Table Of Content

AUTHOR INDEX FEDERAL COURTS, PRACTICE & PROCEDURE Marder, Nancy S., Bringing Jury Instructions into the Twenty-First Century ... 449 lidmarsh, Jay, Pound's Gentry, and Oars... o.0.0.6:56 6:60 esiewinc seis veewee's - 513 Wheatman, Shannon R. & Willging, Thomas E., Attorney Choice of Forum in Class Action Litigation: What Difference Does It Make? .............. 591 Willging, Thomas E. & Wheatman, Shannon R., Attorney Choice of Forum in Class Action Litigation: What Difference Does It Make? .............. 591 THE (RE)TURN TO HISTORY IN RELIGION CLAUSE L AW & SCHOLARSHIP Green, Steven K., “Bad History”: The Lure of History in Establishment Clause IND 6 asne vica ce bing ey pu ne van bak ks AR RUN LAA bina ter Hamilton, Marci A. & Steamer, Rachel, The Religious Origin‘so f ee tee ee ee Laycock, Douglas, Regulatory Exemptions of Religious Behavior and the Original Understanding of the Establishment Clause................. 1793 Smith, Steven D., The Jurisdictional Establishment Clause: A Reappraisal ..... 1843 Steamer, Rachel & Hamilton, Marci A., The Religious Origins of eee ee rome ee ee 1755 NL TOe 1, II 6 ooo ove dare viainmk 4a bia ee alemieone Sioa lea 1697 ARTICLES & ESSAYS Chen, Jim, The Parable of the Seeds: Interpreting the Plant Variety Protection Act in Furtherance of Innovation POnHCY «. .....6..csccccccccKeseecesives 105 Clark, Bradford R., Constitutional Structure, Judicial Discretion, and the Le EE ECCT 1149 Cook, Julian A., III, Crumbs From the Master’s Table: The Supreme Court, Pro Se Defendants and the Federal Guilty Plea Process .............. 1895 Cunningham, Lawrence A., The Common Law as an Iterative Process: A aN MUNIN oss Gt Sinn. vicinus vetnnan ien inRteser re etala nlei eheimyai eis1 975s Eisen, Joanne D., Kopel, David B. & Gallant, Paul, Is Resisting Genocide a Engler, Mitchell L. & Sterk, Stewart E., Property Tax Reassessment: Who Needs BOE sire Nias band Rilo pd wre Wadd RASS wicele ea KE Raha De pe Rew ote ola tie ga ae Oaee aren 1037 Fee, John, Eminent Domain and the Sanctity of Home .................5-. 783 Ferguson, Katharine, Lawson, Gary € Montero, Guillermo A., “Oh Lord, Please Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood!”: Rediscovering the Mathews v Eidvides ana Fount Contial Prameworas ...« ...6 .5 6: 600 086 sseccesscvecewess 2147 . 81:5 Gallant, Paul, Kopel, David B. ©& Eisen, Joanne D., Is Resisting Genocide a 1275 Gatter, Robert, The Mysterious Survival of the Policy Against Informed Consent Liability for Hospitals 1203 Cabson, James, Once anid Puawe COpgrignt «.<.... ccc con seencceecsnwesnenden 167 Henning, Kristin, Loyalty, Paternalism, and Rights: Client Counseling Theory and the Role of Child’s Counsel in Delinquency Cases Kopel, David B., Gallant, Paul & Eisen, Joanne D., Is Resisting Genocide a OEE OO COT OE Ee, Pere Tee ee Phe Continuity Principle, Administrative Constraint, and the Kwall, Roberta Rosenthal, Inspiration and Innovation: The Intrinsic Dimension Lawson, Gary, Ferguson, Katharine Montero, Guillermo A., “Oh Lord, Please Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood!”: Rediscovering the Mathews v enn Central Frameworks Magliocca, Gerard N., Constitutional False Positives and the Populist Moment 821 McDonald, Barry P., Speech and Distrust: Rethinking the Content Approach lo Protecting the Freedom of