CANADA £> OECD Economic Surveys Electronic Books TheOECD, recognisingthestrategicroleofelectronicpublishing, issuesthe OECDEconomicSurveys, both fortheMembercountries and forcountriesofCentral andEasternEuropecoveredbytheOrganisation's Centre for Co-operation with Economies in Transition, as electronic books - incorporating the text, tables and figures ofthe printed version. The information will appear on screen in an identical format, including the use ofcolour in graphs. The electronic book, which retains the quality and readability of the printed version throughout, will enable readers to take advantage of the new tools that the ACROBAT software (included with the diskette) provides by offering the following benefits: User-friendly and intuitive interface Comprehensive index for rapid text retrieval, including a table of contents, as well as a list ofnumbered tables and figures Rapid browse and search facilities Zoom facility formagnifying graphics or for increasing page size foreasy readability Cut and paste capabilities Printing facility Reduced volume foreasy filing/portability Working environment: DOS, Windows orMacintosh Subscription: FF 1 800 US$317 £200 DM545 Complete 1994/1995 series on CD-ROM: FF2 000 US$365 £220 DM600 Please send your order to OECD Electronic Publications or, preferably, to the Centre orbookshop with whomyouplacedyourinitial orderforthisEconomic Survey. OECD ECONOMIC SURVEYS 1995-1996 CANADA ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT Pursuant to Article 1 of the Convention signed in Paris on 14th December I960, and which came into force on 30th September 1961, the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) shall promote policies designed: - to achieve the highest sustainable economic growth and employment and a rising standard ofliving in Member countries, while maintaining financial stability, and thus to contribute to the development ofthe world economy; - to contribute to sound economic expansion in Member as well as non-member countries in the process of economic development; and - to contribute tothe expansion ofworld trade on a multilateral, non-discriminatory basis in accordance with international obligations. The original Member countries of the OECD are Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, Greece, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, the United Kingdom and the United States. The following countries became Members subse¬ quently through accession at the dates indicated hereafter: Japan (28th April 1964), Finland (28th January 1969), Australia (7th June 1971), New Zealand (29th May 1973), Mexico (18th May 1994), the Czech Republic (21st December 1995), Hungary (7th May 1996) and Poland (1996). The Commission ofthe European Communities takes part in the work of the OECD (Article 13 ofthe OECD Convention). Public également en français. © OECD 1996 Applications for permission to reproduce or translate all or part ofthis publication should be made to: Head of Publications Service, OECD 2, rue André-Pascal, 75775 PARIS CEDEX 16, France. Table of contents Assessment and recommendations 1 I. The current cycle in perspective 9 A moderate economic recovery 9 The short-term outlook 24 A medium-term scenario 28 II. Economic policies 31 The overall strategy 31 Progress in implementation 32 The challenges ahead 52 III. Implementing the OECD Jobs Strategy 57 Labour market and employment performance 59 Policy requirements 69 Recent policy actions 99 Assessment and scope for further action 104 IV. The pension system: problems and options for reform 113 Main features of the system 116 Problems with the system 122 Reforming the system 130 Overall assessment 146 Notes 148 Bibliography 155 Annexes I. Estimates of the structural rate of unemployment 157 II. The impact of minimum wages on youth unemployment 162 III. The Quebec Pension Plan 165 IV. Chronology of economic events 167 Statistical annex and structural indicators 173 Box The OECD Jobs Strategy: synopsis of recommendations for Canada 67 Tables Text 1. Demand and output 13 2. Labour supply and demand 17 3. Wages, profits and prices 21 4. Balance of payments 22 5. Short-term projections 25 6. A medium-term scenario 28 7. Money and credit 38 8. Federal deficit: projections and outcomes 41 9. The 1995 and 1996 Federal Budgets 43 10. Provincial deficits and debt 46 11. Evolution of the Unemployment Insurance system since 1971 78 12. Public expenditure on labour market programmes 89 13. Participants covered by ALMPs 90 14. Evaluation of training measures 92 15. Estimated public pension expenditure and implicit replacement rates 1 14 16. Public pension programmes 117 17. Income replaced by public pension programmes 120 18. Schedule of CPP contribution rates set in 1991 122 19. Projected CPP pay-as-you-go rates in 2030 126 20. The projected levels of the "Seniors Benefit" in 2001 144 Annexes Al. Recent estimates of the structural rate of unemployment in Canada 159 Statistical annex and structural indicators A. Selected background statistics 174 B. Supply and use of resources 175 C. Industrial production, employment and other business indicators 177 D. Prices, wages and finance 178 E. Balance of payments 179 F. Public sector 180 G. Financial markets 181 H. Labour market indicators 182 I. Production structure and performance indicators 183 Figures Text 1. The recovery in perspective 10 2. Determinants of growth 11 3. Business fixed investment 14 4. Household demand 15 5. Inflation indicators 19 6. The current balance and its major components 23 7. Inflation targets 33 8. Monetary conditions 35 9. Interest rate and exchange rate developments 37 10. Decomposition of the general government financial balance 40 11. Direct budget savings 43 12. Government debt 48 13. Key developments in the labour market 58 14. Labour force participation rates 61 15. Youth participation and enrolment rates 62 16. The composition of the labour force 63 17. Long-term unemployment and inflows 64 18. Regional unemployment rates 65 19. Incidence of low pay and earnings inequality 70 20. The minimum wage 71 21. Net transfers under UI 76 22. Index of unemployment insurance disincentives 77 23. Unemployment and social assistance caseloads 81 24. Social assistance caseloads in Ontario 82 25. Social assistance benefit rates and minimum wages 83 26. Disability beneficiaries 85 27. Components of payroll taxes 86 28. Payroll taxes in major OECD countries 88 29. Public expenditure on active labour market measures 89 30. Educational attainment in OECD countries 94 31. Unemployment rate by level of education attained 95 32. Distribution of population by literacy level 95 33. Projected expenditures on public pensions 115 34. Elderly dependency ratios 124 35. Scenarios for alternative contribution rates to the Canada and Quebec Pension Plans 134 36. Scenarios for reducing expenditure of the Canada and Quebec Pension Plans 139 Annexes Al. Unemployment rates in Quebec and Ontario 163 A2. Relative youth unemployment rates and the minimum wage 163 BASIC STATISTICS OF CANADA THELAND Area(thousandsq. km) 9976 Populationofmajorcities,including Agriculturalarea(1990.aspercent metropolitanareas(thousands): oftotal area) 6.4 Montréal 3 127 Toronto 3 893 THE PEOPLE Population(1995) 29571 305 Civilian labourforce(1995) 14927600 Numberofinhabitantspersq. km 3.0 Employmentagriculture(1995) 430700 Population,annualnetnaturalincrease Immigration(annual average 1991-1995) 233233 (average 1991-1995) 187 100 Averageannualincreaseincivilian labour Natural increaserale per 1 000inhabitants force(1991-1995,percent) 0.8 (average 1991-1995) 6.6 PRODUCTION GDPin 1995 (millionsofCanadiandollars) 776299 Originofgrossdomesticproduct GDPperhead(Canadiandollars) 26300 (1995,percentoftotal, 1986prices): Grossfixed investment(privateandpublic) Agricultural, forestryand fishing 2.8 perhead(Canadiandollars) 4543 Miningandquarrying 4.4 Grossfixedinvestment(privateandpublic) Manufacturing 18.9 aspercentofGDP 17.3 Construction 5.0 Non businesssector 16.9 Other 54.8 THEGOVERNMENT Governmentcurrentexpenditureongoods Numberofseats andservices(1995. aspercentofGDP) 19.4 CompositionofParliament Houseof <. Governmentgross fixedcapital formation (June 1996): Commons Senate (1995,aspercentofGDP) 2.3 Federal Governmentcurrentrevenue ProgressiveConservative 2 50 (1995,aspercentofGDP) 19.1 Liberal 176 50 Federaldirect andguaranteeddebt NewDemocratic 9 (1995, percentofcurrentexpenditure) 58.6 Blocquébécois 53 Independent 2 3 Reform 51 IndependentLiberal 2 FOREIGN TRADE Exports(1995) Imports(1995) Exportsofgoodsandservices,aspercent Importsofgoodsandservices,aspercent ofGDP 37.4 ofGDP 34.9 Mainexports(percenl ofcommodily Mainimports(percentofcommodily exports): imports): Wheat 1.7 Industrial materials 19.1 Naturalgas 2.2 Motorvehiclesandparts 22.4 Lumberandsawmill products 5.4 Producers' equipment 33.5 Pulpandpaper 8.7 Consumergoods 11.3 Othermetalsandminerals 10.0 Mainsuppliers(percentofcommodily Molorvehiclesandparts 24.3 imports): Othermanufacturedgoods 27.9 UnitedStales 75.0 Maincustomers(percentofcommodity EEC 8.9 exports): Japan 3.7 UnitedStates 79.6 EEC 6.3 Japan 4.5 THE CURRENCY Monetaryunit: Canadiandollar CurrencyunitperUSdollar,average ofdailyfigures: Year 1995 1.372 Note: Aninternationalcomparisonofcertainbasicstatisticsisgiven inanannextable. This Survey is based on the Secretariat's study prepared for the annual review of Canada by the Economic and Development Review Committee on 9 September 1996. m Afterrevisions in the lightofdiscussionsduring the review,final approval ofthe Surveyforpublication was given by the Committee on 25 September 1996. The previous Survey of Canada was issued in November 1995.