Table Of Content

Vol 430 No 7002 pp815-949 Editorials News News Feature Correspondence Commentary Books and Arts Essay News and Views Brief Communications Articles Letters to Nature Outlook Naturejobs 19 August 2004 Editorials Passing the torch 815 With the death of Francis Crick, biology is mourning one of its deepest thinkers. A work of futurology, published in 1970, reveals the extent of his prescience — and suggests challenges for today's theorists. Let's blame Canada 815 Americans should worry less about their neighbour and more about the prestige of regulators who protect public health. News Biologists fear cloning hype will undermine stem-cell research 817 Talk of disease cures obscures challenges facing cloning teams Crisis foments as unstable lake builds in the Himalayas 818 Indian scientists say China is denying access to dammed river Climate modellers go local to target California's politicians 818 Regional study ushers in new generation of forecasts Newton's religious screeds get online airing 819 Biblical musings reveal another side of the father of modern science Firm sets sights on gene silencing to protect vision 819 RNA technology on track for first clinical trials Kerry pledges to axe Yucca Mountain nuclear-waste dump 820 Troubled repository embroiled in US election race Researchers seek to turn the tide on problem of acid seas 820 Rising carbon dioxide levels could devastate marine ecosystems Sick veterans pin hopes on Gulf War inquiry 821 Confusion surrounds cause of veterans' ill-health Plan for light relay sparks heated opposition 821 Physics celebrations will cause light pollution, say astronomers news in brief 822 News Feature CERN: The show goes on 824 CERN, the centre for particle physics in Europe, has been smashing its way through the subatomic world for the past 50 years. Alison Abbott finds out what's in store for the future. I Archaeology: Pyramid power 828 Archaeologists have failed to learn the secrets of Mexico's largest ancient monument. Particle physicists might save the day, says Michael Hopkin. Correspondence Communication is key to aid development efforts 829 Government could hone its use of science but scientists need to understand the issues. Proud past but no future for pioneering institute 829 Plant biologists need to get back to their roots 829 Commentary Raising Europe's game 831 ROBERT M. MAY How to create a research council that is a Champions League for science. Books and Arts Seeing stars in a big way 833 SIDNEY C. WOLFF reviews Giant Telescopes: Astronomical Ambition and the Promise of Technology by W. Patrick McCray The Gemini project typifies the growth of astronomy into 'big science'. The course of true science 834 ROBERT OLBY reviews Investigative Pathways: Patterns and Stages in the Careers of Experimental Scientists by Frederic Lawrence Holmes A struggle for order 834 BERNADETTE BENSAUDE-VINCENT reviews A Well-Ordered Thing: Dmitrii Mendeleev and the Shadow of the Periodic Table by Michael D. Gordin An architectural aside 835 GIOVANNI F. BIGNAMI Essay TURNING POINTS The blind leading the sighted 836 RICHARD GREGORY An eye-opening experience of the wonders of perception. News and Views Chemical biology: Hitting the sweet spot 837 DAVID A. TIRRELL By taking advantage of the cell's carbohydrate metabolism, reactive sugar analogues can be used to tag specific cells, potentially singling them out for imaging studies or drug delivery. Medicinal chemistry: A worthy adversary for malaria 838 PAUL M. O'NEILL A remarkable set of antimalarial drug candidates has been developed by an international collaboration of scientists, using the age-old Chinese herbal medicine artemisinin as a template. Condensed-matter physics: Vortices weave a tangled web 839 DAVID R. NELSON In high-temperature superconductors, quantized vortex filaments can be twisted up into a DNA-like double helix. An experiment is proposed to test how easily these vortex lines cut through each other. Cell division: Timing the machine 840 BRUCE BOWERMAN During cell division everything must happen at the right time, or errors occur. A common cellular control device, protein phosphorylation, is now shown to time the assembly of a key part of the II division machinery. 100 and 50 years ago 841 Palaeoclimatology: Fresh angle on the polar seesaw 842 TROND M. DOKKEN AND KERIM H. NISANCIOGLU During the last glacial period, climatic variation in the Northern and Southern Hemispheres was evidently linked. Modelling work points to freshwater discharge into the North Atlantic as a driving factor. Structural biology: Anthrax hijacks host receptor 843 JAMES G. BANN AND SCOTT J. HULTGREN An atomic picture of how anthrax toxin binds to its host's cells reveals that the toxin commandeers a host receptor protein and tricks it into helping the toxin enter the cell. Oceanography: Islands in the stream 843 HEIKE LANGENBERG Obituary: Francis Crick (1916–2004) 845 ALEXANDER RICH AND CHARLES F. STEVENS Alexander Rich and Charles F. Stevens, respectively an early collaborator of Crick's and a long-standing colleague at the Salk Institute, describe the life and work of one of the great thinkers of twentieth-century biology. Research highlights 848 Brief Communications Communications: Quantum teleportation across the Danube 849 RUPERT URSIN, THOMAS JENNEWEIN, MARKUS ASPELMEYER, RAINER KALTENBAEK, MICHAEL LINDENTHAL, PHILIP WALTHER & ANTON ZEILINGER A real-world experiment marks a step towards worldwide quantum communication. Biomechanics: Hydrodynamic function of the shark's tail 850 C. D. WILGA AND G. V. LAUDER Articles Strong hemispheric coupling of glacial climate through freshwater discharge and ocean circulation 851 R. KNUTTI, J. FLÜCKIGER, T. F. STOCKER & A. TIMMERMANN The structure and evolution of centromeric transition regions within the human genome 857 XINWEI SHE, JULIE E. HORVATH, ZHAOSHI JIANG, GE LIU, TERRENCE S. FUREY, LAURIE CHRIST, ROYDEN CLARK, TINA GRAVES, CASSY L. GULDEN, CAN ALKAN, JEFF A. BAILEY, CENK SAHINALP, MARIANO ROCCHI, DAVID HAUSSLER, RICHARD K. WILSON, WEBB MILLER, STUART SCHWARTZ & EVAN E. EICHLER Letters to Nature Discovery of five irregular moons of Neptune 865 MATTHEW J. HOLMAN, J. J. KAVELAARS, TOMMY GRAV, BRETT J. GLADMAN, WESLEY C. FRASER, DAN MILISAVLJEVIC, PHILIP D. NICHOLSON, JOSEPH A. BURNS, VALERIO CARRUBA, JEAN-MARC PETIT, PHILIPPE ROUSSELOT, OLIVER MOUSIS, BRIAN G. MARSDEN & ROBERT A. JACOBSON Addition of nanoparticle dispersions to enhance flux pinning of the YBa Cu O 2 3 7-x superconductor 867 T. HAUGAN, P. N. BARNES, R. WHEELER, F. MEISENKOTHEN & M. SUMPTION Direct evidence for atomic defects in graphene layers 870 AYAKO HASHIMOTO, KAZU SUENAGA, ALEXANDRE GLOTER, KOKI URITA & SUMIO IIJIMA Chemical remodelling of cell surfaces in living animals 873 JENNIFER A. PRESCHER, DANIELLE H. DUBE & CAROLYN R. BERTOZZI Variable ageing and storage of dissolved organic components in the open ocean 877 III AI NING LOH, JAMES E. BAUER & ELLEN R. M. DRUFFEL Impact of climate change on marine pelagic phenology and trophic mismatch 881 MARTIN EDWARDS AND ANTHONY J. RICHARDSON Context-dependent autonomous self-fertilization yields reproductive assurance and mixed mating 884 SUSAN KALISZ, DONNA W. VOGLER & KRISTEN M. HANLEY A barley cultivation-associated polymorphism conveys resistance to powdery mildew 887 PIETRO PIFFANELLI, LUKE RAMSAY, ROBBIE WAUGH, ABDELLAH BENABDELMOUNA, ANGÉLIQUE D'HONT, KARIN HOLLRICHER, JØRGEN HELMS JØRGENSEN, PAUL SCHULZE-LEFERT & RALPH PANSTRUGA SNF-6 is an acetylcholine transporter interacting with the dystrophin complex in Caenorhabditis elegans 891 HONGKYUN KIM, MATTHEW J. ROGERS, JANET E. RICHMOND & STEVEN L. MCINTIRE Coupling of agonist binding to channel gating in an ACh-binding protein linked to an ion channel 896 CECILIA BOUZAT, FERNANDA GUMILAR, GUILLERMO SPITZMAUL, HAI-LONG WANG, DIEGO RAYES, SCOTT B. HANSEN, PALMER TAYLOR & STEVEN M. SINE Identification of an antimalarial synthetic trioxolane drug development candidate 900 JONATHAN L. VENNERSTROM, SARAH ARBE-BARNES, RETO BRUN, SUSAN A. CHARMAN, FRANCIS C. K. CHIU, JACQUES CHOLLET, YUXIANG DONG, ARNULF DORN, DANIEL HUNZIKER, HUGUES MATILE, KYLIE MCINTOSH, MANIYAN PADMANILAYAM, JOSEFINA SANTO TOMAS, CHRISTIAN SCHEURER, BERNARD SCORNEAUX, YUANQING TANG, HEINRICH URWYLER, SERGIO WITTLIN & WILLIAM N. CHARMAN Crystal structure of a complex between anthrax toxin and its host cell receptor 905 EUGENIO SANTELLI, LAURIE A. BANKSTON, STEPHEN H. LEPPLA & ROBERT C. LIDDINGTON Cell cycle regulation of central spindle assembly 908 MASANORI MISHIMA, VISNJA PAVICIC, ULRIKE GRÜNEBERG, ERICH A. NIGG & MICHAEL GLOTZER Structural basis for inhibition of the replication licensing factor Cdt1 by geminin 913 CHANGWOOK LEE, BUMSOO HONG, JUNG MIN CHOI, YUGENE KIM, SAORI WATANABE, YUKIO ISHIMI, TAKEMI ENOMOTO, SHUSUKE TADA, YOUNGCHANG KIM & YUNJE CHO Structural basis for redox regulation of Yap1 transcription factor localization 917 MATTHEW J. WOOD, GISELA STORZ & NICO TJANDRA erratum: No stellar p-mode oscillations in space-based photometry of Procyon 921 JAYMIE M. MATTHEWS, RAINER KUSCHNIG, DAVID B. GUENTHER, GORDON A. H. WALKER, ANTHONY F.J. MOFFAT, SLAVEK M. RUCINSKI, DIMITAR SASSELOV & WERNER W. WEISS corrigendum: Sirt1 promotes fat mobilization in white adipocytes by repressing PPAR- 921 FRÉDÉRIC PICARD, MARTIN KURTEV, NAMJIN CHUNG, ACHARAWAN TOPARK-NGARM, THANASET SENAWONG, RITA MACHADO DE OLIVEIRA, MARK LEID, MICHAEL W. MCBURNEY & LEONARD GUARENTE Outlook Malaria 923 Plague of my people 925 PASCOAL MOCUMBI "It is high time we addressed the widening inequities that characterize our planet today. We need to focus our energies towards achieving basic healthcare for all." Pascoal Mocumbi, former prime minister of Mozambique Between hope and a hard place 926 BRIAN GREENWOOD Campaigns against malaria are multiplying, but so are malaria deaths. Brian Greenwood asks what can be done to turn the tide. IV Power to the people 928 DECLAN BUTLER In Africa, where malaria hits hardest, scientists are crying out for countries to take matters into their own hands, says Declan Butler. An attack on all fronts 930 RICHARD KLAUSNER AND PEDRO ALONSO To win the fight against malaria we will need to scale up existing programmes and develop new weapons, say Richard Klausner and Pedro Alonso. Where did it all go wrong? 