OECD ECONOMIC SURVEYS 1986/1987 3 3 3 J 3 ) 3 .V7 ) 3 3 ? 3 3 1 3 3 3 3 3 ] 3 BD = 3?13i7]DU .133 31 ^ 11333137 NETHERLANDS 3 3 3 J 3 ) 3 J 7 ) D 3 3 1 B 3 3 ? i 3 .1 7 ) D 3 17 3 1 3 3 V 1 1 D ? ? 1 11 1 3 7 13 3 3 3 3)3313 JULY 1987 nHTnnnnr nrnTinnnrrmnl OECD ECONOMIC SURVEYS (cid:9),-^rw^ * .._ w C > T -,-*-= ,__r W-*" """ . ...--'- NETHElâbXfibs JULY 1987 ORGANISATION FOR ECONOMIC CO-OPERATION AND DEVELOPMENT Pursuanttoarticle1 oftheConventionsignedinParison 14th December, 1960,andwhichcameintoforceon30thSeptember, 1961,theOrganisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) shall promote policiesdesigned: - toachievethe highestsustainableeconomicgrowthandemployment andarisingstandardoflivinginMembercountries,whilemaintaining financial stability, and thus tocontribute to the development ofthe worldeconomy; - to contribute to sound economic expansion in Member as well as non-membercountries in theprocessofeconomicdevelopment; and - to contribute to the expansion of world trade on a multilateral, non-discriminatory basis in accordance with international obliga¬ tions. The original Member countries of the OECD are Austria, Belgium, Canada, Denmark, France, the Federal Republic of Germany, Greece, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain,Sweden,Switzerland,Turkey,theUnited Kingdomand the United States. The following countries became Members subsequently through accessionatthedatesindicatedhereafter:Japan(28thApril,1964),Finland (28thJanuary, 1969), Australia (7thJune, 1971) and New Zealand (29th May, 1973). TheSocialist Federal RepublicofYugoslavia takes part in some ofthe work ofthe OECD (agreement of28thOctober, 1961). Publiéégalementen français. ©OECD, 1987 Application forpermission toreproduce ortranslate all or part ofthis publicationshould be made to: HeadofPublicationsService,OECD 2, rue André-Pascal, 75775 PARISCEDEX 16, France. CONTENTS Introduction 7 I. Economictrends,policiesandshort-termprospects 8 Developmentsin1986 8 Monetarypolicyandconditions 19 Fiscalpolicy 22 Outlookfor1987and1988 25 II. Medium-termimbalances 28 Originofpresentimbalances 28 The1982reorientationofpolicies 32 The1987-1990budgetaryprogramme 34 Thescopeforunwindingimbalances 37 III. Structuralpoliciestoimproveeconomicperformance 41 Thetransfersystemandtheminimumwage 41 Thetaxsystemanditsreform 44 Thehousingsector 47 Specificaspectsofindustrypolicy 48 IV. Conclusions 50 Notesandreferences 53 Annexes I. Recentchangestothesocialsecuritysystem 59 II. ThetaxsystemintheNetherlands 62 III. ThehousingsectorintheNetherlands 65 IV. Calendarofmaineconomicevents 69 Statistical annex TABLES Text 1. Demandandoutput 8 2. Appropriationaccountforhouseholdsandprivatenon-profitinstitutions 10 3. Outputandproductivity 11 4. Thelabourmarket 12 5. Registeredunemployedandunemploymentbeneficiaries,January 1986 13 6. Wages,costsandprices 14 7. Profitsandsolvencyinthemarketsector 15 8. Merchandisetrade 18 9. Thecurrentaccount 18 10. Balanceofpayments 19 11. Monetaryconditions 20 12. Publicsectordeficits 23 13. Short-termprospects 26 14. Numberofbeneficiariesofsocialsecurityandsocialwelfare 30 15. Savingsandinvestment 33 16. GovernmentCoalitionAgreementandsupplementary1987budgetmeasures 35 17. ImpactoftheGovernmentCoalitionAgreementonemploymentandunemployment 36 18. Medium-termbaselineof GovernmentCoalitionAgreement 38 19. Centralgovernmentdeficitanddebt 39 20. Incomedistributionofhouseholds 44 21. Distributionofsomegovernmentexpenditureitems,1983 