Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 1992: Vol 12 Index

7 Pages·1992·1.8 MB·English

INDEX
Actus reus United Nations Human Rights
intent and 381 et seq Committee’s approach to 288-91
mistake and 301, 308 Caribbean, Commonwealth, capital
Administrative law offence cases, right to legal
natural justice and 517 et seq representation in 284-94
proportionality in English 237-64 approach to in courts,
application in England, including JCPC 286-7
suggested 249 et seq inadequate and unavailable
Bill of Rights affecting, representation 284-6
lack of 259-60 Common law, Solomonic
cases, English, application justice and 480-506
to 249 et seq bipolar and polycentric
conceptual and structural issues 492-6
problems 254-64 logical and conceptual
constitutional law, influence issues 482-6
of 257 et seq situations possibly suitable
institutional framework for 490-2
in France 245-7 winner-take-all aspect 486-90,
French system and, 486-506
an outline of 239-47 arbitration 489-90
interpretation and application authority of law and 505-6
of in France 247 et seq commutative and distributive
Parliament, questioning justice and 498 et seq
supremacy of 257 moral luck, tie-breaking and
theoretical framework distributive justice 500-4
constraints of 256-64 precedent, role of 504-5
‘unreasonableness’ and 254-6 reasons for 496-506
public law and democracy 404-18 statutory tribunals 490
Apportionment of loss see Common law, utility of 497
Solomonic justice and Tort Company law
apportionment of loss flotations in the 1870’s and
Assaults, reckless, after postal rules in contract 184-9
Savage and Parmenter 578-85 secured transactions see Trusts,
alternative verdicts 581 Quistclose secured transactions and
foreseeability and 580, 582 Comparative law
intent and 581-2 English and French administrative
Australia law, proportionality and 238 et seq
causation in see Tort, causation in Constitutional law
Australia administrative law,
influence on 257 et seq
Bentham, J. Bill of Rights and 259-61
moral rights, on 162 et seq Parliament, supremacy of 257
Blackstone political freedom in Britain and
duelling, on 420 et seq the United States 362-79
Braithwaite checks and balances 374-5
sentencing, desert-based citizen’s values and 363-4
on 84 et seq constitutional organization
and 370-5
Capital offences, right to legal constitutional politics and 375-9
representation in 284-94 democracy, elite theory of 364-5
approach to in Commonwealth Dicey, A. V.—views on
Caribbean 286-7 constitutional traditions and
Caribbean, Commonwealth, institutions 365-6
inadequate and unavailable in 294-6 elite tolerance and 364-5, 375-7
European Court of Human Rights flag burning and the First
on legal representation 291-3 Amendment in the US 378-9
591
INDEX
foundations of, theories on 363-7 and circumstances 381-5
Hand, Judge Learned on 364 murder, intent and 390-1
judicial activism and 371-4 objectivism and limits of 45-58
Madisonian prescription for rape, in 50-2, 296 et seq, 381 et seq
constitutional organization subjectivist account, the
and 366-7 traditional 46-8
political culture and 368-70 Williams, Prof G., on 381 et seq
separation of powers 371 sentencing, desert-based see
Sunday Times and Malone Sentencing, ‘proportionalist’ or
cases and, the 377 desert-based
theories on, evaluation of | 367-75 Critical Legal Studies
tolerance levels among contemporary, from criticism
general public 369-70, 376 to construction 507-42
written rights and 371 autonomy of law, problems
public law and democracy 404-18 of 520-31
rebel and, rights to 158 et seq comparison of methods 518-20