932 AMIR ATTARAN International agencies have failed to meet their own malaria performance targets and should be held to account, says Amir Attaran. The invisible victims 934 ROBERT W. SNOW We need to know how bad the malaria situation is before we can make it better, says Robert Snow. Struggling to make an impact 935 APOORVA MANDAVILLI Taking aim at mosquitoes 936 JANET HEMINGWAY The malaria vector is back in scientists' sights, says Janet Hemingway, with insecticides and transgenic insects offering fresh hope. The long and winding road 937 JULIE CLAYTON AND DECLAN BUTLER Documentary makers can get as close to the war zones of disease as doctors and researchers — perhaps even closer. Julie Clayton and Declan Butler talk to Kevin Hull about his experiences. Strength in unity 938 MELINDA MOREE, SARAH EWART & CARTER DIGGS The world must increase collaboration to meet the pressing need for a malaria vaccine, argue Carter Diggs, Sarah Ewart and Melinda Moree. Save the children 940 STEPHEN HOFFMAN Creating a malaria vaccine will be tough. But Africa needs one now more than ever, says Stephen Hoffman. Winning the drugs war 942 ROBERT RIDLEY AND YEYA TOURE We have the science to make new antimalarials, say Robert Ridley and Yeya Toure, but we need better mechanisms and resources to develop drugs and deliver them. Know thine enemy 944 DANIEL CARUCCI The malaria and mosquito genomes will allow us to find new drug and vaccine targets, says Daniel Carucci. Naturejobs Prospects: Granting longevity 947 PAUL SMAGLIK Careers & Recruitment: Breathing life into chemistry 948 TIM CHAPMAN Chemical biology, using chemical tools to solve biological problems, is awakening interest among students and creating a new breed of researcher, says Tim Chapman. V 19.8 Editorial 815 MH 17/8/04 1:36 pm Page 815 19 August 2004 Volume 430Issue no 7002 Passing the torch With the death of Francis Crick, biology is mourning one of its deepest thinkers. A work of futurology, published in 1970, reveals the extent of his prescience — and suggests challenges for today’s theorists. When Francis Crick and James Watson described the double- worlds.The nature ofconsciousness — to which Crick devoted his helix structure ofDNA in 1953,they charmed many with later years — similarly remains shrouded in mystery. their unassuming pay-off line: “It has not escaped our Crick also had some observations about the future ofthis journal. notice that the specific pairing we have postulated immediately “I hope,”he wrote,“that Naturewill not become overloaded with too suggests a possible copying mechanism for the genetic material.” many detailed papers in what we now regard as the more classical In fact,little in the broad landscape of biology escaped Crick’s parts ofmolecular biology.” attention.The publication ofhis obituary (see page 845) marks a good In terms ofwhat was then seen as “classical”,Crick’s wish has been time to revisit one ofhis lesser-known works,a 1970 essay in Nature granted.But in recent years,there’s no denying the preponderance of on‘Molecular Biology in the Year 2000’(www.nature.com/nature/ Naturepapers on the molecular details ofsuch topics as signal trans- focus/crick/pdf/crick228.pdf).Unlike most exercises in crystal-ball duction and the cell cycle.Crick would probably have been disap- gazing,it holds up remarkably well to the scrutiny ofhindsight. pointed by the relative paucity ofgreat contributions on the origins Setting about his task with some trepidation,Crick divided bio- oflife,and astrobiology.In part,this may reflect a conservative system logical problems into three categories:those that would be solved by ofresearch funding that discourages biologists from attempting the the turn ofthe millennium;those that would have advanced consid- high-risk imaginative leaps that Crick favoured.But it’s also a reflec- erably towards resolution;and the big questions that would still be tion ofthe nature ofthe beast.Crick’s essay hinted at this:“Problems taxing the best scientific minds. involving complex interactions can hardly be avoided,since some of In some respects,Crick overestimated the rate ofprogress.We are the most profound aspects ofbiology are ofthis character.” still some way from a complete understanding ofthe significance of Crick understandably failed to predict the rise ofhigh-throughput repetitive ‘junk’DNA;much the same can be said for the sequences techniques,including whole-genome sequencing,DNA microarray that regulate gene expression.But,as he predicted,the replication of analysis and proteome profiling.These techniques have confirmed, DNA and the structure ofchromosomes are now well documented. ifthere was any doubt,that the details ofbiology are truly devilish. Crick’s choices for the second category were similarly prescient. In the wake ofgenomics,the emerging discipline ofsystems biology Some problems fell more easily than he expected:apart from minor has the potential to make sense ofthese details,by treating genes and details, the mechanism of muscle contraction can be considered proteins as networks,ripe for theoretical analysis.There’s reason to solved.Others,such as “the nature ofthe influences which produce hope that theorists will soon be able to advise lab-based biologists on ‘gradients’in embryological development”,have proved more com- where to look for answers,much as theoretical physicists predicted plex.But his list represents a remarkably accurate summary ofthe the existence offundamental subatomic particles a generation ago. issues that have occupied biologists over the past three-and-a-half Molecular biology is easily dismissed as a book ofrecipes,and too decades — not all ofwhich would have been obvious back in 1970. many ofits practitioners allow this criticism to pass unchallenged. As for the final category ofunsolved problems,we’re still wrestling Crick would not have wanted this to happen.Let’s hope his legacy of with the origins of life on Earth,and whether life exists on other thinking big lives on. ■ Let’s blame Canada Americans should worry less about their neighbour and more about the prestige of regulators who protect public health. Lester Crawford, acting commissioner of the US Food and prestigiousfederal agencies,such as the FDA,into political poodles. Drug Administration (FDA),is worried that the importation The FDA has an inspiring history.Its record ofstalwart indepen- of cheap pharmaceuticals could expose Americans to attack dence is one of the reasons Americans have such high confidence from bioterrorists.In an interview with the Associated Press on 11 in the safety of both their pharmaceuticals and their food supply. August,he raised the potential contamination ofimported drugs as Only a few years ago,for example,FDA commissioner David Kessler a threat to national security. launched an audacious effort to regulate tobacco as a drug.Congress In practice,the imports come mainly from Canada,where drugs opposed the move and Kessler received little support from his bosses are subject to government price controls.They are increasingly sanc- in the Clinton administration.But his stand,for a while,had ‘big tioned by state governments in the United States,where citizens are tobacco’shaking in its boots. tiring ofpaying inflated prices for medicines.The Bush administra- Today,the chances of such an initiative originating within the tion — taking its cue from US drug companies — would like to close FDA itselfare slight — not much larger than the chances ofsomeone the door to such imports. choosing to terrorize the US public by contaminating a shipment of As that acclaimed documentary the South Parkmovie demon- drugs before their export from Canada.It is scandalous that the FDA’s strated,the United States’paranoia about its threatening northern leadership seems ready to make politically motivated pronounce- neighbour is richly justified.But Canadian perfidy must not blind ments that link two serious issues — drug pricing and bioterrorism Americans to a starker domestic threat:the degeneration ofonce- — in a manner likely only to inflate public cynicism about both. ■ NATURE|VOL 430|19 AUGUST 2004|www.nature.com/nature 815 © 2004 Nature PublishingGroup 19.8 news 817 new MH 17/8/04 2:25 pm Page 817 news Valley life Seeing red Desert storm Viral strain Climate model offers Marine scientists UK inquiry seeks Vietnam confirms California a taste of bid to halt ocean clarity on ‘GulfWar three human deaths things to come acidification syndrome’ from bird flu p818 p820 p821 p822 Biologists fear cloning hype will undermine stem-cell research Jonathan Knight ES G A dose ofreality needs to be injected into the A M excitement surrounding therapeutic cloning, Y I T T senior stem-cell biologists have warned. E G Researchers fear that optimism generated AFP/ by recent advances,including the award on 11 August ofthe first UK licence for research on the technique,has raised expectations of individualized cures for degenerative dis- eases.In reality,say those in the field,such a prospect remains distant at best. “Ifwe keep talking about cures and they don’t come in the next few years,that’s going to be a problem,”says Jose Cibelli,a stem-cell researcher at Michigan State University in East Lansing. The decision by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority to grant a licence to the Newcastle Fertility Centre,part ofthe Media attention on these cloned embryos,created this year,has obscured short-term research benefits. city’s Life biotechnology village,triggered a storm ofmedia attention.The licence allows Yet the scientific hurdles that remain are who has collaborated with colleagues there. scientists to create human embryos by insert- immense. Cloning is tremendously ineffi- The Newcastle group faces fewer prob- ing nuclei from human skin cells into human cient,for example.When researchers at Seoul lems,as researchers there will have access to eggs.The Newcastle team will then be able to National University in South Korea produced eggs left over from in vitrofertilization proce- extract stem cells from the cloned embryo. the world’s first human embryonic stem-cell dures.These number some 2,000 a year,says Although researchers such as Cibelli were line from a cloned embryo in February,they Alison Murdoch, a reproductive biologist thrilled at the news, some worry that the got through 242 eggs from 16 women.Until with the group,although the actual number media coverage underplays just how few labs that success rate is improved,cures or treat- available will depend on how many women are working on therapeutic cloning.They also ments from therapeutic cloning will be give permission for their eggs to be used. say that short-term benefits ofthe work,such impossible.