Expression 1347 Viontero, Guillermo , Lawson, Gary, & Ferguson, Katharine, “Oh Lord, Please Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood!”: Rediscovering the Mathews v. Eldridge and Penn Central Frameworks .............000000eeeeee Murphy, Jane C., Legal Images of Fatherhood: Welfare Reform, Child Support Enforcement, and Fatherless Children ...........ccccsccsecccccesees 325 Parker, Wendy, Lessons in Losing: Race Discrimination in Employment S889 Ribstein, Larry E., Accountability and Responsibility in Corporate 1431 Sadat, Leila Nadya, Exile, Amnesty and International Law 4 955 Segal, Uzi ©& Stein, Alex, Ambiguity Aversion and the Criminal Process 1495 Alex ©& Segal, Uzi, Ambiguity Aversion and the Criminal Process 1495 Sterk, Stewart E. © Engler, Mitchell L., Property Tax Reassessment: Who Needs 1037 1., Smoked Out: Bars, Restaurants, and Restrictive Antismoking Laws as Regulatory Takings.............. 1095 Durham, Dory Mitros, The Once and Future Judge: The Rise and Fall (and Rise?) of Independence in U.S. Immigration Courts 655 Enright, Anthony ]., The Originalist’s Dilemma: Katz and the New Approach to the State Sovereign Immunity Defense ..... 2... 0c sce cccccceccccss 1553 Foster, Brian E., Serious Mischiefs: Exxon Mobil Corp. v Allapattah Services, Inc., Supplemental Jurisdiction, and Breaking the Promise of Finley 2013 Glessner, Michele M., One Size Does Not Fit All: Keeping the “Totality of the Circumstances” Test for Public Use Cases After Pfaffand SmithKline... 387 Hill, Alison, Banishment: Stopping Stalkers at the County Line 1123 Judge, Stephen M., Codex Imaginarius: Visual Codes in Land Use Planning and Aesthetic Regulation 1595 Killen, Matthew M., Intolerable Cruelties: Retaliatory Actions in First Amendment Public Employment Cases 1629 2006 | INDEX 2149 Lawson, Jonathan S., Eight Million Performances Later, Still Not a Dime: Why It Is Time To Comprehensively Protect Sound Recording Public IE a a 5:r0.4 61070. 9:0 0h nie awle ewre es wanes heehee Sith dsS ee ara 693 Mallen, Travis H., Rediscovering the Nondelegation Doctrine Through a Unified Separation of Powers Theory . ... «00066 ssecscseci $19 Vathues, G. David, Shadow of a Bulldozer?: RLUIPA and Eminent Domain 1653 and Government Speech After Johanns v. Livestock Marketing IR ten Ut aoa aces argersCanieatn Rp) Serre engt eeo ya re ee 2059 Simone, Patricia E., A Presumptive Constitutional Time Limit for Administrative Overdetention of Inmates Entitled to Release ....... 719 Stuckey, Tara M., Jurisdictional Hooks in the Wake of Raich: On Properly Interpreting Federal Regulations of Interstate Commerce ............ 2101 2150 NOTRE DAME LAW REVIEW [VOL. 81:59 SUBJECT INDEX ARTS & LITERATURE Kwall, Roberta Rosenthal, Inspiration and Innovation: The Intrinsic Dimension eee SEIS BN og cart c cnwadecksthsaesusecuncnsabunelsaeawenewan 1945 Lawson, Jonathan S., Eight Million Performances Later, Stiil Not a Dime: Why It Is Time To Comprehensively Protect Sound Recording Public NN Foi cna sng 'r6 :p ec cecSllin ce in oe herb maa a top APN ie 693 BANKRUPTCY LAW Enright, Anthony J., The Originalist’s Dilemma: Katz and the New Approach to the State Sovereign Immunity Defense .....................00000: 1553 CIVIL RIGHTS & DISCRIMINATION Killen, Matthew M., Intolerable Cruelties: Retaliatory Actions in First Amendment Public Employment Cases ..................eeeeeeees . 