undtd h Lee gaocfMy o se(9s19 ;8R )adiEcvaiAll P :h ilosophi­
caIln tertrioo(0gn2a0 2a)n;dT hAe busoefE viTlh:eC orrupotfPi oloint ics
anRde ilgoins in9c/er( z020 5H)i.s mroescteb noto kT hiPesr agmatic Turn
(2010).
LeorBai lsiky sP rofeosfsL oarwa tT el-AUvniivv erasnidtt hyae u thoofr
TraonrsmftaiJvues tIiscreIa:de elniot niT trliy( a 0204).
JeaLn.C ohein sPr ofeosfPs oolri tTihceaoalrt yC olumUbniiav erSshiiets y .
thaeu thoofCr l aasnsCd i vSiolc iTehtyLe:i miotfMs a rxiCarni tTihecoaryl
(918)2C;i vSiolc iaentyPd o iltiTcheaolry ( 9192w)it Ahn dreAwr ataan;d
RethiInnktiinmgAaN ceywL: e gPaaldr iag(m2 0)0S.h2 iecs o mpleatb ionogk
for CambUrniidvgeerP srietosynsl egaalnidtl ye gitiimnta hceey p ocohf
globalization.
Bryan GarsteinPs r ofesPsoolri tSoicfci aealntY c aelU en ivearnsaiduty t hor of
SaviPnegr suaAs Diefonenso:ef R hetaonrJdiu cd egmn(to2 o6H)e. haalss o
writatretni ocntl heesm reesl attore edp resegnotvaetrinvimenet nhtteh ought
ofH obbeRso,u ssTeoacuq,u eavinldBl een,j aCmionn stant.
DickH owarid sD istingPurieosfshseoodfrP hilosaottp hhSeyt aUtnei ver­
siotfyN ewY orakt S tonByr ooHke.i st haeu thooffr o urtebeono kmso,s t
receTnthley SpoefDc etmceorra (c02y0 2L)an; a issaInpac eene ps deoielt ique
americ(a2oio5na)en; dL ad emcoraat li'eper euCvher:o niaqmueersi caines
(o2o6T)h.Pe r imoaftc hyPe ol itAi Hciatslo:ro yfP oiltiTchoaulg frhotm t he
Greetkots h e AmerFirceanRnce vhoau nltdi woansps ub lish2e01d .0in
GeorgKea teib sW illiNaeml sCorno mwePlrlo feosfsP oorl itics Emeritus
atP rincUentiovne rHissi btoyo.k isn clHuadne nAarhe nPdolti:t Ciocns­,
scieEnvci(el1,4 9)8T;h eIn nOecre aInn:d ividaunaDdle imcsorma Ctuilc­
tur(9e1 92E)m;e rsaonnSde -lRfeli(a91n94,c2 e0 0)J2;o hSnt uMairltl , On
Libecrotye,d iwtietDdha viBdr omwi(c02h0 )3a;n dP atriaontdi smO ther
Mista(ok2oes6 ).
RichaHr.d Kingi Psr ofeEsmseorri otfAu mse riIcnatne llHeicsttuaoatrtl yh e
UniverosfNi ottyt ingUKh.a Hme,i st haeu thoofrR acCeu,l taunrdte h e
IntellIe9c4t0u-aI(l092s074,)0 a, n cdo ediotfHo arn nAarhe nadnttdh Ues es
ofH itsorIym:p eriNaaltiisomn,, GReanccoei d(0ea20 n)d7H. e i sc urrently
atw orokn T heA meriAcraenn wdhti,cw hi lflo counsA renditm'psao cnt
Ameritchaonu gahntdt hiem paocfht e erx periienAn mceer iocnha e orw n
thought.
KarunaM anteniasA ssisPtraonfte osfPs oolri tSicciaealntY c ael e University.