“There is a limited number ofeggs Murdoch and her colleagues will initially as providing fresh insight into diseases such as for all the patients in the world,”says Cibelli. attempt to generate a cell line from the cloned diabetes and Parkinson’s (see Nature422,787; embryo ofa healthy subject,to make sure the 2003),are not acknowledged. Limited company procedure works.Only then will they try to Short-term and long-term benefits are Efficiency may improve with time,although produce a cell line from a patient with dia- usually mentioned in the same breath,but the that will require repeat trials with larger betes,the clinic’s primary disease focus. possibility ofcures seems to overshadow the numbers of eggs.But sources estimate that Even getting the first healthy cell line will research benefits,says Lawrence Goldstein,a fewer than five labs around the world are be hard.The South Korean team used adult stem-cell researcher at the University ofCali- even trying. The South Korean group has cell nuclei transferred from cumulus cells sur- fornia,San Diego.“Many ofus in the scien- halted its cloning work until a new licensing rounding the donor’s egg.Using nuclei from tific community talk about both ofthese,but law comes into effect next January (see the donor avoids problems with mitochon- the press often seizes on one,as do the public Nature429,12–14;2004).Singapore,home dria — energy-producing parts ofa cell that and the patient advocates,”he says. to several stem-cell groups,has not yet final- carry their own genetic content,which is not Talk ofcures is justified,say experts,but ized legislation relating to the licensing of always compatible with any mitochondrial only in the long term. Researchers believe therapeutic cloning. DNA found in the donor’s egg.Cumulus cells that embryonic stem cells can be coaxed to US law prohibits federal funds from being also combine relatively easily with eggs. form any tissue in the body.So if they can used for therapeutic cloning,and private labs The Newcastle group, by contrast, will be extracted from embryos cloned from a are not thought to be working on the tech- take nuclei from skin cells and attempt to patient, they could be used as genetically nique.And in Israel,another country with fuse them with eggs from many different identical replacements for damaged tissue. stem-cell expertise,researchers are discour- donors.“Ifwe can get the technique to work This would avoid the risk ofrejection associ- aged because only a small number ofeggs can reliably in the first year we will have made a ated with transplants. be used in experiments,says a US scientist great deal ofprogress,”says Murdoch. ■ NATURE|VOL 430|19 AUGUST 2004|www.nature.com/nature 817 © 2004 Nature PublishingGroup 19.8 news 818 MH 17/8/04 1:37 pm Page 818 news Crisis foments as BIS R O unstable lake builds ES/C M OL in the Himalayas H R. K.S.Jayaraman,New Delhi Landslides on the India–China border have created a lake holding millions of cubic metres ofwater.Scientists and engineers in the region are puzzling over how to avoid a catastrophic collapse ofthe lake wall,but Indian researchers say their plans have been hampered by China’s refusal to allow them to visit the site. The Chinese government warned on Green remembered hills:the wine ofthe Napa valley could lose its edge ifemissions are not reduced. 11 August that landslides had blocked the Climate modellers go local to Pare Chu river in Tibet,creating a lake about 40 metres deep and holding 60 million cubic metres ofwater.China said target California’s politicians it was evacuating people downstream and advised India to do the same.The river enters India about 35 kilometres from the lake and,as the Sutlej,continues past Emma Marris assessment,”says Hayhoe,who adds that the several towns in Himachal Pradesh. A “pioneering”example of a new breed of team chose California because the state is According to Muthaia Perumal,a climate model, designed to plug the gap both tough and potentially responsive.“It hydrologist at the Indian Institute of between academic research and political has a lot of different climate zones,so it is Technology (IIT) in Roorkee,the water decision making,has been published. challenging. Also, California is a leader in will rush into a narrow gorge should the The analysis of California’s climate by terms of reduction of emissions. It might lake wall break .“It will not be like floods Katharine Hayhoe and colleagues outlines actually use our findings.” in the plains where water can spread how conditions in the state will change under Hayhoe hopes her forecasts will be politi- out,”he says.“We expect a huge wall of two alternative scenarios: one models the cally effective,but says she wants the science water moving in bulk without its height state’s future under aggressive policies to to be unbiased and to be perceived as being diminishing.” reduce carbon dioxide emissions;the other so.She adds that her team used low estimates Creating tunnels in the lake wall could predicts its fate without them. The result for emissions and their effect on the climate: have provided an exit for the accumulating is an analysis of the implications for heat- “We tried to err on the conservative side.” water had measures been taken when the related human mortality,the water cycle and She also says that after the initial suggestion, landslides occurred in early July,says agriculture. It is designed to influence the the UCS stepped aside, although two Manoj Datta,a civil engineer at the IIT in state’s policy-makers. authors do list the UCS as an affiliation. Delhi.“Now the dam is overflowing it is “Other researchers looked at just one State officials declined requests to comment too risky to try anything,”he adds.The scenario, which is kind of fatalistic,” says on the paper. Indian government has evacuated 50,000 Hayhoe,who is based at the University of The study is “pioneering”,according to people from the danger zone. Illinois at Urbana–Champaign.“This way Warren Washington,a climate researcher at Indian researchers regret that a joint you have a choice.” the US National Center for Atmospheric strategy was not put in place early on,but Rajendra Pachauri,chairman ofthe Inter- Research in Boulder, Colorado, who pro- the Indian government said on 13 August governmental Panel on Climate Change vided tailored data from the centre’s global that a request toChina for permission to (IPCC),has flagged up such regional studies climate model.He predicts that the format send scientists and engineers to the site as a vital part ofthe panel’s next assessment will be popular.“This type of paper and had been rebuffed.The Chinese (see Nature417,106;2002).In this case,the analysis will be repeated for many regions government says the site is difficult to project was suggested to Hayhoe by the around the world,”says Washington. reach and is briefing Indian authorities on Washington-based Union of Concerned Regional assessments are becoming more progress made by its own team at the lake. Scientists (UCS),which fears that the find- feasible as computing power improves,adds Chinese hydrologists working on the lake ings ofclimate-change science are not being David Viner,ofthe IPCC’s Data Distribution could not be reached for comment. ■ disseminated in a useful form. Centre at the University of East Anglia in The study,which is published in print on Norwich,UK.The regional models,although D BA 16 August (K.Hayhoe et al.Proc.Natl Acad. huge,can now be done on off-the-shelfcom- A ER Sci.USA doi:10.1073/pnas.0404500101),uses puters.“I’ve got a G5 Power Mac on my desk, D HY data from two global climate models,along which has the capability ofa supercomputer A RS with local weather histories. In the high- from five or ten years ago,”says Viner.“There N emissions scenario,there will be six to eight are lots ofpeople doing this now.” times more heat waves and five to seven times He adds that moving the data around is more heat-related deaths in 2100 than there probably more problematic than producing are now.Alpine forests will practically dis- it.Global models,which can require up to appear,snow packs will shrink and the vine- 5,000 gigabytes ofmemory,are starting to Dam danger:a catastrophic flood is feared yards will move from producing gourmet become publicly available on the Internet. after landslides blocked a Tibetan river. wine to plonk. However,they do not yet provide the detail “What we did is a model for a regional needed for a rigorous local model. ■ 818 NATURE|VOL 430|19 AUGUST 2004|www.nature.com/nature © 2004 Nature PublishingGroup 19.8 news 819 MH 17/8/04 10:16 am Page 819 news Newton’s religious screeds get online airing PL Geoff Brumfiel Protestant parliament,before Charles Y/S “Among the Beasts that represent II was restored to the throne. R R TE Kingdoms I reccon the Dragon one. But the vehemence of Newton’s S. A Dragon signifies the person of a arguments pushed him well beyond hostile King & serpents according the Anglican faith,to which he osten- to their bigness the persons ofother sibly belonged.