1629 Parker, Wendy, Lessons in Losing: Race Discrimination in Employment ...... 889 COMPARATIVE LAW Kwall, Roberta Rosenthal, Inspiration and Innovation: The Intrinsic Dimension ae ra NI 55 sc scar G:erhilayih Wine veo sa reese nce rerio dias nk we 1945 COMPUTER LAW Gibson, James, Once and Future Copyright ......0..... e.e ce.ce. ee.e e.e e ee 167 CONSTITUTIONAL LAW Clark, Bradford R., Constitutional Structure, Judicial Discretion, and the I 3s dg each ale de wi Ne Ghar ARR Rae DAN ast 1149 Cook, Julian A., HI, Crumbs From the Master’s i= le: The Supreme Court, Pro Se Defendants and the Federal Guilty Plea Process .............. 1895 Danella, Nicholas A., Smoked Out: Bars, Restaurants, and Restrictive Antismoking Laws as Regulatory Takings.................0eeeeeeeees 1095 Enrighi, Anthony J., The Originalist’s Dilemma: Katz and the New Approach to the State Sovereign Immunity Defense ................ ale nearer 155% Fee, John, Eminent Domain and the Sanctity of the Home.................. 783 Ferguson, Katharine, Lawson, Gary © Montero, Guillermo A., “Oh Lord, Please Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood!”: Rediscovering the Mathews v. Eldridge and Penn Central Frameworks ...............ccceccsccscscecs l Foster, Brian E., Serious Mischiefs: Exxon Mobil Corp. v. Allapattah Services, Inc., Supplemental Jurisdiction, and Breaking the Promise of Finley. . poate 2013 2006] INDEX Green, Steven K., “Bad History”: The Lure of History in Establishment Clause Adjudication Hamilton, Marci A. & Steamer, Rachel, The Religious Origins of Oe ee ee ee Killen, Matthew M., Intolerable Cruelties: Retaliatory Actions in First Amendment Public Employment Cases 1629 Krent, HaroldJ .,T he Continuity Principle, Administrative Constraint, and the Fourth Amendment 53 Lawson, Gary, Ferguson, Katharine & Montero, Guillermo A., “Oh Lord, Please Don't Let Me Be Misunderstood!”: Rediscovering the Mathews v. Eldridge and Penn Central Frameworks .. .....5..0.cccscccccceccceccees Laycock, Douglas, Regulatory Exemptions of Religious Behavior and the Original Understanding of the Establishment Clause 1793 Magliocca, Gerard N., Constitutional False Positives and the Populist Moment 821 Mallen, Travis H., Rediscovering the Nondelegation Doctrine Through a United Separation of Powers TROY... <<:06.0<6 601090 6 9.0scievisedwe's 119 Mathues, G. David, Shadow of a Bulldozer?: RLUIPA and Eminent Domain After Kelo 1653 McDonald, Barry P., Speech and Distrust: Rethinking the Content Approach To Protecting the Freedom of Expression 1347 Montero, Guillermo A., Lawson, Gary & Ferguson, Katharine, “Oh Lord, Please Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood!”: Rediscovering the, Mathews v. Eldridge and Ponts: Contral Fram wowis .:.0.. 0-2 sins 00sec 0c ee ee vvsiewe sis Morrissey, Brian P., Jr., Speech and Taxes: Balancing Freedom of Conscience and Government Speech After Johanns v. Livestock Marketing PI 500.5 oho a ee SE aon 8a ie a ee alee leahena 2059 Segal, Uzi & Stein, Alex, Ambiguity Aversion and the Criminal Process 1495 Simone, Patricia E., A Presumptive Constitutional Time Limit for Administrative Overdetention of Inmates Entitled to Release ......... 