National Aeronautics and Space Administration Effects of Damage on Long-term Displacement Data of Woven Fabric Webbings Under Constant Load for Inflatable Structures Winfred S. Kenner NASA LaRC Structural Mechanics and Concepts Branch AIAA SciTech 2016, January 3-8, 2016 San Diego, California Outline National Aeronautics and Space Administration • Background Inflatable Structures § Problem Statement § • Approach • Hardware and Test Facility • Test Results • Summary 2 Inflatable Structures National Aeronautics and Space Administration Research Materials: Typical Inflatable Structures Kevlar Webbing Vectran Webbing 1 2 Lightweight Small Storage Volume Fast Build 3 Typical Roll of Webbing Material 4 (Flexible Structural Restraint Layer) 4 Problem Statement National Aeronautics and Space Administration Goal: Conduct an experimental creep study to identify effects of damage on webbing performance over extended time period Causation: Damage due to deployment and/or service Definition: Damage is defined as vertical incisions of varying length and number Analytical analysis: Inaccurate for nonlinear materials over time Time period: Study was conducted over an 18-month time period Typical Inflatable Module Damaged Area Interwoven Webbings Y-axis Y-axis Incision Orienta2ons X-axis X-axis 5 Research Approach National Aeronautics and Space Administration Goal: Generate long-term displacement data from webbings under load Computer system Webbing (damaged) Test Facility Load ?∆ Test Facility Test Hardware Displacement Data Measuring Acquisition • Large • High load • Overhead crane capacity D evice • Variable rate • Available for • Quick • Accurate • Continuous multiple years assembly • Continuous recordings measurements over multiple years 5 Creep Test Facility National Aeronautics and Space Administration Initial creep test, Feb 2012 Creep test hardware (3 rows) I-beam structures Concrete weights Typical displacement sensor Webbing displacement measuring and support fixture • Webbing material • Transducer sensor Applied load 6 Magnified Webbing Images National Aeronautics and Space Administration Pristine Webbing Damaged Webbing Fill yarns Yarn cuts Warp yarns Selvage edge yarns Small vertical incision Fibers Damage categories: Small, Medium, Large Eleven test groups defined by test material, applied load, and damage Horizontal incision: Known to have an adverse effect on strength proportional to length 7 Test Matrix National Aeronautics and Space Administration Pristine Webbings Damaged Webbings Group Webbing Webbing UTS W ebbing Length Group Webbing Webbing UTS W ebbing Length Incision # materials # (%) length of test # materials # (%) length of test length (months) (months) (inches) 1 6K 1 20 144 34 7 6K 1 20 60 18 5 Kevlar 2 20 144 34 Kevlar 2 20 60 16 5 2 6K 1 20 60 3 6K 1 6.7 60 14 1 8 Kevlar 2 20 60 3 Kevlar 2 6.7 60 14 1 3 6K 1 43 68 39 3 6.7 60 14 1 Kevlar 2 43 84 39 9 6K 1 20 62 3 5 3 50 82 35 Kevlar 2 20 62 3 5 4 50 80 35 3 20 62 3 5 4 6K 1 50 80 34 10 6K 1 20 60 18 5 (multiple) Vectran 2 50 80 34 Vectran 2 20 60 18 5 (multiple) 3 50 80 34 3 20 60 18 5 (multiple) 5 12.5K 1 29 116 29 11 12.5K 1 29 48 18 1 Vectran 2 29 116 29 Vectran 2 29 41 18 1 3 29 43 18 1 3 29 116 22 6 6K 1 25 66 44 Vectran 2 25 66 44 3 25 66 44 4 25 66 44 5 20 66 44 *Ultimate tensile strength (UTS) 8 Environmental Influences on Displacement Displacement Data Temperature Data 105 0.455 ) F ˚ ( ) e s r e u h t c 0.385 a n r e i ( p t m n ---External Temperature e e ---Internal Temperature m T 0 e 0.315 12/23/11 12/12/15 c a pl Time (date) Webbing #1 s i D Webbing #2 0.245 Webbing ?∆ 2/5/13 1/14/14 12/23/14 12/1/15 Time (date) Daily, seasonal, and yearly temperature and humidity effects influence the creep displacement curve Webbings exhibits negative coefficient of thermal expansion ( C T E) 9 National Characteristics of Displacement Curve Aeronautics and Space Administration 6K Kevlar Webbings Loaded to 22% UTS 4.47 Material creep Global wave 4 ) s pattern e h 1 c 4.39 Seasonal n i expansion/ ( t 3 n contraction e m e 4.31 Local c a 2 wave l p s pattern i D 4.23 8/11/12 9/24/13 11/7/14 12/21/15 Time (date) 3-year time period Pristine Four characteristic curve patterns Webbing Failure experienced above 50% UTS 10