45 22. Averagetaxwedges,1973and 1985 45 Annexes Al. Durationoftheunemploymentbenefitbyworkingage,inyears 60 A2. Reductioninsocialsecurityoutlaysexpectedfromreforms 61 A3. Taxesandsocialsecuritycontributions 62 A4. Deductionsagainstincometax, 1981 63 A5. Socialsecuritycontributions,enterprisesector, 1986 64 A6. ThehousingsectorintheNetherlands,1986 65 A7. Budgetarycosts,housingsector 66 Statistical annex A. Nationalproductandexpenditure(millionGld.,currentprices) 74 B. Nationalproductandexpenditure(millionGld.,1980constantprices) 75 C. Originofgrossdomesticproductatfactorcost 76 D. Incomeandexpenditureofhouseholdsandprivatenon-profitinstitutions 77 E. Industrialproductionandproductivity 78 F. Thelabourmarketandemployment 79 G. Theimportanceofthepublicsectorandpublicsectordeficits 80 H. Moneyandbanking 81 I. Merchandisetrade 82 DIAGRAMS 1. Domesticdemandandproduction 9 2. Contributionstotheprivateconsumptiondeflator 16 3. Competitivenessindicatorsandchangesinexportperformance,manufacturing 17 4. Interestratesandexchangerates 21 5. Governmentgasrevenues 24 6. Macroeconomicperformanceindicators 29 7. Energyproductionandtrade 31 8. Totalgovernmentoutlaysandsocialsecuritytransfers 32 9. Changeinunemploymentratebyincomelevel, 1977-1983 42 10. Effectivemarginaldirecttaxrateonlabour,1983 46 BASIC STATISTICS OF THE NETHERLANDS THELAND Area(thousandsq.km.in 1986) 41.8 Majorcities, 1stJanuary 1986(thousandinhabitants): Agriculturalarea (asapercentageoftotal) 64.5 Amsterdam 679 Forest(asapercentageoftotal) 8.0 Rotterdam 571 TheHague 444 THEPEOPLE Population, 1986(thousands) 14572 Employmentin 1985(thousandmanyears): 4561 Persq. km.oflandarea 403 Agriculture,fishing 271 Netincreaseinpopulation(average Industry 1 254 1980-1986,thousands) 73 Otheractivities 3036 THEPUBLICSECTOR Governmentemployees(incl.military)inpercent Expenditureongoodsandservicesinpercentof oftolalemploymentin 1985 16.1 grossdomesticproductin 1985 16.3 Contributiontonetnationalincomeatfactor Taxrevenue(incl.Soc.Sec.com.)inpercentofnet costin 1985 (percent) 13.9 national incomein 1985 50.2 PRODUCTION Grossdomesticproductin 1985(USdollarsbillion) 124.9 Growthofrealbusinessinvestment, 1983-1986 GrowthofrealGDP, 1983-1986(annualrate, (annualrate,percent) 7.7 percent) 1.9 Growthoftotallabourproductivityintheenterprise Grossfixedinvestmentinpercentofgrossdomestic sector1, 1983-1986(annualrate,percent) 2.1 productin 1985 18.6 ofwhich:Manufacturing 4.0 FOREIGNTRADEANDPAYMENTSIN 1985 (million USdollars) Commodityexports,fob 62028 Percentagedistributionofforeigntrade: Commodityimports,fob 56709 Exports Imports Services,net 910 Transfers,net -980 Byarea: Currentbalance 5249 OECDcountries 87.0 76.4 Long-termcapital -3492 Otherdevelopedcountries 1.7 5.0 Basicbalance I 757 Developingcountries 11.3 18.6 ExportsofgoodsandservicesinpercentofGDP 64.1 BySITCgroups: ImportsofgoodsandservicesinpercentofGDP 59.3 Food,drinks,tobacco(0, I) 18.0 12.2 Materials(2,3,4) 29.4 29.4 ofwhich:Petroleumandprod. (3) 23.1 22.3 Finishedmanufacturedgoods(5,6,7, 8,9) 52.6 58.4 THECURRENCY Monetaryunit:Guilder CurrencyunitsperUSdollar,averageofdailyfigures: Year 1986 2.45 December 1986 2.25 Note: Aninternationalcomparisonofcertainbasicstatisticsisgiveninanannextable. 