“He believed that the greater or lesser enemies.” These Pope was the personification of the words were penned not by an Antichrist here on Earth,”Iliffe says. obscure mystic,but by a man many Newton knew such beliefs lay out- consider to be the father ofmodern side the social mores ofhis peers,and science — Isaac Newton.They are there is no evidence that he ever pub- part of the introduction to the lished any ofthe writings now avail- 300,000-word interpretation of the able online.Still,Iliffe says,Newton’s book of Revelation that Newton religious writings constitute more wrote in the late seventeenth cent- than halfofhis entire written work. ury.The work was published for the In the past, many thought that first time last month. Newton pursued religion only in his The writings reveal a religious fer- spare time, or that the majority of vour that until now has been seen his religious work had been copied only by scholars of science with from others. But Iliffe claims that access to archival manuscripts, these writings show his theological according to Robert Iliffe,a science work was carefully planned and often historian at Imperial College Lon- related to his work in mathematics don.Iliffe directs the Newton Pro- and physics.For example,he sets up ject, which posted the documents Revelation:the majority ofNewton’s writings were theological tracts. his text on the Apocalypse with math- online on 15 July.“This is the first ematical formalism,outlining rules, time that people can see what he really Among the unorthodox ideas in the text is a definitions and a proofofhis beliefs. believed,”he says. beliefthat Catholics,led by the Pope,are the Ultimately,Newton’s religion and science Historians ofscience have long known of false idolaters spoken ofin the book ofRevela- may have been tied together by belief in Newton’s interest in religion and alchemy,but tion.Antagonism towards Catholics was not absolute truth. Newton used testable few realize the radical nature ofhis work,says uncommon in Newton’s period: during his hypotheses to find truth in nature, and Iliffe. “What he believed would have been lifetime England had experienced a bloody believed that his religious writings revealed hideous to virtually everybody in Oxford and civil war that pitted Charles I,widely regarded the truth about God,says Iliffe. ■ Cambridge for decades to come,”he says. as a Catholic sympathizer,against the mainly ➧www.newtonproject.ic.ac.uk Firm sets sights on gene silencing to protect vision Erika Check,Washington Acuity hopes to use a small interfering 1.65 million people in the United States. A much-hyped technology known as RNA RNA to treat patients with wet age-related Dale Pfost,Acuity’s chiefexecutive,says interference (RNAi) has moved a step macular degeneration.The condition is his firm has applied for a patent on the RNA closer to the clinic. caused by extended growth ofblood vessels molecule involved,but the intellectual- Biotechnology firm Acuity in the retina — a problem that Acuity thinks properties issues are not straightforward. Pharmaceuticals ofPhiladelphia, can be tackled by silencing the gene that Rival firm Alnylam,based in Cambridge, Pennsylvania,asked for permission on triggers the growth.The company says Massachusetts,has already requested a 10 August to use the technique to treat a that the condition affects more than patent on the method ofRNA delivery that common cause ofblindness.The clinical Acuity will use.Alnylam says it plans to R/SPL trial,ifapproved by the US Food and Drug begin its own clinical trials in macular KE Administration,would be the first ofits kind. degeneration next year. R PA RNAi,which uses short lengths of Pfost is confident that Acuity’s disease- P. genetic material to selectively shut offgenes, specific patent will be granted,but Alnylam was demonstrated in human cells in 2001 begs to differ.“We’re very pleased to see and has yet to be tested in people.Some silencing RNAs entering the clinical stage,” studies have raised concerns about just how says John Maraganore,chiefexecutive of selective the technique is,so observers say Alnylam.“But at the end ofthe day,we the filing is a landmark for the field but believe that anybody developing RNAi remain cautious. therapies needs to talk to us.” ■ “This is a significant milestone,”says Greg Jensen,a biotechnology analyst at Ernst For more news and analysis go to & Young in Palo Alto,California.“Whether it Light relief:RNAi may stop the degeneration will work out,or give us the first bad news seen here (right) in an ageing retina. www.nature.com/news about RNA interference,we don’t know yet.” NATURE|VOL 430|19 AUGUST 2004|www.nature.com/nature 819 © 2004 Nature PublishingGroup 19.8 news 820 MH 17/8/04 10:16 am Page 820 news Kerry pledges to axe M O C Yucca Mountain EPL. R U AT nuclear-waste dump N Geoff Brumfiel,Washington Plans for a multimillion-dollar nuclear- waste dump,already shaken by a string of budgetary and legal setbacks,have taken a further knock.The Democrat presidential candidate John Kerry pledged last week to block the scheme ifhe is elected. Debate over the Yucca Mountain repository has injected some science into the presidential race,as both candidates campaign heavily for the swing state ofNevada,home to the site.Advocates ofnuclear power hope to make Yucca Mountain the nation’s primary nuclear dump,but opposition from the state government and scientific questions about the site have delayed the project (see Nature412,850–852;2001). Sea change:falling pH levels caused by carbon dioxide emissions could devastate oceanic ecosystems. On 10 August,Kerry used scientific studies to claim the plan was flawed, Researchers seek to turn the including one saying that corrosion could destroy the metal waste-storage canisters. tide on problem of acid seas “I can sum up my stance on Yucca Mountain in four words,”Kerry told supporters in Nevada.“Not on my watch.” His attack was rebuffed by President Quirin Schiermeier,Munich marine organisms will play a prominent part George W.Bush,who two days later Researchers met last week to map out plans in the research plan.Last month,researchers accused Kerry of“trying to turn Yucca to study a serious but largely neglected showed that the shells and hard skeletons of Mountain into a political poker chip”. environmental problem — the gradual plankton and corals will begin to dissolve Kerry may also be out ofstep with the acidification ofthe oceans. as the oceans become more acid (R.A.Feely scientific evidence.According to a 28 July Since the industrial revolution,sea sur- et al.Science305,362–366;2004).The loss of letter from the Nuclear Waste Technical face pH levels have dropped by around 0.1 these creatures would have incalculable con- Review Board,the government agency units as the oceans absorb atmospheric car- sequences for the entire marine food chain. that raised the corrosion concern,new bon dioxide.This is already enough to trou- Carol Turley,a senior scientist at the Ply- data show that corrosion is “unlikely”. ble some marine species, but researchers mouth lab,says researchers will investigate The campaign rhetoric comes at a warn that values could fall by a further 0.5 the growth, reproduction and adaptation turbulent time for the site.The facility units by 2100.If steps are not taken to cut capability of marine species ranging from is designed to last 10,000 years,but on CO emissions,pH could drop even further, bacteria to vertebrates. Results from these 2 10 July a federal appeal court ruled that perhaps to levels that are thought to have experiments will help to shape protocols for it must comply with a 1995 National triggered catastrophic extinction events in open-ocean studies.With the help of mea- Academy ofSciences study that raises Earth’s history (Nature425,365;2003). surement tools such as pH sensors attached to this to 100,000 years.The decision came “We’re taking a huge risk,”says UlfRiebe- profiling floats,researchers will try to track as federal officials were rushing to file a sell,a marine biologist at the Leibniz Insti- the subtle ecosystem interactions between licence application for the site with the tute of Marine Sciences in Kiel, Germany. the sea surface and the sea floor,and between Nuclear Regulatory Commission,which “Chemical ocean conditions 100 years from coastal areas and the open ocean. oversees nuclear-waste disposal. now will probably have no equivalent in the Modelling the likely changes in ocean Yucca’s advocates are also faced with geological past,and key organisms may have chemistry,and determining how they may a budgeting miscalculation that led the no mechanisms to adapt to the change.” affect temperature, salinity and nutrient House ofRepresentatives in June to Aspects of the threat are already being availability, will be another priority, says approve just $130million ofthe $880 studied, but marine scientists met at the Turley. Researchers will also add CO to 2 million requested for the site in the next Plymouth Marine Laboratory,UK,on 11–13 the ocean to simulate long-term changes. financial year.Many doubt that the bill, August to start work on a comprehensive Together, these studies should show how when it is completed,will provide full research plan. The scheme, to be finalized biogeochemistry,species diversity and evo- funding.“The project is caught in a later this year,will list key scientific questions lution will change in an acidic ocean. perfect storm right now,”says Bob Loux, and provide a blueprint for funding agencies Riebesell hopes that the initiatives,which director ofthe State ofNevada Agency for and researchers. will be overseen by the Integrated Marine Nuclear Projects,which opposes the site. Their efforts were due to be boosted on Biogeochemistry and Ecosystem Research The fate ofthe site may now depend on 17 August by news that Britain’s Royal Soci- project,will influence funding agencies.“We the outcome ofthe presidential election. ety is to probe the likely changes to marine know quite a lot about the ocean ofthe past,” IfBush wins,he may be able to negotiate ecosystems following a rise in ocean acidity. he says.“But we owe it to people to tell them a new 2005 budget for the project. ■ Studies ofthe effects ofacidification on more about the ocean ofthe future.” ■ 820 NATURE|VOL 430|19 AUGUST 2004|www.nature.com/nature © 2004 Nature PublishingGroup

ebook img

Nature (Vol. 430, No. 7002, 19 August 2004) PDF

134 Pages·2004·15.144 MB·English
by  
#
Save to my drive
Quick download
Download
Upgrade Premium
Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.

