OECD URVEY: FINLAND OECD OCDE 1993 ECONOMIC S FINLAND ORGANISATIONFORECONOMICCO-OPERATIONANDDEVELOPMENT ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT PursuanttoArticle 1 oftheConvention signedinParis on 14th December 1960, and which cameintoforceon30th September 1961, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)shallpromotepoliciesdesigned: to achieve the highest sustainable economic growth and employment and a rising standard ofliving in Member countries,whilemaintainingfinancialstability,andthusto contributetothedevelopmentoftheworldeconomy; to contribute to sound economic expansioninMemberas well as non-membercountries intheprocess ofeconomic development;and to contribute to the expansion of world trade on a multilateral, non-discriminatory basis in accordance with internationalobligations. The original Member countries of the OECD are Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, Greece, Iceland, Ireland,Italy,Luxembourg,theNetherlands,Norway,Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, the United Kingdom and the United States. The following countries became Members subsequently through accession at the dates indicated hereafter: Japan (28th April 1964), Finland (28th January 1969), Australia (7th June 1971) and New Zealand (29th May 1973). The Commission ofthe European Communities takes part in the work ofthe OECD (Article 13 ofthe OECDConvention). Publiéégalementenfrançais. ©OECD1993 Applicationsforpermissiontoreproduceortranslate allorpartofthispublicationshouldbemadeto: HeadofPublicationsService,OECD 2,rueAndré-Pascal,75775PARISCEDEX16,France Table of contents Introduction 9 I. Recent economic developments 11 The prolonged recession and its domestic implications 11 The export recovery 20 The short-term outlook 27 II. Economic policies 30 Monetary and exchange rate management 30 Government response to the banking crisis 36 The fiscal stance 40 Progress in structural reform 45 III. Labour market institutions and policies 50 Main features of the Finnish labour market 51 Factors behind the recent surge in unemployment 61 Labour market policies: the scope for change 67 IV. Conclusions 73 Notes and references 78 Annex: Chronology of main economic events and policy measures 81 Statistical annex 87 Tables Text 1. Demand and supply 14 2. Households' disposable income and saving ratio 17 3. Contributions to increases in labour costs in manufacturing 19 4. Consumer price inflation during 1992 20 5. Export performance 23 6. Export prices 27 7. Short-term projections 28 8. Money growth 36 9. Profit and loss account of Finnish deposit banks 37 10. Banks' non-performing loans and credit losses at the end of 1992 37 11. Disbursements of public support to banks 1991-92 39 12. Number of deposit banks, branches and staff 40 13. General government budget 41 14. Initial budget proposal and outcome for the consolidated central government 42 15. Local government finances 43 16. Labour force participation rates 53 17. Evolution of sectoral employment 54 18. Government employment as a percentage of total employment 55 19. Average working hours and part-time employment 55 20. Unemployment rates by age group 56 21. Unemployment rates by industry 57 22. Social policy ingredients of incomes agreements in Finland 59 23. Cyclicality of labour market components 60 24. Recent developments in labour force participation rates by age group 62 25. Active and passive labour market policy measures, 1965-1990 68 Statistical annex Selected background statistics 89 A. Supply and use of resources, current prices 90 B. Supply and use of resources, 1985 prices 91 C. Gross domestic product by industry of origin 92 D. General government account 93 E. Balance of payments 94 F. Labour market 95 G. Imports: prices, volumes and values by commodity group 96 H. Exports: prices, volumes and values by commodity group 97 I. Foreign trade by area 98 J. Prices and wages 99 K. Interest rates, money and credit 100 L. Production structure and performance indicators 101 M. Public sector 103 Diagrams 1. Output growth and unemployment 11 2. Export market growth - 1990-1992 12 3. Production in manufacturing and other sectors 14 4. Output losses by sector, 1990-1992 15 5. Capital stock and output in the business sector 16 6. Investment and capacity utilization in industry 18 7. Consumer prices 21 8. Relative unit labour costs in the manufacturing sector 22 9. Capital income share in the business sector 23 10. Structure of exports 25 11. External balances 26 12. Foreign exchange interventions and official reserves 31 13. Exchange rate and interest rate movements 32 14. Real interest rates 34 15. Indicators of credit behaviour 35 16. Gross public debt 44 17. Unemployment rates in Finland and the OECD area 50 18. The employment situation in