1. Excludingnaturalgasextraction. ThisSurveyisbasedontheSecretariat'sstudypreparedfor the annual review of the Netherlands by the Economic and DevelopmentReviewCommitteeon25thMay1987. Afterrevisionsin thelightofdicussions during thereview, final approval ofthe Surveyforpublication was given by the Committeeon10thJune1987. The previous Survey of the Netherlands was issued in March1986. INTRODUCTION Final domestic demand strengthened substantially in 1986, and, for the first time since 1983, contributed more to economicgrowth than exports. Business fixed investment was the major element of strength, but private consumption growth also accelerated, influenced by higher real disposable income. As stronger domestic demand was offset by a turnaround in stockbuilding and weaker net exports, real GDP growth was of the same order as in 1985 (2 per cent). Output in the non-gas business sector rose by nearly 3 per cent. Total employment increased, for the second year running, and unemployment fell. Price performance was again one of the best among OECD countries. In spite of a significant reduction, the current external surplus remained large, ofthe order of2% per cent ofGDP. The formulation of monetary policy has remained influenced by the twin objectives of preventing an excessive growth in domestic liquidity and maintaining the guilder in line with the Deutschemark. In the year to March 1987, the exchange rate of the guilder against the Deutschemarkwasunchanged. However, reflectingchangesintheinternationalconfiguration of exchange rates and two EMS realignments, the effective exchange rate of the guilder appreciated by around 6 per cent over the same period. On the fiscal side, further progress was achieved in reducing the Central Government budget deficit, allowing it to meet the medium-term targetsset bythe authoritiesin 1982. Prospectsuptotheend of1988pointto a weakening of activity. Under such circumstances, further progress in reducing the large budget deficit and bringing unemployment down to more acceptable levels may prove more difficult than envisaged by the authorities in their 1987-1990 budgetary programme. Recent economic trends, policy measures and the short-term outlook are presented in Part I ofthe present Survey. The scope for unwinding imbalances over the medium term is assessed in Part II. Part III reviews a number of areas where improved incentives, together with more flexible and efficient markets might improve macroeconomic performance in a context of fiscal retrenchment. Four major areas which affect public finances, the labour market and resource allocation are reviewedin thiscontext, namely: the transfersystem and theminimum wage; the taxsystem and itsproposed reform; the housingsector; and specific aspects of industry policy. Finally, policy conclusions are presented in Part IV. I. ECONOMIC TRENDS, POLICIES AND SHORT-TERM PROSPECTS Developments in 1986 Major sectors of aggregate demand Private business fixed investment grew by more than 10 per cent in 1986 (Table 1). Investment in machinery and equipment remained buoyant, and construction outlays picked up substantially suggesting a shift from capital deepening to capital widening. Improved profitability, strengthened balance sheets and high capacity utilisation were the main factors behind the upsurge in investment; lessgenerousinvestment subsidies asfrom May 1986 may also have brought some projects forward1. Although net businessinvestmentrecovered from the cyclical low of around 2 per cent of NNI in 1981-1982 to 5'4 per cent in 1986, its level Table 1. Demandmodoutput Levelin 1980prices,percentchanges bill, guilder» 1983 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 