She rheasse aracnhdwe rdi totnee nm piarnedi mperiianlm iosdmep ronl it­
ical thouegshpte caionannd li,ln ye,t eenth-centuryi dBeroiltoigys.h imperial
Shies t haeu thoofAr l iobfiE sm piHreen:Mry a ianent dh Een dosfL iberal
Imperi(a02l1i0s)m.
NotoensC ontributors ix
PatcMhaernk iesAlls socPiraotfeeo sfPs oolri Stciiceaanltc eUt nhiev ersity
ofC hicaangtdoh aeu thoofBr o unbdyR ecogn(i02t03i) Ho.en i csu rrently
writianb goo k-lesntguotdfhHy a nnAraehn td'Tsh Heu maCno ndiatnido n
ipsu rsaul ionngg erp-rtoejorencmc o tn cepotfpi oowneasrg ,e nacnyrd,u ilne
democtrhaetoircy .
SusNane imainDs ir ecotfto hre EiFnosrtuemBi enir nlG ienr,m aHneymr.o st
recbeonotak rsEe v iilnM odeTrhno u(g0h204t) w,h ihcahbs e en translated
inntinole a nguaangMdeo sr,Ca lla rAiG tyu:i tdoGe r won-UIpd ea(l02i08s)ts,
aN ewY orTki mNeost aBboloek .
JonatShcanhi etsllh e aoufTt hhFeoa rto eft hEea r(trh89 2a)n Tdh Uen con­
querWaobrllPedo w:e rN,o nvioalnetdnh cWeei o,ll f Ptehoep( 0l204e) a,m ong
othbeoro .kH ismso srte cbeonotik Ts h See veDnetcha TdheNe:e wS haopfe
NuclDeaanrg (e2roo 8H)e.i saP eace FelNlaotwiI onanst t aitnthadue t e
lectuirnie nrt ernsattuidoainneaedsl t hipcotsli,ica sn,ed conoamtYi aclse
University.
RoyT .T sahoa tsa ugpholti ttihceaoalrt y YGaeloer,g eatnoBdwr no,w n
univerHsehi atpsiu lebiss.nh uemde raorutsio cnal sepseo cAftr se ntdhto'usg ht.
PetJe.Vr e rovissae P khD ..c andiidnpa otilet isccailea ntYc aelU en iver­
sitBye.f coroem itnoYg a lhees, p eany te aorna F ulbrGirgarhnetts earching
howm emoroifWe osr lWda rII conttiona ufefp eocltiw tiitchtsihf neo rmer
Yugosalnaindvt ihare e laotfiit ossnu sc cesstaswtoiertIs ht aHliyds.i ssertation
examitnhceeos n nebcettwieomenen m oarnypd o lictoimcmaulnt ihtryo ugh
thdee veloopftm heEenu trp oeaUnn ion.
_ �·
ChristianV olkr ecehiivdseo dc tdoergafrlre oeAm a chen U(neiGrvmerasniyt)y
in2 00.H9 ei s atuhteho ofDr ie O rdngud neFrr eiRheeciuhtnt.Pd o litiimk
DenkHeann nAarhe n(do2tsr )oH.e c urrenhtollaydp sot sdoctoprosailta ito n
thHeu mbdotl-UniivnBe errsalinitidnyws o rkoinnh giH sa bilitraotjtie oknsp
"TheP aradiPgosmt -eoSrfoe viLganwta ynD:de mocrina cGayl obOarldr e."
JereWmalyd rioUnsn ivePrrsoifteaysNt se owYr o rUkn iveSrcshiootfLoyal w .
Hei tsh aeu thoofLr a wa nDdi sagre(9er9me9an)nGtd o ,dL ocakneEd q ua­
li(ty02 02a)m onogt hbeorko sH.e i tsh aeu thoof"r Are ndCto'nss titutional
Poli"it niD casnVai l(le)adT ,.h eC amrbidCgoem pantioHo ann nAarhe ndt
(2oaonr"d)Wh aWto ulHda nnSaah"y i ?nT he NewR eYvoiorefkBw oo ks,
Marcrhs2, 0 07
.