719 Smith, Steven D., The Jurisdictional Establishment Clause: A Reappraisal 1843 Steamer, Rachel & Hamilton, Marci A., The Religious Origins of Disestablishment Principles ..... Pe ee ee ep ee ee Te 1755 Stein, Alex & Segal, Uzi, Ambiguity Aversion and the Criminal Process 1495 ee eea en eae 1697 Stuckey, Tara M., Jurisdictional Hooks in the Wake of Raich: On Properly Interpreting Federal Regulations of Interstate Commerce 2101 CORPORATE LAW Ribstein, Larry E., Accountability and Responsibility in Corporate Governance 143] CRIMINAL LAW & PROCEDURE Clark, Bradford R., Constitutional Structure, Judicial Discretion, and the Eighth Amendment 1149 Cook, Julian A., II, Crumbs From the Master’s Table: The Supreme Court, Pro Se Defendants and the Federal Guilty Plea Process 1895 Hill, Alison, Banishment: Stopping Stalkers at the County Line 1123 Krent, Harold ? ]., The Continuity PrincipIl e, Administrative Constraint, and the Fourth Amendment 2152 NOTRE DAME LAW REVIEW [VoOL. 81:5 Segal, Uzi ©& Stein, Alex, Ambiguity Aversion and the Criminal Process....... 1495 Stein, Alex & Segal, Uzi, Ambiguity Aversion and the Criminal Process....... 1495 DISPUTE RESOLUTION Cunningham, Lawrence A., The Commor Law as an Iterative Process: A I cob nceetarenek gees Sh Soe ho senders nce was alealeg 747 DOMESTIC RELATIONS Murphy, Jane C., Legal Images of Fatherhood: Welfare Reform, Child Support Enforcement, and Fatherless Children .... 2.0... ccccccccccecccccecs 325 ESTABLISHMENT CLAUSE Green, Steven K., “Bad History”: The Lure of History in Establishment Clause I icin whi, AG cc ec eae Rae Ae RE SO ee alae eas 1717 Hamilton, Marci A. & Steamer, Rachel, The Religious Origins of | ee er eer ee er ere eee 1755 Laycock, Douglas, Regulatory Exemptions of Religious Behavior and the Original Understanding of the Establishment Clause................. 1793 Smith, Steven D., The Jurisdictional Establishment Clause: A Reappraisal..... 1843 Steamer, Rachel & Hamilton, Marci A., The Religious Origins of Disestablishment Principles ....... Mnate aa iara ate a aula ohn oa waiie’ 1755 See eh OUD a sleccuhitnedseeegien eecvesiuareneeaeens Oe RaweN 1697 FREEDOM OF SPEECH Killen, Matthew M., Intolerable Cruelties: Retaliatory Actions in First fmmenament Fubsc Emeployiient Cases 2.0.6 vccciveevsicsssescass 1629 McDonald, Barry P., Speech and Distrust: Rethinking the Content Approach lo Protecting the Freedom of Expression................... awe. “ae Morrissey, Brian P., Jr., Speech and Taxes: Balancing Free rene of Conscience and Government Speech After Johanns v. Livestock Marketing NOI a ness. a: ocig a TRAD Rte Pec Sanitt ie Gil ariat a args RINE eee Ries Orme Mle 2059 HEALTH LAW & POLICY Gatter, Robert, The Mysterious Survival of the Policy Against Informed RAWURCUE EAE WOT SRUMNNIIE oo 65.0.9 ois. eieis ve daliDimwmncanwedionvewen 1203 HUMAN RIGHTS LAW Eisen, Joanne D., Kopel, David B. & Gallant, Paul, Is Resisting Genocide a I ks 6.r ok on cig hurcie hue ald» Cade Sura teaia ela hha oe wun ne 1275 Gallant, Paul, Kopel, David B. & Eisen, Joanne D., 1s Resisting Genocide a I nk ch Cds ce ie dee eign Win cE OS ees bw ee R eM alenes 1275 Kopel, David B., Gallant, Paul ©& Eisen, Joanne D., 1s Resisting Genocide cies Secta nes cecal saclay Sed ad6 ike eis ergs nL AT Re wa ea 1275 2006] INDEX INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY LAW Chen, Jim, The Parable of the Seeds: Interpreting the Plant Variety Protection Act in Furtherance of Innovation