Privateconsumption 244.8 -1.2 0.8 -0.4 1.6 3.1 Governmentconsumption 67.5 0.7 1.2 -0.6 1.1 0.9 Grossfixed investment 77.4 -4.0 2.2 4.3 3.9 8.0 Public 10.9 -7.1 -A6 7.5 -4.3 -0.9 Private 66.5 -3.4 3.5 3.7 5.4 9.4 Dwellings 19.0 -5.6 -0.3 3.1 -4.4 5.8 Equipment 37.0 1.0 11.5 5.2 13.5 9.0 Others 10.5 -9.0 -8.2 -0.5 -0.3 18.4 Finaldomesticdemand 389.6 -1.4 1.2 0.5 2.0 3.7 Stockbuilding1 5.1 0.5 0.4 1.0 0.3 -0.8 Totaldomesticdemand 394.7 -0.9 1.5 1.4 2.3 2.8 Exportsofgoodsand services 266.3 0.0 3.5 7.0 4.6 2.6 Importsofgoodsandservices 246.0 1.1 3.9 5.5 5.7 4.2 Foreign balance1 20.3 -0.6 -0.1 1.0 -0.4 -0.8 Grossdomesticproduct 415.1 -1.4 1.4 2.4 1.7 1.9 Memorandumitems: Netfactor income' 1.1 0.0 0.1 0.1 0.0 -0.5 Depreciation 42.8 1.4 1.9 2.7 2.2 2.0 Net national product 373.4 -1.8 1.5 2.3 1.7 1.3 Terms-of-tradecorrection1 1.8 -0.4 0.4 0.4 0.5 Net national income 0.0 1.1 2.7 2.1 1.8 1. ChangemeasuredaspercentageofpreviousperiodGDP. Sources: CBS,NationaleRekeiingenI9SS,1986;CPB.CentrantEcorwmischFlan1987.1987;OECDSecretariatestimates. Diagram1. Domesticdemandandproduction 1979= 100 % % 110 110 108 / 108 / 106 S 106 REALGOP .-«a»*" 104 EXCLUDINGGAS S/ 104 V 102 f 102 """""" S'*"*''' REALGDP 100 **x ' 100 96 96 REALFINAL DOMESTICDEMAND 96 96 94 94 1979 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 Source: CPBsubmission. remained below that ofthe early 1970s. Higher outlays on tangible assets were accompanied by increased expenditure on information technology and research and development. These developments suggest that the underlyingposition ofthe business sectorhasbeen improving. The fall in oil prices led to a 10 per cent drop in investment in the mining sector (which includes gas and oil). For the manufacturing sector as a whole, investment continued to be lessthan cash flow except forcertain sub-sectors like the electro-technical industrywhere the introduction of new technology has kept the pace of investment high. Investment in the petro-chemical industry fell, because of the completion of some large investment projects. The rate of capital formation accelerated in the service sector. Residential investmentrose by6 percent. Housingstartsincreased by 15 percent as the price of existing houses recovered and interest rates fell. There also appears to be a shift towardshigherqualitydwellingswhile therenovationofexistinghouseshasbeen encouraged by government programmes allowing the use of unemployment insurance funds for this purpose. Public investment declined slightly with the completion of the Oosterschelde project2. Private consumption expenditure rose by 3 per cent in 1986, in line with real disposable income (Table 2). Consumer confidence strengthened further, at least in the first halfofthe year, and the cost of consumer credit fell. These factors, together with the stepping up of residential construction and the compulsory inspection ofoldercars (which was reflected in a 15 per cent rise in auto sales) led to a marked increase in purchases of consumer durables. Government consumption is estimated to have risen by 1 per cent, essentially reflecting higher non-wage expenditure, particularly on road maintenance and military equipment. StockbuildingmadeanegativecontributiontoGDPgrowthof\ ofapercent,despitean increase in output. Deliveries of transport equipment reduced work in progress, while the replenishment ofinventories was probably delayed by expectations offurtherprice declines.