Preview Nature (Vol. 430, No. 7002, 19 August 2004)

Vol 430 No 7002 pp815-949 Editorials News News Feature Correspondence Commentary Books and Arts Essay News and Views Brief Communications Articles Letters to Nature Outlook Naturejobs 19 August 2004 Editorials Passing the torch 815 With the death of Francis Crick, biology is mourning one of its deepest thinkers. A work of futurology, published in 1970, reveals the extent of his prescience — and suggests challenges for today's theorists. Let's blame Canada 815 Americans should worry less about their neighbour and more about the prestige of regulators who protect public health. News Biologists fear cloning hype will undermine stem-cell research 817 Talk of disease cures obscures challenges facing cloning teams Crisis foments as unstable lake builds in the Himalayas 818 Indian scientists say China is denying access to dammed river Climate modellers go local to target California's politicians 818 Regional study ushers in new generation of forecasts Newton's religious screeds get online airing 819 Biblical musings reveal another side of the father of modern science Firm sets sights on gene silencing to protect vision 819 RNA technology on track for first clinical trials Kerry pledges to axe Yucca Mountain nuclear-waste dump 820 Troubled repository embroiled in US election race Researchers seek to turn the tide on problem of acid seas 820 Rising carbon dioxide levels could devastate marine ecosystems Sick veterans pin hopes on Gulf War inquiry 821 Confusion surrounds cause of veterans' ill-health Plan for light relay sparks heated opposition 821 Physics celebrations will cause light pollution, say astronomers news in brief 822 News Feature CERN: The show goes on 824 CERN, the centre for particle physics in Europe, has been smashing its way through the subatomic world for the past 50 years. Alison Abbott finds out what's in store for the future. I Archaeology: Pyramid power 828 Archaeologists have failed to learn the secrets of Mexico's largest ancient monument. Particle physicists might save the day, says Michael Hopkin. Correspondence Communication is key to aid development efforts 829 Government could hone its use of science but scientists need to understand the issues. Proud past but no future for pioneering institute 829 Plant biologists need to get back to their roots 829 Commentary Raising Europe's game 831 ROBERT M. MAY How to create a research council that is a Champions League for science. Books and Arts Seeing stars in a big way 833 SIDNEY C. WOLFF reviews Giant Telescopes: Astronomical Ambition and the Promise of Technology by W. Patrick McCray The Gemini project typifies the growth of astronomy into 'big science'. The course of true science 834 ROBERT OLBY reviews Investigative Pathways: Patterns and Stages in the Careers of Experimental Scientists by Frederic Lawrence Holmes A struggle for order 834 BERNADETTE BENSAUDE-VINCENT reviews A Well-Ordered Thing: Dmitrii Mendeleev and the Shadow of the Periodic Table by Michael D. Gordin An architectural aside 835 GIOVANNI F. BIGNAMI Essay TURNING POINTS The blind leading the sighted 836 RICHARD GREGORY An eye-opening experience of the wonders of perception. News and Views Chemical biology: Hitting the sweet spot 837 DAVID A. TIRRELL By taking advantage of the cell's carbohydrate metabolism, reactive sugar analogues can be used to tag specific cells, potentially singling them out for imaging studies or drug delivery. Medicinal chemistry: A worthy adversary for malaria 838 PAUL M. O'NEILL A remarkable set of antimalarial drug candidates has been developed by an international collaboration of scientists, using the age-old Chinese herbal medicine artemisinin as a template. Condensed-matter physics: Vortices weave a tangled web 839 DAVID R. NELSON In high-temperature superconductors, quantized vortex filaments can be twisted up into a DNA-like double helix. An experiment is proposed to test how easily these vortex lines cut through each other. Cell division: Timing the machine 840 BRUCE BOWERMAN During cell division everything must happen at the right time, or errors occur. A common cellular control device, protein phosphorylation, is now shown to time the assembly of a key part of the II division machinery. 100 and 50 years ago 841 Palaeoclimatology: Fresh angle on the polar seesaw 842 TROND M. DOKKEN AND KERIM H. NISANCIOGLU During the last glacial period, climatic variation in the Northern and Southern Hemispheres was evidently linked. Modelling work points to freshwater discharge into the North Atlantic as a driving factor. Structural biology: Anthrax hijacks host receptor 843 JAMES G. BANN AND SCOTT J. HULTGREN An atomic picture of how anthrax toxin binds to its host's cells reveals that the toxin commandeers a host receptor protein and tricks it into helping the toxin enter the cell. Oceanography: Islands in the stream 843 HEIKE LANGENBERG Obituary: Francis Crick (1916–2004) 845 ALEXANDER RICH AND CHARLES F. STEVENS Alexander Rich and Charles F. Stevens, respectively an early collaborator of Crick's and a long-standing colleague at the Salk Institute, describe the life and work of one of the great thinkers of twentieth-century biology. Research highlights 848 Brief Communications Communications: Quantum teleportation across the Danube 849 RUPERT URSIN, THOMAS JENNEWEIN, MARKUS ASPELMEYER, RAINER KALTENBAEK, MICHAEL LINDENTHAL, PHILIP WALTHER & ANTON ZEILINGER A real-world experiment marks a step towards worldwide quantum communication. Biomechanics: Hydrodynamic function of the shark's tail 850 C. D. WILGA AND G. V. LAUDER Articles Strong hemispheric coupling of glacial climate through freshwater discharge and ocean circulation 851 R. KNUTTI, J. FLÜCKIGER, T. F. STOCKER & A. TIMMERMANN The structure and evolution of centromeric transition regions within the human genome 857 XINWEI SHE, JULIE E. HORVATH, ZHAOSHI JIANG, GE LIU, TERRENCE S. FUREY, LAURIE CHRIST, ROYDEN CLARK, TINA GRAVES, CASSY L. GULDEN, CAN ALKAN, JEFF A. BAILEY, CENK SAHINALP, MARIANO ROCCHI, DAVID HAUSSLER, RICHARD K. WILSON, WEBB MILLER, STUART SCHWARTZ & EVAN E. EICHLER Letters to Nature Discovery of five irregular moons of Neptune 865 MATTHEW J. HOLMAN, J. J. KAVELAARS, TOMMY GRAV, BRETT J. GLADMAN, WESLEY C. FRASER, DAN MILISAVLJEVIC, PHILIP D. NICHOLSON, JOSEPH A. BURNS, VALERIO CARRUBA, JEAN-MARC PETIT, PHILIPPE ROUSSELOT, OLIVER MOUSIS, BRIAN G. MARSDEN & ROBERT A. JACOBSON Addition of nanoparticle dispersions to enhance flux pinning of the YBa Cu O 2 3 7-x superconductor 867 T. HAUGAN, P. N. BARNES, R. WHEELER, F. MEISENKOTHEN & M. SUMPTION Direct evidence for atomic defects in graphene layers 870 AYAKO HASHIMOTO, KAZU SUENAGA, ALEXANDRE GLOTER, KOKI URITA & SUMIO IIJIMA Chemical remodelling of cell surfaces in living animals 873 JENNIFER A. PRESCHER, DANIELLE H. DUBE & CAROLYN R. BERTOZZI Variable ageing and storage of dissolved organic components in the open ocean 877 III AI NING LOH, JAMES E. BAUER & ELLEN R. M. DRUFFEL Impact of climate change on marine pelagic phenology and trophic mismatch 881 MARTIN EDWARDS AND ANTHONY J. RICHARDSON Context-dependent autonomous self-fertilization yields reproductive assurance and mixed mating 884 SUSAN KALISZ, DONNA W. VOGLER & KRISTEN M. HANLEY A barley cultivation-associated polymorphism conveys resistance to powdery mildew 887 PIETRO PIFFANELLI, LUKE RAMSAY, ROBBIE WAUGH, ABDELLAH BENABDELMOUNA, ANGÉLIQUE D'HONT, KARIN HOLLRICHER, JØRGEN HELMS JØRGENSEN, PAUL SCHULZE-LEFERT & RALPH PANSTRUGA SNF-6 is an acetylcholine transporter interacting with the dystrophin complex in Caenorhabditis elegans 891 HONGKYUN KIM, MATTHEW J. ROGERS, JANET E. RICHMOND & STEVEN L. MCINTIRE Coupling of agonist binding to channel gating in an ACh-binding protein linked to an ion channel 896 CECILIA BOUZAT, FERNANDA GUMILAR, GUILLERMO SPITZMAUL, HAI-LONG WANG, DIEGO RAYES, SCOTT B. HANSEN, PALMER TAYLOR & STEVEN M. SINE Identification of an antimalarial synthetic trioxolane drug development candidate 900 JONATHAN L. VENNERSTROM, SARAH ARBE-BARNES, RETO BRUN, SUSAN A. CHARMAN, FRANCIS C. K. CHIU, JACQUES CHOLLET, YUXIANG DONG, ARNULF DORN, DANIEL HUNZIKER, HUGUES MATILE, KYLIE MCINTOSH, MANIYAN PADMANILAYAM, JOSEFINA SANTO TOMAS, CHRISTIAN SCHEURER, BERNARD SCORNEAUX, YUANQING TANG, HEINRICH URWYLER, SERGIO WITTLIN & WILLIAM N. CHARMAN Crystal structure of a complex between anthrax toxin and its host cell receptor 905 EUGENIO SANTELLI, LAURIE A. BANKSTON, STEPHEN H. LEPPLA & ROBERT C. LIDDINGTON Cell cycle regulation of central spindle assembly 908 MASANORI MISHIMA, VISNJA PAVICIC, ULRIKE GRÜNEBERG, ERICH A. NIGG & MICHAEL GLOTZER Structural basis for inhibition of the replication licensing factor Cdt1 by geminin 913 CHANGWOOK LEE, BUMSOO HONG, JUNG MIN CHOI, YUGENE KIM, SAORI WATANABE, YUKIO ISHIMI, TAKEMI ENOMOTO, SHUSUKE TADA, YOUNGCHANG KIM & YUNJE CHO Structural basis for redox regulation of Yap1 transcription factor localization 917 MATTHEW J. WOOD, GISELA STORZ & NICO TJANDRA erratum: No stellar p-mode oscillations in space-based photometry of Procyon 921 JAYMIE M. MATTHEWS, RAINER KUSCHNIG, DAVID B. GUENTHER, GORDON A. H. WALKER, ANTHONY F.J. MOFFAT, SLAVEK M. RUCINSKI, DIMITAR SASSELOV & WERNER W. WEISS corrigendum: Sirt1 promotes fat mobilization in white adipocytes by repressing PPAR- 921 FRÉDÉRIC PICARD, MARTIN KURTEV, NAMJIN CHUNG, ACHARAWAN TOPARK-NGARM, THANASET SENAWONG, RITA MACHADO DE OLIVEIRA, MARK LEID, MICHAEL W. MCBURNEY & LEONARD GUARENTE Outlook Malaria 923 Plague of my people 925 PASCOAL MOCUMBI "It is high time we addressed the widening inequities that characterize our planet today. We need to focus our energies towards achieving basic healthcare for all." Pascoal Mocumbi, former prime minister of Mozambique Between hope and a hard place 926 BRIAN GREENWOOD Campaigns against malaria are multiplying, but so are malaria deaths. Brian Greenwood asks what can be done to turn the tide. IV Power to the people 928 DECLAN BUTLER In Africa, where malaria hits hardest, scientists are crying out for countries to take matters into their own hands, says Declan Butler. An attack on all fronts 930 RICHARD KLAUSNER AND PEDRO ALONSO To win the fight against malaria we will need to scale up existing programmes and develop new weapons, say Richard Klausner and Pedro Alonso. Where did it all go wrong? 