SYNIMESIS OF RORON NITRIDE. NANOTUBES FOR ENGINEERING APPLICATIONS net Hurst David Lill NASA Glenn Research Cancer 21000 Brookpark Itd Clevsand, Ohio 44135 Duciel Gariean 58 Group 21600 Brookpark Rd Cleveland. Ohio 44135 ABSTRAC ‘Boron nitride nanotubes (BNNT) an: of signifisent interest 9 the selcaisic and techie ccuonmunites for many of the same reasons thl urbon nanotubes (CNT) bave attracted, ‘wide attention, Bor materials have pocemially unique and important properties for sieuctcal an clevtroniv upplieasions, However of even snore consequence than their similarities may be the complementary differeuees bewwenn catbou and boron nitride nanotubes. While BNNT passess a very high modulus similar to CNT they also pasecas supstior chemical and therunal stability, Additionally, BNNT howe mame uniform Teoironic properties. with « uniform band gap of 5.5 eV while CNT vary (roms seri anduclive kr highly eonduvsive behavior. otor nitride nanotubes have been synthesize] both inch litenture and at NASA Glen Research Come. by a varicty of methods such as cheznieal wapor depasilion, are discharge und reactive milling. Consistent large scale production ol aceliuble product has proven difficull. Progress ia the reproducible syethesis of 1-2 gram sized basshes a ‘boron nitride naniubes ill he discuss! 9 well as porential uses for this que note INTRODUCTION, Inthe last decade, sigifivam attention fe the sieatife comaunniy as been focused cnr ava of naotechnalogy and spacifieally upon mnoiuhe synthesis, While ebon nanotubes have generated the bulk of interest to date, other vorpnitions ofr promise ‘wel and may have achmtages ox complementary properties eelauve to caehoo nanatubes for various appligatens.. ACNASA Glenn Rewsrch Center, were application iotereste ane often foctsed on high temperature propulsion, both BN and SiC nanotube synthesis axe curemly under investization for hig temperturssrvetural and cleetonie materials (1.3), The focus of tc eurtoneeffor is BRN eemesis. While heron aire minotubes «rc known to bs structusll simile to cacbon nanotubes inasrauch as hol are lormial fam graphene sets, mnch les is katown abont BNA Jn large part this is due to the difficulty in spathesiing this material rahe toa lack of utes, Is been fou that BNI have excellent mechanical properties with a measured Young's modulus of 1.22 +5024 BAG). BNNT also have a constant baad yop of shoul 5.5 eV (4). in comin, Ins preprint or epar 2 epoine derprasersation ata ‘omfoenes scape enanges nay bo made ters fs Duotone ase avails ite undarstanng that "otos cledor predused thou! Is remission oe anor COL vary thom semi-conducting to condueting behavior depending, on chitality ond ameter of the product. Little proyress has been demonstrated in the conzal of the chiral angle and honee the clestzonio propertics ef CWT, On the ochor hand, BUNT preferentially toms the igeag etuuctas rah than the ammichair or chiral stmetures duc to the polar aanue pl the BEN hand (5). Recenlly. it has phic heen shaven tha NT systcuns have exccllemr piezoelectric pruperties, superior ta those ol pievpelectric polymers (6), Ackltioually. the cxpeeted oxidetion resistance of BNI relative to CNL suggests BNNT riyy he stable for high temperature stuctaral applicatious. This srability may be an imsportanesalety consideration (ir some applications, ssh 2s hydrogen storage, as carbon uauotubes ecadily busn in aie. Many aynchesis approaches have heen Wed with varying degrews of success, Among these approaches arc pyrolysis caver Cr (7), CVD inethuads (8), are discharge (9) laser ablation (10), and reactive mil techniques 1,12}, The reported approach develope! wf NASA Glenn Reseurch Center produced BNNT of significant length and abundance. EXPRRIMENTAL PROCEDURE TINNT were prepared by reacting amorphous boron powder in a flowing atmosphere of hicrngen with a small amonat of NTs. Prier to heat toatmacnt, fine iron eatalyst particles ‘yore added inthe range of up tp several wefght percent and brietly med in polyetiylene bottcs with a hydrocarbon solvent and ceric grialing media. Bauch Sizes of 2 grams are rypivilly produced bur the