Contract law Constitutive Theory of Law,
economic loss and 559 et seq in the US 524-6
negotiate, the contract to 586-9 deconstruction in the US 512-15
postal rules in, a deconstruction deviationist doctrine is US,
of 170-94 strategy for reconstruction,
acceptance cases in 1840s as 53144
and 1870s 172-5 evaluation of the Theories 530-1
Adams v Lindsell 170 et seq immanent critique—the
alternative explanations for European Theory 515-18
decisions 176-84 methods of criticism 512-20
company flotations and the Neo-Evolutionary Theory of
1870’s decisions 184-9 Law in Europe 526-30
decisions and their Pashukanis, E., views of 521 et seq
reasoning 170 et seq prospects for US Theory 539-42
delivery, posting identified reconstructing law, strategy
with 180 et seq for 531-9
electronic data interchange reflexive law, European strategy
(EDI) and 193-4 for reconstruction 535-9
fax technology and 192 et seq society, relationship of law to
postal reforms, 1840’s decisions 520-31
and 178-84 theory of 507-12
revocation cases, the 175-6, 189-92 Teubner, G.,
telephone and, invention and 526 et seq, 535 et seq
of 189 et seq US compared with
Trollope’s The Eustace European 507 et seq
Diamonds, in 181-4, 189 English, prospective histories 195-236
Cork Committee, the 336, 354 fates and futures of 232-6
Criminal law Fraunce, A., and 218-9
assaults, see Assaults, reckless after imaginary laws and 219-32
Savage and Parmenter national characteristics
capital offences see Capital offences and 203 et seq
mistake as a defence see Defence, Wiseman, Sir Robert,
mistake as a and 206 et seq
recklessness, subjective 45—58, 380-81
see also Assaults, reckless after Defence, mistake as a 295-310
Savage and Parmenter alteration, desireability of an 305-9
aggravated 388-91 different effects of a mistake
alternative, intents in the 385-8 until 1976 295-8
driving, reckless, examples of 54 errors, modern 299-309
Duff, A. on 46 et seq, 381 et seq inconsistency of Beckford
intent, culpability and 380-91 with Morgan 300
mental elements as to consequences mens rea, denying 296
INDEX 593
piecemeal approach, a 305 European Court of Human Rights
rape cases in 50-2, 294 et seq legal representation, approach to 291-3
self-defence to murder European Court of Justice see also EEC
and, post 1976 298-9 law
‘unlawfulness’, inclusion of 300-4 direct effect cases and 453 et seq
Dicey, A. V. establishment, freedom of,
administrative law, views on 410-11 on 463 et seq
constitutional traditions and labelling directives, on 475
institutions, views on 365-6 nationality, discrimination
Discrimination on grounds of 469-70
nationality, on grounds of 469-70 sex discrimination,
racial, USA, in 129 et seq on 467 et seq, 476-7
sex, ECC law and 467 et seq, 476-7 Treaty of Rome, interpretation
Duel, the, the English law of homicide of 453 et seq
and see Homicide, duel and the Evidence
English law of, the expert, law, practice and
Duff, A. probability and 392-403
criminal law, mental DNA testing and 395 et seq
element in 46 et seq
Federalization, EEC law and see EEC
Economic loss, liability for see Tort, law, federalization of and direct
economic loss, liability for effect
EEC law France
establishment, freedom administrative law in,
of 463 et seq proportionality and 238 et seq
federalization of and direct Fraunce, A.
effect 453-79 English law, critical
directives 472-8 analysis of 218-19
enforcement function, direct Freedom, political see Constitutional
effect and 458-63 law, political freedom in Britain
enforcement function, and the United States
expansion of 460-3 Frey, R. G.