932 AMIR ATTARAN International agencies have failed to meet their own malaria performance targets and should be held to account, says Amir Attaran. The invisible victims 934 ROBERT W. SNOW We need to know how bad the malaria situation is before we can make it better, says Robert Snow. Struggling to make an impact 935 APOORVA MANDAVILLI Taking aim at mosquitoes 936 JANET HEMINGWAY The malaria vector is back in scientists' sights, says Janet Hemingway, with insecticides and transgenic insects offering fresh hope. The long and winding road 937 JULIE CLAYTON AND DECLAN BUTLER Documentary makers can get as close to the war zones of disease as doctors and researchers — perhaps even closer. Julie Clayton and Declan Butler talk to Kevin Hull about his experiences. Strength in unity 938 MELINDA MOREE, SARAH EWART & CARTER DIGGS The world must increase collaboration to meet the pressing need for a malaria vaccine, argue Carter Diggs, Sarah Ewart and Melinda Moree. Save the children 940 STEPHEN HOFFMAN Creating a malaria vaccine will be tough. But Africa needs one now more than ever, says Stephen Hoffman. Winning the drugs war 942 ROBERT RIDLEY AND YEYA TOURE We have the science to make new antimalarials, say Robert Ridley and Yeya Toure, but we need better mechanisms and resources to develop drugs and deliver them. Know thine enemy 944 DANIEL CARUCCI The malaria and mosquito genomes will allow us to find new drug and vaccine targets, says Daniel Carucci. Naturejobs Prospects: Granting longevity 947 PAUL SMAGLIK Careers & Recruitment: Breathing life into chemistry 948 TIM CHAPMAN Chemical biology, using chemical tools to solve biological problems, is awakening interest among students and creating a new breed of researcher, says Tim Chapman. V 19.8 Editorial 815 MH 17/8/04 1:36 pm Page 815 19 August 2004 Volume 430Issue no 7002 Passing the torch With the death of Francis Crick, biology is mourning one of its deepest thinkers. A work of futurology, published in 1970, reveals the extent of his prescience — and suggests challenges for today’s theorists. When Francis Crick and James Watson described the double- worlds.The nature ofconsciousness — to which Crick devoted his helix structure ofDNA in 1953,they charmed many with later years — similarly remains shrouded in mystery. their unassuming pay-off line: “It has not escaped our Crick also had some observations about the future ofthis journal. notice that the specific pairing we have postulated immediately “I hope,”he wrote,“that Naturewill not become overloaded with too suggests a possible copying mechanism for the genetic material.” many detailed papers in what we now regard as the more classical In fact,little in the broad landscape of biology escaped Crick’s parts ofmolecular biology.” attention.The publication ofhis obituary (see page 845) marks a good In terms ofwhat was then seen as “classical”,Crick’s wish has been time to revisit one ofhis lesser-known works,a 1970 essay in Nature granted.But in recent years,there’s no denying the preponderance of on‘Molecular Biology in the Year 2000’(www.nature.com/nature/ Naturepapers on the molecular details ofsuch topics as signal trans- focus/crick/pdf/crick228.pdf).Unlike most exercises in crystal-ball duction and the cell cycle.Crick would probably have been disap- gazing,it holds up remarkably well to the scrutiny ofhindsight. pointed by the relative paucity ofgreat contributions on the origins Setting about his task with some trepidation,Crick divided bio- oflife,and astrobiology.In part,this may reflect a conservative system logical problems into three categories:those that would be solved by ofresearch funding that discourages biologists from attempting the the turn ofthe millennium;those that would have advanced consid- high-risk imaginative leaps that Crick favoured.But it’s also a reflec- erably towards resolution;and the big questions that would still be tion ofthe nature ofthe beast.Crick’s essay hinted at this:“Problems taxing the best scientific minds. involving complex interactions can hardly be avoided,since some of In some respects,Crick overestimated the rate ofprogress.We are the most profound aspects ofbiology are ofthis character.” still some way from a complete understanding ofthe significance of Crick understandably failed to predict the rise ofhigh-throughput repetitive ‘junk’DNA;much the same can be said for the sequences techniques,including whole-genome sequencing,DNA microarray that regulate gene expression.But,as he predicted,the replication of analysis and proteome profiling.These techniques have confirmed, DNA and the structure ofchromosomes are now well documented. ifthere was any doubt,that the details ofbiology are truly devilish. Crick’s choices for the second category were similarly prescient. In the wake ofgenomics,the emerging discipline ofsystems biology Some problems fell more easily than he expected:apart from minor has the potential to make sense ofthese details,by treating genes and details, the mechanism of muscle contraction can be considered proteins as networks,ripe for theoretical analysis.There’s reason to solved.Others,such as “the nature ofthe influences which produce hope that theorists will soon be able to advise lab-based biologists on ‘gradients’in embryological development”,have proved more com- where to look for answers,much as theoretical physicists predicted plex.But his list represents a remarkably accurate summary ofthe the existence offundamental subatomic particles a generation ago. issues that have occupied biologists over the past three-and-a-half Molecular biology is easily dismissed as a book ofrecipes,and too decades — not all ofwhich would have been obvious back in 1970. many ofits practitioners allow this criticism to pass unchallenged. As for the final category ofunsolved problems,we’re still wrestling Crick would not have wanted this to happen.Let’s hope his legacy of with the origins of life on Earth,and whether life exists on other thinking big lives on. ■ Let’s blame Canada Americans should worry less about their neighbour and more about the prestige of regulators who protect public health. Lester Crawford, acting commissioner of the US Food and prestigiousfederal agencies,such as the FDA,into political poodles. Drug Administration (FDA),is worried that the importation The FDA has an inspiring history.Its record ofstalwart indepen- of cheap pharmaceuticals could expose Americans to attack dence is one of the reasons Americans have such high confidence from bioterrorists.In an interview with the Associated Press on 11 in the safety of both their pharmaceuticals and their food supply. August,he raised the potential contamination ofimported drugs as Only a few years ago,for example,FDA commissioner David Kessler a threat to national security. launched an audacious effort to regulate tobacco as a drug.Congress In practice,the imports come mainly from Canada,where drugs opposed the move and Kessler received little support from his bosses are subject to government price controls.They are increasingly sanc- in the Clinton administration.But his stand,for a while,had ‘big tioned by state governments in the United States,where citizens are tobacco’shaking in its boots. tiring ofpaying inflated prices for medicines.The Bush administra- Today,the chances of such an initiative originating within the tion — taking its cue from US drug companies — would like to close FDA itselfare slight — not much larger than the chances ofsomeone the door to such imports. choosing to terrorize the US public by contaminating a shipment of As that acclaimed documentary the South Parkmovie demon- drugs before their export from Canada.It is scandalous that the FDA’s strated,the United States’paranoia about its threatening northern leadership seems ready to make politically motivated pronounce- neighbour is richly justified.But Canadian perfidy must not blind ments that link two serious issues — drug pricing and bioterrorism Americans to a starker domestic threat:the degeneration ofonce- — in a manner likely only to inflate public cynicism about both. ■ NATURE|VOL 430|19 AUGUST 2004|www.nature.com/nature 815 © 2004 Nature PublishingGroup 19.8 news 817 new MH 17/8/04 2:25 pm Page 817 news Valley life Seeing red Desert storm Viral strain Climate model offers Marine scientists UK inquiry seeks Vietnam confirms California a taste of bid to halt ocean clarity on ‘GulfWar three human deaths things to come acidification syndrome’ from bird flu p818 p820 p821 p822 Biologists fear cloning hype will undermine stem-cell research Jonathan Knight ES G A dose ofreality needs to be injected into the A M excitement surrounding therapeutic cloning, Y I T T senior stem-cell biologists have warned. E G Researchers fear that optimism generated AFP/ by recent advances,including the award on 11 August ofthe first UK licence for research on the technique,has raised expectations of individualized cures for degenerative dis- eases.In reality,say those in the field,such a prospect remains distant at best. “Ifwe keep talking about cures and they don’t come in the next few years,that’s going to be a problem,”says Jose Cibelli,a stem-cell researcher at Michigan State University in East Lansing. The decision by the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Authority to grant a licence to the Newcastle Fertility Centre,part ofthe Media attention on these cloned embryos,created this year,has obscured short-term research benefits. city’s Life biotechnology village,triggered a storm ofmedia attention.The licence allows Yet the scientific hurdles that remain are who has collaborated with colleagues there. scientists to create human embryos by insert- immense. Cloning is tremendously ineffi- The Newcastle group faces fewer prob- ing nuclei from human skin cells into human cient,for example.When researchers at Seoul lems,as researchers there will have access to eggs.The Newcastle team will then be able to National University in South Korea produced eggs left over from in vitrofertilization proce- extract stem cells from the cloned embryo. the world’s first human embryonic stem-cell dures.These number some 2,000 a year,says Although researchers such as Cibelli were line from a cloned embryo in February,they Alison Murdoch, a reproductive biologist thrilled at the news, some worry that the got through 242 eggs from 16 women.Until with the group,although the actual number media coverage underplays just how few labs that success rate is improved,cures or treat- available will depend on how many women are working on therapeutic cloning.They also ments from therapeutic cloning will be give permission for their eggs to be used. say that short-term benefits ofthe work,such impossible.