process should be casily sesleable to Targer size. Milled materiel sass upplied 10 varigus high lemperature substruics such 4s ‘ltunina silicon carbide, platinum and molybdenum, Nunolubes were larmed during beat treatments to temperanines rauging ftom 1109 € to 1400 € tor brief times, 20 rime 2 hones Nanovulbes were imaged with a Itachi $4700 field emission searing electron amieroscope with a super shin window MDAX Genesis System energy dispersive spectrometer (HDS) or Phillips CM2U0 ansmission election mictoscope operated at 200 EY, with Catan clectran onergy Ieee spoetumetsr (EELS), Lhemogravimerdc aualysis ETGA) was done iat gir up us 1000 €. RESULTS TIKNT synthesived by this msthod are shown in Figure 1. The low magnification photo in Figure La shows an us-preduced Tlake of BNNT, The flake was removed by tweeze08 hom a 25 mmx 5 mam subsite oe crucible, i rshust und easily undled Uh Fora, Also, as the nuotubes are anchored wichin a growth medi, there is 00 respiration hard, BN nunetubes urow extensively both Hom the “top” and “bottom of the growth rmedia, where “up” relirs ly Ure side exposed ky the atmosphere, Rolh top and bextom laycis can bo obscrved in Figure Ta as the edges were slightly rolled during handling. ‘The nanotubes az quite long. 100 microns being common as shown in Figs 1b and Ie. (Gin the bostam «the growth r:=dia, 4 lyyer of short nanocabes develons berweeu the film ad subsieate or crucible, TTDS ul showed Cha the NNT gras per a ffm composed primarily of 8, N, ©, Fe and some purities. Nunolube diacasters wun he very zat throughout thele length; however tis is processing temperature dependent, ‘Not surprisingly. variation in the heat ueatnent temperature resulted in somewhat ‘igierent prodnct, Lower processing temperature, resillad in more Tne, uaiforin ranolubes, as those show in Figure 1h, fumeters of 20mm to 50 aan were typical. Tigher iemperaiures enor longer times resulted in lage “uanombs" growth as shown in Figure 2b, Growth originated thom finc uuelei but vith cxocssive tempat, large strucnucs quickly devcloped. up ro a ow microns in diameter, Ax shosen in Figures 2a and 2b, sscondary nucleation of small dismeter BNNT also necurred on these larger ‘iructures. Tigher processing lemperatures, as wel as excess ezralyst concentration, resulted in interesting structures, such as nanohorns or uanoflowers, as seen in figure 2a “These serucures also generally had considerable amounts of oxygen found by TIDS, up ta 6 wi. ais! Fe castbnstatagsovin mentane meget 9) alate pate manera) Te ‘epvrsmon rane toe gin Some Aransotssion sloetron mioreseopy reauits ars shown in Figures 3 and 4. TEM results showed fhe nanotubes to be nearly stnichiometric BN and a mixture of both straight ‘walled naneituhes, 2s shown in Figure 3, and the "bamboo" steuetues, Figure 4. Predominately, the product from this method is multiwalled, commonly composed of 15- 30 lattice layers, although this ean be affected by processing conditions, Diameters af the Figure 2. Examples of ess ypical srusraressynthesiand st provessing oxromes, 2) Adjacent enirems insias 5) upen sed nanepode¢) ine BNST nucleus un lrg tubes nations, Figure 3 TEM photos of ties! straight walled BNNT _mltivslled BNL were often in the 20-401 nm range, again determined by processing ‘conditions wn extalysts eoneouraion, Figure 3 shows the atomic planes within the straight walled sanctubes exhibited lattice fringes at an angle of 12.5° wilh respect to the ‘ube ais. Lhis hes also aeen noted elsewhere (§, 13) and may he wn neation of vocmohedrel sacking onder (12). In Figure 4 tho iypially highly Felted lattice wall of the bamboo aucture are evident, These lauted shor walls, with their open edge lavers hve been sugserted i he superoe foe hydrogen storage (14,15). ‘he stuctse ofthe BN layers are unslagous to stacked paper cups with potential hydrogen storege sites on the surface and bervcen lattice panes. ad slso pecaars within tho isolated voids. Predominatsly bamboo sroctures can bo eensisteily proshuced hy this proces rthod, Figure 5 shanssu region of exclusively hamboo BNNT: igure 4 TEM photos of gpl