Policy 105 Gibson, James, Once and Future Copyright 167 Glessner, Michele M., One Size Does Not Fit All: Keeping the “Totality of the Circumstances” Test for Public Use Cases After Pfaffand SmithKline... Kwall, Roberta Rosenthal, Inspiration and Innovation: The Intrinsic Dimension of the Artistic Soul Lawson, Jonathan S., Eight Million Performances Later, Still Not a Dime: Why It Is Time To Comprehensively Protect Sound Recording Public Performances 693 INTERNATIONAL LAW Eisen, Joanne D., Kopel, David B. & Gallant, Paul, Is Resisting Genocide a Sadat, Leila Nadya, Exile, Amnesty and International Law INTERNATIONAL TRADE Mallen, Travis H., Rediscovering the Nondelegation Doctrine Through a Unified Separation of Powers Theory IMMIGRATION LAW Durham, Dory Mitros, The Once and Future Judge: The Rise and Fall (and Rise?) of Independence in U.S. Immigration Courts . 09D JUDGES Clark, Bradford R., Constitutional Structure, Judicial Discretion, and the PY FUEUEINUR 6 5 ce ws es ates enum see eet ee Gone ewe eee m ews 1149 Durham, Dory Mitros, The Once and Future Judge: The Rise and Fall (and b9D JURISPRUDENCE Cunningham, Lawrence A., The Common Law as an Iterative Process: \ Preliminary Inquiry 747 JUVENILES Henning, Kristin, Loyalty, Paternalism, and Rights: Client Counseling Theory and the Role of Child’s Counsel in Delinquency Cases 2154 NOTRE DAME LAW REVIEW [VOL. LABOR & EMPLOYMENT LAW Killen, Matthew M., Intolerable Cruelties: Retaliatory Actions in First Amendment Public Employment Cases 1629 Parker, Wendy, Lessons in Losing: Race Discrimination in Employment 889 LAND USE PLANNING Judge, Stephen M., Codex Imaginarius: Visual Codes in Land Use Planning and Aesthetic Regulation LEGAL HISTORY Green, Steven K., “Bad History”: The Lure of History in Establishment Clause ER PE ee ee ee re Ee tt Pe ee ee eee ee Hamilion, Marci A. & Steamer, Rachel, The Religious Origins of Disestablishment Principles Laycock, Douglas, Regulatory Exemptions of Religious Behavior and the Original Understanding of the Establishment Clause................. 1793 Magliocca, Gerard N., Constitutional False Positives and the Populist Moment 821 Smith, Steven D., The Jurisdictional Establishment Clause: A Reappraisal ..... 1843 Steamer, Rachel © Hamilton, Marci A., The Religious Origins of Disestablishment Principles ..... 1755 Strang, Lee ]., Introduction .... 1697 LAW ENFORCEMENT & CORRECTION Hill, Alison, Banishment: Stopping Stalkers at the County Line ............. 1123 Simone, Patricia E., A Presumptive Constitutional Time Limit for \dministrative Overdetention of Inmates Entitled to Release 719 LEGAL ANALYSIS & WRITING Tidmarsh, Jay, Pound’s Century, and Ours .... LEGAL PROFESSION Henning, Kristin, Loyalty, Paternalism, and Rights: Client Counseling Theory and the Role of Child’s Counsel in Delinquency Cases no_ ur LEGISLATION Chen, Jim, The Parable of the Seeds: Interpreting the Plant Variety Protection Act in Furtherance of Innovation Policy kee, John, Eminent Domain and the Sanctity of the Home.................. Foster, Brian E., Serious Mischiefs: Exxon Mobil Corp. v. Allapattah Services, Inc., Supplemental Jurisdiction, and Breaking the Promise of Finley...... Mathues, G. David, Shadow of a Bulldozer?: RLUIPA and Eminent Domain After Kelo... 2006] INDEX ho ur | MEDICAL JURISPRUDENCE Gatter, Robert, The Mysterious Survival of the Policy Against Informed Consent Liability for Hospitals 1203 POLITICS Magliocca, Gerard N., Constitutional False Positives and the Populist Moment 82] PRACTICE & PROCEDURE Foster, Brian E., Serious Mischiefs: Exxon Mobil Comp. v. Allapattah Services, Inc., Supplemental Jurisdiction, and Breaking the Promise of Finley........ 