“There is a limited number ofeggs Murdoch and her colleagues will initially as providing fresh insight into diseases such as for all the patients in the world,”says Cibelli. attempt to generate a cell line from the cloned diabetes and Parkinson’s (see Nature422,787; embryo ofa healthy subject,to make sure the 2003),are not acknowledged. Limited company procedure works.Only then will they try to Short-term and long-term benefits are Efficiency may improve with time,although produce a cell line from a patient with dia- usually mentioned in the same breath,but the that will require repeat trials with larger betes,the clinic’s primary disease focus. possibility ofcures seems to overshadow the numbers of eggs.But sources estimate that Even getting the first healthy cell line will research benefits,says Lawrence Goldstein,a fewer than five labs around the world are be hard.The South Korean team used adult stem-cell researcher at the University ofCali- even trying. The South Korean group has cell nuclei transferred from cumulus cells sur- fornia,San Diego.“Many ofus in the scien- halted its cloning work until a new licensing rounding the donor’s egg.Using nuclei from tific community talk about both ofthese,but law comes into effect next January (see the donor avoids problems with mitochon- the press often seizes on one,as do the public Nature429,12–14;2004).Singapore,home dria — energy-producing parts ofa cell that and the patient advocates,”he says. to several stem-cell groups,has not yet final- carry their own genetic content,which is not Talk ofcures is justified,say experts,but ized legislation relating to the licensing of always compatible with any mitochondrial only in the long term. Researchers believe therapeutic cloning. DNA found in the donor’s egg.Cumulus cells that embryonic stem cells can be coaxed to US law prohibits federal funds from being also combine relatively easily with eggs. form any tissue in the body.So if they can used for therapeutic cloning,and private labs The Newcastle group, by contrast, will be extracted from embryos cloned from a are not thought to be working on the tech- take nuclei from skin cells and attempt to patient, they could be used as genetically nique.And in Israel,another country with fuse them with eggs from many different identical replacements for damaged tissue. stem-cell expertise,researchers are discour- donors.“Ifwe can get the technique to work This would avoid the risk ofrejection associ- aged because only a small number ofeggs can reliably in the first year we will have made a ated with transplants. be used in experiments,says a US scientist great deal ofprogress,”says Murdoch. ■ NATURE|VOL 430|19 AUGUST 2004|www.nature.com/nature 817 © 2004 Nature PublishingGroup 19.8 news 818 MH 17/8/04 1:37 pm Page 818 news Crisis foments as BIS R O unstable lake builds ES/C M OL in the Himalayas H R. K.S.Jayaraman,New Delhi Landslides on the India–China border have created a lake holding millions of cubic metres ofwater.Scientists and engineers in the region are puzzling over how to avoid a catastrophic collapse ofthe lake wall,but Indian researchers say their plans have been hampered by China’s refusal to allow them to visit the site. The Chinese government warned on Green remembered hills:the wine ofthe Napa valley could lose its edge ifemissions are not reduced. 11 August that landslides had blocked the Climate modellers go local to Pare Chu river in Tibet,creating a lake about 40 metres deep and holding 60 million cubic metres ofwater.China said target California’s politicians it was evacuating people downstream and advised India to do the same.The river enters India about 35 kilometres from the lake and,as the Sutlej,continues past Emma Marris assessment,”says Hayhoe,who adds that the several towns in Himachal Pradesh. A “pioneering”example of a new breed of team chose California because the state is According to Muthaia Perumal,a climate model, designed to plug the gap both tough and potentially responsive.“It hydrologist at the Indian Institute of between academic research and political has a lot of different climate zones,so it is Technology (IIT) in Roorkee,the water decision making,has been published. challenging. Also, California is a leader in will rush into a narrow gorge should the The analysis of California’s climate by terms of reduction of emissions. It might lake wall break .“It will not be like floods Katharine Hayhoe and colleagues outlines actually use our findings.” in the plains where water can spread how conditions in the state will change under Hayhoe hopes her forecasts will be politi- out,”he says.“We expect a huge wall of two alternative scenarios: one models the cally effective,but says she wants the science water moving in bulk without its height state’s future under aggressive policies to to be unbiased and to be perceived as being diminishing.” reduce carbon dioxide emissions;the other so.She adds that her team used low estimates Creating tunnels in the lake wall could predicts its fate without them. The result for emissions and their effect on the climate: have provided an exit for the accumulating is an analysis of the implications for heat- “We tried to err on the conservative side.” water had measures been taken when the related human mortality,the water cycle and She also says that after the initial suggestion, landslides occurred in early July,says agriculture. It is designed to influence the the UCS stepped aside, although two Manoj Datta,a civil engineer at the IIT in state’s policy-makers. authors do list the UCS as an affiliation. Delhi.“Now the dam is overflowing it is “Other researchers looked at just one State officials declined requests to comment too risky to try anything,”he adds.The scenario, which is kind of fatalistic,” says on the paper. Indian government has evacuated 50,000 Hayhoe,who is based at the University of The study is “pioneering”,according to people from the danger zone. Illinois at Urbana–Champaign.“This way Warren Washington,a climate researcher at Indian researchers regret that a joint you have a choice.” the US National Center for Atmospheric strategy was not put in place early on,but Rajendra Pachauri,chairman ofthe Inter- Research in Boulder, Colorado, who pro- the Indian government said on 13 August governmental Panel on Climate Change vided tailored data from the centre’s global that a request toChina for permission to (IPCC),has flagged up such regional studies climate model.He predicts that the format send scientists and engineers to the site as a vital part ofthe panel’s next assessment will be popular.“This type of paper and had been rebuffed.The Chinese (see Nature417,106;2002).In this case,the analysis will be repeated for many regions government says the site is difficult to project was suggested to Hayhoe by the around the world,”says Washington. reach and is briefing Indian authorities on Washington-based Union of Concerned Regional assessments are becoming more progress made by its own team at the lake. Scientists (UCS),which fears that the find- feasible as computing power improves,adds Chinese hydrologists working on the lake ings ofclimate-change science are not being David Viner,ofthe IPCC’s Data Distribution could not be reached for comment. ■ disseminated in a useful form. Centre at the University of East Anglia in The study,which is published in print on Norwich,UK.The regional models,although D BA 16 August (K.Hayhoe et al.Proc.Natl Acad. huge,can now be done on off-the-shelfcom- A ER Sci.USA doi:10.1073/pnas.0404500101),uses puters.“I’ve got a G5 Power Mac on my desk, D HY data from two global climate models,along which has the capability ofa supercomputer A RS with local weather histories. In the high- from five or ten years ago,”says Viner.“There N emissions scenario,there will be six to eight are lots ofpeople doing this now.” times more heat waves and five to seven times He adds that moving the data around is more heat-related deaths in 2100 than there probably more problematic than producing are now.Alpine forests will practically dis- it.Global models,which can require up to appear,snow packs will shrink and the vine- 5,000 gigabytes ofmemory,are starting to Dam danger:a catastrophic flood is feared yards will move from producing gourmet become publicly available on the Internet. after landslides blocked a Tibetan river. wine to plonk. However,they do not yet provide the detail “What we did is a model for a regional needed for a rigorous local model. ■ 818 NATURE|VOL 430|19 AUGUST 2004|www.nature.com/nature © 2004 Nature PublishingGroup 19.8 news 819 MH 17/8/04 10:16 am Page 819 news Newton’s religious screeds get online airing PL Geoff Brumfiel Protestant parliament,before Charles Y/S “Among the Beasts that represent II was restored to the throne. R R TE Kingdoms I reccon the Dragon one. But the vehemence of Newton’s S. A Dragon signifies the person of a arguments pushed him well beyond hostile King & serpents according the Anglican faith,to which he osten- to their bigness the persons ofother sibly belonged.