bamboo BNNT. ‘The sompernure subility of as-produced| BN nunoluhes was investigated by nen gavimelrie anulysis, The revulls were compared ta corumercial asspeoduced carbon. nanotubes*. Photos of the as-produecd CNT and BNNT aaterials arc shown in Figurs 6 ‘swell as these following heating in the TOA, The BNNT sucture is elesly intact with the CNT decomposed, leuving hehind he extensively sided jn catalyst. Faure 7 shows the TGA dau in ir, ecnfiring That the earbon nasonubes have decomposed b 400 C. However, the BNNT are unaflected by the heat ceaument with the exception of some Slight weighr gain from oxidation above LUDU C. oF CNT sample folowing TGA, we 8, Asproosssey BNNT aixl CNT saps eis exaniinod Defoe ard as 130 Cina TGA. Photos onthe lft are as-processed sarrpiss, On tke right are paolo aleial emaning flowing a TCA ru ie 1000C | 2 0 tan 1500 | Temperature (©) Figure 7. TGA results for NNT and CNT samples shasving the superior slability of BNNT relative to CNT CONCLUSION Boron niteide nanotubes were successfully ard reproducibly grivn by a NASA Glenn Ressavcl Center developed proccss. Curtently 1-2 aramn batches ace being synthesized: hhomever, the process is scaleable to umuch lager batch sizes. Suificicut smouats ate aow available s0 that haram ritride nanoluhes are eirrenily being ineorporaled inla eomposives 1 provide high steength heliavie at high temperature. [cis also possible that this watered andy have many applications for sensors, cleewouies, piezoelecties, among other ugplicuions a interes! to NASA snd the teclnies] cocamunity. A preponderance of bamboo structured nanotubes could be achieved hy careful altions of catalyst materials and coatol of processing conditions, These bamboo steuctures are cof inieres! fhe hydrngen slorage applications, ‘Ibe boron nitride nanotubes were found to be much mone sable ul high lemparalure hem exthxn nanouhes ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ‘This work-was sponsoved by the Alscenate Fue] Foundation ‘Technologies (AEE) Suisgnojest of the Low Emissions Alterastive Power (LEAP) Project at tho NASA Gloan_ Research Center Csrbon Nanotechnologics, Ino.16200 Park Row, Houston, 1X RETERENCHS | J. Hust NASA RAT 2002, NASA TM—2002-211253, 2 Tarkin NASA RAT 2002, NASA TM - 2002-211 2 NG. Chipra, A. Zell, “Viewurement af the Plastic Modulus of Multi-wall Boron Niteide Nanotube", Suid State Commun. 105 (1998) 297 *'X Blaise, A. Rubio. S.G. Louie and M.L. Cohen, Eusophys. Let. 28 (1994) © L,Bounysois,¥. Bando and T, Selo, “Tubos of khombobsdal Boron Nitride”, J. Phys: D: Appl. Phys. $3 (2000)1902, MLNakmanton, A. Ca7olani, ¥. Meunier, J. Berle, ond Mf. Buongiome Sarde, “Sponraneous Polarization and bezoeleciricty in Barun Nitride Narlabes” Py. Rey. B 67.235406 2003). R, Sn, BC, Soishkmw, A. Govindera, KR. Havikumar, G. Kaine. JP. Zhang, AK. Cheetham, CNR. Rin, “BACAN. CN snd BEN Nanotubes Produced by the Pyrolysis of Precursor Molecules Over Co Catalysts", Chern. Phys. Lai. 287 (1998) 671 "Ma, ¥. Bando, and £. Santo, “CVD Ssathesis of Baron Niuide Nanonbes ‘Wihouy Men Catlyate Chem, Phys, Lee, 337 (2001) 61-64 NG. Chapra, RJ. Luyren, K. Cher. VIL Cres, ML. Caen, 8.6. Louie, A {Zenle, “Boron Nitide Nanotubes", Science, New Series, 269 (1895) 966. De, Yo, XS, Sum, CS. Les, Bello, 8. T.Lee, HD. Gu, KM Leme, GW. Zhovs.7.P. Dawg, 7. Zhang, Appl. Phys, Lett 72 1998) 196, "OY. Chen. Let. Chadderton, J. Wiliams, and J. Fitz Geld, “Solid Stare Vormation of Carbon and Boron Nitride Nanolubes", Mater, Sci, Forum 342, 63 (2000) 3 ¥. Chen, M. Conway. J.$ Williams, 1. Zou, “Lanye-Quentity Yreduerion of High-Yield Boron Nise Nunoiubes", J Mater, Res, Vol 17 No-8 (2002) 1896-1899. "Ma, ¥. Bando, T. Saio ana K, Kurasbima, " Growth, Morphology, and Struciury of Ronn Nitride Nanotubes", Chera. Maer, (2001) 15 2985 "R Chen. ¥, Bando, 1. Zhu, 1. Sato, C, Xu, and D. Wu. “Hydrogen Uptake in Boron Nitide Nanotubes at Room Temperature”, J Am, Chem, Soe, 2002, 124 7672. SVT.Oku, M. Kuno. 1, Natta, “Hydrogen Storage in Boren Nitride Nanomarciials Studied by TGIDIA and Cluster Coleulstions”, I. Phys, and Cher. af Solids 65 (2004) 549,