2013 Marder, Nancy S., Bringing Jury Instructions into the Twenty-First Century ... 449 A ee eee 513 Wheatman, Shannon R. ©& Willging, Thomas E., Attorney Choice of Forum in Class Action Litigation: What Difference Does It Make? .............. 591 Willging, Thomas E. © Wheatman, Shannon R., Attorney Choice of Forum in Class Action Litigation: What Difference Does It Make? .............. 591 PROPERTY—PERSONAL AND REALTY Danella, Nicholas A., Smoked Out: Bars, Restaurants, and Restrictive Antismoking Laws as Regulatory Takings....................04- Ve 1095 Engler, Mitchell L. © Sterk, Stewart E., Property Tax Reassessment: Who Needs DOO acpRicRane enasenc srege 1037 Fee, John, Eminent Domain and the Sanctity of the Home 783 Ferguson, Katharine, Lawson, Gary & Montero, Guillermo A., “Oh Lord, Please Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood!”: Rediscovering the Mathews v. Miavags ome Penn Contral Pramewores. ...s...0 60sec cecscccseccasseces Judge, Stephen M., Codex Imaginarius: Visual Codes in Land Use Planning and Aesthetic Regulation 1595 Lawson, Gary, Ferguson, Katharine & Montero, Guillermo A., “Oh Lord, Please Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood!”: Rediscovering the Mathews v. Eidvedep ani Perm: ConWall PLAC Wore o.oo. 5 5.06 08 6.csine 5 0'9:9-0' 9 510 80:4 00:9 Mathues, G. David, Shadow of a Bulldozer?: RLUIPA and Eminent Domain After Kelo 1653 Montero, Guillermo A., Lawson, Gary & Ferguson, Katharine, “Oh Lord, Please Don’t Let Me Be Misunderstood!”: Rediscovering the Mathews v. Eldridge and Poan Contval Framewores . ... 2... 000scccensetscrsavexes Sterk, Stewart E. & Engler, Mitchell L., Property Tax Reassessment: Who Needs OU situs a ech cera oT OSO RR PLT RN IOS IUeRiaD lad) Sook: RCRSN ola ten re inl ead ente ear 1037 SCIENCE & TECHNOLOGY Chen, Jim, The Parable of the Seeds: Interpreting the Plant Variety Protection Act in Furtherance of Innovation Policy Gibson, James, Once and Future Copyright NOTRE DAME LAW REVIEW SOCIAL WELFARE Murphy, Jane C., Legal Images of Fatherhood: Welfare Reform, Child Support STATUTORY INTERPRETATION Chen, Jim, The Parable of the Seeds: Interpreting the Plant Variety Protection Act in Furtherance of Innovation Policy TAXATION—STATE & LOCAL Engler, Mitchell L. & Sterk, Stewart E., Property Tax Reassessment: Who Needs ge AE EE Le Be eT ey ee ey Oe ey ee OR ENE ee Sterk, Stewart E. © Engler, Mitchell L., Property Tax Reassessment: Who Needs TORTS Gatter, Robert, The Mysterious Survival of the Policy Against Informed Consent Liability for Hospitals TRADEMARK & COPYRIGHT LAW Gibson, James, Once and Future Copyright Glessner, Michele M., One Size Does Not Fit All: Keeping the “Totality of the Circumstances” Test for Public Use Cases After Pfaffand SmithKline... Kwall, Roberta Rosenthal, Inspiration and Innovation: The Intrinsic Dimension of the Artistic Soul Lawson, Jonathan S., Eight Million Performances Later, Still Not a Dime: Why It Is Time To Comprehensively Protect Sound Recording Public Performances