Finland since 1970 52 19. Negotiated wages and wage drift in manufacturing 58 20. Cyclical sensitivity of the employed workforce 1977-1992 61 21. Relative wages in manufacturing 63 22. Beveridge curve 23. Migration between municipalities 24. Wage dispersion 25. Long-term unemployment 26. Public spending on labour market programmes in relation to the unemployment rate BASICSTATISTICSOFFINLAND THELAND Area(lOOOsq.km) 338 Populationinmajorcities, ofwhich: 31.1Z1991: CultivatedUnd 27 Helsinki 497542 Forests 187 Ejpoo 175670 Lakes 32 Tampere 173797 Turku 159403 THEPEOPLE Totalpopulation(31.12.1992), Manpowerbyindustryin1991 tboiaandi 5056 (percentoftotal): Peraq.kmoflandarea ISA Agricultureandforestry 12J Pettbouaandinhabitant»(1992): Industryandconstruction 40.6 Lhrebirthi 133 Commerce 20J Deatûi 9.8 Transportandcommunication 10.0 Netnaturalincreate 3.4 Services 16.4 NetIncreateatpopulation 5.4 PARLIAMENTANDGOVERNMENT CompositionofParliament, Government,numberofministers numberofaeata(1991): from: CenterParty 55 CenterParty 8 SocialDemocraticParty 48 NationalCoalition(Conservatives) 6 NationalCoalition(Conservative*) 40 SwedishPeople'sParty 2 Left-Win»Alliance 19 ChristianLeague 1 SwedishPeople'sParty 12 GreenLeague 10 Total 17 ChristianLeague 8 RuralParty 7 LiberalParty 1 Total 200 PRODUCTION GrossDomesticProduct1992 GrossDomesticProductbyIndustry (Mkmillion) 525900 in1991(percentoftotal): GDPperhead,USdollars,1992 25141 Agricultureandforestry 6.7 Grossfixedcapitalformation Industryandconstruction 38.0 1992(Mkmillion) 92078 Commerce 133 Transportandcommunicatioo 10.5 Otherservices 31.4 PUBLICSECTOR Publicconsumption1992, Generalgovernmentrevenueand percentofGDP 24.9 expenditure,1992(Mkmillion) Grossfixedcapitalformation Currentrevenue 209703 1992,percentofGDP: Currentexpenditure 244676 Generalgovernment 3.0 ofwhich: Consumption 122205 Transfers 93020 Subsidies 17191 Interestonpublicdebt 12260 FOREIGNTRADE Exportsofgoodsandservices, Importsofgoodsandservices, percentofGDP,1992 25.9 percentofGDP,1992 24.7 Mainexportsin1991(percentoftotal): MainImportsin1991(percentoftotal): Agriculturalproducts 1.1 Rawmaterials 55.6 Woodproducts 7.5 Fuelsandlubricants 3.6 Pulpandpaper 32.0 Investmentgoods 15.9 Metalandengines 31.4 Consumergoods 24.2 Othergoods 27.9 THECURRENCY Monetaryunit:Markka CurrencyunitsperUSS,averageof dairyfigures: Year1992 4.49 June1993 5.56 Note: Aninternationalcomparisonofcertainbasicstatisticsisgiveninanannextable. This Survey is based on the Secretariat's study preparedforthe annual reviewofFinlandby the Economic andDevelopmentReview Committeeon 17June 1993. m After revisions in the light ofdiscussions during the review, final approval ofthe Surveyforpublication was givenbythe Committeeon 13August1993. The previous Survey ofFinland was issued in August J992. Introduction Real output, which had declined by 6.5 per cent in 1991, fell again by 3.5 per cent in 1992, thus prolonging the worst recession experienced by Finland in post-war history. Domestic demand contracted as falling real incomes and over-capacity in thebusiness sectorreducedprivate consumption and investment. This was partly offset by a strong revival of exports: the substantial increase in Finland's international competitiveness, resulting from the 25 per cent deprecia¬ tion of the markka (against the ecu) since November 1991 and from wage moderation, allowed exporters to regain shares on western markets, thereby compensating for the collapse of sales to the former Soviet Union. As a result, given the weak demand for imports, the trade balance increased markedly, leading to some improvement of the current account position. The sharp fall in activity was reflected in a dramatic surge in the unemployment rate, which reached ahistoricalhigh of 18 percentin early 1993. Duetothegrowing slackin the labour market, inflation pressures have remained low despite the depreciation of the currency. Current indicators suggest that export growth might accelerate, as competi¬ tiveness gains should be preserved by a second year ofno increase in negotiated wages as well as by falling domestic raw material prices in the forestry industry, which is Finland's main source of exports. Consequently, although domestic demand should remain subdued, a gradual economic recovery is expected during 1993-94. But, as the increase in employment in the booming export sector - which is capital intensive - will not be sufficient to compensate for furtherjob losses in the sectors servicing the domestic market, unemployment is likely to remain high for some time. In response to the weakness of activity, monetary conditions were allowed to ease progressively following the floating ofthe markka in 1992, the tightening of fiscal policies and the moderate wage settlements for 1993. This movement