A READER’S DIGEST BOOK Copyright © 2012 The Reader’s Digest Association, Inc. All rights reserved. Unauthorized reproduction, in any manner, is prohibited. Reader’s Digest is a registered trademark of The Reader’s Digest Association, Inc. FOR READER’S DIGEST U.S. Project Editor: Katherine Furman Project Designer: Jennifer Tokarski Managing Editor: Lorraine Burton Senior Art Director and Cover Designer: George McKeon Associate Publisher, Trade Publishing: Rosanne McManus President and Publisher, Trade Publishing: Harold Clarke Executive Editor, Reader’s Digest North America: Courtenay Smith Creative Director, Reader’s Digest North America: Robert Newman Editor-in-Chief and Chief Content Officer, Reader’s Digest North America: Liz Vaccariello President, Reader’s Digest North America: Dan Lagani President and Chief Executive Officer, Reader’s Digest Association, Inc.: Robert E. Guth Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Simmons, Andy. Now that’s funny : hilarious stories from the man in charge of making America laugh / Andy Simmons. p. cm. ISBN: 978-1-60652-504-3 1. American wit and humor. I. Title. PN6165.S56 2012 818’.602—dc23 2012008802 We are committed to both the quality of our products and the service we provide to our customers. We value your comments, so please feel free to contact us. The Reader’s Digest Association, Inc. Adult Trade Publishing 44 South Broadway White Plains, NY 10601 For more Reader’s Digest products and information, visit our website: www.rd.com (in the United States) www.readersdigest.ca (in Canada) This book is dedicated to my beautiful and devoted wife, Linda, who…wait, that’s not her name. What’s her name? I said it just this morning, “Hey, HER NAME, you ate the last Entenmann’s crumb donut again!” It’s a name with a “G” sound. Geronimo? No. Gulie? Wait, it’s right here on page 59…Salsa? No, that’s not it. There’s someone named Jennifer here…That’s it! To my wife…wait, where’s that page again…Jennifer! To my wife, Jennifer (JenniferJenniferJenniferJennifer, okay, got it). Who has good-naturedly allowed herself to be used as my unwitting dupe in so many articles over the years. That, or she never complains because she doesn’t bother to read anything I write. In any case, she is beautiful and devoted and even laughs at most of my jokes. Okay, some. Okay, smiles appreciatively. All right, nods in recognition that my mouth is moving before she turns back to watch Ghost Hunters. Oh, what the hell, I love her. Now I’m blushing. Contents The Most Important Thing About This Book Part One: America the Funny My Life as an Award-Winning Jokes Editor America’s Ten Funniest Jokes Be the Funniest Person in the Room America’s Funniest Family Stories Stand Up? Sit Down! Part Two: All in the Family Welcome to My Life Macho, Macho Man The “F” Word Ode to My Puppy #1 Lord of the Dance Brush Up on Your Shakespeare Yankee Doodle Andy Ode to My Puppy #2 Making Up Is Hard to Do “In Five Hundred Feet, You Will Be Lost” “Plutonic” Friends How to Ruin a Joke Itching for a Fight Buff Your Shoes with a Banana How Sweet It Is The Dow of Pooh Part Three: America the Odd America, the Beautiful…and Odd…and Hysterical…and… My American Journey (Part 1) Lessons I Learned from Dumb Criminals—All Too True Edition Liar, Liar Calling Dr. Frankenstein! Don’t Call Us, We’ll Call You So Sue Me! The Guide to the American Man-Hug Lame Excuses My American Journey (Part 2) Part Four: I Work with Other Funny People Let Me Get My Red Pencil The Petrified Woman! Humorist Jimmy Tingle Proposes an Alternative to the Alternative to the Alternative Energy Plan The Mad Men of Pranks Inc.! What Does a Movie Producer Do? Make It Stop!! Part Five: I Suck Up to Famous People A Q&A with the King of Ha-Has, Andy Simmons Tragedy Tomorrow, Comedy Tonight: A Chat with Woody Allen The Funniest Person I Know: Carl Reiner on Mel Brooks Robin Williams Grows Up (Just a Little) A Comic’s World The Funniest Person I Know: An Older Garry Shandling on a Younger Garry Shandling Stop Clowning Around: Alan Alda Says the Joke’s on You Oy, It’s the Holidays! Mirth Mother: My Interview with Comedian Anita Renfroe The Funniest Person I Know: The Office Writer/Actor B. J. Novak on Ricky Gervais, et al. Acknowledgments The Most Important Thing About This Book I wrote my first book when I was six years old. The title was Me, and it was a no-holds-barred look at its young subject (turns out he was a perfect angel!). It was one page, the perfect length—long enough for the reader to enjoy the then state-of-the-art crayon typeface, short enough for them not to get bored. I mention this because when the book editors at Reader’s Digest asked me to write a book covering my years as the magazine’s humor editor here, I was already a seasoned author and confident that I could produce a quality one-page tome. After all, my first book sold out its entire print run of one copy, and I was more than confident that my father would once again rise to the occasion and buy another. “This needs to be a little longer than one page,” they said. “Are you sure?” I asked. “One page is a perfect length—long enough for the reader to…” “We’ll need a few more pages because we want you to walk us through what it’s like to be the humor editor of America’s largest magazine. Tell the world how you choose the jokes and reader-submitted anecdotes that are among the most popular destinations in the magazine. Include essays you’ve written, as well as the interviews you’ve conducted with famous comedians. Who were the authors you most enjoyed working with? Who do…?” “Yeah, great. But let’s first talk about my author photo?” “Excuse me?” “The photo on the book jacket. We are going to have one, aren’t we?” “We haven’t really thought that far…” “Well, I think we should discuss it.” “But we haven’t even discussed what articles you might include in the book. Maybe…” “I think if we have the author’s photo the rest will fall into place. Now, what should I wear?” “We see this as a multifaceted work, part memoir and part collection of articles you’ve written and edited…” “Know what would be nice? A black and white photo. Very dramatic. Besides, I have a lot of black and white clothes. I don’t look good in pastels.” “You’ve been here nine years, right? We want to hear all about your favorite jokes…” “Although one year for Halloween I went dressed as an L.L. Bean catalog and won first prize.” “We also want you to discuss how the humor departments came to be, you know, ‘Life in These United States,’ ‘All in a Day’s Work,’ ‘Humor in Uniform,’ and…” “Should I wear a hat? Hats are in.” “…what you look for when a reader contributes a gag about his or her life…” “Would you be able to see my socks? I have a collection of very cool socks. They’re hand-me-downs from my father. They all have holes in them, but don’t worry, they’re in the heels, so they’ll be covered by the shoes.” “You wear hand-me-down socks?” “My father has excellent taste in socks.” “We also want to hear about the many celebrities you edited or interviewed…” “Where’s the photo going to be? The back cover or inside the dust jacket? Will we have a dust jacket? Do books really get dusty? And if so, can’t you just wipe the dust off on your pants?” “…like Woody Allen, Fran Lebowitz, Jerry Lewis…” “How much are we going to charge for this book?” “What does that have to…” “If we charge a lot then we can afford a really good photographer. And makeup artist. Shouldn’t I be over zits at my age?” “…” “Should I smile or should I be serious?” “…” “How about when I pose I set my chin on the backs of my hands, you know, pompous-ass style.” “…” “…” “…” “Basically, I’m looking for a photo that will leave people thinking, Now that guy can write! Because, truth be told, I’m not sure the words in the book will do the trick.” “How about this, why don’t you pull together your favorite humor articles from the past nine years, including interviews, essays you’ve written, and jokes