legislation: enforcement and moral rights, on 151 et seq
monitoring functions 470-8
legislative function and direct Hand, Judge Learned
effect, the 463-70 political freedom, on 364
public enforcement, limits of 454-8 Homicide
regulations 470-1 duel and the English law
Van Gend en Loos, reasoning of, the 419-30
in 458 et seq Blackstone on 420 et seq
labelling directives and 475 duellists as murderers? 427-30
nationality, discrimination murder, chance medley
grounds of 469-70 manslaughter and 419-27
products liability 472-3 intent, murder and 390-1
sex discrimination 467 et seq, 476-7 Housing law see Property law, housing
*1992’, influence of on legal and rent control
scholarship 99-111 Human rights
history 99-103 Commonwealth Caribbean,
law publishing, effect on 103-111 in 284 et seq
Employment law see Labour law European Convention on see
Establishment, freedom of European Convention on Human
EEC law and 463 et seq Rights
Europe see also EEC Law; European European Court of see European
Court of Justice Court of Human Rights
Critical Legal Studies in see Critical legal representation, to 284-94
Legal Studies United Nations Committee on see
European Convention on Human Rights United Nations Committee on
Art 6, fair hearings 291-2 Human Rights
594 INDEX
Insolvency law critique of, a 30-5
Cork Committee, the 336, 354 democracy and 25-35
secured transactions see Trusts, Dock Labour Scheme,
Quistclose, secured transactions and abolition of 36
International Covenant on Civil and elections, trade union, on 27
Political Rights freedom and, concept of 38-9
Art 14 288-9 implications of 39-44
International law industrial action, on 27 et seq
Capital offences, right to laissez-faire and 39 et seq
legal representation in 284-94 legislation, the 26 et seq
approach to in Commonwealth political funds, on 28
Caribbean 286-7 trade union immunities
European Court of Human Rights and 25 et seq
on legal representation 291-3 Wages Councils, restriction
inadequate and unavailable of 38
representation in the Landlord and tenant law see Property
Commonwealth Caribbean 284-6 law, housing and rent control
United Nations Human Rights Legal theory
Committee’s approach criminal law, recklessness and see
to 288-91 Criminal law, recklessness,
international corporations in subjectivism, objectivism and limits
English courts 135—48 of
foreign corporations, Critical Legal Studies see Critical
recognition as 142-4 Legal Studies
implications of recent distributive justice see Common law,
legislation 144-8 Solomonic justice and
non-recognition 141-2 Kelsen, H., General Theory of
recognition 136-41 Norms, review of 265-74
Kelsen, H., pure theory of law see
Kant, I. Kelsen, H., law, pure theory of,
antimonies, jurisprudential, neo-Kantian dimension of
on 314 moral theory, aims and authority of
Kelsen, H. see Moral theory, aims and
General Theory of Norms, authority of
review of 268-70 moral rights, defence of see Moral
Law, Pure Theory of, theory, moral rights, defence of
neo-Kantian dimension of 311-32 public law and democracy see Public
antimony, the law, democracy and
jurisprudential 313-22 Lijphart, A.
criticism of others 315-18 democracy, on 411-12
mistaken interpretation of
scheme 320-22 Madison, J.
morality and separability political freedom, constitutional
theses 318-19 organization and, views on 366-7
reductive and normativity Mens rea
theses 319-20 assault, for 581 et seq
‘Regressive’ or neo-Kantian mistakes which deny 296, 301
argument 322-32 recklessness and intent 38 et seq
transcendentals 323-32 Mistakes in Defence see Defence,
Kennedy, D. mistake as a
Critical Legal Studies Moral theory
and 524 et seq, 533, 539 et seq aims of authority of 1-23
moral rights, in defence of 149-69
Labour law Bentham, J. on 162 et seq
rights, new, Thatcher conventional rights 161 et seq
ideology and 24-44 duties and 154 et seq
Commissioner for the Rights of legal rights and 156 et seq
Trade Union Members 38 model of legal rules and 166 et seq
INDEX 595
rebel, rights to 158 et seq Dicey, A. V. and 410-11
Ryle, G., on 166-7 Lijphart, A., on 411-13
Sumner, L. W., on 163 et seq pluralism and 414-16
terminology 149 et seq positivism, legal and 407-9
necessity of theory and 18 et seq reform and, constitutional 413-14
philosophical and moral methodological considerations 569-71
enquiry into 4 et seq public lawyers’ role, ambit of 564-9
Rawls, J., on 2 et seq substantive considerations 571-5
reflective equilibrium and 2 et seq
utilitarianism and 7 et seq Racial discrimination see
Walzer, M., on 1 et seq Discrimination, racial
Williams, B., on 1 et seq Rape, mistake in see Criminal law,
Morris, N. recklessness, subjectivism,
sentencing, on 89 objectivism and the limits of, rape,
Murder see Homicide mistake in; Defence mistake as a,
rape cases in
Natural justice 517 et seq Rawls, J.
