Table Of Content

OXFORD JOURNAL OF LEGAL STUDIES VOLUME 15 Published on behalf of The Faculty of Law, University of Oxford OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS 1995 General Editor: J. Eekelaar Editorial Committee: P. Cane, J. W. Davies, J. Gardner, S. Gardner, C. Gray, J. Hackney, J. Horder, G. McCrudden, D. Prentice Oxford University Press, Walton Street, Oxford OX2 6DP Oxford New York Toronto Delhi Bombay Calcutta Madras Karachi Petaling Jaya Singapore Hong Kong Tokyo Nairobi Dar es Salaam Cape Town Melbourne Auckland and associate companies in Beirut Berlin Ibadan Nicosia © Oxford University Press 1995 except where otherwise indicated CONTENTS ARTICLES BATNITZKY, LEoRA, A Seamless Web? John Finnis and Joseph Raz on the Obligation to Obey the Law BaxTER, COLIN, Demystifying D & O Insurance CHAN, JosEPH, Raz on Liberal Rights and Common Goods CHRISTOPHER, RUSSELL L., Unknowing Justification and the Logical Necessity of the Dadson Principle in Self-Defence Foot, Puiippa, Does Moral Subjectivism Rest on a Mistake? Hopeson, Davin, Probability: the Logic of the Law—a Response Marks, Susan, Civil Liberties at the Margin: the UK Derogation and the European Court of Human Rights McBripe, NICHOLAS J. and McGraTH, PAuL, The Nature of Restitution Morris, ANDREW J., On the Normative Foundations of Indirect Discrimination Law: Understanding the Competing Models of Discrimination Law as Aristotelian Forms of Justice PottaGE, ALAIN, The Originality of Registration Ramsay, IaIn, Consumer Credit Law, Distributive Justice and the Welfare State Saj6, ANDRAS, Reading the Invisible Constitution: Judicial Review in Hungary SMITH, STEPHEN A., Restructuring Restraint of Trade TAMANAHA, BRIAN Z., An Analytical Map of Social Scientific Approaches to the Concept of Law WARNER, RICHARD, Excluding Reasons: Impossible Comparisons and the Law WHITTAKER, SIMON, Privity of Contract and the Law of Tort: the French Experience ZIMMERMANN, REINHARD, Unjustified Enrichment: The Modern Civilian Approach REVIEW ARTICLES BarRKER, Kit, Unjust Enrichment: Containing the Beast BRADLEY, CAROLINE, Corporate Power and Control in the 1990s: The Transnational Dimension Duxsury, NEIL, History as Hyperbole Paton, Ewan, Respecting Freedom of Speech SuLLIVAN, G. R., Expressing Corporate Guilt SHORTER ARTICLES Durr, R. A., Recklessness in Attempts (Again) Goo, Say Hak, Enforceability of Securities and Guarantee after O’Brien KERRUISH, VALERIE, Worthy Hearts of Gold: Ideology and Intentions Ocus, ANTHONY, Rethinking Self-Regulation PAULSON, STANLEY L., Radbruch on Unjust Laws: Competing Earlier and Later Views? REED, ALAN, A Commentary on Hunt v Severs TALMON, STEFAN, War Booty of ‘Separate Entity’ Protected by Sovereign Immunity TICKNER, KAREN, Rogers v Whitaker—Giving Patients a Meaningful Choice LEGISLATION (Entries refer to statutes receiving substantial discussion or criticism in this volume] UNITED KINGDOM Companies Act 1985 s 310 540 et seq s 727 542 et seq Consumer Credit Act 1974 185 et seq Conveyancing and Law of Property Act 1881 379, 390 Courts and Legal Services Act 1990 105-6 Criminal Attempts Act 1981 250, 314 et seq Criminal Damage Act 1971 sl 309 Land Registration Act 1925 s 70 (1)(g) 123-4, 403 et seq Land Transfer Act 1897 379 et seq, 392 Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Act 1989 69 et seq Race Relations Act 1976 225-6 State Immunity Act 1978 295 et seq s2 298, 301-4 s 10 s 14(2) Clean Air Act (US) s 7409 Community Reinvestment Act (US) 181 Constitutional Court Act 1989 (Hung) 254 et seq German Criminal Code 1975 249 Loi 1975 (Fr) 358 et seq CASES [Entries refer to cases receiving substantial discussion or criticism in this volume] Air Canada v British Columbia (1989) 35 Amoco Australia Pty Ltd v Rocca Bros Motor Engineering Co Pty (1973) (Aus) 579n, 589 Attorney-General’s Reference No 3 of 1992 309-25 Barclays Bank plc v O’Brien (1993) 119-31 BCCI v Aboody (1992) 127-8 Bolam v Friern Hospital Management Committee (1957) 110 et seq Bowers v Hardwick (1986) (US) 528-9 Brannigan & McBride v UK (1993) (EU) 69 et seq Brogan & Others v UK (1989) (EU) 69 et seq Bull v Pitney-Bowes Ltd (1967) 594 CIBC Mortgages plc v Pitt (1993) 119, 127, 130-1 Claim against the Empire of Iran (1945) (Ger) 297 et seq Clifford Davis Ltd v WEA Records (1975) 583, 587, 590 Cunningham v Harrison (1973) 133 et seq Dadson (1850) 229-51 Daly v General Steam Ship Navigation Co Ltd (1980) 138-9 Davy v Spelthorne Borough Council (1984) 300 Donnelly v Joyce (1974) 133n, 135-6 Enderby v Frenchay Health Authority (1993-4) (EU) 220-2 Esso Petroleum v Harper’s Garage (Stourport) Ltd (1968) 565 et seq Griggs v Duke Power Co (1971) 221 Helby v Mathews (1895) 183 et seq Herbert Morris Ltd v Saxelby (1916) 572n, 578, 580, 588, 592 Hunt v Severs (1993) 133-40 I Congreso del Partido (1983) 297-8, 299 Ireland v UK (1978) (EU) 73 et seq Kingsnorth Finance Co Ltd v Tizard (1986) 122-3 Kuwait Airways Corporation v Iraqi Airways Company and Another (1993-4) 295-307 LAffaire Lamoriciére (1951) (Fr) 342 LArrét Besse (1991) (Fr) 256 LArrét Lamborghini (1979) (Fr) 345 Lipkin Gorman v Karpnale Ltd (1991) 40-2 McEllistrim v Ballymacelligott Co-operative Society (1919) 573, 581, 586 Moore v The Regents of the University of California (1990) (US) 445-9 National and Provincial Bank v Ainsworth (1965) 124-5 National Westminster Bank v Morgan 127-8 New York Dock Co v McCollum (1939) (US) 558 Nordenfelt v Maxim Nordenfelt Guns & Ammunition (1894) 566n, 587-8 Ojutiku v Manpower Services Commission (1982) 218 et seq Petrofina (GB) Ltd v Martin (1966) 567 et seq Planché v Colburn (1831) 47-8 Re Diplock (1948) 34-5 Re Montagu’s Settlement Trusts (1987) 38-9 Rogers v Whitaker (1992) (Aus) 109-118 Schroeder Music Publishing Co v Macauley (1974) 565 et seq Sidaway v Governors of Royal Bethlam Hospital (1985) 110 et seq Strittmatter (1988) (Fr) 355 Thomas Saunders Partnership v Harvey (1990) 555 Vancouver Malt & Sake Brewing Co v Vancouver Breweries Ltd (1934) 575n, 588, 593, 594 Watson v Prager (1991) 567n, 584, 590 Wyatt v Kreglinger (1933) 594