“He believed that the greater or lesser enemies.” These Pope was the personification of the words were penned not by an Antichrist here on Earth,”Iliffe says. obscure mystic,but by a man many Newton knew such beliefs lay out- consider to be the father ofmodern side the social mores ofhis peers,and science — Isaac Newton.They are there is no evidence that he ever pub- part of the introduction to the lished any ofthe writings now avail- 300,000-word interpretation of the able online.Still,Iliffe says,Newton’s book of Revelation that Newton religious writings constitute more wrote in the late seventeenth cent- than halfofhis entire written work. ury.The work was published for the In the past, many thought that first time last month. Newton pursued religion only in his The writings reveal a religious fer- spare time, or that the majority of vour that until now has been seen his religious work had been copied only by scholars of science with from others. But Iliffe claims that access to archival manuscripts, these writings show his theological according to Robert Iliffe,a science work was carefully planned and often historian at Imperial College Lon- related to his work in mathematics don.Iliffe directs the Newton Pro- and physics.For example,he sets up ject, which posted the documents Revelation:the majority ofNewton’s writings were theological tracts. his text on the Apocalypse with math- online on 15 July.“This is the first ematical formalism,outlining rules, time that people can see what he really Among the unorthodox ideas in the text is a definitions and a proofofhis beliefs. believed,”he says. beliefthat Catholics,led by the Pope,are the Ultimately,Newton’s religion and science Historians ofscience have long known of false idolaters spoken ofin the book ofRevela- may have been tied together by belief in Newton’s interest in religion and alchemy,but tion.Antagonism towards Catholics was not absolute truth. Newton used testable few realize the radical nature ofhis work,says uncommon in Newton’s period: during his hypotheses to find truth in nature, and Iliffe. “What he believed would have been lifetime England had experienced a bloody believed that his religious writings revealed hideous to virtually everybody in Oxford and civil war that pitted Charles I,widely regarded the truth about God,says Iliffe. ■ Cambridge for decades to come,”he says. as a Catholic sympathizer,against the mainly ➧www.newtonproject.ic.ac.uk Firm sets sights on gene silencing to protect vision Erika Check,Washington Acuity hopes to use a small interfering 1.65 million people in the United States. A much-hyped technology known as RNA RNA to treat patients with wet age-related Dale Pfost,Acuity’s chiefexecutive,says interference (RNAi) has moved a step macular degeneration.The condition is his firm has applied for a patent on the RNA closer to the clinic. caused by extended growth ofblood vessels molecule involved,but the intellectual- Biotechnology firm Acuity in the retina — a problem that Acuity thinks properties issues are not straightforward. Pharmaceuticals ofPhiladelphia, can be tackled by silencing the gene that Rival firm Alnylam,based in Cambridge, Pennsylvania,asked for permission on triggers the growth.The company says Massachusetts,has already requested a 10 August to use the technique to treat a that the condition affects more than patent on the method ofRNA delivery that common cause ofblindness.The clinical Acuity will use.Alnylam says it plans to R/SPL trial,ifapproved by the US Food and Drug begin its own clinical trials in macular KE Administration,would be the first ofits kind. degeneration next year. R PA RNAi,which uses short lengths of Pfost is confident that Acuity’s disease- P. genetic material to selectively shut offgenes, specific patent will be granted,but Alnylam was demonstrated in human cells in 2001 begs to differ.“We’re very pleased to see and has yet to be tested in people.Some silencing RNAs entering the clinical stage,” studies have raised concerns about just how says John Maraganore,chiefexecutive of selective the technique is,so observers say Alnylam.“But at the end ofthe day,we the filing is a landmark for the field but believe that anybody developing RNAi remain cautious. therapies needs to talk to us.” ■ “This is a significant milestone,”says Greg Jensen,a biotechnology analyst at Ernst For more news and analysis go to & Young in Palo Alto,California.“Whether it Light relief:RNAi may stop the degeneration will work out,or give us the first bad news seen here (right) in an ageing retina. www.nature.com/news about RNA interference,we don’t know yet.” NATURE|VOL 430|19 AUGUST 2004|www.nature.com/nature 819 © 2004 Nature PublishingGroup 19.8 news 820 MH 17/8/04 10:16 am Page 820 news Kerry pledges to axe M O C Yucca Mountain EPL. R U AT nuclear-waste dump N Geoff Brumfiel,Washington Plans for a multimillion-dollar nuclear- waste dump,already shaken by a string of budgetary and legal setbacks,have taken a further knock.The Democrat presidential candidate John Kerry pledged last week to block the scheme ifhe is elected. Debate over the Yucca Mountain repository has injected some science into the presidential race,as both candidates campaign heavily for the swing state ofNevada,home to the site.Advocates ofnuclear power hope to make Yucca Mountain the nation’s primary nuclear dump,but opposition from the state government and scientific questions about the site have delayed the project (see Nature412,850–852;2001). Sea change:falling pH levels caused by carbon dioxide emissions could devastate oceanic ecosystems. On 10 August,Kerry used scientific studies to claim the plan was flawed, Researchers seek to turn the including one saying that corrosion could destroy the metal waste-storage canisters. tide on problem of acid seas “I can sum up my stance on Yucca Mountain in four words,”Kerry told supporters in Nevada.“Not on my watch.” His attack was rebuffed by President Quirin Schiermeier,Munich marine organisms will play a prominent part George W.Bush,who two days later Researchers met last week to map out plans in the research plan.Last month,researchers accused Kerry of“trying to turn Yucca to study a serious but largely neglected showed that the shells and hard skeletons of Mountain into a political poker chip”. environmental problem — the gradual plankton and corals will begin to dissolve Kerry may also be out ofstep with the acidification ofthe oceans. as the oceans become more acid (R.A.Feely scientific evidence.According to a 28 July Since the industrial revolution,sea sur- et al.Science305,362–366;2004).The loss of letter from the Nuclear Waste Technical face pH levels have dropped by around 0.1 these creatures would have incalculable con- Review Board,the government agency units as the oceans absorb atmospheric car- sequences for the entire marine food chain. that raised the corrosion concern,new bon dioxide.This is already enough to trou- Carol Turley,a senior scientist at the Ply- data show that corrosion is “unlikely”. ble some marine species, but researchers mouth lab,says researchers will investigate The campaign rhetoric comes at a warn that values could fall by a further 0.5 the growth, reproduction and adaptation turbulent time for the site.The facility units by 2100.If steps are not taken to cut capability of marine species ranging from is designed to last 10,000 years,but on CO emissions,pH could drop even further, bacteria to vertebrates. Results from these 2 10 July a federal appeal court ruled that perhaps to levels that are thought to have experiments will help to shape protocols for it must comply with a 1995 National triggered catastrophic extinction events in open-ocean studies.With the help of mea- Academy ofSciences study that raises Earth’s history (Nature425,365;2003). surement tools such as pH sensors attached to this to 100,000 years.The decision came “We’re taking a huge risk,”says UlfRiebe- profiling floats,researchers will try to track as federal officials were rushing to file a sell,a marine biologist at the Leibniz Insti- the subtle ecosystem interactions between licence application for the site with the tute of Marine Sciences in Kiel, Germany. the sea surface and the sea floor,and between Nuclear Regulatory Commission,which “Chemical ocean conditions 100 years from coastal areas and the open ocean. oversees nuclear-waste disposal. now will probably have no equivalent in the Modelling the likely changes in ocean Yucca’s advocates are also faced with geological past,and key organisms may have chemistry,and determining how they may a budgeting miscalculation that led the no mechanisms to adapt to the change.” affect temperature, salinity and nutrient House ofRepresentatives in June to Aspects of the threat are already being availability, will be another priority, says approve just $130million ofthe $880 studied, but marine scientists met at the Turley. Researchers will also add CO to 2 million requested for the site in the next Plymouth Marine Laboratory,UK,on 11–13 the ocean to simulate long-term changes. financial year.Many doubt that the bill, August to start work on a comprehensive Together, these studies should show how when it is completed,will provide full research plan. The scheme, to be finalized biogeochemistry,species diversity and evo- funding.“The project is caught in a later this year,will list key scientific questions lution will change in an acidic ocean. perfect storm right now,”says Bob Loux, and provide a blueprint for funding agencies Riebesell hopes that the initiatives,which director ofthe State ofNevada Agency for and researchers. will be overseen by the Integrated Marine Nuclear Projects,which opposes the site. Their efforts were due to be boosted on Biogeochemistry and Ecosystem Research The fate ofthe site may now depend on 17 August by news that Britain’s Royal Soci- project,will influence funding agencies.“We the outcome ofthe presidential election. ety is to probe the likely changes to marine know quite a lot about the ocean ofthe past,” IfBush wins,he may be able to negotiate ecosystems following a rise in ocean acidity. he says.“But we owe it to people to tell them a new 2005 budget for the project. ■ Studies ofthe effects ofacidification on more about the ocean ofthe future.” ■ 820 NATURE|VOL 430|19 AUGUST 2004|www.nature.com/nature © 2004 Nature PublishingGroup

See more

The list of books you might like

Upgrade Premium
Most books are stored in the elastic cloud where traffic is expensive. For this reason, we have a limit on daily download.
DMCA & Copyright: Dear all, most of the website is community built, users are uploading hundred of books everyday, which makes really hard for us to identify copyrighted material, please contact us if you want any material removed.
Copyright @ PDFdrive.to, 2022 | We love our users