Negligence, moral theory, on 2 et seq
contributory 482, 485-6, 488 Recklessness, subjective see Criminal
Nervous shock, liability for see Tort, law, recklessness subjective
psychiatric illness, liability for after Rent control see Property law, housing
Hillsborough and rent control
Royal Commission on Civil Liability
Pashukanis, E. and Compensation for Personal
law and society, on 521 et seq Injury 76
Pettit Ryle, G.
sentencing, desert-based, on 84 et seq moral theory, on 166-7
Pharmaceutical products in the
UK and USA, liability for 59-82 Sentencing, ‘proportionalist’ or
informed consent and 68-72 desert-based 83-98
learned intermediary rule 66 et seq blameworthiness, ignoring 88-90
critique of 78-81 Braithwaite and Pettit on 84 et seq
exceptions to in the USA 72-6 censure and desert 92-5
vaccines, contraceptives and decremental strategy, the 91-2
English law 76-8 ‘dominion’ and 87
negligence and 67 prediction, reliance on 90-1
strict liability in the USA 64 et seq role of desert, question of 95-8
warnings, provision of 59-66
upper limits, question of 88
Property law
Sex Discrimination see Discrimination,
assured tenancies 543 et seq sex, EEC law and
housing and rent control 543-57 Social legislation, the economic impact
alternative view, an 555-6 of see Property law, housing and
fixed rent mechanisms 551
rent control
framework, the traditional Story, R.
theoretical 544-7 rebel, on right to 158
landlord, nature of 552-3 Sumner, L. W.
modifications to the
moral rights, on 163 et seq
traditional view 547-53
options, other 553-5
quality of housing and 550-1 Teubner, G.
rent control, meaning of 547-50 Neo-Evolutionary Theory
security of tenure 551-2 of Law 526 et seq
USA housing shortages and 553-4 reflexive law, thesis of 535 et seq
notices, postal rules and Title, transfer of 493 et seq
the serving of 191, 192 Tort
Public law see also Administrative law; apportionment of loss 482 et seq
Constitutional law causation in Australia 431-9
democracy and 404-18 ‘but for’ rule 434 et seq
596 INDEX
common sense, application ‘security’, meaning of
of 436 et seq security, reason for
economic loss, liability taking
for 112-28, 558-63 undertakings by payee
Anns, liability under 114-16 textbooks on
common law developments 123-4
consumer protection and 118-28 Unger, R. M.
defective buildings after, Critical Legal Studies
Murphy 112-28 and 513, 519, 531 et seq, 539 et seq
Dutton, liability under 113-14 United Kingdom
failures to establish in administrative law, proportionality in
the past 113-17 compared with French, see
Junior Books, builders’ liability Administrative law, proportionality
and 116-17 in English
necessary developments 128 pharmaceutical products in, liability
pharmaceutical products, liability for for see Pharmaceutical products,
see Pharmaceutical products, liability for
liability for political freedom in see Constitutional
psychiatric illness, liability for law, political freedom in Britain
after Hillsborough 440-52 and the United States
communication of shock, United Nations Commitee on
mode of 446-7 Human Rights 284 et seq
Hillsborough litigation, legal representation,
the 443 et seq approach to 288-91
immediacy, need for 446 United States of America
proximity of relationship 445-6 civil rights, restriction of 129-34
sudden and gradual assaults Atonio case, reasoning in
on nervous system 447-51 and implications of 1314
Trade unions see also Labour law background 129-31
Commissioner for the Rights of Critical Legal Studies in, see Critical
Trade Union Members 38 Legal Studies, contemporary, from
elections 27 criticism to construction
industrial action and 27 et seq housing shortages in 553-4
legislation, on, new 27 et seq pharmaceutical products in
new rights and, Thatcher liability for 59 et seq
ideology on 25 et seq political freedom in see Constitutional
postal ballots and 27, 29 law, political freedom in Britain
Trollope, A. and the United States
postal rules of contract and 170 et seq racial discrimination in 129 et seq
Trusts sentencing in, desert-based 83-98
Quistclose, secured transactions
and 333-61 Walzer, M.
cases prior to 347-50 moral theory, on 1 et seq
charges, registration of 360-1 Williams, B.
conduct, drawing inferences moral theory, on 1 et seq
from 358-60 Williams, Prof G.
facts of 351-2 recklessness and intent,
modern case law 3514 on 381 et seq
priorities 342-5 Wiseman, Sir Robert
security, legal sanctions for 340-2 common law, critique of 207 et seq